News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by practicalpants on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @04:49AM (#26409582)
Yep, for my first programming job out of college a recruiter arranged an onsite interview for a Java role, when I was under every impression it was for Ruby/Rails. I don't know Java.

The first interviewer laughed and walked out. I explained things to the recruiter, he cursed, said he would "visit the Ruby team upstairs". He actually managed to setup an impromptu on-site interview with the Ruby team on that same day. I got the job.

Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by dempseye on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @06:32AM (#26410185)
The recruiter did good work here. I suspect this was a screw up in internal HR.

The external recruiter has absolutely no incentive to send you for an interview you will bomb out of.

Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by viraptor on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @07:00AM (#26410343)
I'm not sure. Recruiters can spray and pray with candidates the way candidates can spray and pray with applications. They're not going to be great quality, but if you're paid commission on a hire and the recruitment channel can handle the load... what's to stop the recruiter?
Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by pc86 on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @07:11AM (#26410398)
Aside from it destroying future business (we've had recruiters change candidates' resumes on us and that recruiter is blacklisted - by name - forever, to anyone who will listen), most contracts will have a 30-day clause where if the employee leaves for any reason within 30 days the fee is returned. Some even have if employee is fired within 30 days that the next placement fee is discounted.
Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by thrwyoilarticle on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @07:21PM (#26418485)
When I connect with recruiters on Linkedin, I often notice they've spent a short time at their current position. Their tactics might not be sustainable.

That said, it's a bit absurd there aren't separate classes of users on Linkedin. Do I need to know a recruiter's work history?

Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by notahacker on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @07:19AM (#26410459)
Spray and pay works for sending people a little underqualified for a job. Sending people who don't know why they've been put forward for a job under false pretences just means the client won't interview any more candidates you send, especially if that candidate is plenty employable enough not to bother bluffing their way through.

And unlike candidates, recruiters can potentially get paid to fill a lot of a company's vacancies, provided they don't get blacklisted by them...

Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by wott on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @11:21AM (#26412857)
> Sending people who don't know why they've been put forward for a job under false pretences [...]

Isn't this called 'consulting'?

Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by sitkack on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @08:38AM (#26411050)
The good recruiter matches the right candidate to the right company. The dysfunction is a property of the system and is borne by everyone.
Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by jschwartzi on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @11:17AM (#26412803)
And that's probably how I got an interview with AWS once upon a time.
Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by eternalban on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @08:11AM (#26410848)
Nonsense told to me repeatedly by recruiters over the years:

- (your point) no incentive to send you for an interview if not a good fit.

- "I make more money if you make your money" often said to spin the "what is your salary requirement" question

Most recruiters work for an agency. Agencies have accounts with businesses. The account is central. You are in no position whatsoever to make determination as to what incentives drive the recruiter's business.

Recruiters also routinely b.s. young developers by "I get more if you get more money" when pressuring them into agreeing to a "salary expectation" right at the beginning of the employment negotiation.

Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by indeed30 on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @08:34AM (#26411025)
Yes, recruiters have accounts with companies, but in my experience the recruitment fee is a percentage of salary, and the individual recruiter compensation is on a commission model. In short, I personally have no problems in believing that the higher the salary, the higher the payment to both the recruitment company and individual recruiter.

However, I think we all know that closing the deal is far more important to the recruiter than negotiating small changes to the salary, so your point stands.

Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by buu700 on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @09:09AM (#26411347)
I haven't worked with a recruiter, so this is pure speculation, but it seems to me that a recruiter's greatest incentive would be to close any deal at all as quickly as possible, because they're competing against the alternative of you finding a position on your own first (or otherwise no longer requiring their services). Getting you a high salary is just gravy.
Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by pdpi on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @09:45AM (#26411715)
It’s more complicated than that.

You’re an engineer with a certain degree of experience and the recruiter will have an idea of how much that’s worth when they start the conversation with you, so they know up front how much money they stand to make as a ballpark figure, and how much work is worth putting into getting you an offer.

Once they get you to the offer stage, and most of the work is done, they want to close the deal as soon as possible for as much money as possible. They know the band for the position so, if you’re lowballing your ask, they have every incentive to bump that up.

On the flip side, if you’re asking for something on the top end of the range, and it looks like a long negotiation, they’re looking to spend a lot of incremental time for not a lot of incremental money, so it’s better to get you to accept an offer - any offer.

Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by kamarg on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @09:34AM (#26411596)
> they're competing against the alternative of you finding a position on your own first (or otherwise no longer requiring their services)

Almost every recruiter will constantly ask you if you're interviewing anywhere else or working with any other recruiters. They do this so they can be sure nobody else has the right to represent you to a client but also to gauge how much effort to put into presenting you to any of their clients. If you're not working with a a single recruiter exclusively, you'll often find that the amount of work they put in to get you in front of their clients drops dramatically to the point they no longer return your calls/emails.

Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by jschwartzi on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @11:19AM (#26412825)
I have actually had a recruiter negotiate a salary bump on my behalf though.
Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by thrwyoilarticle on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @07:28PM (#26418547)
As in they did it without you asking or they were the go-between during negotiation?
Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by bena on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @09:19AM (#26411451)
It's one of those things that are technically true, but doesn't matter as much as the candidate is led to believe.

