News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by audunw on Sunday March 28, 2021 @11:32AM (#26611177)
What the hell is is with cryptocurrency proponents and trying to redefine words to suit their narrative? First Bitcoin was NOT fiat currency (despite being one of the most fiat currencies by definition), then it was also a store of value (despite it being a horrible store of value, a high-risk high-reward investment is more accurate). Now it's supposed to be a battery? When the energy being put into it is basically pure waste?

There is no way to make aluminum other than putting huge amounts of energy. Aluminum has value to everyone in some way, not just those invested in it. There are plenty of ways to do digital transactions, or even to do proof-of-work cryptocurrency (if you feel that's necessary), besides using Bitcoin. With aluminum you can even reverse the process and use it as an actual battery. With Bitcoin you can't. The energy is burned forever.

I really do think cryptocurrency and block-chain technology is cool. But the level of hype and double-think is getting insane.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by bryanrasmussen on Sunday March 28, 2021 @11:50AM (#26611320)
You need to have a triadic understanding of bitcoin, this is what allows it to be a flat currency, a store of value, and a battery at both one and the same time, through the act of transubstantiation of the coin a quantum state is triggered that allows the individual coin to choose which form it will manifest itself as.
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by pyinstallwoes on Monday March 29, 2021 @02:30AM (#26618286)
You're spot on, in fact, the superposition is key. You see, bitcoin is actually a time machine. Every block entangles itself with a coordinate in spacetime. This allows anyone in the future to relive any moment in the past by just entering the block number they want to visit.

Unfortunately, this same architecture gave birth to both artificial intelligence because of the way it mimics DNA, and a black hole. The inevitable faith of a configuration of matter permeating all spacetime is the end of the universe.

Thank you bitcoin, the worst ecological disaster, like, ever!

At least we got AI and a Blackhole.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by bryanrasmussen on Monday March 29, 2021 @07:06AM (#26619951)
I agree 100%, but wait - is this theory following the Bitcoin Time Machine Cryptocurrency Adventist Council of 2020 or the Bitcoin Time Machine Cryptocurrency New Revelation of 2019?
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by pyinstallwoes on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @02:46AM (#26631790)
Was it only two options? I thought the Vogon's branched into "Catuskoti as a Non-Deterministic Way to Handle Options Deterministically" - I thought there was at _least_ the "Council of A New World: 0 BCAD" and "Council of Thoth was First"

Oh well, on my timeline I hung out with Thoth.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by sgt101 on Sunday March 28, 2021 @02:01PM (#26612566)
You had me there!
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by viklove on Monday March 29, 2021 @12:19PM (#26624119)
It's interesting how your comment hasn't been flagged into the ground and garnered a response from dang. I guess sarcastic flamebait is OK when it agrees with the HN hivemind.

(meanwhile, my comment will be flagged in 3... 2... 1...)

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by funkychicken on Sunday March 28, 2021 @12:33PM (#26611683)
I wish I could give this comment HackerNews Gold.
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by bryanrasmussen on Sunday March 28, 2021 @01:43PM (#26612368)
I'm actually surprised at the reception, I was expecting a -3, but I wanted to say it anyway.
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by bob1029 on Sunday March 28, 2021 @03:17PM (#26613299)
Parody & sarcasm are very effective tools for illustrating how hyperbolic a situation has become.
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by capableweb on Sunday March 28, 2021 @12:20PM (#26611564)
> I really do think cryptocurrency and block-chain technology is cool. But the level of hype and double-think is getting insane.

I agree with this, the amount of hype makes it hard to find the true innovations in the space, because most of it is honestly shit.

> There are plenty of ways to do digital transactions

Yes, but Bitcoin was not initially made to just "do digital transactions". It was made to be able to do digital transactions without any trusted 3rd party. The distinction is important, because that's why Proof of Work exists and is energy intensive in the first place.

Now a couple of years into blockchain technology, we have some alternatives that _might_ work as well as Proof of Work (Proof of Stake for example) but we've yet to see if it actually can work on the scale that Bitcoin operates in. Time will tell.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by danShumway on Sunday March 28, 2021 @12:47PM (#26611822)
> It was made to be able to do digital transactions without any trusted 3rd party.

