News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by cybrexalpha on Thursday February 18, 2021 @10:13AM (#26180700)
Have nvidia lost their minds?

It's going to take days for mining operations to reverse-engineer the driver and undo this. So commercial operations won't be affected at all.

Worse, their detection isn't going to be 100% perfect. What if After Effects does something that looks "kind of" like mining. Is it just going to be crippled? What will nvidia do then? Suggest I buy a Quadro for AE support?

This will only penalise average users.

Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by PragmaticPulp on Thursday February 18, 2021 @08:53PM (#26188546)
> This will only penalise average users.

How?

Currently, average users can't get their hands on any of these cards because they're being bought in bulk by crypto miners. As soon as mining becomes unprofitable, the market will be flooded with cards that have been run 24/7 for months or years, which isn't a recipe for a good experience.

The average user can only benefit from getting access to these cards again. nVidia knows they can't afford to burn goodwill with their customers, whom they depend on to buy card upgrades every few years.

> Worse, their detection isn't going to be 100% perfect. What if After Effects does something that looks "kind of" like mining. Is it just going to be crippled? What will nvidia do then?

nVidia isn't a resource-limited startup. They have a lot of smart people. They're obviously going to test the firmware against common workloads.

Regardless, don't buy a card unless you know it does what you want it to do. These cards are all mining-limited from day 1, so it's not like the performance will regress suddenly.

Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by Const-me on Thursday February 18, 2021 @11:11PM (#26189595)
> They're obviously going to test the firmware against common workloads.

They can only test against pre-existing software. If they start penalizing uncommon workloads, this kills innovation in many areas, videogames included.

In one of my projects I'm using GPGPUs for complicated optimizations in CAM/CAE. I don't use any libraries/frameworks. From nVidia's point of views, my compute shaders are extremely uncommon workload. Unwanted too, because I skipped CUDA and their vendor lock-in.

Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by neurostimulant on Friday February 19, 2021 @12:19PM (#26195359)
> If they start penalizing uncommon workloads, this kills innovation in many areas, videogames included.

I'm not too worried about that. Nvidia has track record of releasing driver updates to address issues in end-user applications. If a legitimate application got accidentally flagged, people will report it and nvidia will whitelist them.

Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by Const-me on Friday February 19, 2021 @02:51PM (#26197263)
> people will report it and nvidia will whitelist them

That approach doesn’t work in general. Look at “Manage 3D settings / Program settings” in nVidia’s control panel. They only have presets for very popular software like Adobe After Effects or Premiere, benchmarks like 3D mark, or AAA videogames.

Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by rubatuga on Friday February 19, 2021 @02:07AM (#26190506)
Just use a floating point op and it'll probably be never picked up as hashing.
Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by zelon88 on Thursday February 18, 2021 @10:45AM (#26181150)
That's for the people who already own the card.

If you're in the market for a new card and you have the option of a powerful, purpose-built card that works out of the box or one that needs endless tweaking, few people would choose the more complex option. Especially if it means every new driver that gets released is going to require days to make work properly.

Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by wtallis on Thursday February 18, 2021 @02:05PM (#26184058)
There's no "endless tweaking" to keep your GPU mining rig working.

Constant GPU driver updates are the norm for gaming GPUs because GPU drivers include a huge pile of workarounds for buggy games, and there are new buggy games hitting the market all the time. But if you just want to run a specific straightforward GPGPU task like a miner, you only need to get one driver version properly cracked to unlock full performance, and keep using that until the hardware is no longer profitable to mine with.

And it seems pretty likely that a countermeasure bolted on to the drivers this late in the process will be defeated fairly quickly, and miners will go on a second shopping spree after clearing out the stock of the new purpose-built mining cards. (Assuming those even ship before the 3060 drivers get cracked.)

Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by judge2020 on Thursday February 18, 2021 @04:59PM (#26186265)
Plus, part of the profitability of mining cards is being able to resell them once their profitability is low (and they do usually still work fine for gaming after a year of mining). The new mining cards will have to be insanely profitable to make them look better than the 30-series cards.
Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by nuodag on Friday February 19, 2021 @04:02AM (#26191034)
And i suspect this is one of the reasons Nvidia is doing this. Market Segmentation -> Sell two cards instead of one that gets resold on ebay
Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by arsome on Thursday February 18, 2021 @05:06PM (#26186336)
It all depends on availability - if there are no more CMP cards available, but GeForce cards are still around and there's a known good cracked driver for them, this won't even be a question.

