News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by itg on Saturday June 04, 2011 @12:34PM (#2619768)
This is also infuriating when it comes to medical knowledge and dealing with doctors. I personally know someone who had a uncommon disease and he did extensive research looking at articles published in journals and science/medical books. However, almost every doctor he went to dismissed him and laughed at the idea that he could possibly know what he was talking about. Most of them don't deal with the uncommon diseases and refuse to believe it when it is in front of their eyes.

It wasn't until he got into touch with a scientist who did research into the same disease he had that they were finally able to convince doctors to take a closer look and start receiving treatment. Turns out he was right but had to suffer for a few years because of the arrogance of a few "professionals".

Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by phren0logy on Saturday June 04, 2011 @02:39PM (#2620129)
This happens with legit medical conditions, but also diagnoses that have been made up by the internet. For example, "Wireless Sensitivity," and "Moregellons Disease." It would be helpful to know which category we're talking about.

Speaking of which, the idea that they might "refuse to believe it when it is in front of their eyes" is, when judiciously applied, a strength of evidence-based medicine. Anecdotal experience should not be discarded, but needs to be put in the context of the existing mountain of scientific data.

Edit: Also, it is totally unacceptable that any of these doctors would laugh at your friend. No matter the situation, this should prompt a thorough discussion of the reasoning the doctor is using to decide to treat or not treat.

Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by Qz on Saturday June 04, 2011 @04:20PM (#2620361)
Damnit, here I was, having completely forgotten about the fictitious horrors of Moregellons Disease, and now you had to remind me. For a fake disease, that shit still creeps me the fuck out.
Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by dr_ on Saturday June 04, 2011 @12:49PM (#2619803)
That's true but hopefully not too common. In medical school, when it comes to diagnosing conditions, we are taught "When you hear hoofbeats, think of horses, not zebras". Fortunately there is a wealth of information available to patients online which can help them when working with their physicians in dealing with uncommon medical conditions. There needs to be a much better way to sort through it all however.
Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by sambe on Saturday June 04, 2011 @01:08PM (#2619862)
In my experience, almost every single doctor will not only talk down to patients who know something, they will also put them in the "crackpot hypochondriac" bucket. Further, most of those I've seen are not even scientists: sure, they have all the knowledge of a good medical training and can deal with common and emergency situations exceptionally well. But anything more than that and it's time for rampant lack of logic and stock recommendations that have already failed to work.
Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by noonespecial on Saturday June 04, 2011 @02:09PM (#2620031)
Further, most of those I've seen are not even scientists:

I've been disappointed by this realization a couple of times. Finally, it dawned on me. Doctors aren't scientists. They're not supposed to be. They are technicians. They look in a service manual, pick a likely problem, and do the hotfix. If its not in the manual (or the part they have memorized), they're done.

Medical research and medical practice are two entirely different animals.

Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by watty on Saturday June 04, 2011 @02:59PM (#2620182)
Of course doctors aren't scientists, but comparing them to a "technician" is a horrible analogy. Doctors go through intense schooling and have a very deep understanding of all parts of the body. Your analogy fits more closely to a nurse, someone with very basic symptom/problem repertoire - not a dr. who knows what and WHY things are happening.

I've also never heard of a doctor being "done" - when have you encountered this? They may not be able to diagnose you immediately but they do research in other resources to help diagnose.

Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by protomyth on Saturday June 04, 2011 @04:42PM (#2620409)
I agree with noonespecial about the technician statement, but sense that you regard that as an insult. Every good technician I know has an great understanding about the "item" they work on. I have a lot of respect for good technicians of all stripes. Doctors don't build new people, they repair, maintain, treat, and fix them.

As to a doctor being "done". Yeah, I have heard that in government provided (USA) health care settings. It happens, and it gets much worse the later in the budget year your are ("Don't get sick after June").

Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by watty on Sunday June 05, 2011 @10:00AM (#2622010)
Sure doctors "fix things" but that's an oversimplification of their jobs. It's like saying rocket scientists are like construction workers because they "build things". There is a vast difference in the knowledge/schooling required. I didn't think the simple analogy as a doctor/technician as an insult as much as the description of their duties (1. Look in manual, 2. Hotfix, 3. If not there, done) - this is insulting whether describing technicians or doctors.

And no, doctors aren't "done" when the problem isn't in the manual. You're referring to something completely different, "I don't have money or healthcare and expect you to work for free". Maybe they're like technicians after all.

Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by protomyth on Sunday June 05, 2011 @01:59PM (#2622484)
I guess I don't believe a definition of a real technician is simply someone who looks in a manual to fix thing. I believe technicians of all stripes need knowledge and a good feel to fix things. I think your definition of technician is limited and does disservice to a wide variety of professions.

"I don't have money or healthcare and expect you to work for free" - no, the USA was paid in land via treaty, so the bill was paid.

Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by cma on Saturday June 04, 2011 @05:58PM (#2620584)
>a dr. who knows what and WHY

Same could be said of an auto mechanic--the prototypical technician.

Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by watty on Sunday June 05, 2011 @10:11AM (#2622020)
Good point, but it can only be said of certified auto mechanics. I don't know the percentage of auto-mechanics that are certified and tested to know "why" but I'm guessing it's less than doctors (100%).

Either way, it's a pointless argument comparing the systems and schooling required to understand automobiles vs. the human body.

Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by Locke1689 on Saturday June 04, 2011 @04:18PM (#2620357)
Both of my parents are physicians (pathologists). What you're saying isn't true at all -- they do diagnostic medicine all the time. This is in every way scientific. At the moment they're both doing research, but previously my mother was in private practice.
Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by noonespecial on Saturday June 04, 2011 @04:50PM (#2620433)
The further up the specialization ladder you travel, the more scientist-like the doctors become until you reach the pinnacle where doctors at research hospitals are doing ground-breaking treatments and publishing the results.

The gulf between the average MD doing GP and this pinnacle is huge. Much larger than most people suspect.

Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by Locke1689 on Saturday June 04, 2011 @06:45PM (#2620647)
I don't understand what you're trying to say. First, the average MD isn't a PCP with generalist training. In fact, a lot of PCPs now are IM specialists. In fact, when talking about PCPs, there are many cases when no generalists come into the equation at all -- kids should see pediatricians as their PCP.
Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by ceejayoz on Saturday June 04, 2011 @01:12PM (#2619869)
> In my experience, almost every single doctor will not only talk down to patients who know something, they will also put them in the "crackpot hypochondriac" bucket.

In fairness, that's generally the appropriate approach. Given the choice between "crackpot hypochondriac" and "disease most doctors won't see in a lifetime of practice", the former is far more common.

Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by gruseom on Saturday June 04, 2011 @01:18PM (#2619891)
Supercilious dismissal is not generally the appropriate approach.
Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by carbocation on Saturday June 04, 2011 @01:39PM (#2619948)
Yeah, so as it turns out, speaking in generalities is useless. Let's talk about the specific condition so those of us with a medical background can talk about the degree of difficulty of diagnosis and treatment. Saying "being dismissive is bad" is just universally true.
Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by robrenaud on Saturday June 04, 2011 @03:23PM (#2620236)
I think my spam filter does a pretty good job at being dismissive, and I am thankful for it.
Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by carbocation on Saturday June 04, 2011 @05:02PM (#2620460)
I guess I thought we were talking about physicians.
Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by ceejayoz on Saturday June 04, 2011 @02:17PM (#2620062)
In a perfect world, perhaps. Here in the States, though, there's already a shortage of general practitioners.

Expecting them to spend significant extra time with all the hypochondriacs is simply not practical. Doing so would be a detriment to every patient in the system.

Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by StrawberryFrog on Saturday June 04, 2011 @03:35PM (#2620267)
But for "disease most doctors won't see in a lifetime of practice" it generally is appropriate (or at least some form of dismissal is appropriate), since the patient is generally wrong.

NB: "generally" in this case means approx 99.9% of the time.

Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by Locke1689 on Saturday June 04, 2011 @04:24PM (#2620371)
Well, no offense but anecdotal evidence does not a large dataset make. I personally have the opposite experience. Since my parents are physicians I've grown up in and around hospitals all my life and met probably hundreds of physicians. In talking with them and talking with my parents about them I've found maybe two dozen that are either unscientific or incompetent. I completely agree that ~20% is way too high, but insulting all doctors based on your knowledge of maybe 3 or 4 of them is like saying all computer scientists are unscientific (although many are) just because you had a ten minute chat with three or four bottom-level PHP programmers.
Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by enko on Saturday June 04, 2011 @10:59PM (#2621164)
Thanks for your input, but what were you saying about "anecdotal evidence does not a large dataset make" ; )
Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by Locke1689 on Sunday June 05, 2011 @05:02AM (#2621662)
Oh, I thought it was clear I was simply presenting this as counter-anecdotal evidence (although my anecdotal data set is probably an order of magnitude higher than the ops). I was arguing more for the null hypothesis than "physicians are definitely scientific."
Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by westicle on Saturday June 04, 2011 @10:43PM (#2621137)
I wonder if African doctors are taught "When you hear hoofbeats, think of zebras, not horses"?

That might sound like a flippant comment, but I found it interesting that such a subjective example is used to demonstrate what should be an objective axiom.

Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by StrawberryFrog on Sunday June 05, 2011 @06:32AM (#2621754)
Having lived in Africa (Cape Town) I I'd say that I saw more horses than zebras there.

Though sometimes, in the bush, it was zebras.

Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by maeon3 on Saturday June 04, 2011 @12:59PM (#2619830)
With the explosion of information and data collected about diseases, it is quite possible for a patient to walk in with a rare disease to be FAR more informed about his condition than any doctor.

If you have a rare disease, then it behooves you to put on your Science hat and get creative about how to motivate smart people to investigate your condition rather than going to a doctor to have him tell you that it is hopeless and the best he can do is give you a battery of drugs which might work, and that you have 1 year to live.

Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by thaumaturgy on Saturday June 04, 2011 @01:07PM (#2619855)
You're right, but don't forget about all the many hypochondriacs out there; unfortunately, given the current Western model of medical care, a doctor may not know their patient well enough to know if the patient has rationally, logically, and objectively diagnosed themselves, or if the patient has a psychological disorder instead that's manifesting as a rare physical disease.
Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by joe_the_user on Saturday June 04, 2011 @03:25PM (#2620245)
Yes, the situation today is an extraordinary dilemma. I'm not sure why hypochondriacs are so common today but I would speculate that this it is because many people are starved for attention.

But you have a situation where a doctor, who is a highly professional but not a research scientist, confronts a growing number of individuals who have gotten a mass of scientific information from the Internet but are proportionately even less likely to engage in a rational process of determining what malady they have. Some of these patients probably know what's wrong with them much better than the doctor but what percentage is it? What is likely to happen given a health care system which measures the doctor's visit times by the second?

Perhaps there should be online exam for patients wanting to diagnose themselves, including basic test of inferential reasoning? Hey, there's a startup idea for you - a website which prepares your diagnosis using language your doctor can understand.

Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by philwelch on Saturday June 04, 2011 @05:12PM (#2620478)
There's also something called "medical students' disease" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medical_students_disease) where people who research medical conditions become convinced that they have those conditions. It's easy to see how a hypochondriac researching their medical problems online would end up developing medical students' disease.
Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by CamperBob on Saturday June 04, 2011 @04:31PM (#2620386)
With the explosion of information and data collected about diseases, it is quite possible for a patient to walk in with a rare disease to be FAR more informed about his condition than any doctor.

