News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The case for trailer parks by chrisco255 on Thursday April 01, 2021 @04:27AM (#26657946)
As someone who has been living full time in a travel trailer in the past year, I would go even further than pushing for mobile home communities and push for blended mobile home / tiny house / RV communities. I'm currently in one in Austin and it's a blend of tiny houses, motorhomes, travel trailers, and mini hotels. It's a dynamic inventory of housing. It's a very flexible use of space, and each lot is less than 0.1 acres, but you still have access to common apartment amenities like pool, clubhouse, etc.

I could imagine more of allowing property owners to subdivide down to that scale would go far to solve affordability. Quality of construction in travel trailers, tiny houses, and mobile homes has improved compared to what they were 50-60 years ago when the trailer park trope was coined.

At any rate, I enjoy the flexibility of being able to hitch up my travel trailer and move locations in no time flat. It's been great during the pandemic to go visit national parks and get outdoors. I just see it as a no brainer. It shouldn't cost a quarter million minimum to lock in a nice location for yourself. You should be able to scoop up a 0.12 acre lot for a few thousand bucks and put a modular or travel trailer on it.

Re:The case for trailer parks by datavirtue on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:25AM (#26658279)
All of the most ideal places to do this have already outright banned any mention of it. I have property in an area (township) that is quasi-suburban (country but 30 min from "civilization") but has a zoning code that is so thoroughly constructed and exclusive that it would make your mouth drop.

Nevermind putting a trailer on your own property, that ain't happening, you can barely build a house.

Re:The case for trailer parks by Shivetya on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:42AM (#26658382)
Zoning pretty much dooms this where I live and many other places. One recent recommendation to allow tiny homes in Atlanta had the caveat, no mobile homes. They wanted housing that could not move. The Atlanta proposal was to permit them on lots that already have a home but not elsewhere.

Issues of utilities along with school load come to mind but those occur with any other dense housing. So why wouldn't apartments be better? To make it easier on residents with bad credit and such the utilities could be baked in to the rent and the state or city could offer to subsidize.

However what doomed many existing communities near me were property taxes. The land is more valuable for actual homes or in some cases businesses. With tiny/mobile homes as you propose your location may require local governments reducing the tax load to make the location affordable.

Re:The case for trailer parks by wil421 on Thursday April 01, 2021 @09:56AM (#26660554)
Why does Atlanta need tiny homes? We don’t have restrictive zoning policies and we can build out or up in most directions.

Brookhaven worked with developers to provide low income housing. They also provide legislation that doesn’t completely gentrify Brookhaven.

Re:The case for trailer parks by rektide on Thursday April 01, 2021 @01:22PM (#26663489)
Why? Kids that return to the nest. Grandparents that come to help. Grandparents that need help. Being able to rent out your property for additional income.

I live in DC and there was a flurry of activity, with neighbors forming housing cooperatives, getting together to build up. It's possible. At least, it used to be. You talk about upzoning as if it's sensible & straightforward, & tiny home or additional separate dwelling units are weird, but they're what's in reach for a lot of people.

I'd love to see a resurgence of coop housing developments. There's so many older row houses around here, way under-developed, and I think of how much value those folks are sitting on, if only they could work with each other, & find funding & trustworthy developers to do the job. In addition to construction costs, everyone's got to go find somewhere to live for a year while the place gets redeveloped, which is costly & disruptive. Another advantage to tiny houses &c.

Re:The case for trailer parks by yellowapple on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:59AM (#26658484)
Moving from property tax to land value tax would readily address that last point. This would incentivize turning unused land into tiny/mobile home parks - and would further incentivize residents cooperatively owning that land in order to reduce overhead to a bare minimum.
Re:The case for trailer parks by sokoloff on Thursday April 01, 2021 @06:28AM (#26658659)
Cramming more people into a land value taxed plot of land doesn’t address the school funding issue.

Taxes exist to provide services. Finding ways to structure housing to minimize local taxes is just squeezing a balloon.

Re:The case for trailer parks by yellowapple on Thursday April 01, 2021 @09:37AM (#26660352)
> Cramming more people into a land value taxed plot of land doesn’t address the school funding issue.

LVT itself addresses the school funding issue, since schools increase land value and therefore increase the tax revenues on that land value.

