Re:The Road from Rome
by satya71 on Thursday April 15, 2021 @08:03AM
(#26819372)
Looks like they are talking only about the Roman Empire in the west. The Empire in the east, which was bigger and wealthier, continued for another 1000 years or so [1]
Re:The Road from Rome
by uniqueid on Thursday April 15, 2021 @09:03AM
(#26819935)
Also, Constantine the Great created the Catholic Church. That an institution from Ancient Rome is still going strong today boggles my mind.
If humanity is around ten or twenty thousand years from now, perhaps historians will just lump us together with the Ancient Romans, and consider it all part of the same era.
Re:The Road from Rome
by yongjik on Friday April 16, 2021 @07:25PM
(#26840139)
Well, we already do something similar with terms like "Antiquity", even though Julius Caesar lived closer to us than construction of the Pyramid of Giza.
Re:The Road from Rome
by kibwen on Saturday April 17, 2021 @12:40AM
(#26841624)
The opening line of the 4,000 year-old Sumerian poem "Gilgamesh, Enkidu and the nether world":
"In those days, in those distant days, in those nights, in those remote nights, in those years, in those distant years; in days of yore, when the necessary things had been brought into manifest existence, in days of yore, when the necessary things had been for the first time properly cared for, when bread had been tasted for the first time in the shrines of the Land, when the ovens of the Land had been made to work, when the heavens had been separated from the earth, when the earth had been delimited from the heavens, when the fame of mankind had been established, [...]"
Even the people of 4,000 years ago were romanticizing the ancient past!
Re:The Road from Rome
by pjmlp on Saturday April 17, 2021 @05:00AM
(#26842728)
It is somehow fun to be able to read > 2000 years old letters from rich people complaining how their sons were wasting their money at the Athens university, by spending it all in parties and playing rich instead of attending classes.
Or how Greek medicine students would do "erasmus" in Egypt, considered more advanced in medicine practices.
Re:The Road from Rome
by mncharity on Saturday April 17, 2021 @06:46AM
(#26843219)
> They considered themselves modern...
Last week I was surfing google books. Was skimming The History of Modern Europe. Noticed it was from 1871.
At least for me, there's something about human artifacts, that can change what feels old. View a museum exhibit, a clay tablet, prescribing interval training for horses, from 3 kya. Something that was held in hands, and could be held in yours. Then, medieval objects, feel like they're from just yesterday, not old at all. I wonder if you could structure an stepped experience, where users repeatedly experience an "oh my, that's old", a baseline shift, and then get hit again with something older, and again. And then walk back through, feeling it all compressed into a stretched now.
I don't get the same effect from critters, or geology. Perhaps I'm not familiar enough with them, or thinking in genealogy. Lunch-time's inquisitive squirrel feels peer, but not "just yesterday" cousin. Enjoying the sea breeze, glad Boston is recently coastal, and that there's an ocean there to be coastal with. Despite flowering trees and chirping birds for context. On Gondwanan crust. I wonder if you could cultivate that feeling, and use it when teaching deep time? [fwiw, those are vaguely: 80 Mya, 12 kya, ~150 Mya, ~200 Mya, ~300 Mya, and ~~1 Gya]
I've lately been thinking about transformatively improved science education content. For AR, in part. Current content, classrooms, practices, apps, even education research... they've been starting to feel to me... distant? Clustered with inkwells in wooden desks, student arithmetic on Roman wax diptych and drawn on Sumerian sand. The modern of the present, become the patinaed old, the before. The "oh my, people lived like that? How curiously odd."
Re:The Road from Rome
by cwyers on Friday April 16, 2021 @07:06PM
(#26840008)
Three paragraphs in:
> It’s true that Rome’s collapse reverberated widely, at least in the western – mostly European – half of its empire. (A shrinking portion of the eastern half, later known as Byzantium, survived for another millennium.)
Re:The Road from Rome
by billfruit on Saturday April 17, 2021 @12:19AM
(#26841550)
HRE did claims legitimacy, and had the weight of the Catholic church behind it. Tension brewed for centuries between HRE and the Eastern Empire as to who was the legitimate emperor.
As a fan of pluralism, it's sometimes hard to keep the faith when confronting empires and monopolies. Pluralism is so messy and slow, sometimes it seems like it can't compete. This essay does a good job reminding me that not only is pluralism desirable, it is also competitive.
Re:The Road from Rome
by CryptoPunk on Saturday April 17, 2021 @12:05PM
(#26845261)
It really is hard to make the case for pluralism, and ideas related to it, like the free market and natural selection, over centralization/homogeneity and its corollaries, like planned economies and intelligent design.