Which is what makes it even more absurd that people are claiming that adding centralized layers on top of Bitcoin is a valid solution to the cost and speed of transactions.

They're devoted to Bitcoin itself above any of the reasons why the technology was built in the first place. But if people don't actually care about having distributed payments, and if they're perfectly willing to buy into payment processors that are only using Bitcoin as a store-of-value in the backend, then Proof of Work doesn't matter.

Proof of Work/Stake only matter if Bitcoin is actually being used as a trustless and anonymous payment system for regular transactions, which is ironically the task that (among most other cryptocurrencies on the market) it's perhaps least suited for technologically.

I'm not saying there's no innovation here. I am saying that I don't see any evidence that Bitcoin's largest proponents care about that innovation. I don't see any evidence that any of this matters beyond giving them an excuse to hype a speculative asset. If they did care, they would have abandoned Bitcoin and moved to basically any other coin -- anything at all that did Proof of Stake to reduce transaction fees and environmental costs, or that fixed its price to the dollar, or that had better privacy.

I firmly believe at this point that the technology of Bitcoin matters to the majority of its investors about as much as the technology of Beanie Babies mattered to its investors. That's not to say the technology isn't interesting or that it can't be used in useful ways, but most of the time that people talk about Bitcoin's success, they're not talking about technology.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by capableweb on Sunday March 28, 2021 @01:00PM (#26611969)
> I'm not saying there's no innovation here. I am saying that I don't see any evidence that Bitcoin's largest proponents care about that innovation. I don't see any evidence that any of this matters beyond giving them an excuse to hype a speculative asset. If they did care, they would have abandoned Bitcoin and moved to basically any other coin -- anything at all that did Proof of Stake to reduce transaction fees and environmental costs, or that fixed its price to the dollar, or that had better privacy.

To be fair, a large part of the ecosystem doesn't actually deal with Bitcoin at all. The total market capitalization of cryptocurrencies seems to reach up to 1.5T USD at this point. Bitcoin is 1T USD of that, with the rest of the ecosystem quickly catching up[1]

It's really hard to generalize that everyone in any given ecosystem are the same way or act with the same interest. Yes, most people in the oil industry probably don't care about the environment either, but I'm sure there are many in the oil industry who actually care about the environment as well. Same goes for cryptocurrencies.

- [1] "Percentage of Total Market Capitalization (Dominance)" graph - https://coinmarketcap.com/charts/

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by verdverm on Sunday March 28, 2021 @02:37PM (#26612920)
BTC at times has had less than 50% of the total market value, so if it is now 2/3, then the rest of the market has lost ground, the opposite of catching up
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by danShumway on Sunday March 28, 2021 @01:35PM (#26612293)
That's fair, but how much of that 33% of the overall cryptocurrency ecosystem is going onto forums and arguing specifically about Bitcoin?

I don't necessarily want to generalize about all cryptocurrencies or all crypto-enthusiasts -- there is genuinely interesting technology here. But I find it increasingly hard not to generalize about the subset that shows up in these discussions arguing that Bitcoin is the future.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by pcthrowaway on Sunday March 28, 2021 @02:32PM (#26612875)
> Proof of Work/Stake only matter if Bitcoin is actually being used as a trustless and anonymous payment system for regular transactions, which is ironically the task that (among most other cryptocurrencies on the market) it's perhaps least suited for technologically.

I agree that many cryptocurrencies are not suited for this... but some are, and of those, Cardano is proof-of-stake from launch, has ~50 billion USD market cap, 20s to 1 minute confirmations (up to 10 for complete irreversibility, but one confirmation is really reliable already), an amazing community, relatively low fees (about $0.20 USD right now but hopefully decreasing in the future), ability to support 1 million transactions/s without fee increasing, and extremely high decentralization.