Re:The case for trailer parks by francisofascii on Thursday April 01, 2021 @06:42AM (#26658737)
Land value taxes help to prevent inflated real estate prices. The purpose is more than just providing services.
Re:The case for trailer parks by sokoloff on Thursday April 01, 2021 @07:45AM (#26659222)
When GP proposes using them to replace property taxes, they need to serve the role that property tax served.
Re:The case for trailer parks by chrisco255 on Thursday April 01, 2021 @08:40AM (#26659721)
Are schools underfunded right now? I'm not aware of any such issues in my state.
Re:The case for trailer parks by sokoloff on Thursday April 01, 2021 @08:47AM (#26659768)
a. That depends on who you ask. I think ours are adequately funded as well now.

b. My concern over school funding was if you cram more households into a given amount of tax, which was an explicit part of the strategy above, you create a school funding issue that wasn't there before. (I admit I was not explicit about that point and should have used another dozen words to make that clear.)

Re:The case for trailer parks by Spooky23 on Thursday April 01, 2021 @11:10AM (#26661411)
For the people on the internet who yak about LVT, it solves all problems.
Re:The case for trailer parks by yellowapple on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:40AM (#26669064)
Well yeah, because it does ;)
Re:The case for trailer parks by clairity on Thursday April 01, 2021 @11:31AM (#26661728)
> "The Atlanta proposal was to permit them on lots that already have a home but not elsewhere."

they implemented something similar here in southern california. the reason for this is to get homeowners on board, by giving them all the control and potential income from a proposal that nominally increases housing (giving politicians a 'win' without changing much).

the problem with this kind of policy is many-fold, but most egregiously it serves to intentionally lock out non-homeowners from both homebuying (by raising prices further) and homebuilding (by keeping buildable land off the market). it's literally designed to suppress class mobility and exclude the lower classes from homeownership. it also exacerbates homelessness, misallocates capital, and ultimately stagnates an economy.

instead, we need to overhaul zoning regulations, building codes/permitting processes, and tax policy (perhaps by land value principally) to encourage subdivision and construction.

Re:The case for trailer parks by kodah on Thursday April 01, 2021 @12:11PM (#26662408)
When I visited my folks out in Texas it was common to find RV and tiny home communities alongside suburban communities (I was in North Texas).

Meanwhile, out here in California people have outright banned parking of RVs or have made it so the parks are cast away from "desirable" areas. Especially around the Google campus in Mountain View people are particularly picky.

While I understand some of the common criticisms of RVs, I don't think people understand very well that I will probably never earn enough money to buy a California home but I do want a California salary. The delta between my home states compensation for software workers and what the Bay Area pays is extremely beyond cost of living, and lets me make up for years of not being able to save.

Re:The case for trailer parks by leoedin on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:41AM (#26658377)
Trailer parks feel like a symptom of zoning laws rather than the solution. They're a loophole in the rules which mandate low density large housing. Allow higher density prefabricated (but not "mobile") construction and trailer parks would become less attractive.

There's nothing fundamentally nicer about living in a very thin walled low quality "mobile" home rather than a more solid nicer "prefabricated" home on the same plot.

Re:The case for trailer parks by fredgrott on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:52AM (#26658449)
it's an equity trap as one does not own the land the 'house' is on and you own any right to live in the house through land ownership and thus can be forced out at anytime
Re:The case for trailer parks by thedracle on Thursday April 01, 2021 @10:42AM (#26661064)
This is the situation my Dad is in.

He owns the trailer, but the park jacks up the rent. So he's caught behind not being able to afford the cost to move his trailer, and the steadily increasing rent which is slowly driving him further into poverty.

I've tried to help him out of it, but he won't accept any help.

Re:The case for trailer parks by robert_foss on Thursday April 01, 2021 @06:06AM (#26658530)
Additionally mobile homes are not actually all that mobile after 20years. Relatedly they tend to lose value over time as opposed to permanent buildings.
Re:The case for trailer parks by lotsofpulp on Thursday April 01, 2021 @07:38AM (#26659159)
Permanent buildings also lose value over time, and you have to spend money to repair various portions of it at some point.
Re:The case for trailer parks by kube-system on Thursday April 01, 2021 @07:55AM (#26659313)
Permanent buildings typically only lose value if not maintained. The issue with many mobile homes is that they’re often designed in a way that is not easily maintainable.
Re:The case for trailer parks by lotsofpulp on Thursday April 01, 2021 @08:40AM (#26659713)
Newer buildings come with updated building codes and benefit from technological advances. Unless there is reason to believe the newer building was built with subpar quality materials or workmanship compared to an older building, the older building will be worth less.

https://www.trulia.com/research/new-or-existing-home/

> We found that that new homes (those built in 2013 or 2014) are typically priced 20% higher than older homes with similar attributes (e.g., square footage, bedrooms, bathrooms, etc.) and in the same zip code.