The latter are more compelling in a shallow analysis. The former are based on a lot of extrapolation, so I think the immediate impression many have is that they're based on wishful thinking / ideological fundamentalism.
I don't think so. Islamic societies had already appeared and the Ottoman Empire was in the process of expand. I think Byzantium primarily controlled areas in Eastern Europe and the Caucasus. The development that happened there came later, from elsewhere.
But I haven't heard a single analysis claiming the fall of Constantinople actually caused this and the parent article gives a pretty standard analysis why the fall of the Western Roman Empire eventually gave rise to the modern world.
The fall of Constantinople was more a matter that a variety of more advanced societies (Venice, the Turks, etc) were rising and the Byzantines were there, so why not loot them, as far as I understand the situation.
Re:The Road from Rome
by didericis on Friday April 16, 2021 @10:34PM
(#26841167)
I listened to a podcast called “12 Byzantine Rulers” a while back. I believe they said a number of people fleeing after Constantinople fell made it into Venice and transplanted a lot of old knowledge that had been locked up and stagnant within the city. The Renaissance and the Enlightenment were both heavily influenced by a resurgence of interest in classical work that seems to have started around the exact same time Constantinople fell. I don’t know enough history to know all the reasons in favor or against that argument, but it makes a lot of sense to me that it was a contributing factor.
Re:The Road from Rome
by EarlKing on Saturday April 17, 2021 @12:21AM
(#26841557)
The fleeing of scholars from Constantinople to Venice is comparable to the fleeing of scholars from Ionia to mainland Greece in the wake of the failed Ionian Revolt which kickstarted the golden age of Greek philosophy. They appeared at the right place and time with the right ideas which took root and transformed Western Europe.
Re:The Road from Rome
by didericis on Sunday April 18, 2021 @04:15PM
(#26855909)
It’s humbling to trace these kinds of intellectual lineages. Makes you appreciate the millennia of accumulated knowledge we’ve inherited/how everyone seems to be standing on the shoulders of the past.
Re:The Road from Rome
by fidesomnes on Saturday April 17, 2021 @01:09AM
(#26841731)
Nōn longa via est Rōmam, ubi habitat amīca mea pulchra.
Nōn longa via est Rōmam, ubi habitat amīca mea pulchra.
Per ātrium, ex ōstiō, ex vīllā, in templum,
Tūsculō Rōmam, per agrōs et silvās.
Cantat Mēdus apud ōstium amīcae suae Lȳdiae.
Nōn longa via est Rōmam, ubi habitat amīca mea pulchra.
Nōn longa via est Rōmam, ubi habitat amīca mea pulchra.
Per ātrium, ex ōstiō, ex vīllā, in templum,
Tūsculō Rōmam, per agrōs et silvās,
Viā Latīnā, per Portam Capēnam,
cum rosīs et liliīs, cum nummīs sine dominō.
Cantat Mēdus apud ōstium amīcae suae Lȳdiae.
Nōn longa via est Rōmam, ubi habitat amīca mea pulchra.
Nōn longa via est Rōmam, ubi habitat amīca mea pulchra.
Re:The Road from Rome
by rektide on Friday April 16, 2021 @07:20PM
(#26840097)
I think a lot of the opportunity cost of there being one & only one interesting city. It took generations, but Rome's fall lead to other places being able to find their own identity & value. Civilizations value became decentralized.
This is also a fine example of the classic Trimurti, the cycle of creation, maintaining, & collapse that defines existence. Rome flourished & became, but the world had been "stuck" with Rome for so long, had maintained it for so long, & it's presence was not leaving room for other acts of creation. This article largely asserts that destruction was necessary: Rome was facing a millennia+ old version of "The End of History" hypothesis. Which, to double back to the Trimurti, is against the cycle of creation & existence.
Re:The Road from Rome
by mtmail on Sunday April 18, 2021 @07:09AM
(#26851476)
Out of your 12 comments to far 4 have been flagged. That's a very high ratio and flags is a stronger 'this doesn't belong on this platform' than any downvote. If you believe downvotes send the author of a comment a message, check your own messages, too.
Re:The Road from Rome
by rektide on Sunday April 18, 2021 @08:08PM
(#26857846)
since you don't have the karma, my suggestion is you provide a comment where you say something of value. offer a reason, & explanation.
but don't worry, the people who did have the karma to downvote also didn't decide to meet this bar either. still, would have been nice to hear from them. would be nice to hear from you. what makes you want to downvote?
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Byzantine_Empire
If humanity is around ten or twenty thousand years from now, perhaps historians will just lump us together with the Ancient Romans, and consider it all part of the same era.
