News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by jspash on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @03:57AM (#26564587)
I listen to both Bach and Glass somewhat regularly. ie. they pop up in my Spotify "made for you" list form time to time.

The clear difference to me is that compositions by Glass never stop me in my tracks, make me think, make me feel anything. It's background music, full stop.

I've had the pleasure to see Philip Glass perform on two occasions. I would rate it with the time I saw The Blue Man Group. An entertaining evening. Never bored. Couldn't wait to get to the restaurant afterwards. And the concert wasn't discussed as much as the appetizers.

Just one man's opinion.

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by inopinatus on Thursday March 25, 2021 @03:07AM (#26577246)
That lumpy blue sweater you're wearing? It's actually cerulean.

I've been dealt a very different view, perhaps because I'm tainted by the analytical snobbery of a formal musical education, one that included studying, arranging, and performing the works of both. The pioneers of minimalism - Terry Riley, Philip Glass, Steve Reich et al - redefined my expectations and comprehension of music, and I perceive their ideas bright and clear in every genre today from pop to EDM to incidental.

I too have seen and heard Mr Glass play live, in two very different settings. Once in a very small chamber close enough to hear the piano stool creak in Metamorphosis, and once as part of the 2013 staging of Einstein on the Beach. Both were mind-blowing, and the only topic of conversation afterwards was the music.

For my generation of music students, both Glass and J.S.Bach remain towering geniuses whose influence will ripple for centuries, whose ideas are clearly still identifiable, and thereby form an indelible contribution to the arts.

Spotify won't give you the whole of Mishima, in the same way it will never collect together the three essential recitals of the Op.92 II. Allegretto, nor will it knowingly preface The Orb's Adventure's Beyond The Ultraworld with Steve Reich's Electric Counterpoint, nor Hendrix with Handel, and in general is not a conscientious guide to anyone's oeuvre or the relationships across music forms.

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by riverdweller on Thursday March 25, 2021 @06:56AM (#26578634)
> the three essential recitals of the Op.92 II Allegretto

Karajan and the Berlin Philharmonic (1963) for grave and majestic, Gardiner and the Orchestre Révolutionnaire et Romantique (1994) for bright and invigorating - but what's the third?

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by inopinatus on Thursday March 25, 2021 @07:59AM (#26579130)
Well, obviously I'm joshing a little, since there are certainly more than three worth the listen, and no "top 3" can be definitively argued. For example, I actually prefer Karajan's 1951 recording with the Philharmonia, and of the more sprightly renditions I go for the Christopher Hogwood (1997) with the Academy of Ancient Music, which is salient not merely for its instrumentation but also the interplay of the ensemble.

Nevertheless, for my personally selected essential version, I'll always nominate Erich Kleiber (1950, Decca) with the Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra. Once heard, never forgotten, it is spine chilling.

His son Carlos's is better known, but I think it's a goofy misreading.

Bonus: the Liszt transcription for piano reveals fascinating details that otherwise tend to submerge in the symphonic effusion. There's a pleasing version on Youtube purporting to be from Glenn Gould, but note that the provenance is disputed.

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by riverdweller on Thursday March 25, 2021 @10:16AM (#26580564)
Thank you for the additional recommendations.

Unspeakably irreverent but great fun (though you've probably already encountered it) is Joachim Horsley's Beethoven in Havana: https://youtu.be/mZRb0FyAa9s

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by jimlikeslimes on Thursday March 25, 2021 @04:58AM (#26577838)
I just listened to some of the music you mention in your post, and thoroughly enjoyed it. Do you have any other recommendations? Especially where you see connections between modern musicians / electronic artists and classical? I've listened to a lot of electronic music, especially at parties, but I'm still fumbling around in the classical world.
Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by jabl on Thursday March 25, 2021 @08:59AM (#26579660)
What is the musically educated snobbish opinion on Einaudi? Might not be a pioneer in the same sense as Glass, but the style is in many ways similar, no?
Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by Waterluvian on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @10:47PM (#26575992)
I love this comment so much because I very intensely feel the opposite. Glass' music teleports me to another world.

Bach... Okay Bach actually has a lot of incredible pieces. But also a ton of on-hold music.

I love disagreeing so strongly about this because it tells me there's at least one entire parallel universe to how I experience music. So there's so much more to experience.

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by gnulinux on Friday March 26, 2021 @01:19PM (#26594596)
This is why music is such an incredible art form. It's all sine waves of air at the end of the day, but there are entire universes hidden somewhere there in the air. You can be a musician, explore classical western music, jazz, rock, pop etc... and still discover a brand new genre or avant-garde style that sounds nothing like any other music.

What is most sad to me is, nowadays music mostly taught as a means of practice. People go through entire schools of music without composing their own pieces. As a total nooby, composing music is one of the most fun I have interacting with music, it allows me to explore what these composers thought about writing their music. Like, pick up a guitar and try to improvise a jazz piece, or pick a classical composer (Bach/Mozart/Glass/etc...) and try to write variations based on their theme or re-harmonize the piece. It shows you what each composer valued the most, and why certain trade-offs made sense.