Another example is the higher tier hotel brands won’t sell you their branding to convert older buildings, you have to build new (unless you have a very desirable location, but that’s beside the point).

Also, the IRS lets you depreciate buildings, but not land:

https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-regs/depreciation_faqs_v2.pdf

I do not think the IRS would let people do that if they thought buildings maintained their value.

Re:The case for trailer parks by kube-system on Thursday April 01, 2021 @10:00AM (#26660600)
Maintenance, modifications, and repairs done to old homes are also done to updated building codes.

Trulia is partially measuring the fact that the set of homes that are 2 years old inherently contain ~zero homes that have fallen into disrepair.

Two houses 20 years apart in manufacture date that are similar in overall quality, rather than superficial MLS data, will not have a significant price differential.

Mobile homes are very different in this regard. A 40 year old traditional home may still have a lot of value, partially because they are sold with the land.

It is not uncommon for mobile homes to depreciate like a car, or worse. Perfectly livable but older mobile homes can sell for 4 or even 3 digit prices.

Re:The case for trailer parks by lotsofpulp on Thursday April 01, 2021 @10:42AM (#26661061)
Depends which 20 years we are talking about. Before and after lead paint/pipe/asbestos, as well as before/after some of the newer insulation and plumbing. Even in recent decades, there have been some significant advances in insulation quality, electrical standards, cat 6 wiring, heat pumps, etc.

Of course, mobile homes will depreciate much quicker than non mobile, but wear and tear and technological advances happen to old buildings nonetheless.

Re:The case for trailer parks by kube-system on Thursday April 01, 2021 @01:16PM (#26663405)
In the US, non-obvious environmental or code concerns are discovered during home inspections which are typically performed after a home is already under contract. I found a couple similar issues with my current home after I made an offer on it; they were fixed at the owners expense and didn’t affect the selling price.

Obvious deficiencies, like old mechanicals, are what I’m referring to by a home being “maintained”.

Mobile homes, on the other hand, are often exempt from many building codes and are notorious for their use of proprietary or non-standard parts. They’re throwaway construction.

Re:The case for trailer parks by throwaway0a5e on Thursday April 01, 2021 @09:55AM (#26660551)
>Newer buildings come with updated building codes and benefit from technological advances

Lol. The "updated code and technical advances" are part of what keeps the value of existing structures from losing value.

Between ever increasing setback rules and asinine code changes that preclude features people actually want (like electrical outlets that are easy to use) and waste ever increasing space (look at the code for stairways and doorway sizes over the years).

For everyone getting suckered into a modern spec home there's someone else buying something because you can't build whatever that something is anymore. This is even more true with commercial operations where you can buy a facility but you couldn't get a new facility through the permitting process.

Re:The case for trailer parks by lotsofpulp on Thursday April 01, 2021 @10:44AM (#26661086)
> Lol. The "updated code and technical advances" are part of what keeps the value of existing structures from losing value.

That is not evidenced by transaction data. There’s a few, mostly urban areas where older builds are valued due to not having to conform to modern codes, but certainly not representative of all existing structures versus new.

The easiest evidence I can offer is the IRS letting you deduct depreciation for buildings. Surely they would only do this if existing structures did lose value.

Re:The case for trailer parks by kube-system on Thursday April 01, 2021 @01:47PM (#26663800)
The IRS sometimes lets you depreciate that portion of a rental property which is the building itself or improvements, sure... but if we’re talking about homes - almost all of those buildings are physically attached and sold with land which is a component of those transactions.

In practice, people continually put money into permanent homes to update it, because their property as a whole is widely seen as an investment. It’s a package deal.

Mobile homes have none of this. They are not attached to land. The transactions in which they are transferred are not connected to land. They’re usually titled, and often sit on rented land.

Re:The case for trailer parks by michaelmrose on Thursday April 01, 2021 @12:36PM (#26662758)
Tax cuts are gifts for the wealthy. Starting with the premise that they are logical is extremely dubious.

Older buildings may be deemed worth less on average partially because not all are well maintained and many may trivially hide expensive problems due in part to defects in workmanship and in part due to defective or absent maintenance.

People will pay a premium not to deal with anyone else's problems or even a chance of same.

Re:The case for trailer parks by Broken_Hippo on Thursday April 01, 2021 @07:35AM (#26659137)
So, like an apartment, then? No real loss, considering the apartment is the alternative.

On the other hand, in many places I've lived, owning or renting a trailer was the closest folks can get to a house or the easiest/cheapest way to get a place with space.

