News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by jonathanlydall on Monday March 15, 2021 @07:27AM (#26464629)
For those not from South Africa, this app is primarily for people to be able to get notifications or look up when their area will be affected by a "planned power outage", or as Eskom (our state owned power utility) refers to it, "load shedding". "Load shedding" is enacted whenever they have a power production capacity issue where different areas take turns without power so as to not let the power grid collapse.

This app aggregates information from various data sources and provides push notifications too. It is without a doubt the best source of this information and the app being unavailable significantly affects the day to day lives of a significant portion of the South African population who use it to plan around these power outages.

While the app also has a "chat" feature, it's really tangental to the primary purpose of the app and I expect that most users of the app, like myself, don't use that feature at all and only care about knowing when they will be without electricity.

In case you're wondering why they hell we have load shedding, it's because Eskom is grossly incompetent. Their incompetence is hugely exacerbated by nepitism and corruption where government has historically appointed people to Eskom management positions solely as "favours", rather than on qualification for the job.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by tremon on Monday March 15, 2021 @10:28AM (#26466461)
Load shedding is the correct technical term for it. It's not just a South African thing either, industrial consumers in Europe have the same stipulation in their power contracts: in case of emergency, the power company (network operator) may choose to suspend power delivery to protect the grid.

However, in the EU this 1) isn't a regular occurrence, and 2) the grid has a tiered system for load shedding. I can't find a reference for the tier classifications right now, but if I remember correctly: tier 1 consumers (the ones who will be disconnected first) are heavy industries with huge power draw, tier 2 are other commercial uses, tier 3 is residential, and tier 4 is critical infrastructure (emergency services).

I don't think I've ever experienced a load shedding event that affected residential areas. There have been local blackouts but I don't recall any grid-wide emergency events.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by jimmydorry on Monday March 15, 2021 @07:37PM (#26470821)
The better technical term for what South Africa has is rolling black-outs that increase in frequency (and ultimately duration) depending on the amount of load that needs to be shed.

South Africa also has actual load shedding, where industrial customers are asked then forced to reduce usage, but the black-outs are entirely different. They are region-by-region complete loss of power for all but the hospitals (but often take out hospitals and emergency services too).

Compounding this issue, the grid is not designed to be switched on and off frequently. While there is a set schedule for the rolling blackouts, transformers and other equipment will blow under the sudden loads, meaning your regional blackout may last a lot longer than planned. You may also get blackouts sooner or completely out of schedule for region, for which no explanation is given.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by saberdancer on Monday March 15, 2021 @10:53AM (#26466726)
Texas had tier 3 level of load shedding recently.
Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by dylan604 on Monday March 15, 2021 @11:43AM (#26467329)
Based on the incompetent decisions that ERCOT has made over the past few "severe weather events", I would say ERCOT and ESKOM are eerily similar.
Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by jrochkind1 on Monday March 15, 2021 @11:57AM (#26467551)
All my reading said that the decisions ERCOT made during the weather event were all very competent. They kept the grid from collapsing, which was their job.

The fact that extensive load shedding and brownouts etc needed to happen was not a result of decisions made during the weather event, but lack of infrastructure investment over decades (that may or may not have been under the control of ERCOT, rather than the legislature and state government regulators, but ERCOT certainly was on board with/lobbying for the conditions of deregulation that led to them).

During the weather event... ERCOT, the grid operator, did their job very competently. Making more capacity come online or reducing consumer demand was not really something that could be done during the weather event. They kept the grid from collapsing -- and it nearly did collapse, it was a close call. That was their job during the event.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by msandford on Monday March 15, 2021 @12:13PM (#26467798)
> All my reading said that the decisions ERCOT made during the weather event were all very competent. They kept the grid from collapsing, which was their job.

I respectfully disagree. Demand might have been twice what supply was, but the way the load shedding was done wasn't smart at all. The rolling blackouts were done on a roughly 18-48 hour basis, i.e. if you lost power you probably lost it for at least 18 hours and I know plenty of people who lost it for much longer, up to 48 hours.

If demand was double what the supply was then it should have been possible to give people power for say 2 hours every 4 hours. Or maybe 6 hours every 12 hours. If demand outstripped supply by a factor of 4 then 3 hours every 12 hours.

But that's not what happened. A lot of houses have gas furnaces but they need electricity to run the fans and the ignition system and such. People died in their houses either from the cold or from running their cars in their garages trying to stay warm. A lot of pipes were burst due to not enough heat in the buildings.