I agree that many cryptocurrencies aren't suited to real use at scale as a transaction layer, but I think the hype about the power of this when done right is very fair.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by danShumway on Sunday March 28, 2021 @03:03PM (#26613152)
I should clarify, Proof of Work/Stake for Bitcoin only matters if Bitcoin is actually being used as a trustless and anonymous payment system for regular transactions.

I agree that there are other parts of the full crypto ecosystem that are leveraging blockchain more effectively. I don't know how optimistic I am about them overall, but at the very least on the technology side of things they certainly have a lot more potential to turn into real payment systems than Bitcoin does, and I don't mean to disparage the people working on them.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by smashem on Sunday March 28, 2021 @01:10PM (#26612052)
> Which is what makes it even more absurd that people are claiming that adding centralized layers on top of Bitcoin is a valid solution to the cost and speed of transactions.

Who's claiming this? The Lightning Network is gaining popularity as a decentralized Layer 2 solution, for example.

You mean like Cash App and PayPal?

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by capableweb on Sunday March 28, 2021 @01:12PM (#26612072)
I think things like centralized exchanges doing trading with centralized technology also "claims" this. Some people seem to be fine with using those as well, even though it supposedly goes against their interest of a payment network without trusted 3rd parties.
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by bingbong70 on Sunday March 28, 2021 @02:31PM (#26612865)
Efficient decentralized exchanges are not easy to build but an increasing number exist with the aim of solving the centralization issue (overreaching regulation attempts will push this into hyperdrive).

We can't act like a 12 year old invention should arrive with drop in decentralized replacements for every component of the legacy financial system...this is all being built from scratch as we criticize its shortcomings.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by agumonkey on Sunday March 28, 2021 @01:55PM (#26612504)
I believe that this will follow the usual technobubble pattern, pump energy (money) until it blows, gather the remaining working bits on the ground afterwards and come back in 10 years.
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by pyinstallwoes on Monday March 29, 2021 @04:45AM (#26618950)
Agreed. Only concern is that irrationality can last longer than rationality and the longer that happens the bigger the attack vector becomes.
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by pyinstallwoes on Monday March 29, 2021 @02:33AM (#26618303)
Trusted third parties:

1. Those who wrote the encryption and understand the math (very small %).

2. Those who write the software powering the blockchain (small %)

3. Those who write the wallet software you use to use the blockchain (small %)

4. Those who build the software you use on the same platform you use your wallet.

5. The operating system you use implementing all of the above.

6. The hardware you use implementing all of the above.

Yeah, tons of no trust....

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by jebeng on Sunday March 28, 2021 @09:30PM (#26616776)
> Now a couple of years into blockchain technology, we have some alternatives that _might_ work as well as Proof of Work (Proof of Stake for example) but we've yet to see if it actually can work on the scale that Bitcoin operates in. Time will tell.

Proof of Stake as a theory and concept is probably almost 10 years old at this point. And as an actual real-money-in-production blockchain Proof of Stake will actually be 10 years old in the next couple of years or so.

I wish I could confidently remember specific names and dates here, but on bitcointalk I remember SunnyKing coding and launching a real in production a PoS coin almost 10 years ago now...I want to say it was something like "NuCoin" but I could be off on the name there. I do speicifically remember he made Primecoin which was an alternative PoW function based on discovering the world's highest prime numbers(kind of cool, which is why I remember it I guess) after he was done with his initial PoS coin. He(SunnyKing) was also endlessly trolled and mocked due to the theoretical threat PoS posed to those invested in Bitcoin and other PoW coins like Litecoin at the time.

There was also a larger PoS coin called NXT from that era(again, almost 10 years ago, 2013 maybe?) that I suppose never really caught on, perhaps it was technically flawed?

There were lots of legitimate criticisms of PoS regarding whether or not it was a truly viable decentralized consensus mechanism. And I don't claim to after the answer to whether or not it is, or was sufficiently viable. But historically there was also lots of trolling and suppression from people trying to protect their investments.

It apparently may be finally getting its time, given PoS as a technology seems to have only recently become a mainstream topic of interest, despite how old the tech and theories themselves are. Perhaps that's just because the problems were only recently solved?