Re:The case for trailer parks by klyrs on Thursday April 01, 2021 @11:42AM (#26661916)
Only you buy the house, so it's like an apartment but with a $50-$100k deposit that depreciates and when you move out, you don't get it back from the landlord, you sell it to the next tenant
Re:The case for trailer parks by Broken_Hippo on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @09:29AM (#26711501)
So?

And honestly, it isn't that much upfront. Generally cheaper than a house with monthly payments lower than rent, and that is including lot rent, if you have it. Total rent is generally cheaper than a like sized house if you are just renting. No shared walls. You can often have pets.

When your option is to rent part of a house, especially from a not-so-wonderful landlord, this is a nice option. It literally doesn't matter if you don't get your money back or if it doesn't seem like a good investment.

Few folks are in it for the investment, but honestly, most folks aren't really buying a house for the investment, but rather that they get some freedom and security (the bank won't kick you out for willy-nilly reasons: A landlord can simply decide not to renew your lease, at least in places with poor renter's protections). Quality of life things are important.

Re:The case for trailer parks by sixothree on Thursday April 01, 2021 @11:00AM (#26661274)
Except there are situations where a trailer sitting idle for some time loses ability to move to a new location.
Re:The case for trailer parks by Broken_Hippo on Tuesday April 06, 2021 @09:35AM (#26711547)
That's not really a consideration for most folks buying them, honestly. Even if they are physically able to move, the cost prohibits this. It is generally difficult to give them away.

None of this is a secret, either. Every poor person I knew that saw trailers as a better option than renting knew the downsides.

Re:The case for trailer parks by ncmncm on Thursday April 01, 2021 @03:22AM (#26657520)
If you have money to invest, you can do some easy good by buying or starting a trailer park, organized so you are selling the lots instead of renting them. Maybe loan residents money for the lot.

Get people to move from predatory rental lots, which they can, and will, with a little encouragement. It won't be a great good, but it is better than letting VCs and bankers hold your money, and you will be able to see the people you are helping.

Maybe put in a school kids can walk to, and a smallish grocery store. Make sure it's on a good bus route, with a county drug-counseling office and a community college on the same route. People want to improve their lives, and will when they can. But American life lately seems designed to grind them down.

Representing a bloc of votes can help get local government on their side, if they can be persuaded to vote for their own benefit.

Re:The case for trailer parks by dazc on Thursday April 01, 2021 @03:41AM (#26657635)
Sounds a great idea, in theory, but the problems begin when you add people; some of whom will not share your ideals or have respect for their neighbours.

Soon enough your ideal housing solution will become yet another place where decent people don't want to live.

Re:The case for trailer parks by ip26 on Thursday April 01, 2021 @12:05PM (#26662320)
I don't think you can build paradise this way. There will always be bad tenants. But you could still make life better for many people.
Re:The case for trailer parks by rel2thr on Thursday April 01, 2021 @10:44AM (#26661082)
I don’t see lot rentals as being predatory

Usually they are less than 500/month, that’s less than the property taxes on most home types and it covers amenities that the community has

Also most trailer park residents are not going to qualify for a traditional mortgage so the rental model opens it up to more people

Re:The case for trailer parks by ip26 on Thursday April 01, 2021 @12:01PM (#26662248)
I like the idea & have looked at it before. Unfortunately all except the smallest & most marginal seem to have been bought up by private equity.

It's allegedly somewhat volatile & the margins aren't amazing, which makes super-conglomerates that much harder to bid against.

Re:The case for trailer parks by dcolkitt on Thursday April 01, 2021 @07:58AM (#26659342)
Virtually no municipalities in America are approving new trailer parks.
Re:The case for trailer parks by ncmncm on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:53AM (#26669290)
A very great deal of US land is adjacent to municipalities, close enough in to benefit residents without requiring municipal approval for projects. One deals with the county, then. That makes it difficult to get town political representation unless someone hungers enough for the voting bloc to expand the municipal boundary to encompass the development.
Re:The case for trailer parks by habosa on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:29AM (#26658304)
This is some lazy math:

> A trailer park at 5 homes per acre and 2.5 people per household works out to 8,000 people per square mile, or more than twice as dense as Phoenix.

Well yes but a trailer park is just housing. What about streets, businesses, and open space? Nobody wants to live in an infinite trailer park even if it's an infinite luxury trailer park.

I actually think there's amazing potential for mixed-use commercial/residential space in a trailer park because the cost of starting a new business would be so low and you could even relocate your business over time.

But until the non-housing aspects are addressed a trailer park is just a cheap suburb, which isn't really inspiring.

