News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by neolog on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:17PM (#26666147)
That's probably true everywhere. If you build for certain requirements, your building won't meet a different set of requirements.
Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by handmodel on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:27PM (#26666283)
I don't think this is true for the reasons listed, though. It isn't like they are illegal because they have old pipes or something. The interactive shows they are illegal because they are duplexes or apartments where now they only allow you to build single family homes.

I suppose you could go to smaller cities/towns and say that it would also be illegal to build apartments there - but the types of houses in suburban towns built 50 years are still very legal today.

Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by shados on Thursday April 01, 2021 @06:01PM (#26666716)
Yeah, that's why the title is kind of meaningless here. If you did the opposite (make it illegal to build single families in an area with only single families, to promote density), you'd end up with the exact same issue.

A title like "Zoning laws explicitly forbid increasing density" or something would be more interesting/accurate. Saying "X% of houses would be illegal OMGZ!", while true, is not particularly productive as it implies its bad, but the a solution using zoning to increase density could have the exact same headline.

Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by drewgross on Thursday April 01, 2021 @06:47PM (#26667220)
The map also explicitly lists "number of homes that would be illegal", presumably for that reason. If you make it illegal to build anything smaller than a duplex, on a lot that currently contains a single family home, the "number of illegal homes" on that lot is still zero.
Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by handmodel on Thursday April 01, 2021 @06:21PM (#26666965)
I'm aware of very limited cases in which there is minimum density zoning on lots. It is just that given a vacant lot within a demand area developers are going to naturally build the highest density legally allowed.

I'm fairly certain you could buy an apartment building in Manhattan, demolish it, and build a picket-fence house there. It was just lose you tens or hundreds of millions of dollars so no one has done it.

From what I can tell the way that interactive was constructed it would also highlight a lot if it fell into the category you mentioned but I can't find any where this is the case. It is a one-side problem and to pretend like it is two-sided is a bit detached from reality.

Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by varjag on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:30PM (#26666330)
That's also true in any old enough city and is probably what the GP means.
Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by modeless on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:20PM (#26666180)
> These buildings aren't illegal to build because of safety reasons or any construction deficiencies - they are only illegal due to regulations called zoning laws that San Francisco passed to restrict the density of housing in certain areas, originally to keep poor minorities out of white neighborhoods.
Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by shiftpgdn on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:21PM (#26666210)
You're going to need some sort of evidence to back that up. Most of the restrictions are around keeping current homeowner's values artificially inflated.
Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by pembrook on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:25PM (#26666261)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Housing_segregation_in_the_Uni...

"White communities are more likely to have strict land use regulations (and whites are more likely to support those regulations).[25][26] Strict land use regulations are an important driver of housing segregation along racial lines in the United States.[25]"

Further reading: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/american-political-s...

Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by neolog on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:25PM (#26666262)
Parent is quoting the original post which links to a document with sources.
Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by shiftpgdn on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:33PM (#26666366)
Source document is mainly empty conjecture.
Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by neolog on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:57PM (#26666649)
it's a link to a book
Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by api on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:25PM (#26666260)
Historically those two objectives are closely related, as people would worry that blacks moving into a neighborhood would decrease property values.
Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by themihai on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:30PM (#26666333)
>> blacks moving into a neighborhood would decrease property values.

I'm not from U.S but why would black people decrease property values? Isn't this really about poor people (that in the U.S are more likely to be black) decrease property values?

Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by api on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:33PM (#26666375)
It's because racist Americans don't want to live near blacks, reducing demand, and because of perception of blacks as always being poor.

Here's an example of the same house in the same neighborhood being appraised much higher when the appraiser didn't know there was a black occupant:

https://www.ktvb.com/article/news/nation-world/jacksonville-...

Money quote: "... because in the Black community, it’s just common knowledge that you take your pictures down when you’re selling the house."

Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by kbuchanan on Thursday April 01, 2021 @06:29PM (#26667042)
I'm reading this claim every day across so many subjects now—that the goal was racist in origin. Not knowing anything about SF myself, I am however tempted to ask if __classism__ is the better culprit. Classism can masquerade as racism (as in this example), creating the same outcomes, but it requires a different antidote to treat.
Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by jedberg on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:20PM (#26666196)
They point out in that post that Houston for example doesn't this problem because they have no zoning laws.

But also, the point is that SF keeps changing the rules. Places that don't change the rules as often won't have this problem.

Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by shiftpgdn on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:23PM (#26666237)
That's nonsense. Houston absolutely has the same problems and many many buildings and home that exist in Houston would also be illegal to build today under city ordinances. The reason Houston doesn't have the same degree of housing shortage is Houston has over 668 square miles of land (1779 square miles for Harris county) vs 40 for San Francisco.
Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by jedberg on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:40PM (#26666450)
You're confusing safety ordinances with land use.
Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by shiftpgdn on Thursday April 01, 2021 @06:00PM (#26666713)
Land use ordinances exist in Houston. To an extreme degree even. But its about how you build and not where. It's defacto zoning.
Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by colinmhayes on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:34PM (#26666383)
That definitely plays a big part, but banning high density housing is a major contributor to the problem SF is facing.
Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by imtringued on Friday April 02, 2021 @06:52AM (#26670427)
Geography prevents you from fleeing bad zoning.
Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by wyldfire on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:26PM (#26666282)
Is it a problem? Or is it awesome that they were able to raise the bar for newly constructed residences?

I've lived in newer homes over the last couple of decades. It's awesome to have smoke detectors in every room, grounded outlets, GFCI outlets, well-insulated windows and exterior walls, firewalls, plenum-rated cables, safe and easy-to-maintain plumbing.

The market would've only demanded a subset of these improvements. And the least expensive builders would've just built residences without them.

Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by mikeyouse on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:40PM (#26666448)
This isn't talking about lacking safety features that make the properties "illegal" to build -- they are referring to the minimum parking requirements, minimum lot setbacks, maximum height limits and other zoning restrictions that effectively legalized single family homes at the expense of all other varieties of housing. None of those things are connected to safety, only to NIMBYish ideals.
Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by jedberg on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:41PM (#26666460)
The article is about land use restrictions, not safety ordinances. Safety is great, but doesn't cause housing shortages.
Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by kazen44 on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:29PM (#26666318)
Also, because land is scarce and people need a place to live, houses will sell, regardless of their regulatory condition.

Also, newer homes are amazing in terms of heath retention and isolation. Having lived in buildings from before the war with either none of very little isolation.or even worse, i once lived in a home with a split in the wall thanks to a WW2 bmobin raid. The crack was not an issue in regards to the structural integrity, but it made isolation mood.

Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by Ericson2314 on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:46PM (#26666533)
No one is saying housing and building regulation is always bad; those are good!

It's just regulation promoting low density is bad.

Libertarians love this example to troll the statist left that the state can't be trusted to control things wisely, but I'm just happy to hope undoing these things can be bipartisan, because the real estate lobby is so strong it's needed.

Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by closeparen on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:26PM (#26666272)
You might naively expect a booming area to zone for more capacity over time, not less.
Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by ethagknight on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:42PM (#26666475)
Whoaaaaa whoa whoa, not in my backyard, pal! Build that stuff in THEIR backyard!

That’s the refrain.

Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by zip1234 on Thursday April 01, 2021 @08:10PM (#26667838)
This is why zoning is dumb. How do most cities zone? They draw borders around what is already there and make it a zone based on what is there. The first effect is to freeze those areas how they already are.

The places that are not built up get borders around them too. Those places are zoned for a particular use based on the wild ass guess of some elected officials. Since those elected officials cannot see the future, those wild ass guesses are often wrong.

Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by brudgers on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:39PM (#26666439)
Around the turn of the century, I worked for the city of St. Petersburg (FL). More than sixty percent of the single family housing was non-conforming to base flood elevation requirements. Much of what wasn't in the flood plane was non-conforming to zoning because people built on the high ground first.

And then there was Isla del Sol. Dredged from Boca Ciega Bay, it destroyed the incredibly productive fishery and is the reason the ACoE became involved in reviewing projects for environmental impact.

That's they way cities are. They build and learn.

Re:54% of San Francisco homes are in buildings that would be... by kazen44 on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:24PM (#26666253)
i would assume so. Atleast in my experience (in a northern european country with many 120> old houses) almost no houses are strictly "up to modern standards" in terms of building regulations. Usually it is something minor or energy inefficient. Using single pane windows for instance.

Most dangerous regulations are taken quite seriously however, Electrics are usually old(80's and later) but not ancient(pre-ww2 - reconstruction).

Water and gas supply is usually in good order because of the strict laws regarding those regulations.