But regardless, I find it funny how much play PoS gets these days now that mainstream media is reporting on how PoW mining as a whole is using more power than many nation states, as if there was any other path for PoW to scale given its fundamental design.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by hackernudes on Sunday March 28, 2021 @12:10PM (#26611491)
You don't think bitcoin should be valuable. Your point is fine, but it really doesn't address the article at all!

Assuming bitcoin stays valuable, does it make sense to use bitcoin mining to augment some power projects? Like using otherwise wasted energy to mine or to mine in places where it might not be easy to transmit the electricity?

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by verdverm on Sunday March 28, 2021 @02:39PM (#26612940)
Actual batteries would be a better choice than consuming the energy at the time it is created. Investing in better transmission infrastructure would increase this benefit.
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by mr_woozy on Monday March 29, 2021 @12:24AM (#26617684)
This doesn't hold for places like Iceland (where I live) as there will never be transmission of power to either continent due to distance impedance losses.
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by jcrben on Wednesday March 31, 2021 @08:47PM (#26655354)
These are perfect places to do heavy industry, and in fact that's what happens now https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/01/us/politics/american-comp...

Hydrogen production is another possible use in addition to aluminum.

Renewable energy like that provided by Iceland is a relatively rare and precious resource

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by ftlio on Sunday March 28, 2021 @05:10PM (#26614608)
Bitcoin is P2P software. Every model that doesn't start there is wrong. Certainly most hype pieces start somewhere else. All critiques do. It's easy to ignore them.
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by berkes on Sunday March 28, 2021 @11:51AM (#26611325)
'Pure waste' is very much a point of view. If you dislike porn, the entire energy to create and distribute that, is 'pure waste' in your view (last time I looked, streaming porn consumes about the same amount of energy as Bitcoin. This probably changed by now). If, like me, you dislike billboards, all those giant flaring screens, burning neon, or LCD pixels, screaming to make you buy Pepsi, is 'pure waste'.

If you dislike Bitcoin, obviously any kilowatt used by it is 'pure waste'.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by IMTDb on Sunday March 28, 2021 @12:20PM (#26611563)
The vast difference here is that the energy consumption required by Bitcoin is integral to its model. The stated goal is to make massive amount of otherwise useless computations.

If there was any way to stream porn using less electricity, we would consume less electricity for that. If there was any way to make those billboards consume less electricity, we consume less electricity.

As soon as there is a new way to do bitcoin related operations using less electricity (eg: ASICS), the security of the network decreases. And everyone moves to the new model, in order to go back to consuming a lot of electricity, in order to restore trust in the network.

On a macro scale, Bitcoin has to consume lots of electricity, any possible improvement in that area needs to be wiped out by just people going back to consuming more electricity, otherwise the model fails. The whole bitcoin trust model revolves around people being ready to waste a ton energy for it. That's not the case of porn, or billboards: the energy consumption is just a side effect and not a requirement, they have value outside of the consumed electricity. Bitcoin entire value is only dependent on how much people are willing to invest in it, which roughly translates on how much electricity is wasted.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by capableweb on Sunday March 28, 2021 @12:23PM (#26611607)
> If there was any way to stream porn using less electricity, we would consume less electricity for that

In a perfect world, yes. We would use less electricity if we realize we could. Unfortunately it doesn't work like that in the real world. In reality it has to make economic sense, as capitalism is "the way of life" in the western world (and many other places), otherwise it won't be thought of. We're slowly changing this.

Bitcoin is capitalism modernized, fully on the internet and on our computers. Since computers and the internet tends to multiply everything, we now have capitalism as a protocol, intensified like never before. Since being environment friendly is not a benefit for the participant in the network, it won't be a consideration.

