News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by TwoBit on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:43AM (#26354453)
----------------------------------------------------------------

Dear battery technology claimant,

Thank you for your submission of proposed new revolutionary battery technology. Your new technology claims to be superior to existing lithium-ion technology is is just around the corner from taking over the world. Unfortunately your technology will likely fail, because:

[ ] it is impractical to manufacture at scale.

[x] it will be too expensive for users.

[ ] it suffers from too few recharge cycles.

[ ] it is incapable of delivering current at sufficient levels.

[ ] it lacks thermal stability at low or high temperatures.

[x] it lacks the energy density to make it sufficiently portable.

[ ] it has too short of a lifetime.

[ ] its charge rate is too slow.

[ ] its materials are too toxic.

[ ] it is too likely to catch fire or explode.

[ ] it is too minimal of a step forward for anybody to care.

[ ] this was already done 20 years ago and didn't work then.

[x] by this time it ships li-ion advances will match it.

[ ] your claims are lies.

----------------------------------------------------------------

Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by evgen on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:21AM (#26354764)
Yet another example of a glib response ignoring the actual facts in the article and ironic to boot given that lithium-ion suffers from several of the flaws listed. The funny thing is, none of the claims you make are correct and you miss the point where this tech is specifically designed to cover areas where Li-ion fails (like high temp and places where having a battery explode into flaming debris is a bad thing.)
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by the_duke on Friday March 05, 2021 @05:41AM (#26355312)
Humour is rarely appreciated here, but I found this funny and on point.

Battery technology announcements are always extremely over hyped. Mostly by media and PR departments rather than actual scientific or domain specific outlets.

Advancements happen, but even if they are technically and commercially viable, it takes years until anything becomes actually useful.

Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by matthewmacleod on Friday March 05, 2021 @08:52AM (#26356837)
Battery technology announcements are always extremely over hyped.

Right, except this announcement specifically isn't. It's a short description of a new technology with targeted use-cases, which explicitly points out the ways in which it's not ready to displace existing technologies.

You are correct that there is often unjustified hype around battery technology in general. But this article is absolutely not that.

Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by conjectures on Friday March 05, 2021 @10:23AM (#26357804)
This is true, the article is essentially 'cool new battery - for satellites'.
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by guenthert on Friday March 05, 2021 @03:18PM (#26361505)
The title is also misleading. It should be "World's highest specific capacity solid state battery developed developed in Japan".
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by SiVal on Friday March 05, 2021 @06:38AM (#26355706)
I agree with you. Year after year we read about "revolutionary" battery technologies that are finally going to change the world. A laundry list of reasons why previous technologies that made the same claim ended up fizzling out is completely appropriate. Presenting the list formatted as humor instead of as a humble submission suits me just fine, because 1) I enjoy the humor, which ribs me a bit for how many times I've been fooled by announcements like these over the decades, and 2) I'm still aware that this time could be different. Probably won't be, but could be. The technology will either work out or not based on its merits, my "middlebrow" humor and skepticism notwithstanding.
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by GrantZvolsky on Friday March 05, 2021 @06:17AM (#26355535)
While the comment is funny, it is misplaced on an article that is refreshingly hype-free.
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by turtlebits on Friday March 05, 2021 @11:34AM (#26358756)
The title is full of hype.
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by Qwertious on Friday March 05, 2021 @12:37PM (#26359515)
The title is factually accurate, as no other solid-state battery has as high a capacity.

Perhaps it could be better phrased to be clearer that it's "the highest of solid state batteries" and not "the highest of batteries, and also solid state".

Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by TwoBit on Saturday March 06, 2021 @12:58AM (#26365539)
But that's the problem with these announcements. They make one or two factual statements that seem positive but hide the downsides. A year or two from now and the downsides aren't overcome and at best they gain a small market niche.
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by Intermernet on Friday March 05, 2021 @06:12AM (#26355500)
Funnily enough, I remember reading an article many years ago (I was about 10, so it would have been mid to late 80s) about LiPo being the next big thing, and the author making all sorts of claims about how battery technology announcements being over-hyped.