I can think of at least a dozen ways in which the load shedding could have been better managed. I wouldn't agree that it was very competent.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by mindslight on Monday March 15, 2021 @12:51PM (#26468368)
> If demand was double what the supply was then it should have been possible to give people power for say 2 hours every 4 hours

The problem is if that electricity is being used for heat, the draw of the 2 hour on periods will increase to make up for the time off. Perhaps even resulting in more total usage, because when power is on, people will set the thermostat to 80 instead of 65, anticipating the power going off and it getting colder. When really you need everyone's expectations of comfort to change to 40 degrees (half the delta T).

The only way to win and supply some power to all houses is to keep the duty cycle so low that the amount of resistive heating equipment becomes the limiting factor (1 hour every 6 hours?). I don't know if they could have managed this, but it's certainly more complicated to figure out than simply lowering the period of the rolling blackouts.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by Dylan16807 on Monday March 15, 2021 @05:40PM (#26469510)
Only so much of the load is heating, and heaters can only draw so much current.

Even 1 hour every few would stop food from rotting and let people do important tasks.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by john-shaffer on Monday March 15, 2021 @08:42PM (#26471483)
> Even 1 hour every few would stop food from rotting

I just put my food outside, in the car. I never lost power, but I didn't want to waste any electricity on cooling food when it was needed so badly.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by bcrl on Monday March 15, 2021 @07:21PM (#26470634)
ERCOT failed to adjust pricing appropriately after the initial emergency, which allowed energy producers to milk the situation for billions of dollars more than is fair or reasonable. It's not like their input costs went up by billions of dollars that required compensation.
Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by dylan604 on Monday March 15, 2021 @12:40PM (#26468222)
> All my reading said

Comparing that to "All my expierincing" first hand. Not even close to the same thing. They would not have been in the stressed situtation in the first place had they enforced the recommended corrections for cold weather protection in the first place. The fact that they had to turn off power generation because pipes were freezing at the generating stations is an absolute joke, and is the prime cause of the stress.

The local weather forecasts remind people to move plants indoors, cover exposed plumbing, etc. Maybe they should also start including a friendly reminder to the local power plants to also cover exposed plumbing, but why would they listen to that when they've ignored government sanctioned reports from investigations into previous failures?

> ERCOT, the grid operator, did their job very competently "Turn off the power so the demand goes away" Check "Issue rolling black outs so that the demand is lowered and manageable, and give people a fighting chance" Nope. These were absolutely not rolling black outs, but static black outs. The method they chose to "save the grid" was just as incompetent as not maintaining their systems in the first place.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by jrochkind1 on Monday March 15, 2021 @12:54PM (#26468418)
Thank you for more info!

Do you know of any good journalistic coverage of this, since apparently I've been reading bad stuff?

It seems important info for those who don't have first-hand professional experience to get.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by dylan604 on Monday March 15, 2021 @01:18PM (#26468722)
I read articles from every where. Local stations had coverage of the damage and lack of "rolling" black outs, national outlets had coverage as well, and I'm pretty sure I remember seeing international coverage from BBC, Daily Mail, etc. I can't remember where I was seeing the scathing reports on ERCOT's ineptitude, but they were plenty.

https://www.texastribune.org/2021/02/17/texas-power-grid-fai... https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9270343/Texas-perfe...

just a snippet of a quick search from soooo many articles

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by brmgb on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @10:30AM (#26477136)
> industrial consumers in Europe have the same stipulation in their power contracts: in case of emergency, the power company (network operator) may choose to suspend power delivery to protect the grid.

You can't really compare.

Industries can chose in their contract to be part of the load shedding system. It's done with their agreement and the system is purely based on the grid frequency. The disconnection is done on site in an orderly fashion. In a way, it's probably more correct to view it as industries electing to temporary disconnect rather than the provider stopping supplying them.

> I don't recall any grid-wide emergency events.

The European electrical grid is extremely resilient. It was accidently split in two a couple months ago and that was barely noticeable for the customers of either half.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by LorenPechtel on Monday March 15, 2021 @01:31PM (#26468902)
American here--I've experienced load shedding once. The problem was a lineman started a wildfire that took out the primary source of power for the town. Until the line was repaired there was nowhere near enough power available, they directed what they had to things like the hospital etc and everyone else was in the dark.

There is also the mess we currently have in California. High winds blew stuff into high power lines and started a bad wildfire. In the lawsuits that followed the utility was told to shut down the risky lines under high wind conditions--which of course causes massive outages. Of course the utility is "at fault" because the ecology types blocked efforts to keep the vegetation away from the lines.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by ArchOversight on Monday March 15, 2021 @01:45PM (#26469058)
PG&E is at fault because they refused to properly maintain the power lines, and lines that had been hanging for years from the same supports where the supports failed are the cause of the fires.