A big fault in the protocol, and hard to see how it can be solved in Proof of Work. Luckily there are some people working on alternatives but we have yet to see if they actually work in practice on the same scale as Bitcoin.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by klyrs on Sunday March 28, 2021 @12:40PM (#26611742)
Data centers and cloud providers are optimizing flops per watt, not flops per second. Energy providers are finding that wind and solar have become incredibly cheap, and transitioning as fast as they can. It took us a while to overcome political hurdles erected by the carbon-burning industry, but it turns out this stuff just makes sense on an economic level.
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by capableweb on Sunday March 28, 2021 @12:56PM (#26611916)
Not sure it's happening as fast as you seem to indicate here. And if it is, what's the problem with Bitcoin and energy consumption, exactly the same thing will happen, but faster since Bitcoin is all about money?
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by klyrs on Sunday March 28, 2021 @01:26PM (#26612210)
Where did I indicate a timescale (outside of "it took us a while" -- wherein I said that progress is slow)? As many others have pointed out, energy efficiency is seen as a bug and bitcoin has repeatedly increased hashing difficulty in order to offset increasing efficiency. Likewise, if a locale is known to have cheap power, miners move in until the power isn't cheap anymore. Eventually we'll be on 90+% renewables, and it won't be as bad, but ultimately, bitcoin is a space heater, and never a battery unless you devise a system to capture, store, and generate electricity from that heat.
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by klyrs on Sunday March 28, 2021 @03:35PM (#26613517)
On the topic of space heaters, though... if you replace your gas furnace with a bitcoin mining rig, and your electric is 100% renewable, then that's fine by me.
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by user-the-name on Sunday March 28, 2021 @03:21PM (#26613341)
It will not. Bitcoin is literally designed specifically to make sure this never happens.

Again, as soon as you manage to develop a way to mine bitcoin more efficiently, the difficulty of mining will automatically go up to make sure you are still wasting just as much energy.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by ChainOfFools on Sunday March 28, 2021 @06:56PM (#26615598)
the diff goes up for everyone, not just you. you still have a relative advantage over all the other miners who have not yet reproduced your efficiency gains.
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by burnished on Monday March 29, 2021 @02:09PM (#26625880)
'relative difficulty' was never germane to the discussion. The point is that the system self-corrects for more efficient energy use by increasing its energy use. And its a lot of energy.
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by user-the-name on Monday March 29, 2021 @05:29AM (#26619215)
Irrelevant to the question of destroying the planet.
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by JoeAltmaier on Sunday March 28, 2021 @11:53AM (#26611346)
A waste by most societal measures. Purely imaginary point backed by nothing that is easily defrauded and highly volatile. With no societal or personal value. And we've chosen to burn gigawatts of energy on this foolish game. Its easy to see it as enormous waste.
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by WinstonSmith84 on Sunday March 28, 2021 @12:41PM (#26611751)
A waste by your societal measures. It's easy to see it as enormous waste, for you

Speaking of "burnt gigawatts", if our society is still using coal to produce energy, are you blaming also Bitcoin for this? Too easy, sorry.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by africanboy on Sunday March 28, 2021 @02:50PM (#26613033)
it's a waste for 99.9% of the World population, assuming that bitcoin's 6 million wallets represent 6 million different people.

So yes, it's arithmetically a total waste.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by Monitorio on Monday March 29, 2021 @07:40AM (#26620194)
yes 'pure waste'

Now 1. a bad billboard doesn't make bad btc better. Neither does everything else you mentioned.

2. there is a margin of difference on how much enjoyment and entertainment something like porn makes vs. btc does.

If we would need to cut down on a lot of things to reduce co2, i would argue that btc would be much much further up the list then porn.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by atmosx on Sunday March 28, 2021 @01:48PM (#26612433)
I agree with the sentiment, but this part is way off:

> [...] despite being one of the most fiat currencies by definition [...]

FIAT currencies are by design inflationary to enhance spending. Bitcoin is deflationary _by design_. Since there's no bank or state backing Bitcoin, the only way that bitcoin makes sense was/is deflation. This quality makes BTC an asset and that's what it is, a digital asset. As a currency BTC has already failed.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by lottin on Sunday March 28, 2021 @03:44PM (#26613639)
A fiat currency is any currency that isn't backed by a commodity, i.e. it's not redeemable for a certain quantity of the commodity by the issuer, and bitcoin falls squarely into this category.
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by lowkey on Monday March 29, 2021 @01:13PM (#26625021)
The definition of fiat means by decree. In other words fiat currency has value because a central government authority (formerly king) decrees that the paper has value. Bitcoin has no central authority that decrees it has value - only demand by the people drives the value of Bitcoin.

