News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by ecf on Thursday April 01, 2021 @03:29PM (#26664984)
Perhaps this is an idealistic and naive world view but internet connectivity _should_ transcend governments and be something that no one has control over and no one can shut down.
Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by brobdingnagians on Thursday April 01, 2021 @03:32PM (#26665019)
I like this point. The first question we should ask when someone develops a single switch to shut off an entire, critical piece of infrastructure is why? Who would need to do that? Whose interest is it for? Surely not the company, why would they stop serving their customers and go through the expense of making it easy to do that. There is no other reason to have and use that capability than to stop an entire population from communicating. No one has a good justified reason for wanting to do that. Corrupt reasons? Yes. But not any that are in the interest of a truly open, democratic society.
Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by karatinversion on Thursday April 01, 2021 @04:02PM (#26665330)
Well in this case, the order is from a military government, which locked up the elected politicians earlier this year and is shooting its people in the streets, so the boat on “a truly open, democratic society” has kind of sailed. It also suggests, to the people running the networks on the ground, that the military is very open to coming round and shooting you if you don’t shut it down.
Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by luckylion on Thursday April 01, 2021 @04:12PM (#26665444)
> The first question we should ask when someone develops a single switch to shut off an entire, critical piece of infrastructure is why?

They don't though. From a technical view point, they have the same "off switch" that every country has: boots on the ground, guns and trust that they'll use them. They didn't switch the internet off, they ordered the service providers to switch it off. Every country on earth can do that with the service providers that are running physical infrastructure in the country, it's harder for satellite internet.

There's absolutely no reason why the US, Germany or Switzerland couldn't do the same. They probably won't any time soon, but they can: all it takes is a few phone calls and the service providers' belief that they mean it.

Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by sedatk on Thursday April 01, 2021 @04:07PM (#26665384)
> why? Who would need to do that? Whose interest is it for?

"National security" is the blanket answer to all those questions.

Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by JTbane on Thursday April 01, 2021 @03:49PM (#26665191)
Because encryption exists, the internet can hopefully always stand as a transcendental entity.

VPNs, TOR, steganography and obfuscation are some of the best tools against tyranny.

Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by simplicio on Thursday April 01, 2021 @04:05PM (#26665366)
In this case, it sounds like they're physically shutting off the broadband wireless servers. Encryption seems unlikely to help if the actual connection is severed.
Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by bathtub365 on Thursday April 01, 2021 @03:56PM (#26665266)
These tools are useless if your tyrannical government cuts off access to the internet.
Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by karatinversion on Thursday April 01, 2021 @04:08PM (#26665396)
“The protesters are communicating using encryption. Take this $5 wrench and hit the network equipment with it until they stop.”
Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by rich_sasha on Thursday April 01, 2021 @04:10PM (#26665415)
They don’t protect against rubber hose cryptography, and that’s the biggest concern with oppressive governments.
Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by adwi on Thursday April 01, 2021 @04:30PM (#26665631)
Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by umvi on Thursday April 01, 2021 @03:36PM (#26665063)
If it's satellite based internet, there's no way to shut it off, especially if gateway is not in the same country. Of course, the government could always patrol around looking for antennas...
Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by packet_nerd on Thursday April 01, 2021 @04:15PM (#26665477)
I believe in practice the Tatmada keeps a tight grip on satellite Internet, and don't allow services that they don't control.

Remember, this is the country where one of the charges they brought against Aung San Su Kyi during the Feb coup was importing analog two-way radios. And more broadly, people are regularly arrested and imprisoned or sometimes executed for mere possession of radio equipment.

Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by helios_invictus on Thursday April 01, 2021 @03:44PM (#26665141)
It's quite easy to jam satellite comes, as well as locate them. The Tatmadaw has some US company built direction finding equipment.
Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by squarefoot on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:29PM (#26666323)
"It's quite easy to jam satellite comes"

That would literally require a man in the middle attack; the jammer should be kept between the antenna and the satellite, or very close to that position. I mean, it should be in the air.

"as well as locate them"

Possible, but not easy. A satellite dish can be buried, hidden under a camouflaging roof etc It's not like earth antennas that need the space around them free for pointing them; all they need is to see their satellite which is in the sky. One can dig a hole in the ground, put the dish down there pointed to the satellite, then when not in use park their truck above it, and good luck to the government helicopter passing above to track it. And btw, there are ways to build antennas that don't appear as such; they may offer worse performance but they do work, and satellite reflectors can be built that way too.

Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by tbihl on Thursday April 01, 2021 @09:51PM (#26668367)
The location finding would be by RF emissions, not visually.
Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by squarefoot on Friday April 02, 2021 @07:40AM (#26670608)
That's my point. A dish antenna is highly directional, so an tx/rx antenna pointed towards the sky can be detected/jammed effectively only by standing in between the antenna and the target it's pointed to, ie the satellite. It's not a thin line, but it's still a limited area, and the minor lobes of its radiation pattern produce a very faint signal which can become negligible by burying or covering most of the dish in all directions except the one it's aimed to.
Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by mycall on Thursday April 01, 2021 @09:22PM (#26668255)
It is also easy to detect the jamming stations and fire missiles from black-ops.
Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by ForHackernews on Thursday April 01, 2021 @03:50PM (#26665205)
You can easily jam or overpower a faint satellite signal with a local ground-based antenna.

Or you can shoot down your enemy's satellites and screw up the orbit so he can't launch any more.

Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by AnimalMuppet on Thursday April 01, 2021 @04:18PM (#26665510)
> Or you can shoot down your enemy's satellites and screw up the orbit so he can't launch any more.

Pretty sure Myanmar can't do that.

Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by ForHackernews on Thursday April 01, 2021 @06:26PM (#26667014)
Maybe not yet. Rockets keep getting cheaper and more accessible. Eventually you'll be able to buy a used SpaceX booster second hand for a few million.
Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by srg0 on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:34AM (#26669230)
Eventually you'll be able to buy a used rocket scientist for a few million.

Seriously, though, if the tech needs to be actively camouflaged and there's death penalty only for its possession, there's no way many people will use it. So it will be useless to inform and organize people, it will be useless to broadcast what's really happening inside.

Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by AnimalMuppet on Thursday April 01, 2021 @08:39PM (#26668008)
Targeting a satellite in orbit might be a bit harder than just reaching orbit, though...
Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by squarefoot on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:34PM (#26666381)
"You can easily jam or overpower a faint satellite signal with a local ground-based antenna."

Not doable unless either you are in between the dish and the satellite, or have an extremely powerful transmitter with its directional antenna pointed to the dish, where all that power is needed to cope with the fact that the maximum sensitivity of the dish is towards the satellite, not your jammer. Which also means that they need one jammer and its antenna for every dish they want to silence. That would not scale well.

Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by jasonjayr on Thursday April 01, 2021 @04:55PM (#26665900)
If the government is lawless enough that it will trample on the rights of the citizens, then the laws that prevent citizens from setting up wireless networks securely to recreate the internet backbone are null and void.

(With all the risks that comes with operating + defending a detectable RF emitter from the ground in a hostile environment)

If you want to work to prevent this, keep enough technology and know-how on hand that you could do this on short notice, even if's as simple flinging 5mb/s on a cantana a mile away.

Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by mycall on Thursday April 01, 2021 @09:21PM (#26668246)
This makes SpaceX even more interesting.
Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by abestic9 on Thursday April 01, 2021 @09:32PM (#26668301)
Not to take away from your point but I think you mean to say Starlink - it's a separate company.

Governments could block sales of the customer equipment, but once they're in it would be almost impossible to locate and confiscate them all.

They could order termination of service (based on coordinates or serial numbers), but there's no way for them to physically control that if the company refuses to do so.

Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by tbihl on Thursday April 01, 2021 @09:48PM (#26668355)
The service would be highly susceptible to DF of the outgoing traffic, but could probably be managed on the basis of set up, transmit, run away quickly before they find and arrest/kill you.
Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by femiagbabiaka on Thursday April 01, 2021 @03:31PM (#26665007)
Agreed. I'd love to work on solving this problem.
Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by knolax on Thursday April 01, 2021 @06:58PM (#26667328)
I will never understand the HN crowd's deification of the internet. Out of all the methods of communication out there it doesn't seem particularly special, and definitely not special enough to supercede the sovereignity of nations.
Re:Myanmar orders wireless internet shutdown until further n... by polypodiopsi on Friday April 02, 2021 @09:14AM (#26671144)
In this case the problem is that the sovereignity of the nation has been undermined by a military coup. Which is to say: Unless you believe in the rightfullness of the right of the stronger which in political terms would amount to believe into some elan vitale, a will of the biological organism of the people, some superstition of thinking blood and soil (which is to say a mob of antisocial males) to be the (metaphysical) being of what is considered the nationstate. (Some might also argue that the nationstate has had terrible consequences for the average worker in the dawn of modernity (that bit of history is probably specific to western history))

adding on this: I'd agree with the notion that it is weird that people fetishize the internet as some anarchic free entity when on a material level it is owned in big parts by private interest.