Negotiating $10k more for a candidate might see them get some percentage of that. But if they place you now, they can move on to another candidate and get a percentage of $100k or more.

Churn is far more important than min-maxing any single candidate.

Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by daemin on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @10:41AM (#26412358)
Yep, recruiters like other middlemen make most money with volume not price/quality. It's not the size of the deal it's the constant flow of deals which makes them money.

For them to pay lots of attention on a single deal it has to be rather large, so that's why head hunters exist for top CxO type personnel, but not really for rank and file positions.

Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by dempseye on Tuesday March 16, 2021 @07:48AM (#26475487)
> You are in no position whatsoever to make determination as to what incentives drive the recruiter's business.

My god, how patronising.

My view on his comes from speaking to several hundred recruiters and owners of recruitment agencies as part of research for a product targeted at those businesses.

I also have close friends who worked or have worked in that industry and we have had very frank conversations about what their incentives are.

Maybe they all lied to me, but none of them wanted to put anybody forward for an interview who would make them look incompetent.

Their ideal flow for a deal was as follows:

- Receive brief from client.

- Find about 3 good candidates and get them booked for interviews. Could be more or less, depending on the role.

- Interviews take place and the client considers all candidates to be at least somewhat suitable, but decides to pull the trigger on one of them.

- The recruiter manages the candidate's salary expectations within a range based on their experience of placing other people in similar positions so that the deal gets done. Generally this means that they will try to get it closed within one or at most two offer-counteroffer loops. That may mean disabusing candidates of unrealistic salary expectations. It may also mean convincing clients to increase the previously agreed salary range to accommodate a candidate who is significantly more attractive than the average.

- The recruiter receives a placement fee equivalent to a percentage of yearly salary in most cases.

This does not mean that individual recruiters or agencies may not have other incentives. I know that sometimes interviews of external candidates are a procedural requirement and are conducted just for show so that a preferred internal candidate may be offered the position.

But in general, I am quite sure that the above is a reasonably accurate account of what the usual incentives are.

Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by Mauricebranagh on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @10:15AM (#26412051)
About 4 years ago I outright fired a UK agency over that, told them delete my contact details and never call me again.
Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by jarcane on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @06:35AM (#26410202)
My second ever job was at a startup that put me through three rounds of interviews, all of them in Python. The homework task, the questions, literally nothing else was mentioned through the entire process.

After I got hired, I showed up the first day and one of the managers asks me, "So I heard you know functional programming, right?"

I said "yes" and was immediately whisked off to the backend division that worked entirely in Scala, a language I had literally never spent more than 5 minutes on before dismissing because the online tutorial I was using broke about two chapters in.

Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by seg_lol on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @08:58AM (#26411242)
That is absolutely phenomenal. I assume your Python code had functional stylings that would translate well into how the team used Scala?

What was the rest of your experience like there? Sounds like a place that thinks at a deeper level than most.

Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by meheleventyone on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @11:10AM (#26412716)
Is it unusual? I’ve changed jobs three times now going into places with different languages than ones I had much experience of. IME it takes about as much time to learn the codebase as it does to learn a new language and both go hand in glove.
Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by ajford on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @12:24PM (#26413668)
IME it depends on the shop and it's own skill level. If you've got a bunch of devs with only experience in the tech stack the company is using, they'll be heavily selective for a match to their stack. If they've got a broad set of internal tools in a bunch of languages, they're likely selecting more broadly based on overall skill or the ability to get up to speed.

And I'm 100% with you there, learning a new place's codebase can often take as much or more time than learning a new language (at least if you've got experience with a couple of languages already). There's at least tutorials and guides for a new language, and there's rarely good docs and resources for the codebase.

Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by goodlinks on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @05:15AM (#26409734)
This makes me chuckle, and its a nice story cos you got a job :)..

All the controls in the world mean bugger all when ultimately the deciding factor is a human.

No one ever wants to admit that the world runs on trust and respect :).

Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by ant6n on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @07:25AM (#26410507)
I once applied for an internship at EA and thought I was invited for an interview on C. They gave me some C++ code to fix, which I didn't know, it wasn't on my CV. They just said "well this code is basically C", although I was pretty confused about those extra "&" the whole time, and it was a pretty rough experience.

In the end I didn't get the job, but their response said I didn't get it because the found that my experience didn`t match my CV. Go figure.

Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by panzagl on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @12:32PM (#26413772)
In C++ '&'s are like garlic, just add them until the code tastes good. See also Java and the 'static' keyword.
Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by sitkack on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @08:50AM (#26411161)
That is a very meta occurrence of a flaw in C++. They could have unchecked wrapping addition or they indexed off the end of their array.
Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by rightbyte on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @10:15AM (#26412054)
The extra "&" probably refers to different references.
Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by e-clinton on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @07:00AM (#26410335)
That’s either the best or worst recruiter ever
Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by arethuza on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @07:21AM (#26410470)
"worst recruiter ever"

Quite a lot of competition for that particular prize!

Edit:

There should be a Razzies for Recruiters!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Raspberry_Awards

Re:We created a fake language to root out resume liars by corobo on Wednesday March 10, 2021 @07:42AM (#26410635)
A recruiter actually managing to get someone a job is firmly in the best category