News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The case for trailer parks by chrisco255 on Thursday April 01, 2021 @04:27AM (#26657946)
As someone who has been living full time in a travel trailer in the past year, I would go even further than pushing for mobile home communities and push for blended mobile home / tiny house / RV communities. I'm currently in one in Austin and it's a blend of tiny houses, motorhomes, travel trailers, and mini hotels. It's a dynamic inventory of housing. It's a very flexible use of space, and each lot is less than 0.1 acres, but you still have access to common apartment amenities like pool, clubhouse, etc.

I could imagine more of allowing property owners to subdivide down to that scale would go far to solve affordability. Quality of construction in travel trailers, tiny houses, and mobile homes has improved compared to what they were 50-60 years ago when the trailer park trope was coined.

At any rate, I enjoy the flexibility of being able to hitch up my travel trailer and move locations in no time flat. It's been great during the pandemic to go visit national parks and get outdoors. I just see it as a no brainer. It shouldn't cost a quarter million minimum to lock in a nice location for yourself. You should be able to scoop up a 0.12 acre lot for a few thousand bucks and put a modular or travel trailer on it.

Re:The case for trailer parks by datavirtue on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:25AM (#26658279)
All of the most ideal places to do this have already outright banned any mention of it. I have property in an area (township) that is quasi-suburban (country but 30 min from "civilization") but has a zoning code that is so thoroughly constructed and exclusive that it would make your mouth drop.

Nevermind putting a trailer on your own property, that ain't happening, you can barely build a house.

Re:The case for trailer parks by Shivetya on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:42AM (#26658382)
Zoning pretty much dooms this where I live and many other places. One recent recommendation to allow tiny homes in Atlanta had the caveat, no mobile homes. They wanted housing that could not move. The Atlanta proposal was to permit them on lots that already have a home but not elsewhere.

Issues of utilities along with school load come to mind but those occur with any other dense housing. So why wouldn't apartments be better? To make it easier on residents with bad credit and such the utilities could be baked in to the rent and the state or city could offer to subsidize.

However what doomed many existing communities near me were property taxes. The land is more valuable for actual homes or in some cases businesses. With tiny/mobile homes as you propose your location may require local governments reducing the tax load to make the location affordable.

Re:The case for trailer parks by wil421 on Thursday April 01, 2021 @09:56AM (#26660554)
Why does Atlanta need tiny homes? We don’t have restrictive zoning policies and we can build out or up in most directions.

Brookhaven worked with developers to provide low income housing. They also provide legislation that doesn’t completely gentrify Brookhaven.

Re:The case for trailer parks by rektide on Thursday April 01, 2021 @01:22PM (#26663489)
Why? Kids that return to the nest. Grandparents that come to help. Grandparents that need help. Being able to rent out your property for additional income.

I live in DC and there was a flurry of activity, with neighbors forming housing cooperatives, getting together to build up. It's possible. At least, it used to be. You talk about upzoning as if it's sensible & straightforward, & tiny home or additional separate dwelling units are weird, but they're what's in reach for a lot of people.

I'd love to see a resurgence of coop housing developments. There's so many older row houses around here, way under-developed, and I think of how much value those folks are sitting on, if only they could work with each other, & find funding & trustworthy developers to do the job. In addition to construction costs, everyone's got to go find somewhere to live for a year while the place gets redeveloped, which is costly & disruptive. Another advantage to tiny houses &c.

Re:The case for trailer parks by yellowapple on Thursday April 01, 2021 @05:59AM (#26658484)
Moving from property tax to land value tax would readily address that last point. This would incentivize turning unused land into tiny/mobile home parks - and would further incentivize residents cooperatively owning that land in order to reduce overhead to a bare minimum.
Re:The case for trailer parks by sokoloff on Thursday April 01, 2021 @06:28AM (#26658659)
Cramming more people into a land value taxed plot of land doesn’t address the school funding issue.

Taxes exist to provide services. Finding ways to structure housing to minimize local taxes is just squeezing a balloon.

Re:The case for trailer parks by yellowapple on Thursday April 01, 2021 @09:37AM (#26660352)
> Cramming more people into a land value taxed plot of land doesn’t address the school funding issue.

LVT itself addresses the school funding issue, since schools increase land value and therefore increase the tax revenues on that land value.

Re:The case for trailer parks by francisofascii on Thursday April 01, 2021 @06:42AM (#26658737)
Land value taxes help to prevent inflated real estate prices. The purpose is more than just providing services.
Re:The case for trailer parks by sokoloff on Thursday April 01, 2021 @07:45AM (#26659222)
When GP proposes using them to replace property taxes, they need to serve the role that property tax served.
Re:The case for trailer parks by chrisco255 on Thursday April 01, 2021 @08:40AM (#26659721)
Are schools underfunded right now? I'm not aware of any such issues in my state.
Re:The case for trailer parks by sokoloff on Thursday April 01, 2021 @08:47AM (#26659768)
a. That depends on who you ask. I think ours are adequately funded as well now.

b. My concern over school funding was if you cram more households into a given amount of tax, which was an explicit part of the strategy above, you create a school funding issue that wasn't there before. (I admit I was not explicit about that point and should have used another dozen words to make that clear.)

Re:The case for trailer parks by Spooky23 on Thursday April 01, 2021 @11:10AM (#26661411)
For the people on the internet who yak about LVT, it solves all problems.
Re:The case for trailer parks by yellowapple on Friday April 02, 2021 @12:40AM (#26669064)
Well yeah, because it does ;)
Re:The case for trailer parks by clairity on Thursday April 01, 2021 @11:31AM (#26661728)
> "The Atlanta proposal was to permit them on lots that already have a home but not elsewhere."

they implemented something similar here in southern california. the reason for this is to get homeowners on board, by giving them all the control and potential income from a proposal that nominally increases housing (giving politicians a 'win' without changing much).

the problem with this kind of policy is many-fold, but most egregiously it serves to intentionally lock out non-homeowners from both homebuying (by raising prices further) and homebuilding (by keeping buildable land off the market). it's literally designed to suppress class mobility and exclude the lower classes from homeownership. it also exacerbates homelessness, misallocates capital, and ultimately stagnates an economy.

instead, we need to overhaul zoning regulations, building codes/permitting processes, and tax policy (perhaps by land value principally) to encourage subdivision and construction.

Re:The case for trailer parks by kodah on Thursday April 01, 2021 @12:11PM (#26662408)
When I visited my folks out in Texas it was common to find RV and tiny home communities alongside suburban communities (I was in North Texas).

Meanwhile, out here in California people have outright banned parking of RVs or have made it so the parks are cast away from "desirable" areas. Especially around the Google campus in Mountain View people are particularly picky.

While I understand some of the common criticisms of RVs, I don't think people understand very well that I will probably never earn enough money to buy a California home but I do want a California salary. The delta between my home states compensation for software workers and what the Bay Area pays is extremely beyond cost of living, and lets me make up for years of not being able to save.