News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by andrekandre on Thursday April 08, 2021 @06:44PM (#26744730)
from the article

  the U.S., Japan and Germany have asked Taiwan and South Korea, the two key chip manufacturing economies, to help prioritize chips for the automotive industry, which is crucial to the world economy. This has further squeezed production of semiconductors for consumer electronics and computer products.

does "crucial to the world economy" mean consumer supply of automobiles (a.k.a jobs) or industrial use like in trucks, forklifts etc??
Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by detaro on Thursday April 08, 2021 @06:47PM (#26744761)
It means "crucial to automotive industry in these 3 countries, and it's important to politicians in those countries to look like they support their automotive industry". They need to do something, and it's not like they can do anything substantial that'll fix the problem now, so letter on highest level asking nicely it is.
Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by mr_toad on Thursday April 08, 2021 @09:47PM (#26745907)
Crucial to the automotive industry -> crucial to their campaign funds.
Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by schraeds on Thursday April 08, 2021 @11:17PM (#26746334)
Crucial as in $100 of silicon enables a $30,000 dollar sale for auto instead of $3,000 for a computer
Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by genmud on Friday April 09, 2021 @12:51AM (#26746847)
And yet, the majority of the auto industry decided they should cancel their chip orders as soon as the pandemic hit because it might be an economic downturn.

Apple alone spends more money on semiconductors than the ENTIRE auto industry. They played stupid games and won stupid prizes with this chip shortage.

Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by jdsully on Friday April 09, 2021 @01:36AM (#26747052)
Their margins are much tighter than Apple’s. This outcome is far better than having a ton of unsold stock depreciating in dealer yards. That quickly leads to bankruptcy as it did in ‘08.

Limiting their downside risk was the right call given the information.

Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by tonyedgecombe on Friday April 09, 2021 @04:20AM (#26747973)
So now the auto manufacturers know they don't need to worry the next time it looks like there will be a downturn. They can cancel orders and if they turn out to be wrong just get on the phone to their favourite politician.
Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by profquail on Friday April 09, 2021 @08:22AM (#26749605)
Maybe more like: next time there’s a downturn, keep the orders if they can afford to. Having the chips on hand when the market picks up again could be a great investment, since they’ll be able to produce vehicles when their competitors can’t. Or they can sell some of the chips they’re holding to their competitors (at the going market rate).
Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by detaro on Friday April 09, 2021 @07:08AM (#26748986)
and then what? TSMC falls over itself because oh no, Merkel sent a letter, full focus on automotive chips? I doubt that has very much influence in how production is balanced.
Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by azinman2 on Thursday April 08, 2021 @11:33PM (#26746409)
But which provides more value to the economy over time? That such a large percentage of the economy was able to stop driving and work from home does say a lot about the value of computers today.
Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by Terretta on Friday April 09, 2021 @05:37PM (#26756523)
The iPad Pro with the trackpad keyboard is indeed more of a content consumption device than the typical office PC, but it's also more of a work creation device than the typical office PC, particularly if its user ever has to do work from a different chair.
Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by tablespoon on Thursday April 08, 2021 @11:59PM (#26746540)
> But which provides more value to the economy over time?

Probably the thing that's not another iPad (e.g. the luxury content consumption device).

Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by EvilEy3 on Friday April 09, 2021 @07:41AM (#26749234)
A) iPad costs 350$, it's not luxury by any means

B) iPad can be used for work, studying and much more, not only consumption

Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by mensetmanusman on Friday April 09, 2021 @07:43AM (#26749255)
But they are selling >10x the amount of phones, which are largely supporting a more important supply chain.
Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by izacus on Friday April 09, 2021 @07:50AM (#26749294)
Phones are only really relevant for one of those countries, and even there the actual manufacturing is outsourced to Asia.
Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by tlibert on Thursday April 08, 2021 @09:54PM (#26745942)
If politicians are incentivized to protect jobs that’s a good thing, no?
Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by thephyber on Thursday April 08, 2021 @11:25PM (#26746374)
I’m of the mind it is terrible.

How well did Wisconsin’s deal with FoxConn go? Politicians gave up something in the 7 figures per job that was ostensibly created on that project, but the state went into debt to do lots of the infra and the properties sit idle.

The F-35 is a defense project, but more than that, it is an unkillable jobs program distributed throughout nearly every Congressional district.

