The Hungarians (and presumably the Chinese) have their own just-so stories about why YMD is the most practical order: you use dates mostly when you sort heating bills, invoices, or even fruit preserves, and in all those cases you need to sort by year first.
Australians will tell you a tale about how "day before month" is human-scale, while "month before day" is not. Heck, ask a German why the decimal comma is superior to the decimal point, and you'll hear plenty of practical-sounding reasons. French carpenters will tell you how they use decimal units because those are much more practical than inches. British people will explain how left-hand traffic is the only practical choice (6a41ef).
People are much better at confabulating reasons for sticking with conventions than they are at telling practical and impractical conventions apart. Indeed, if there was one obviously practical choice, there would be no differing conventions for ISO standards to reconcile.
Take for example "October the third, two thousand nine" (10/3/2009, MDY). In German one would pronounce this as "der dritte Oktober zweitausendneun" (3.10.2009, DMY). In Hungarian "kétezer-kilenc október harmadika" (2009. 10. 03., YMD). All of these pronunciations reflect the order numerical dates are written: using any other convention would simply make them less natural to pronounce.
Now it is certainly not unheard of that the order of pronunciation also changes (see the British "the third of October"), but changing language is a lot harder in some cases impossible without breaking grammar than changing written numerical representations.
Sure, date order may be decided based on accidental grammatical features of the target language. But that just reaffirms that "practicality for the common man" is rationalization.
Naturally, the written convention need not affect pronunciation: in the case of numbers, the world standardized on decimals with place values increasing from right to left, but most languages retain their own idiosyncratic ways of naming/reading them This causes negligible friction in practice.
Why big endianness is great though, in practice is that most of the time you actually do care about the year when you use the written form AND it's unambigous. The problem with the reverse notations is not that it seems illogical to some people. The problem is that both d/m/y and m/d/y is used and you can't have the faintest idea which one you are looking at.
Now in theory we could have y/d/m, but we fortunately don't, so seeing the first number being a 4 digit one, you know how to interpret the date.
I should note that the Hungarians (can't speak for the Chinese) obviously leave out the year when it's clear which year is meant.
For most of the literature people read in the 21st century, especially this past decade, the year is the most important part. People normally couldn't care less whether something was published 3 days ago or 3 months ago. But knowing whether it was published 3 years ago makes all the difference in the world to its relevancy.
There are many use cases for dates. From publication date to planning vacation on a calendar. What is the most common use for a date? Calendar, I guess? The most frequently used dates we encounter are within +/- weeks from now. In a day to day use, YYYY is useless.
Another common remaining example might be a bank statement. But what's interesting there is that the dates are in a column and the year disappears. It hardly matters whether the year comes first or last because you don't actually notice it at all unless the year is rolling over--conspicuous change in that column.
But when I'm looking at something lacking implicit context regarding publication date, such as an online magazine article, a YouTube video, or a Tweet, the year is the first thing I'm searching for. Even on HN, the rule is that the year needs to be included in the title if it wasn't published in the current year.
I guess for e-mail the day and month are most important (similar to bank statements), unless you're reading really old messages. But I use mutt with a default mailbox view that doesn't even show the year.
Speaking from personal experience, even an American can make an effort to use YYYY-MM-DD in any situation asking for a numeric date, and almost always succeed. The biggest exceptions are forms asking for MM/DD, and online payment forms asking for credit card expiration as MM/YY.
Nobody forces you to write ISO 8601 dates but if you want your dates to be easily parseable by humans, why would you write them all in numbers?
3 Nov 2020, 3rd November 2020, Nov 3rd 2020, even something like 2020 Nov 3 is uniquely parseable by humans. Even if the human doesn't know the language of the month, they can still find out what date it is from a Google search.
With 3/10/2020 you never know for sure what date it is.
> I personally prefer inches and feet, they are just human scale dimensions.
Meter, centimeters, and millimeters are human scale dimensions, too. Just because you didn't grow up with them doesn't make them non-human.
But that's the beauty about easily convertable units. Even if other people use other conventions, the mental process to convert them is almost zero.
Just imagine somebody giving their height just in inches instead of the usual feet and inches?
Could you mentally parse what 76 inches are?
I guess you have basically no problem with 193cm, 1.93m , or "one ninety-three", or even 19.3dm.
US people measure their weight in pounds, 182lb
So yes, a USian telling their weight to a UKian would be like saying their height in inches.
We also tend to still refer to height informally in feet and inches.
That's about our only remaining usage of imperial units apart from inches in penis size. We refer to a serving of beer between 425mL to 468mL as a pint, but it's only a descriptive term and not a legal measure.
Now only if we evolved to have 12 fingers, we would have a supercharged metric system in duodecimal (base 12). Far superior to the decimal number system we use today.
Really? It's hard to parse the year??
What about when you come across a piece of paper written some time ago, is it not useful to know the year?
> most people convey to others that this box is 12x8x8 inches
"Most people" == nobody outside of the US.
> And no one uses decimeter (10 cm) for some reason which is actually nice since its the size of the index finger
I just measured my index finger. It is 8.45 cm.
Replace inches with cm, I didn't explain it well. Even if it is centimeter, people would tell dimensions to others more than convert them. The point was about frequency of communication between humans vs. frequency of converting units.
You seem to be taking offense that I said something US-centric. I didn't mean that at all.
Is it so hard to write "it is?" Nevertheless, you used a contraction.
You did so entirely unconsciously because that's how langauge works.
And 3/2. Is that the future or the past? No way to know. Did you miss the meeting, or is it next week?
"No one uses a decimeter"... What bubble do you live in? But please, lecture some more about cultures you don't understand.
1 Feb 2021
This is a bit more human-readable and closer to commonly-used forms of dates while still being completely unambiguous.Someone was getting the date as 01MMMYYYY and using it as a partition name. When the first day of the tenth month happened, everything broke, because it was expecting OCT, not OKT.
Unambiguous but wrong.
With humans reading it, either you need to be unambiguous, so use yyyy-mm-dd, or you don't have to be, so use a format that most of your audience will understand.
A bit more human readable you say? So 1 фев 2021, 1 Lut 2021, or 2021 فبراير1 are readable to you? I don't know but to me that's just US-centric thinking all over again.
I was going to ragequit at you for copy+pasting something into google translate, as it's شُبَاط not فبراير.
but TIL, only in the Levant do we say شُبَاط apparently.
But if the software show 2021-03-02, I unambiguously know which it is.
We weren't so globally connected just 20 years ago, so if you were in US, you were used to MM/DD format and if you were anywhere else, you were used to DD/MM format. It was all local.
Within a certain range you'll do fine either way. Outside of a certain range you'll always need a measuring tape, or you just had a had a lot of practice, eyeballing and learned habits going in.
Works fine for the Chinese and Japanese, and last I checked they were humans.
American English already has this weirdness elsewhere - the $-sign in $15 is read in the "wrong" place and always trips me up when I'm reading something out loud but others will defend that practice to the death
Not everything logical works with humans. In my day to day life (not engineering use), I personally prefer inches and feet, they are just human scale dimensions. Conversion happens less often than you think - most people convey to others that this box is 12x8x8 inches. Conversion from inches to feet happens way less often. I hate fractions though. It would be great if a centimeter was twice as long in physical dimensions. It's just too granular and falls in an uncanny valley. And no one uses decimeter (10 cm) for some reason which is actually nice since it is roughly the size of the index finger.