See here: https://www.nbcbayarea.com/news/local/long-term-wear-found-o...

https://www.kqed.org/news/11792217/1987-report-suggested-pge...

I can't find it right now, but there was an absolutely fantastic RCA report that included all the information on the wearing down of the hooks and how this could have all been prevented.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by fragmede on Monday March 15, 2021 @01:43PM (#26469033)
The utility is at fault because they didn't spend enough money on maintenance. As a for-profit company in an established industry, PG&E won't ever be able to "pop" like a SaaS company does, so profits and salaries for executives and shareholders have to come from somewhere. Spending less on maintenance won't bite you - until it does - but until then, thats money that can be put elsewhere like CEO pockets.
Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by igitur on Monday March 15, 2021 @10:30AM (#26466484)
This app is also known for its humorous take the quite serious subject matter. The WHAT’S NEW section in the Google Play Store is known for sarcastic titbits with the fictional Jeff working hard to keep us up to date with the imminent darkness. The app's name itself, Eskom se Push, is wordplay on an extremely vulgar South African insult and feeds into the popular dislike of Eskom.
Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by mhuffman on Monday March 15, 2021 @08:20AM (#26465101)
This sounds like a nightmare!

Eskom seems to have been around for a long time, but this problem seems to have kicked in a little over a decade ago.

Did something recently happen to Eskom to make them incompetent?

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by igitur on Monday March 15, 2021 @11:16AM (#26466994)
It's two-sided.

Apartheid South Africa's government focused on providing electricity mostly for the white minority, which it did well, but the majority of South African, especially in the rural regions, lived with no or unreliable power supply. Post 1994, with removal of sanctions, the economy opened up. There was a lot of international investment in South Africa. The economy grew strongly and the demand for electricity significantly increased.

The supply side was woefully mismanaged and didn't nearly keep up with the pace of the growth in demand. Corruption is definitely a key reason, as others here mention, with the effect being that power plants are not adequatly maintained and new planned power plants going far over budget and missing deadlines [1].

Besides corruption, there are some policitical constraints. Eskom provides power to municipalities who often don't pay. Soweto, with 1.3 million residents owe Eskom in excess of $1 billion [2]. The South African Supreme Court of Appeal has ruled that Eskom is not allowed to cut power to non-paying municipalities [3]. In contrast to a free-market system, Eskom price hikes are subject to regulatory approval [4].

One could debate the relative significance of each of these factors, but it's by no means due to only a single one of these.

[1] https://www.news24.com/fin24/Budget/how-medupi-and-kusile-ar...

[2] https://mg.co.za/article/2019-10-18-00-why-we-dont-pay-for-p...

[3] https://www.iol.co.za/pretoria-news/news/eskom-cannot-cut-el...

[4] https://www.moneyweb.co.za/news/companies-and-deals/electric...

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by jimmydorry on Monday March 15, 2021 @07:43PM (#26470873)
I think you are missing the most important part. Even after Apartheid, the existing utilities provided for the entire population. However, there has not been any new generation capacity since 1994. Instead, the maximum generation capacity has shrunk year on year as boilers and other key parts of the power plants fail and aren't replaced.
Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by igitur on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @01:10AM (#26473256)
> However, there has not been any new generation capacity since 1994.

That's not true. Majuba Power Station was commissioned between 1006 and 2001, although planning started in the Apartheid era. Gourikwa Power Station and Newcastle Cogeneration Plant were commissioned in 2007.

There are a few wind farms built after 2001: Hopefield, Coega, Darling, Klipheuwel, Dassiesklip Wind Energy Facility and Jeffreys Bay.

And solar: Kalkbult, Mulilo Renewable Energy Solar PV Prieska, De Aar Solar PV, Mulilo Renewable Energy Solar PV De Aar, SA Mainstream Renewable Power Droogfontein, Letsatsi Solar Park, Lesedi PV Project, Kathu Solar Energy Facility 1, Sishen Solar Facility and the Jasper Solar Energy Project.

But these were not enough to keep up with the demand.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by igitur on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @07:13AM (#26475254)
Majuba Power Station was commissioned between 1996* and 2001
Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by alienthrowaway on Monday March 15, 2021 @09:20PM (#26471731)
I'm not OP - that they explicitly mentioned this:

>> The supply side was woefully mismanaged and didn't nearly keep up with the pace of the growth in demand.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by alienthrowaway on Monday March 15, 2021 @09:18PM (#26471715)
> Did something recently happen to Eskom to make them incompetent?