Re:The case for trailer parks by Ensorceled on Thursday April 01, 2021 @06:35AM (#26658704)
This is my real objection to trailer parks ... it's still a suburb, just cheaper.

We shouldn't be building sprawling, energy inefficient, land destroying, isolating suburbs.

Grass is the largest irrigated "crop" in the US ...

https://www.businessinsider.com/americas-biggest-crop-is-gra...

Re:The case for trailer parks by lai-yin on Thursday April 01, 2021 @06:51AM (#26658801)
Every alternative to suburbs has its own serious problems.

People like living in suburbs. I like living in them. And maybe if we rebrand trailer parks as tiny home communities it will change attitudes about cheap, affordable homes.

Re:The case for trailer parks by culopatin on Thursday April 01, 2021 @07:19AM (#26658991)
I think allowing a mix of commercial with suburb would solve some of the issues we are having. I’m not from the US and I miss walking down to the store to get some staples (not a corner store, a real food store with more than milk and lottery).

Having a vegetable shop, a butcher, a hair salon, small town way is the way to go. You socialize with your neighbor while you wait, hear some gossip, get acquainted with your veggie guy so next time he picks up those dragon fruits you like, etc.

I currently have to drive 3 miles to get to a supermarket. All the “food stores” near me are in a somewhat industrial area across the train tracks and are ghetto. They only sell beer, maybe bread and lottery tickets, and are secured like a bank. Not the feeling you want.

My fancy neighborhood doesn’t have a single store. Not even a gas station. I’m forced to drive out. Not great.

Re:The case for trailer parks by Ensorceled on Thursday April 01, 2021 @08:24AM (#26659542)
Well, everything humans do at scale has serious problems, but how is, for instance, mixed use urban density worse than infinitely sprawling suburbs?
Re:The case for trailer parks by mobilene on Thursday April 01, 2021 @10:22AM (#26660824)
My grandparents retired from a giant house to a mobile home, in the early 1970s. They parked it on a small lake and Grandpa fished every day. They lived there for almost 20 years and it was a totally acceptable home.
Re:The case for trailer parks by ed25519FUUU on Thursday April 01, 2021 @12:33PM (#26662735)
Similar story with my grandparents. They put a pretty nice double-wide mobile home on about 3 acres and built a HUGE shop right next door. The mobile was more than enough living space for them, and the shop had everything my grandparents needed to tinker.
Re:The case for trailer parks by gcanyon on Thursday April 01, 2021 @11:10AM (#26661402)
“But there is nothing inherently bad about the humble trailer park.”

Apart from the attributes cited and discounted because mobile homes don’t technically have to be built that way, mobile homes are inherently not dense (alluded to by the article’s pivot to apartment buildings) and energy inefficient.

I’ve lived in apartment buildings in Bangkok, Seattle and New York — the power bills are disproportionately small compared to houses or mobile homes, and access to groceries, stores, and transit is far superior to any house or mobile-home-based development could support.

Re:The case for trailer parks by yboris on Thursday April 01, 2021 @12:07PM (#26662353)
I bought a "manufactured home" (aka mobile home) 920 square feet in New Jersey (rich area, 1 hr commute to NYC) for $50,000 with monthly rent (renting the land from the community) at $550/month. 6 years later rent is $600 (it's rent controlled so it stayed relatively low, at least for NJ) and I'm selling the house for about $90,000 (seller's market - got lucky). Most likely prices will drop, it's not typical for manufactured homes to appreciate in value.

But even if I lost money on the home, it was a beautiful place to live. All the people were home owners (they took care of their property). Was an excellent stepping stone as I couldn't have afforded anything, and renting would have been more expensive in the long term.

I highly recommend a manufactured home community. Just keep in mind the rent on land could go up a lot, unless there's rent-control (or some other arrangement, unsure).

Re:The case for trailer parks by ed25519FUUU on Thursday April 01, 2021 @12:32PM (#26662711)
This is interesting. Anecdotally, I notice that all of the trailer parks in the Bay Area seem to be 55+ communities.
Re:The case for trailer parks by yellowapple on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:55AM (#26658467)
> Mobile homes are made cheaply at present because they are aimed at the bottom of the housing market, but there's no reason they couldn't be made as high-quality as you like.

See also: "tiny homes".