Bitcoin may be a lot of thing, but it isn't a fiat currency.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by lottin on Tuesday March 30, 2021 @12:17PM (#26636495)
A currency created "by fiat" means it's created without backing.

"A novelty of the 20th century was the issue of fiat currencies by governments. ("Fiat" means not backed by any reserve commodity, as the gold- and silver-based currencies of previous centuries were)." [1]

[1] https://nakamotoinstitute.org/shelling-out/

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by agumonkey on Sunday March 28, 2021 @02:00PM (#26612548)
how would you quality VISA and Tesla accepting bitcoin ? does it qualify as asset tranfer or currency ? (open question)
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by Consultant32452 on Sunday March 28, 2021 @02:47PM (#26612994)
Governments want you to think of crypto primarily as an asset and not a currency, because they don't want to give up control over currency creation. The fact that you have to file capital gains for every crypto will be the giant silent hurdle that stimies wide spread use. The only way to overcome this is if so many people ignore the law that it becomes unenforceable. Only time will tell.
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by atmosx on Sunday March 28, 2021 @03:11PM (#26613231)
> Governments want you to think of crypto primarily as an asset and not a currency, because they don't want to give up control over currency creation.

According to Adi Shamir[1] 98% of bitcoins belonged to 2% of portfolios in 2012. So... The government is "bad" because you can actually express your opinion in monetary policy, you know who's who, etc. and BTC (or any other crypto) is good because you have absolutely no idea who the 2% is? I'm not following...

Regarding the gov and BTC. The government will tax BTC the same will tax any other asset, so in reality, the gov doesn't care. You can choose to hide profits from BTC and you'd choose to hide profits from any other financial activity. I don't really see the US Gov fighting bitcoin, if anything the gov tries to put BTC into perspective.

If you are anti-gov because "gov is bad (by default)" I get the feeling but has little to do with BTC.

[1]: http://eprint.iacr.org/2012/584.pdf

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by Monitorio on Monday March 29, 2021 @07:45AM (#26620228)
bitcoin will not just replace other mechanism/means of paying without a state interfering.

And why?

Because our current finance market is regulated and we don't need bitcoin to free it.

Its not technology which is putting all those restrictions and systems onto the finance market therefore a technology like btc doesn't solve anything.

Companies for example are not allowed to do trade with North Korea by law. So if everyone starts to use btc to do exactly that, guess who will step in and regulate it?

I'm always lost on why people think btc will fix any issues we currently have. There is a reason why people invest in Euros and Dollars ('hard' currencies) and gold.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by atmosx on Sunday March 28, 2021 @03:06PM (#26613185)
I'm not sure how is this relevant. Would you really buy a Tesla with BTC, when you can buy it with USD? If I give you 10 BTC today, you'd hoard them or go on a spending spree?
Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by TheBlight on Sunday March 28, 2021 @12:17PM (#26611540)
>First Bitcoin was NOT fiat currency (despite being one of the most fiat currencies by definition)

What is your working definition for fiat currency?

Mine is:

"Fiat money is a government-issued currency that is not backed by a commodity such as gold."

Government doesn't issue bitcoins. Stopped reading after that as you seem uneducated on the subject.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by mattnewton on Sunday March 28, 2021 @12:39PM (#26611729)
I think of the government part as largely an accident; my definition of fiat money is “money that has value solely because the transacting parties say it has, and not intrinsic uses” - historically the way to get people to agree something intrinsically value-less has value was by government decree, but there are lots of exceptions. I think of the Yapannese rei stones as fiat money, for example (though there is some question about them having inherent value). Basically any money that isn’t commodity money (or directly redeemable for commodities) is a fiat money.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiat_money

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by Empact on Sunday March 28, 2021 @01:51PM (#26612455)
I think your definition is faulty: are you aware of shell money? This served as money enabling international trade for thousands of years[1], and can you say these shells have intrinsic uses?[2] These shells had value because of their properties: compact, scarce, unforgeable.