Demand for electricity consistently went up over the past 20+ years, with no matching increase in generation capacity.

Maintenance of current power plants hasn't been great either, and the supply/demand situation is precarious such that if any one of the power generation plant is offline for maintenance, there are likely to be compensatory blackouts somewhere.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by pistoriusp on Monday March 15, 2021 @09:35AM (#26465909)
Corruption.
[dead]
Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by jollofricepeas on Monday March 15, 2021 @09:39AM (#26465950)
Ah yes because the Nationalist Party was so much better during the good old days of apartheid when corruption ran at an all-time high.

It does not matter who holds it. Unchecked power always corrupts.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by rendall on Monday March 15, 2021 @09:45AM (#26466019)
I imagine it's difficult to address problems with the government if, whenever anyone does so, someone brings up the former government.

Bring up slavery in Dubai, and people start talking about the transatlantic slave trade and European colonialism.

It gives people of the present a free pass to behave reprehensibly, because other people in the past behaved reprehensibly

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by jollofricepeas on Monday March 15, 2021 @10:00AM (#26466175)
You should read the comments.

1. It was a throwaway. 2. The reply was... “It does not matter who holds it. Unchecked power always corrupts.”

The problem with the ANC is the same issue as The Nationalist. Without strong opposition and even a stronger free press, unchecked power always leads to corruption.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by rendall on Monday March 15, 2021 @12:28PM (#26468051)
> "The reply was... “It does not matter who holds it. Unchecked power always corrupts.”"

I would love it if that was indeed your reply. If your reply were indeed simply "It does not matter who holds it. Unchecked power always corrupts." I would upvote the hell out of that. It's true and eternally true. Well, almost, because when I am World Dictator for Life I will rule only with profound, infinite beneficence and enlightenment.

I'd like to refer you to this tweet: https://twitter.com/lofimandala/status/1371310164821774337

In response to someone pointing out that Dubai is built on slave labor, this person felt the need to say:

"And European cities weren’t? Don’t get me wrong, slave labor is abhorrent but it’s telling it only gets invoked when certain countries participate while the entirety of places like the United States were built upon imperialism, slavery, and genocide."

I am certain, if confronted, this person would point out the *"...Slave labor is abhorrent..." part of the reply, but it is nevertheless difficult for me to understand how the observation as a whole helps current slaves, of which there may be 40 million in the world. "Slave labor is abhorrent, but..." is a sentence that will not end at a good place.

Reeling from the disturbing sight of modern people defending or whatabouting modern slavery, I rebound into this thread. Just, please, you must criticize evil and corruption that exists now, in the present.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by javajosh on Monday March 15, 2021 @10:03AM (#26466193)
The general term for what you describe is "whataboutism". It is a rhetorical technique that allows one to defend the indefensible. First popularized by Russia, the technique has become a favorite among ~40% of Americans.

It's a favorite technique to defend the abuse of power. "Yes, I abused my power, but so does everyone with power," is a cynical, unfalsifiable and worryingly effective argument.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by MikeUt on Monday March 15, 2021 @09:59AM (#26466161)
Did an equal amount of "load shedding" happen during the "good old days"?
Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by ivanbakel on Monday March 15, 2021 @10:49AM (#26466673)
Would the answer to that question be a fair analysis? A great deal has changed about the country between the successive governments - not just the political power structure. Population figures, human development, the march of technology etc, all affect energy demands.

The most optimistic view would be that an energy company that operates without blackouts in an apartheid state should not be applauded for its performance under artificially-depressed demand.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by MikeUt on Monday March 15, 2021 @11:09AM (#26466906)
The current blackouts were blamed on corruption, followed by "the good old days of apartheid when corruption ran at an all-time high", implying blackouts were just as bad in the past.

It would be nice to first clear up the factual issue of whether blackouts have grown more or less frequent, before jumping ahead to the moral calculus of who should be applauded or condemned more.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by ivanbakel on Monday March 15, 2021 @11:55AM (#26467506)
>implying blackouts were just as bad in the past.

I don't understand where this implication comes from. In claiming that current governmental corruption is the cause of the current blackouts, the throwaway commenter implied that blackouts were less prevalent in the past. The reply then objected to the idea that the previous government was less corrupt - but the opposite statement does not require that blackouts were just as prevalent. It is possible that the previous government was corrupt, but any number of other factors meant that the energy grid did not require load shedding.

That's why I asked if the historical frequency of blackouts is really a fair analysis? Is it worth "clearing up", given that blackouts are not a direct function of corruption?