But yeah, prefabricated housing definitely gets a bad rap. I'm pretty gung-ho about the idea of more buildings built from TEU-sized or FEU-sized building blocks - i.e. not necessarily converted intermodal containers (though container homes are cool, too), but blocks built to those dimensions and designed to be pieced together side-by-side or stacked together. Modular construction is one of the three "legs", I think, of driving down housing costs (the others being zoning reform - i.e. getting rid of artificial constraints against housing density or residential/commercial/industrial colocation - and the use of a land value tax to penalize land hoarding/speculation and incentivize denser development).

Re:The case for trailer parks by sevensor on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @09:43AM (#26634517)
This is one of those positions that's so obvious, I struggle to articulate what the contrary position would even be. And yet, my community continues to squeeze out its trailer parks, even though I live in an area with plenty of land. Usually the former trailer park sits vacant for 3-8 years after the evictions are done.
Re:The case for trailer parks by throwaway0a5e on Thursday April 01, 2021 @10:27AM (#26660894)
Ask the HN demographics what "good poors" live like (though you'll have to be more tactful than that to get a real answer) and you'll probably get some answer about a cheap apartment in a city, maybe with roommates, taking public transit, etc. When the smoke and drink they do it inside. Their kids play video games or go to the park. When they want extra money they pick up another job. You get the picture. They're out of sight and out of mind.

The trailer park life is pretty much the opposite of that. Poors that have space, even if just the small space of a trailer sized lot, use it efficiently. They have 1.x cars per person because 1 isn't enough redundancy. They hang their laundry on a clothes line. They litter their lawn with "unsightly" stuff they're flipping for extra cash. They sit around drinking beer while burning something in an old washing machine drum.

It's the same old superiority complex and desire to tell other people how to live that's plagued humanity for all of history.

Re:The case for trailer parks by gnopgnip on Thursday April 01, 2021 @03:38AM (#26657615)
The article doesn't really clarify the difference between trailer parks where the residents own the lot and home, just the home, or the landlord owns everything. The latter is just renting. The middle one here is not really affordable. Owning the land is ideal, but in most of the country you can't do this in a mobile home park, you need to buy a relatively large lot. At that point you have a lot of the same issues with single family homes in developing area, the infrastructure/future maintenance is more expensive than people expect and eventually that will need to be dealt with.
Re:The case for trailer parks by cowsandmilk on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:14AM (#26658223)
There is an existing legal framework for multiple owners sharing a lot, condominiums. That isn’t the barrier. Zoning excluding mobile homes is the barrier.
Re:The case for trailer parks by gnopgnip on Friday April 02, 2021 @01:46AM (#26669271)
It is both zoning and permitting. Most of the desirable parts of the US have exclusionary zoning and permitting and would not allow a condo HOA of mobile/manufactured homes to form today
Re:The case for trailer parks by brudgers on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @01:19PM (#26637430)
The contrary position is public housing.

If you desire non-market rate housing, it's the only solution. Because by definition, the market will always produce market rate housing.

Re:The case for trailer parks by imtringued on Thursday April 01, 2021 @03:03AM (#26657423)
The article argues for a public housing model for trailer parks. Because of the pseudo ownership model where you don't own the land but still own a house sitting on the property that is expensive to move, the operator of the trailer park can just increase rates. It's exploitative compared to the rental market. You basically lose your housing investment unless you can find another trailer park and you can afford the moving fees. Renters can just move on to the next apartment.
Re:The case for trailer parks by Spooky23 on Thursday April 01, 2021 @07:28AM (#26659087)
It’s often nastier, because the trailer is often rent to own or mortgaged by the owner. It’s a depreciating asset, so these arrangements are often exploitive, and the more slumlordy types will find ways to get liens on the trailer.
Re:The case for trailer parks by DubiousPusher on Thursday April 01, 2021 @03:13AM (#26657473)
I'd like to think if funded properly, public housing would improve but I'm not confident. I grew to in a trailer in a trailer park and honestly, it was good for my family. We had 3 loud, boisterous, boys living together and we needed our own four walls. I think it's fair to say subsidizing this kind of private housing might be a bit selfish. After all, why does everyone in a park get a yard when people are just trying to find a studio or a rentable room just to work in the city?

But I think that's the wrong question for two reasons.

1) The choice isn't usually between dense urban developments or trailer parks. I don't even think this type of land use comes into conflict all that much. Occasionally a park is shut down to build a shopping center but most parks are at the edge of cities. They are not usually blocking density. 2) It goes beyond market rate housing. Parks are often limited or banned. Perhaps encouraging parks is manipulating the market but so is what is happening now by law.