For example, Bach was absolutely obsessed with polyphonal/contrapuntal music, maybe to an insane, unhealthy degree. He was so obsessed with this idea, that he went ahead and wrote entire fugues for solo violin, and entire suites for solo cello that have nothing but arpeggiated chords. Once you realize what was the "musical project" (so to say) of each composer was (not just classical but also any genre of music including mainstream pop), your music enjoyment increases an order of magnitude. Like, when Bach was alive the art form of "fugue" was considered outdated and old, but he loved it so much that he simply dedicated his life to exploring contrapuntal music.

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by gnulinux on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @10:20PM (#26575847)
I have the same opinion, but imho this is not on Glass. Bach is simply something else, even within his own generation, his music transcends everyone else. Maybe my music knowledge isn't very wide but I spent some decent time dissenting many baroque composers to find something, even remotely remotely close to, e.g. BWV 1004 (especially Chaconne).

Open to suggestions here! I don't have a formal music theory education but I've been playing violin (classical training) since my childhood.

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by nickserv on Thursday March 25, 2021 @02:34AM (#26577119)
More Renaissance than Baroque, but some of John Dowland's lute pieces have the same emotional impact on me as Bach. Lachrimae Pavane, his most famous, is exceptional when played on lute. Although in all fairness the instrument itself is something I find quite magical.
Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by Uhhrrr on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @10:23PM (#26575862)
I'm absolutely fine with that being your opinion, but will say I'm a huge fan of Glass (and Bach), and can enjoy it as foreground music, even the most meditative works like Music in 12 Parts and the piano pieces. But I've been moved by some works. The Mishima soundtrack and Itaipu come to mind. Also the Reggio soundtracks, although it's hard to separate those in my mind from the movies, which are also great.
Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by alanbernstein on Thursday March 25, 2021 @02:00AM (#26576983)
It seems so common for technical people to be into Bach, but I don't get it. To me, Bach is basically slow, boring religious stuff, or grating harpsichord stuff.

What am I missing? And I mean that as in, what can I listen to, that will help me see what others see?

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by antognini on Thursday March 25, 2021 @02:32AM (#26577117)
There are a couple of different kinds of music that Bach composed. Of course he is well known for his chorales, but based on your comment those probably don't speak to you.

What might be a better place to start would be the cello suites. The first is so well known that it's hard to come to it with an open mind. But my favorite is the second in d minor. Here is a performance by Mischa Maisky: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ki9ySiWQNu8 Much more lyrical and passionate than we often associate with Baroque music.

Bach is, of course, very well known for his counterpoint, which probably is why a lot of technical people like his music so much. I personally like these pieces best on organ. The fugues in particular are always a great deal of fun as each line comes in and the piece gets richer and richer. Here is a performance of the Great Fugue in G major: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6clTa8_QYQE I think there's really no substitute for listening to these pieces live, though. With a good organ you just get enveloped in the sound. The next best thing to do is wear good headphones and really crank up the volume, but headphones just can't match the bass of 64 foot pipes.

I'd also be remiss if I didn't mention the Chaconne from his partita for violin: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HEbi-7tPaqo

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by nickserv on Thursday March 25, 2021 @02:22AM (#26577069)
A lot of Bach (and "classical" music in general) may feel slow, but is actually quite fast if you measure the amount of notes played per minute. But this is something I only realized when I started to learn guitar and tried playing some pieces.

Anyway, what I really like about Bach is how much many of his compositions just swing. He was a big fan of the canon, where a melody is played simultaneously by several voices/instruments, but with an offset and counterpoints. He uses this to create what to me are beautiful textures and great rhythm.

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by jabl on Thursday March 25, 2021 @03:13AM (#26577276)
> A lot of Bach (and "classical" music in general) may feel slow, but is actually quite fast if you measure the amount of notes played per minute. But this is something I only realized when I started to learn guitar and tried playing some pieces.

Not sure classical music generally is much slower or faster than "modern" music (there is of course a wide variety in both), but I would say, also generally, that a classical piece is harder to learn to play because it tends to have a more complex structure and is less repetitive than most contemporary pieces.

(This is not a slight against modern music; personally, I enjoy listening to both classical and modern.)

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by nickserv on Thursday March 25, 2021 @03:57AM (#26577466)
We are in agreement. I was mainly commenting on the feel of the music.

I remember as a teenager listening to Mozart and thinking "this is slow and boring", while Metallica is "super fast and cool", when in actuality the Mozart piece has a faster tempo and many, many more notes produced per minute.

Not a dig on Metallica, I still enjoy their music, just that my horizons have broadened.

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by ivanmaeder on Thursday March 25, 2021 @12:05PM (#26581969)
And repetitive!

https://www.chenalexander.com/Bach

It's not for everyone and that's fine. I have some suggestions to try though.