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by MikeUt on Monday March 15, 2021 @12:23PM (#26467958)
> I don't understand where this implication comes from.

From "blackouts are due to corruption -> corruption was just as bad in the past". Especially since blackouts were the only symptom of corruption mentioned. Yes, it's possible blackouts didn't manifest due to different reasons, despite equal corruption - that's why it's an implication.

> Is it worth "clearing up", given that blackouts are not a direct function of corruption?

A simple hypothetical "Yes blackouts are more common, but the old government was just as corrupt due to <list of reasons>" would have been much more informative, so yes I do think it's worth clearing up.

Are we supposed to compare governments without comparing the state of the country they ran (run)? Except, of course, apartheid - that doesn't get left out.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by shadowgovt on Monday March 15, 2021 @12:15PM (#26467836)
Unfortunately, an under-moderated chat feature is considered a risk these days, like an open email relay or an open proxy. I personally think Google erred too far on the side of caution here, but developers should be aware that chat features aren't as cheap to add as they used to be; they change the risk model of the app.
Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by yawaramin on Monday March 15, 2021 @01:11PM (#26468622)
This. Another example: https://www.theverge.com/2021/2/22/22295496/malaysiakini-gui...

> Malaysian news site fined $124,000 for five reader comments

> Malaysiakini’s co-founder avoided jail time

IMHO a lot of sites and apps should just remove chat/comment functionality and only allow emoji reactions.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by chmod775 on Monday March 15, 2021 @07:45AM (#26464792)
Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by brodo on Monday March 15, 2021 @07:58AM (#26464903)
OMG. This is as bad or even worse than Texas or California...
Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by pistoriusp on Monday March 15, 2021 @09:35AM (#26465900)
It is far worse, but South Africa has an inept and corrupt government, I wonder what the excuse is for Texas?
Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by signal11 on Monday March 15, 2021 @10:04AM (#26466204)
I suspect the truth is, in the narrow domain of electric power distribution, Texas too has an inept government that’s beholden to certain vested interests in the garb of “free markets”.

This is a state that has fetishized “light touch regulation” so much that it, for most of the state, has its own grid to avoid dealing with Federal authorities. And repeatedly failed to take action to get power companies to winterize their equipment even though cold snaps in Texas are not unheard of — they’ve had disruption in 1989 and 2011, in addition to other near misses.

Let’s not even get into the wisdom of a market that allows Griddy to offer wholesale prices without caps to retail customers.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by marcusverus on Monday March 15, 2021 @12:37PM (#26468179)
> I suspect the truth is, in the narrow domain of electric power distribution, Texas too has an inept government...

This is an absurd comparison. South Africa owns and runs its power utility. The result is that they struggle to provide electricity on an ongoing basis. According to Wikipedia, small business owners in South Africa said that load shedding was the number one challenge that they faced in Q1 of 2019.[0]

Texas does not own or run its utilities. They are privately run, and are given wide latitude by the state. The result is that the worst of the utilities are tragically only able to provide 99.95% uptime, with some power consumers experiencing outages for a few days per decade.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/South_African_energy_crisis

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by signal11 on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @07:32AM (#26475378)
Yes, Texas in the realm of power distribution is probably a paradise by comparison with South Africa, but compared to its peers (other US states), Texas has a very non-resilient, or fragile, power distribution system that we know will "crash" when faced with a cold snap. Given that they have known this since at least 1989, I think it's not unfair to use the word "inept".

The giant power bills are just icing on the cake of bad policy-making.

Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by vermilingua on Monday March 15, 2021 @10:26AM (#26466429)
So hang on, why is it that South Africa is “corrupt”, but Texas is “beholden to certain vested interests”?
Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by lovegoblin on Monday March 15, 2021 @11:18AM (#26467020)
The distinction-without-a-difference between these two phrases is exactly the point of the comment you're responding to.
Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by CamTin on Monday March 15, 2021 @11:47AM (#26467372)
...and presumably also the point of the comment it was responding to.
Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by mokus on Monday March 15, 2021 @10:43AM (#26466617)
Did any one person say both of those things?
Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by edoceo on Monday March 15, 2021 @10:44AM (#26466626)
That's just more words for corrupt
Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by dylan604 on Monday March 15, 2021 @11:48AM (#26467390)
Why would you think it is any different? ERCOT was recommended to protect its power generation capabilities from severe winter weather for over 10 years, yet the Republican leadership did nothing about it. That's either corruption or sheer ineptitude.
Re:Our app was banned because the button says “Report User” ... by unethical_ban on Monday March 15, 2021 @09:55AM (#26466112)
There is no comparison.