Politicians cite jobs created as if every “job” held equal weight. In fact, we have lost lots of salary jobs with benefits in the past decade, mostly replaced with independent contractor hours. Politicians don’t care because they are optimizing for the metric most commonly looked at.

Also, it creates a perverse incentive where no politician feels like they can ignore the bad metric because it is the good sound byte (a la “tough on crime” rhetoric when being consistent on crime is far more effective). Instead of working on healthier long term goals, they work on junk food goals.

Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by olliej on Thursday April 08, 2021 @10:16PM (#26746047)
depends - what if they favor a small industry over larger ones? (in the US the quintessential example is the coal industry vs. almost any other because of the insane way the government is elected)
Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by postingawayonhn on Thursday April 08, 2021 @06:49PM (#26744777)
It means it supports a lot of jobs. Large auto plants can directly employ 10,000+ people.
Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by azinman2 on Thursday April 08, 2021 @11:34PM (#26746411)
So do computers.
Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by tablespoon on Friday April 09, 2021 @12:06AM (#26746592)
>> It means it supports a lot of jobs. Large auto plants can directly employ 10,000+ people.

> So do computers.

Computers don't directly employ anyone, yet.

Nitpicking aside, the vast bulk of the jobs enabled by computers in the US, Japan, and Germany will be completely unaffected by computer production delays. I'm guessing there's far more auto than computer production in those countries, so auto production difficulties have a more immediate effect.

Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by azinman2 on Friday April 09, 2021 @02:17AM (#26747249)
Cars similarly don’t directly employ as they’re not sentient beings.

Computer production is just one part of the economic puzzle. The real question is what economic activity do computers and automobiles enable.

Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by tablespoon on Friday April 09, 2021 @03:08AM (#26747519)
> Cars similarly don’t directly employ as they’re not sentient beings.

Yes, but auto plants do directly employ people.

Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by azinman2 on Friday April 09, 2021 @05:43PM (#26756569)
As do tech companies and the factories that make their products. I fail to see why that’s relevant.
Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by nicbou on Friday April 09, 2021 @01:01PM (#26752998)
Cars are being manufactured in the above countries. You can likely name one automotive city in those countries. Wolfsburg, Stuttgart, Detroit, Fremont and so on. The US, Japan and Germany are the 2nd, 3rd and 4th largest automotive producers in the world.

Consumer electronics tend to be manufactured elsewhere, so far from these countries' respective electorates that slave labour could assemble them for all they care. Their jobs are not on these countries' list of priorities.

Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by azinman2 on Friday April 09, 2021 @05:45PM (#26756590)
Is software not manufacturing? How many software engineers are there in the US compared to auto workers?

All of this also ignores the larger economic picture— autos transport goods and people, computers are used to do work in nearly every field. They’re both instrumental to the economy.

Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by Shivetya on Friday April 09, 2021 @08:17AM (#26749555)
Well I do know the the fire in Japan which wiped out a very important plant resulted in BMW shipping a brand new motorcycle without TPMS or even its radio. Worse for my dealer, they were were only allocated three the entire year, a dealer where they expected two dozen of that model.

Crucial as a definition in that the downstream effects are massive.

Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by zsmi on Thursday April 08, 2021 @08:22PM (#26745408)
I saw that too and I wondered how they accomplished that. Can a commercial grade line be tweaked produce more automotive grade parts? Or were they forced to take down entire lines and retool them? If so, that would definitely have... repercussions.
Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by olliej on Thursday April 08, 2021 @10:18PM (#26746054)
The big issue is latency, as time from wafer entering a fab to chip coming out the other end can be in the order of months depending on complexity.
Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by Evan__ on Thursday April 08, 2021 @06:51PM (#26744789)
I'd guess it's skewed towards the former.
Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by golemiprague on Thursday April 08, 2021 @09:40PM (#26745879)
I think it is more crucial because most people only got the one car they need so once a car go out of use you need to immediatly manufactur a different one to fill up the gap.

With electronics it is a bit different, people hoard them and even if someone's tablet breakes there is a good chance that there is another one in the house or you can use a laptop instead or your phone or whatever.

Re:MacBook and iPad production delayed as supply crunch hits... by fakedang on Friday April 09, 2021 @06:42AM (#26748821)
I know of many people who have multiple cars but only one crucial electronic device that is a must-have. Your car can also likely be serviced faster than your computer or mobile phone, when either goes kaput. Your argument can go both ways.