BWV 999

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0g4FrGcRAIs

Goldberg Variations #13

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q5-7QENoXoA

Erbarme dich, mein Gott

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zry9dpM1_n4

Cello Suite #6 Sarabande

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qzb8aEW_Rdc

I'm going to go a little rogue with the Chaconne and suggest an arrangement ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ljb5MvKv0Hw

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by emptyfile on Thursday March 25, 2021 @06:30AM (#26578446)
I'm far from an expert in Baroque music, but I think if both of these pieces are boring to you you're definitely not into Bach! And they couldn't be more different.

Bach: Harpsichord Concerto No.1 in D Minor BWV 1052 (Jean Rondeau)* I'm sure some people will hate on this unorthodox interpretation, but to me this is sublime.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XcsfDxojdV8

Johann Sebastian Bach - Chaconne, Partita No. 2 BWV 1004 | Hilary Hahn * The solo violin bible

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ngjEVKxQCWs

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by throw0101a on Thursday March 25, 2021 @07:45AM (#26579023)
> What am I missing? And I mean that as in, what can I listen to, that will help me see what others see?

Cello suites. See No. 6:

* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wbH3JYfRjOQ

Violin concertos; e.g., D minor:

* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bZFOhkGGr8A

Brandenburgs:

* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hbQORqkStpk

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by ipiz0618 on Thursday March 25, 2021 @04:05AM (#26577512)
As mentioned by others, Bach is a master of counterpoints - that's what made me listen to his pieces over and over.

I guess his slow chorales are played the most in churches and ads. but he composed so much more. Some of my favorites are The Well-Tempered Clavier, Goldberg Variations, and English/Italian Suites.

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by froh on Thursday March 25, 2021 @02:34AM (#26577118)
bach brought polyphony to a completely new level.

Here is some slow, boring but not religious stuff, no hapsi and no singing:

js bach, the art of the fugue

https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PL5BC3686A00C91558

it was a demo of the gist of his composition, his music making: he introduces a melody, the motif, and then overlays it with itself and variants of itself and I admit the details completely escape me.

yet the music captures me and allows me to think.

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by alberto-m on Thursday March 25, 2021 @12:03PM (#26581947)
Bach's music greatly appeals to me as a mathematician because of the sense of universal harmony it irradiates. Many of JSB's compositions are based on precise constraints (symmetries, translations). I think many technical people can somehow perceive the schemes underlying the music, even if they are not musically trained enough to identify them consciously. This is at least how I explain my love for Baroque music.

I found it surprising nobody yet mentioned the “Gödel, Escher, Bach” book by Douglas Hofstadter. Not sure how popular the work is today, but some years ago it was really famous.

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by alanbernstein on Friday March 26, 2021 @01:47AM (#26589100)
Yeah, thanks for mentioning GEB, it was really the original inspiration for my previous question.

I read the book years ago, and loved it. Learning about Gödel's incompleteness theorems had already my blown my mind; Escher already was, and still is, my favorite visual artist. I remember well, at a general level, the book's explanations of counterpoint, constraints, and logic in Bach's compositions. In stark contrast to the rest of the book's content, that was all somewhat academic since the book didn't play any music.

Ever since reading the book, it has greatly saddened me to think about how much enjoyment I get from the work of Gödel and Escher, and that I'm missing out on the third component of Hofstadter's holy trinity of self-reference.

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by scop on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @11:35PM (#26576317)
I share your opinion. I listen to Glass somewhat regularly, almost always as background music. Its fun, though The more attention I give it the less I enjoy it.

Whereas with Bach, I am always returning to him. I go and listen to Mozart...and halfway through the piece I stop and switch it to Bach. Go and listen to a favorite movement of Beethoven, and then I’m back into endless Bach. Spend a few hours enjoying Metallica or Megadeth, and then I round out my day with Bach.

Bach unifies the emotional and intellectual life unlike any other art I’ve encountered. His music is almost unbelievably deep. I’ve listened to some movements an absurd number of times, yet there is always something new to notice.

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by abrowne on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @09:48PM (#26575666)
This mean Glass makes a great movie soundtrack!
Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by nicklaf on Thursday March 25, 2021 @01:41AM (#26576905)
Indeed. In particular, when OP said he wasn't moved emotionally by Glass's music, I immediately thought of the track "67 Cities" from Errol Morris documentary, The Fog of War: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hOCYcgOnWUM

Glass's score makes this a very powerful scene, IMO.

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by abrowne on Thursday March 25, 2021 @08:52AM (#26579594)
Yeah, I was thinking of that film as well as Elena by Andrey Zvyagintsev.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=drDu9Ta1JWc

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elena_(2011_film)

Re:What Philip Glass and J. S. Bach have in common (2018) by adamkittelson on Wednesday March 24, 2021 @09:58PM (#26575730)
I only heard about Glass because he was used in this Battlestar Galactica scene. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kCrxDsuwXjI