Re:The case for trailer parks by imgabe on Thursday April 01, 2021 @03:06AM (#26657435)
Public housing has most of the same problems - poorly maintained, high crime rate.
Re:The case for trailer parks by throwmxncj on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:55AM (#26658466)
Re:The case for trailer parks by mjevans on Thursday April 01, 2021 @02:42AM (#26657295)
Alternately, engineer the conditions of the market to achieve the desired result... rather than engineering the conditions of the market to preserve what's already been built at the cost of future (now current) generations who have no where to call home and establish value or community.
Re:The case for trailer parks by DubiousPusher on Thursday April 01, 2021 @02:55AM (#26657368)
I mostly agree but I think it's important to have perspective that things like historicity or the quality of a neighborhood can be a public good. And a democratic population might choose to invest in such a public good. Obviously it would be better though if the coat of these public goods were being paid more directly by the public and not externalized onto those living most precariously.
Re:The case for trailer parks by lotsofpulp on Thursday April 01, 2021 @07:44AM (#26659217)
> the quality of a neighborhood can be a public good. And a democratic population might choose to invest in such a public good.

This manifests as keeping poorer people out by restricting zoning to larger plots of land and detached single family homes, which also has a nice side effect of making cars a necessity. Everyone wants to live around others at or above their own socioeconomic level.

Re:The case for trailer parks by DubiousPusher on Thursday April 01, 2021 @08:54PM (#26668101)
I agree. But the solution is not to throw out all considerations and give developers their way. There must be a way to balance the interests of those who want a neighborhood to remain a nice place to live with open space, gardens and services while also preventing Nimbys from filibustering density.
Re:The case for trailer parks by imtringued on Thursday April 01, 2021 @03:07AM (#26657441)
You can have that to a certain extend. When people are saying you should build more they don't mean modern style 10 story buildings next to a single family home. They mean a duplex or triplex that fits in with the rest of the neighborhood or a 2-3 story apartment with a nice facade that is in the spirit of the neighborhood.
Re:The case for trailer parks by DubiousPusher on Thursday April 01, 2021 @03:17AM (#26657491)
Uh, I think it's both. Have you been to Houston TX? Housing is cheap there for a large city. They also happen to often have 10 story buildings right up next to single family homes.
Re:The case for trailer parks by dublinben on Thursday April 01, 2021 @01:24PM (#26663524)
Houston is only a "cheap" city if you look at housing costs but not transportation costs. The ridiculous sprawl of Houston increases transportation costs so much that it is actually less affordable than "expensive" cities like New York City.[0][1] This doesn't even take into account the externalities of the higher emissions that come from living in a car-dependent place.

[0] https://htaindex.cnt.org/fact-sheets/?lat=29.7604267&lng=-95...

[1] https://htaindex.cnt.org/fact-sheets/?lat=40.7127753&lng=-74...

Re:The case for trailer parks by DubiousPusher on Thursday April 01, 2021 @08:50PM (#26668076)
I'm not making the case that Houston is a good solution to the housing problem. My whole point is that Houston is evidence of what happens when you ignore most preferential factors and just build. I've enjoyed visiting there but the city is aesthetically unappealing, feels vacant of community and yes is a nightmare to traverse.
Re:The case for trailer parks by captainmuon on Thursday April 01, 2021 @03:23AM (#26657524)
Public housing is one option. Or you have to counter the price hikes. Prices are rising in many parts of the world because people are investing more and more money in housing, as an alternative to stocks or other investments. The expected returns mainly come from the rise in value, and not from the rent income. So the companies holding the houses must get rid of the existing tenants and renovate the appartments to increase their market value.

Basically, private investments currently don't create much housing, they destroy affordable housing. So you need to create incentives to maintain and expand the affordable segment.

Re:The case for trailer parks by lmm on Thursday April 01, 2021 @03:29AM (#26657567)
> The expected returns mainly come from the rise in value, and not from the rent income. So the companies holding the houses must get rid of the existing tenants and renovate the appartments to increase their market value.

Nah. Housing rises in value even if you don't touch it. Demand is rising and supply isn't. The solution is to make it easier to build more.

Re:The case for trailer parks by brudgers on Thursday April 01, 2021 @04:13AM (#26657846)
The market prefers higher priced housing over lower priced. When there is demand for higher price housing the market builds housing. When there is not demand for higher priced housing the market tends to wait out the down cycle.

The market has no preference for building unprofitable housing. Bankers don’t have enthusiasm for loaning money to build it either.

Finally housing is one of the less profitable real estate development types. That’s why commercial property often sits vacant...the long term ROI from sitting out low demand is better than conversion in the present.