It's easy to lose sight of the fact that the ancients also had scholars and studying ancient-to-them history. They considered themselves modern...
"In those days, in those distant days, in those nights, in those remote nights, in those years, in those distant years; in days of yore, when the necessary things had been brought into manifest existence, in days of yore, when the necessary things had been for the first time properly cared for, when bread had been tasted for the first time in the shrines of the Land, when the ovens of the Land had been made to work, when the heavens had been separated from the earth, when the earth had been delimited from the heavens, when the fame of mankind had been established, [...]"
Even the people of 4,000 years ago were romanticizing the ancient past!
Or how Greek medicine students would do "erasmus" in Egypt, considered more advanced in medicine practices.
Last week I was surfing google books. Was skimming The History of Modern Europe. Noticed it was from 1871.
At least for me, there's something about human artifacts, that can change what feels old. View a museum exhibit, a clay tablet, prescribing interval training for horses, from 3 kya. Something that was held in hands, and could be held in yours. Then, medieval objects, feel like they're from just yesterday, not old at all. I wonder if you could structure an stepped experience, where users repeatedly experience an "oh my, that's old", a baseline shift, and then get hit again with something older, and again. And then walk back through, feeling it all compressed into a stretched now.
I don't get the same effect from critters, or geology. Perhaps I'm not familiar enough with them, or thinking in genealogy. Lunch-time's inquisitive squirrel feels peer, but not "just yesterday" cousin. Enjoying the sea breeze, glad Boston is recently coastal, and that there's an ocean there to be coastal with. Despite flowering trees and chirping birds for context. On Gondwanan crust. I wonder if you could cultivate that feeling, and use it when teaching deep time? [fwiw, those are vaguely: 80 Mya, 12 kya, ~150 Mya, ~200 Mya, ~300 Mya, and ~~1 Gya]
I've lately been thinking about transformatively improved science education content. For AR, in part. Current content, classrooms, practices, apps, even education research... they've been starting to feel to me... distant? Clustered with inkwells in wooden desks, student arithmetic on Roman wax diptych and drawn on Sumerian sand. The modern of the present, become the patinaed old, the before. The "oh my, people lived like that? How curiously odd."
https://www.catholic.com/magazine/online-edition/constantine...
(A remarkable feat, I might add, perhaps surpassing the first version in overcoming the "you're not in Asia" geopolitical handicap.)
> It’s true that Rome’s collapse reverberated widely, at least in the western – mostly European – half of its empire. (A shrinking portion of the eastern half, later known as Byzantium, survived for another millennium.)
> (A shrinking portion of the eastern half, later known as Byzantium, survived for another millennium.)
The latter are more compelling in a shallow analysis. The former are based on a lot of extrapolation, so I think the immediate impression many have is that they're based on wishful thinking / ideological fundamentalism.
The fall of Constantinople was more a matter that a variety of more advanced societies (Venice, the Turks, etc) were rising and the Byzantines were there, so why not loot them, as far as I understand the situation.
https://web.archive.org/web/20030930225420/http://www.the-or...
Personally I credit the printing press as the dividing line (yes I know the fall of Constantinople was at the same time).
Sometimes I idly think what would I invent if I was transported via mcguffin to ancient Rome. I'd invent paper and the printing press.
Nōn longa via est Rōmam, ubi habitat amīca mea pulchra. Nōn longa via est Rōmam, ubi habitat amīca mea pulchra. Per ātrium, ex ōstiō, ex vīllā, in templum, Tūsculō Rōmam, per agrōs et silvās, Viā Latīnā, per Portam Capēnam, cum rosīs et liliīs, cum nummīs sine dominō. Cantat Mēdus apud ōstium amīcae suae Lȳdiae.
Nōn longa via est Rōmam, ubi habitat amīca mea pulchra. Nōn longa via est Rōmam, ubi habitat amīca mea pulchra.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BmMauT_GejA
This is also a fine example of the classic Trimurti, the cycle of creation, maintaining, & collapse that defines existence. Rome flourished & became, but the world had been "stuck" with Rome for so long, had maintained it for so long, & it's presence was not leaving room for other acts of creation. This article largely asserts that destruction was necessary: Rome was facing a millennia+ old version of "The End of History" hypothesis. Which, to double back to the Trimurti, is against the cycle of creation & existence.
> Why don't I see down arrows?
> There are no down arrows on stories. They appear on comments after users reach a certain karma threshold, but never on direct replies.
but don't worry, the people who did have the karma to downvote also didn't decide to meet this bar either. still, would have been nice to hear from them. would be nice to hear from you. what makes you want to downvote?