Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ...
by evgen on Friday March 05, 2021 @04:23AM
(#26354780)
Not only that, if this battery had been available first then the attack on someone pushing Li-ion would have been:
[x] it lacks thermal stability at low or high temperatures.
[x] it is too likely to catch fire or explode.
Too many people think Li-ion is magic, when it just happens to occupy a particular niche of characteristics that let it get a good early jump in the race for portable power. Nothing about the chemistry involved mandates it remain in a position of primacy.
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ...
by sambe on Friday March 05, 2021 @05:32AM
(#26355245)
Yes but Li-ion was first, so that's what you now have to beat (including the ways in which world has adapted/overcome its shortfalls).
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ...
by evgen on Friday March 05, 2021 @06:33AM
(#26355668)
Are you kidding me? The 'first' was the Voltaic pile, copper and zinc. The first practical rechargeable was lead-acid. Li-ion is a relative newcomer, but had a sufficient power density to lead to a lot of applications which in turn led to a lot of research on improving Li-ion in a virtuous circle. We are pushing the limits of Li-ion and know that is sucks for some environments or application requirements, which is why people research alternatives.
This particular alternative is useful in some very specific niches in which Li-ion will _never_ be competitive.
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ...
by gnatman on Friday March 05, 2021 @06:55AM
(#26355825)
I believe sambe was using “first” in the same way you did, i.e. first of the two
Re:"World's highest-capacity" solid-state battery developed ...
by rasz on Friday March 05, 2021 @09:28AM
(#26357193)
Could it tho? First commercial liion batteries were developed by Sony in 1991 according to Wiki. By 1996 Toshiba was already shipping Libretto palmtops with 1200mAh 17670 cells. Today, in 2021 you cant go better than 3x this capacity in same/similar form factor.
I'm sure people could have come with similar criticism for li-ion batteries, before them took over