Re:The case for trailer parks by lmm on Thursday April 01, 2021 @10:49PM (#26668613)
> The market prefers higher priced housing over lower priced. When there is demand for higher price housing the market builds housing. When there is not demand for higher priced housing the market tends to wait out the down cycle.

It's not the market, developers don't building cheap housing because regulations generally make it illegal.

> The market has no preference for building unprofitable housing. Bankers don’t have enthusiasm for loaning money to build it either.

Sure, but profitable isn't the same thing as expensive. "Pile 'em high, sell 'em cheap" is a perfectly valid business model that bankers and businesspeople alike are happy to follow. But when the planning rules make it so expensive to build anything at all, building expensive housing is the only way to make a profit.

Re:The case for trailer parks by Spooky23 on Thursday April 01, 2021 @07:25AM (#26659060)
It’s pretty obvious if you look into the issue at all. Trailer parks are modern tenements, and the abusive practices of the owners usually make it a home of last resort.

Most of them predate modern zoning or other laws in the jurisdiction as well, so they are usually an environmental nightmare, often with unsafe wells, or off-code sewers that release sewage.

Re:The case for trailer parks by michaelt on Thursday April 01, 2021 @07:13AM (#26658943)
> This is one of those positions that's so obvious, I struggle to articulate what the contrary position would even be.

The UK has a housing crisis, but it's not due to the cost of constructing the house - it's due to the cost of land with planning permission.

If the cost of a conventional home is 75% land, construction costs are almost irrelevant: Nobody's going to buy a £325,000 trailer in preference to a £400,000 conventional home.

Re:The case for trailer parks by sneak on Thursday April 01, 2021 @04:58AM (#26658131)
There's a much, much better case for apartment buildings, but those increasingly can't be built in places people want to live, so I guess the US is going to have to figure out how to make the cheapest possible low-density detached housing. Trailers and RVs and other manner of tiny-house shantytowns fit that bill.

Shame there can't be population density growth in cities.

Re:The case for trailer parks by Ensorceled on Thursday April 01, 2021 @06:45AM (#26658764)
Livable population density requires public services and common spaces like low cost transit, mixed use diversity (especially local shopping), green spaces, etc.

The US, in its current form, may be incapable of building anything that would be considered a common good.

Re:The case for trailer parks by goatcode on Thursday April 01, 2021 @11:28AM (#26661677)
> supposedly full of disgusting poor people and criminals, and run by slumlords who skimp on maintenance.

Interestingly, back when housing was more affordable, they were, for that reason (using the lingo, of course not judging people). The people who were disadvantaged enough to not be able to enter into the "normal" housing market would have had rough enough lives that it would have manifested in the ways that might have caused others to label them as "disgusting, poor people," and because they would have had few other options, those that operated the parks could easily take advantage of them.

Now, however, the image is perhaps what perpetuates the culture of trailer parks in some areas. People who have a choice go elsewhere, instead of bringing their advantages and positive influences into certain places, do so even it's not overall optimal to their lives, because of an old heuristic. It might be a good financial decision (which I myself have taken advantage of) for people who are less able to afford typical housing, but they may avoid it because of the stigma, and the cycle continues.

This is a neat article, and I believe an important one. When we get together with people whose lives and circumstances differ, we all can potentially benefit.

Re:The case for trailer parks by yboris on Thursday April 01, 2021 @01:42PM (#26663735)
New York Times did a "Rent or Buy" calculator. With the prices of manufactured (mobile) homes so low, it's usually a no-brainer to do that instead of renting:

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/upshot/buy-rent-cal...

Re:The case for trailer parks by kube-system on Thursday April 01, 2021 @02:56PM (#26664620)
That calculator doesn't reflect the reality of ownership for a mobile home, though. You can't mortgage them, and they're not attached to land. You either need to rent land (in which case you're back to square one, where you're really renting), or purchase land that allows it, which often means a longer commute.
Re:The case for trailer parks by yboris on Thursday April 01, 2021 @03:05PM (#26664731)
Incorrect - you can mortgage them. You just need lenders that do it. Our community recommends 4 lenders that all do mortgages on these properties. The APR is higher than conventional, but it can still be worth it.
Re:The case for trailer parks by citizenpaul on Thursday April 01, 2021 @02:56PM (#26664616)
They might as well argue the case for people to not act badly.

Trailer parks are bad because they are the lowest cost lowest effort housing widely available. By definition the worst of people are going to flock there. Which of course means anyone decent is going to seek a better place even at a cost of more work and money to themselves.

Re:The case for trailer parks by andrewfromx on Thursday April 01, 2021 @03:00AM (#26657397)