News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more ... by DrinkWater on Thursday March 04, 2021 @07:18AM (#26341427)
No matter how much i read into NFTs, i cant wrap my head around the idea. It just sounds like a scam.
Re:Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more ... by coldcode on Thursday March 04, 2021 @07:22AM (#26341448)
As a digital artist I find them highly intriguing to consider. As a person I still can't figure out why people would be paying me for a hash and not actually get anything.
Re:Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more ... by bambax on Thursday March 04, 2021 @08:29AM (#26342065)
It's speculation. People who buy highly expensive pieces of art and store them in a vault in Geneva* don't enjoy them in any way. It's a value store.

Why not buy Bitcoins instead? I think it has to do with the cool factor. It feels probably better to own an NFT than a Bitcoin, as it feels different to own actual art than stock in the Coca-Cola company.

(I can only guess though, I have never owned any of those.)

* https://www.crozier.ch/en/services/art-storage

Re:Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more ... by iamacyborg on Thursday March 04, 2021 @07:24AM (#26341470)
Yeah, I just don't understand why people would pay tens of thousands of pounds for a .jpg or .gif
Re:Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more ... by AlwaysBCoding on Thursday March 04, 2021 @07:51AM (#26341689)
1. Money Laundering: If you made money from a pump and dump or something otherwise nefarious that you want to convert back to USD and explain away, a good way is to mint digital art and sell it to yourself. Then when you report it to the IRS you made $100,000 from selling digital artwork to an anonymous buyer instead of from insider trading a low market cap coin. This is not so different from how art works in meatspace (see Mark Rothko).

2. Charity: It's hard to really grok this if you don't live in the crypto world but people make insane amounts of money from Ethereum. I know multiple people who are under 30 and have each made upwards of $500,000,000 from buying ETH in the presale / insider trading in bull markets. Generally someone who bought into the ETH presale is a mega crypto bull and keeps a large percentage of their net worth in crypto. It's trivial for them to support artists by buying their artwork for a minuscule fraction of the money they've made. What sounds like "buying a .jpg for thousands of dollars" to someone not in this world, is more like the crypto equivalent of tipping a live streamer a bit on twitch.

Re:Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more ... by throwaway744678 on Thursday March 04, 2021 @07:53AM (#26341706)
I don't understand it either, but they actually pay for a certificate of ownership of a .jpg or .gif, whatever this means.
Re:Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more ... by kybernetikos on Thursday March 04, 2021 @07:27AM (#26341487)
First of all - you're right.

Second of all - why do people pay more for a limited edition print than a normal print?

Re:Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more ... by jcfrei on Thursday March 04, 2021 @07:46AM (#26341645)
See my previous answer for a possible reason: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26288948
Re:Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more ... by eoo on Thursday March 04, 2021 @07:45AM (#26341633)
I think it's really similar to art. It's more about your relationship with the artist or the emotion that makes you want to own the original... And of course, the art market.
Re:Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more ... by Tenoke on Thursday March 04, 2021 @07:25AM (#26341478)
It's a digital unfakeable deed to an asset, that asset being a trading card, artwork or something else. It's no more of a scam than selling the rights to say a song you made. Although in both cases some might scam by selling/using stuff they don't own.
Re:Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more ... by Lazare on Thursday March 04, 2021 @08:37AM (#26342168)
> It's a digital unfakeable deed to an asset, that asset being a trading card, artwork or something else.

Well...no. Quite the opposite. The art is an asset. NFTs are not the artwork, and they're not a deed to the artwork. Buying an NFT gives you ownership of the NFT; it doesn't give you ownership of the artwork.

Selling digital unfakeable deeds to an artwork, and trading those deeds on the blockchain, sounds really cool. That might have value! But to the best of my knowledge, nobody has done that, largely because it's utterly impossible and we have no idea how to even go about trying to do it. And in any case, NFTs certainly aren't that. You're not buying and selling the artwork, you're buying and selling a numbered acknowledgement that the artwork exists.

Re:Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more ... by kevingadd on Thursday March 04, 2021 @07:36AM (#26341550)
One major scam that's lower effort here is that you can simply sell someone else's digital art. Selling physical art forgeries has always been a thing but the risks involved in doing it (i.e. what if you get caught) and the costs (faking a detailed painting isn't EASY) mean it's not as attractive as just grabbing some Japanese or Chinese artist's stuff off Pixiv and selling it as an NFT to english speakers, where the original artist may never find out about it.
Re:Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more ... by Tenoke on Thursday March 04, 2021 @07:48AM (#26341655)
The comparison isn't so much physical art as selling someone else's photos or songs or game assets on the internet which doesn't involve crypto.
Re:Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more ... by iamben on Thursday March 04, 2021 @07:55AM (#26341715)
Except if I bought the rights to a song (like Hipgnosis Songs Fund are doing, for instance), I could profit off them as the song is mine. As far as I understand, for the most part with NFTs, it's more akin to buying a baseball card - I can't reproduce or profit off it, I just 'own' it.
Re:Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more ... by Tenoke on Thursday March 04, 2021 @08:15AM (#26341893)
Depends how you set it up. Both are possible, just how you can sell both the rights to own an instance of it and the rights to sell.
Re:Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more ... by abledon on Thursday March 04, 2021 @07:25AM (#26341482)
upload all:

- .pngs are you're 8 year old self may have left in your parents windows MyDocuments folder,

- scratch files your 14 year old self made at VFX camp

- any unused game assets that you have made for Unity/Godot

e.g. http://cryptoart.wtf/#https://superrare.co/artwork-v2/spheri...

(assign a GPT3 generated phrase, being fed some texts from the cubism,dada era (duchamp, picasso etc...) )

make 400$!

This thing is gonna get flooded

Re:Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more ... by PebblesRox on Thursday March 04, 2021 @07:46AM (#26341644)
I thought each token cost over a hundred dollars to mint. Otherwise I'd play around with adding a few things. As it is, it's gambling to see if someone will want to pay you more for what you minted than the cost to mint it, right?
Re:Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more ... by andybak on Thursday March 04, 2021 @07:32AM (#26341521)
Already started to happen. People have been posting complaints about junk or low-effort NFTs on Twitter a lot recently.

And I'm sitting on Marcel Duchamp's toilet chuckling to myself.

Re:Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more ... by paulcole on Thursday March 04, 2021 @07:24AM (#26341463)
Can you wrap your head around the idea of BTC? If so, I’d be curious to know how you think they’re different.