In contrast, fiat value is held because an authoritative party says value is held, e.g. Chucky Cheese tokens, or the USD. Fiat requires this authority, as in its definition: “An arbitrary order or decree.”

There are no authoritative parties declaring that Bitcoin has value, rather the market is arriving at that conclusion through decentralized operation, just as has occurred for thousands of years with gold, shells, etc.

[1] https://nakamotoinstitute.org/shelling-out/

[2] To say that a store of wealth also has uses as jewelry is redundant, IMO - storing and displaying wealth are age-old desires.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by mattnewton on Sunday March 28, 2021 @02:37PM (#26612919)
Shell money began as commodity money according to most sources- shells were inherently valuable because of body ornamentation as you mention (similar to how gold was useful to easily work into soft metal jewelry).

If Chucky cheese tokens are money at all, they are “representative money” because they can be readily exchanged for various commodities by the issuer (the prizes and games).

A central authorities decree is not required for money to be fiat, it just simply can’t have intrinsic uses like commodity money or be directly redeemable for commodities like representative money. It has value purely because we have confidence it will have value in the future - and historically the most reliable way to do that is by government decree, but it could also be by a mass consensus that a particular crypto coin will still be used in the future.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by Empact on Sunday March 28, 2021 @03:19PM (#26613322)
I expect economics textbooks in the future will refer to this time as the time this question was settled: were shells and gold money because of their intrinsic ability to be used as jewelry etc., or was it jewelry because their other properties (particularly scarcity / unforgeable costliness) made them natural monies?

Hard money advocates have been arguing this point recently, and IMO it can only be settled by the market and observation. Only if the latter is true, does Bitcoin have a valid claim to become money.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by smashem on Sunday March 28, 2021 @12:57PM (#26611936)
> ...Aluminum has value to everyone in some way, not just those invested in it...

A sound monetary system has more value than anything else on this planet. There's a lot of information out there, but here's one article to illustrate my point: https://breedlove22.medium.com/masters-and-slaves-of-money-2...

> The energy is burned forever.

Wrong. I can use it to pay someone to do work, for example. "Work" in both societal and physical senses. That means the energy is not lost in a bitcoin.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by albntomat0 on Sunday March 28, 2021 @01:05PM (#26612006)
> Wrong. I can use it to pay someone to do work, for example. "Work" in both societal and physical senses. That means the energy is not lost in a bitcoin.

That moves the definition of battery far away from normal usage. That means anything of monetary value is a battery, whether it’s cryptocurrency, a $20 bill, or a piece of gold.

Paying someone to do work has the actual energy come from another source, such gasoline or food.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by smashem on Sunday March 28, 2021 @01:23PM (#26612182)
It just depends on which parts of the system you're focused on.

We'll continue to bridge the gap between monetary -> electrical energy. A bitcoin is a store of monetary energy, and the bitcoin network is readily available. We're building solutions on top of the network to more quickly and easily convert that monetary energy to electrical energy.

It's somewhat analogous as converting readily available wind (kinetic energy) to electrical energy. There is a large gap between the two forms of energy, but we're continuing to close it.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by Monitorio on Monday March 29, 2021 @07:56AM (#26620303)
Its still wrong what you are saying.

A battery stores PRODUCED ENERGY and gives out the SAME PRODUCED ENERGY with loss.

You might not care but the problem is ENERGY which would not be needed to be PRODUCED to save co2 and our planet.

And you can play around with the idea how Bitcoin can be useful on supporting this stuff but honestly? No one needs btc for sustainable energy investment. No one.

And about this excess energy garbage: Either its so much excess energy that the system ooptimizes itself and reduces the co2 output by shutting down or prices are so different than someone is building a REAL Battery to make money out of this. Bitcoin would just put that energy segment onto the global market by some arbitrary decoupled btc value.

Re:Bitcoin as a Battery by machawinka on Monday March 29, 2021 @09:58PM (#26630563)
That assumes that someone is willing to accept Bitcoins as a payment.