That doesn't necessarily mean anything, though. When I broke my collarbone last year, I joined a massive 'community' of patients with the most commonly broken bone in the human body. Initially I thought it'd be easy to get advice online with regard to what to expect in terms of healing time, mobility, pain, and long-term outcome, and what therapies were most/least effective. It wasn't. What I found made me realize that self-diagnosing pretty much anything on the Internet, no matter how trivial, is a really bad idea... and that this is true regardless of whether the doctors have better advice to offer.

Even if the consensus of doctors, nurses, authors, coaches, and fellow sufferers was that "Each case is different, so it's impossible to generalize about any of those things," that would've been fine. Unsatisfying, but fine. It would've been the correct conclusion for a new patient to reach. But it wasn't. If you look up clavicle fractures on the Web, you'll find a ridiculous array of claims, anecdotes, and received wisdom... and that's just in the peer-reviewed literature, never mind the various sports and health forums.

It turns out that nobody really knows the best way to treat collarbone fractures of a given type and severity. Ultimately you just go back for x-rays every couple of months (weeks) until the doctor tells you you can (remove the sling carefully) (get back on the bike) (pick fights with bears.) The nature and location of the fracture affects the prognosis, but doesn't have much to do with the treatment for those patients who don't opt for surgery. Some doctors swear by sling type X, others by brace type Y. Some doctors will yell at you to keep your sling on at all times; other doctors will tell you not to bother with it past the first three or four weeks unless you actually experience pain. Some doctors say not to lift anything at all; others say it's OK to lift until it hurts. The spectrum of advice given to patients who post essentially the same x-rays to various sports forums is amazing, as are the anecdotes ranging from "I blew off the doctor and went swimming in 4 weeks, no problem" to "I followed the doctor's advice and ended up in painful/painless surgery six months/two years later."

Again, none of this is unreasonable given the differences from one case to the next... but you won't recognize this fact based on advice found online. What most people will be tempted to do is surf until they get an answer they like, and then walk away from the browser thinking they know more than they did when they sat down.

As an exercise, I recommend that even HN readers with intact clavicles spend a couple of hours researching the condition from the POV of a newly diagnosed patient. You may not come away as disillusioned with the wisdom of the Internet as I did, but I believe you will think twice about the quality of online information if you're ever diagnosed with a serious, uncommon condition like Crohn's. Sorry, Crohn's (and collarbone) patients -- sometimes the truth just isn't out there.

Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by araneae on Saturday June 04, 2011 @05:51PM (#2620563)
Here's the problem:

Your friend was smart, but most people who come into the doctor with self-diagnoses are whack jobs. Doctors don't know who to take seriously so they take no one seriously, unless you approach them the right way.

Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by tokenadult on Saturday June 04, 2011 @08:19PM (#2620839)
This is also infuriating when it comes to medical knowledge and dealing with doctors.

A really good site about the trade-offs involved in judgment under uncertainty in medical diagnosis is Science-Based Medicine,

http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/

a group blog with bloggers of varying professional credentials that occasionally has truly excellent articles on human cognitive illusions and how they influence medical diagnosis and treatment.

Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by carbocation on Saturday June 04, 2011 @02:20PM (#2620079)
Since this is someone you know and not you, can you at least share what condition this was? If it's something truly rare in the place you live (say, tropical sprue) then it may be a difficult diagnosis that gets misdiagnosed as something more common because of the following approximation:

  var i = 0;
  while(patient==ill){
    if(hoofbeats){
       if(i<20){
         return horses;
       }else{
         return `hunt zebras`
       }
       i++;
    }
  }
Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by gaius on Monday June 06, 2011 @11:18AM (#2624984)
Looks like you're returning an enum on one branch there, and a string on the other.
Re:Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset abou... by carbocation on Monday June 06, 2011 @11:58AM (#2625134)
What do you expect from someone who writes PHP? O_o