You're correct, but eventually one of these announcements will live up to the promise. LiPo was basically stumbling due to a few manufacturing at scale issues at the time, and once those got solved (Sony released a standard LiPo cell in 1991) it wasn't long before it became the new standard.

I'm still sceptical of new battery tech announcements, but I still get excited by them!

Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by tonyedgecombe on Friday March 05, 2021 @05:55AM (#26355394)
I found it tedious. Pretty much every post about advancements in battery technology on HN have a similarly cynical post at the top. I wondered what this one would be before I clicked on the comments link.
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by TwoBit on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:31PM (#26361030)
Well maybe because the cynicism is justified. Every week there's a new battery announcement and only rarely is it not hype.
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by tonyedgecombe on Saturday March 06, 2021 @03:46AM (#26366096)
Yet look at the progress made in battery technologies over the last few decades.
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by walrus01 on Friday March 05, 2021 @05:35PM (#26363115)
I have two different views on new battery technology press releases.

1) "Hey, that's great, I hope it works out for them!"

2) "Can I actually pull out my visa card right now, and buy some individual units online?"

Re: #2, most batteries have very little relevance to me as an end user until they're commercially available to buy. For instance the Panasonic NCR18650GA (245-250Wh/kg) li-ion, the Molicell P42A (21700 size li ion that's capable of being discharged at 45A rate with appropriate cooling), and other state of the art technology. I can go buy those right now from some reputable online stores.

Until whatever other new battery shows up to actually purchase, it exists in a liminal, theoretical state only.

Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by kazinator on Friday March 05, 2021 @11:38AM (#26358813)
Humor is totally appreciated here; I got more than 80 upvotes for a silly comment yesterday.
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by conjectures on Friday March 05, 2021 @10:22AM (#26357784)
> Humour is rarely appreciated here, but I found this funny and on point.

Yes, we just play our hyperbole with a straight bat.

Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by melomal on Friday March 05, 2021 @06:42AM (#26355739)
> [insert AI/ML/other tech] announcements are always extremely over hyped. Mostly by media and PR departments rather than actual scientific or domain specific outlets.

Rule of thumb, if it sounds to good to be true. It probably is but the PR department needs to do something.

Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by kemiller2002 on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:38AM (#26354883)
I’m just curious, is there any time when having a battery explode into flaming debris a good thing? :)
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by hackerbabz on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:39AM (#26354892)
A little extra kick during staging for Rocketlab :)
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by m_mueller on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:54AM (#26354985)
Not if they wanna reuse though. ;)
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by okareaman on Friday March 05, 2021 @10:44AM (#26358089)
TwoBit's response is perfect because I've been hearing of battery breakthroughs on a regular basis for over 30 years. I don't even read them anymore. I'll catch up when they do actually do something notable.
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by Cthulhu_ on Friday March 05, 2021 @10:29AM (#26357863)
The actual facts are that they're not mass produced and commercially available, just like all the other battery advancements that pop up a few times a year.
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by elihu on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:29AM (#26354827)
also, dear technology journalist:

[x] your description uses milliamp hours and milliamps per hour interchangeably

[x] milliamp hours is a useless metric when we don't know how big/heavy said battery is

[x] milliamp hours is a useless metric when we don't know the battery's voltage

Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by jsight on Friday March 05, 2021 @09:59AM (#26357516)
At least it doesn't use milliamp hours per hour as a unit. I'm pretty sure one of the cars actually does that with KW (Kwh/hr).
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by elihu on Friday March 05, 2021 @02:47PM (#26361199)
I can sort of see how that's justified when advertising to people who don't really understand electrical units. The battery capacity is listed in kilowatt hours. If you don't really understand what a kilowatt is but you know the battery has a capacity of 60 kilowatt hours, and the charger charges at 10 kilowatt hours per hour, then it'll charge in about 6 hours.

Still, it does make me cringe a little.

Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by djrogers on Friday March 05, 2021 @11:30AM (#26358701)
That seems like a reasonable unit to use when measuring charge rate though…
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by NobodyNada on Friday March 05, 2021 @11:59AM (#26359071)
A kilowatt-hour is the total amount of energy transferred over the course of an hour at a rate of one kilowatt, so "kilowatt-hours per hour" is just "kilowatts".
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by Escapado on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:03AM (#26354619)
This made me chuckle. Is there a table anywhere with a lot of promising contenders as columns and those criteria as rows (or that transposed)?
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by buran77 on Friday March 05, 2021 @05:00AM (#26355027)
Sure it's a funny checklist but not very useful since it can be used to dismiss anything. Coal can generate a lot of electricity even in the dark or in the gentlest of breezes yet we still develop tech for solar or wind power.
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by ThomPete on Friday March 05, 2021 @07:10AM (#26355924)
as it should be. Energy is about hard sciences, not technology, and so progress is very unlikely and thus slow, much slower than the claims about breakthroughs.
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by ffggvv on Friday March 05, 2021 @12:59PM (#26359798)
[x] it lacks the energy density to make it sufficiently portable.

that only matters if you want a portable battery. there are alot of uses where it doesnt need to be portable at all. thats only for electric cars. same with crash resistance etc, and even affordability for average users.

it literally says "satellites and industrial machinery." in the article, neither of which needs to be very cheap or portable. especially because other batteries arent good under extreme temps

Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by piettes on Friday March 05, 2021 @07:34AM (#26356120)
From the title

> ... applications in industrial machinery and space

In the first line

> ... making it a candidate for use in satellites and industrial machinery.

So 2/3 of your points don't really make sense

Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by hackeraccount on Friday March 05, 2021 @08:29AM (#26356620)
Nice. It's a common enough joke that could have been a dog but enough effort was put in to make it a real winner.

Thanks.

Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by kazinator on Friday March 05, 2021 @11:38AM (#26358805)
Is that hosted somewhere, or did you make it up just for this comment?

It seems inspired by this classic:

https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt

Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by waterhouse on Friday March 05, 2021 @12:52PM (#26359697)
Looks to have come from here (Dec 08 2020, apparently): https://pedriana.wordpress.com/2020/12/08/new-battery-techno...
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by raverbashing on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:16AM (#26354728)
As history has shown w.r.t spam, the stuff eventually gets sorted out

I'm sure people could have come with similar criticism for li-ion batteries, before them took over

Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by evgen on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:23AM (#26354780)
Not only that, if this battery had been available first then the attack on someone pushing Li-ion would have been:

[x] it lacks thermal stability at low or high temperatures.

[x] it is too likely to catch fire or explode.

Too many people think Li-ion is magic, when it just happens to occupy a particular niche of characteristics that let it get a good early jump in the race for portable power. Nothing about the chemistry involved mandates it remain in a position of primacy.

Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by sambe on Friday March 05, 2021 @05:32AM (#26355245)
Yes but Li-ion was first, so that's what you now have to beat (including the ways in which world has adapted/overcome its shortfalls).
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by evgen on Friday March 05, 2021 @06:33AM (#26355668)
Are you kidding me? The 'first' was the Voltaic pile, copper and zinc. The first practical rechargeable was lead-acid. Li-ion is a relative newcomer, but had a sufficient power density to lead to a lot of applications which in turn led to a lot of research on improving Li-ion in a virtuous circle. We are pushing the limits of Li-ion and know that is sucks for some environments or application requirements, which is why people research alternatives.

This particular alternative is useful in some very specific niches in which Li-ion will _never_ be competitive.

Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by gnatman on Friday March 05, 2021 @06:55AM (#26355825)
I believe sambe was using “first” in the same way you did, i.e. first of the two
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by rasz on Friday March 05, 2021 @09:28AM (#26357193)
Could it tho? First commercial liion batteries were developed by Sony in 1991 according to Wiki. By 1996 Toshiba was already shipping Libretto palmtops with 1200mAh 17670 cells. Today, in 2021 you cant go better than 3x this capacity in same/similar form factor.
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by asah on Friday March 05, 2021 @06:10AM (#26355486)
this is amazing, thank you.
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ... by Dirlewanger on Friday March 05, 2021 @10:15AM (#26357690)
Li-ion batteries have been the same for like 40 years, they've just gotten smaller.