Miners don't care about driver updates so it's really a one-off, not endless, once it's running they don't have to touch it.

Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by tshaddox on Thursday February 18, 2021 @06:29PM (#26187315)
But surely it's not like Nvidia is suddenly adding brand new capacity to produce these new cryptocurrency cards. If they could do that, they could just do that with the same cards to make enough for gamers and miners.
Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by PeterStuer on Thursday February 18, 2021 @05:31PM (#26186691)
People are and still will be buying up every card that they can get their hands on at a price that turns an ROI of less than 6 months. They-ll just download a different driver/firmware if needed.
Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by bluescrn on Thursday February 18, 2021 @05:05PM (#26186330)
A GeForce will have much more resale value than a mining-specific card once mining becomes unprofitable or the next generation of cards come along
Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by paulpan on Thursday February 18, 2021 @11:29AM (#26181847)
So true. Nvidia can't not know how resourceful cryptominers are - and to what lengths a miner will go to modify the firmware for even a few percentage point improvements. It'll just lead to a never-ending back and forth (will daily drivers become a thing?) until Nvidia decides it's not worth the effort.

This just seems like a feeble gesture at appeasing gamers. What's interesting is that these "mining-crippling" changes will only apply to the 3060 GPU, not the rest of the RTX 3000 series. If it was a legitimate gesture, then Nvidia would've made it universally applicable.

Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by lxgr on Thursday February 18, 2021 @12:27PM (#26182734)
Maybe there is some hardware enforcement involved? Also, retroactively capping functionality of a sold product seems like a PR and legal nightmare.
Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by g_p on Thursday February 18, 2021 @12:47PM (#26183026)
The Sony PS3 precedent of removing OtherOS springs to mind regards retroactive restrictions.
Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by paulpan on Thursday February 18, 2021 @04:32PM (#26185917)
From the announcement it seems this is driver-side only, so a big nope.
Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by lxgr on Thursday February 18, 2021 @06:49PM (#26187504)
Hm, then I guess that given that this is a so far unreleased product (and assuming it's not supported in current drivers), Nvidia can at least sidestep the issue of miners just using an old driver version to get the hashing functionality back.
Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by cat199 on Thursday February 18, 2021 @04:37PM (#26185993)
> This just seems like a feeble gesture at appeasing gamers.

Color me cynical, but this seems like a strong gesture at increasing margins on GPU computing by upselling using cryptocurrency and gamers as PR pawns/scapegoats

if Nvidia is selling more cards than they can produce/distribute at desired target prices they should produce more cards and improve their distribution networks..

Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by sujinge9 on Thursday February 18, 2021 @04:44PM (#26186088)
Or, even easier, raise prices...
Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by snak on Friday February 19, 2021 @09:31AM (#26193522)
I don't think that would benefit gamers at all.

Maybe it will offset the days it takes for a graphics card to pay itself by a few weeks? (e.g. previously RTX 3070 took x weeks to pay itself by mining 24/7, maybe it will change to x + 2 weeks?)

Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by tibbydudeza on Thursday February 18, 2021 @05:40PM (#26186793)
The CMP cards will be much cheaper than the GPU gaming units so why would they bother ???.
Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by judge2020 on Friday February 19, 2021 @12:31AM (#26190104)
Pricing is 'only via suppliers' so we have no idea if CMP will be insanely cheaper or if it'll only be slightly cheaper. This most likely won't even solve the current shortages since 3060TIs, 3070s and 3080s will work with an old driver (existing drivers doesn't have any online auto-update, so they can't 100% force a new driver on cards), and the 3060 driver/firmware (some speculate the word 'driver' is inaccurate in the blog post and it'll be a firmware thing) might be hacked to bypass this limitation, so once it's hacked they will just always flash that firmware or use the modified driver.
Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by WrtCdEvrydy on Thursday February 18, 2021 @10:27AM (#26180883)
Yeah, this is about par for the course for Nvidia.

I wish AMD had a working product to kick their teeth in...

Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by COGlory on Thursday February 18, 2021 @10:41AM (#26181099)
They do. The 5700XT is still an excellent card, the 6700 and 6700XT are coming out soon, and the 6800 and 6800XT are both absolutely killer cards as well, especially at the reference prices.

Vendors and demand have effectively driven prices to an insane amount, and you just can't get them, unfortunately. Short of AMD doing something like Nvidia is doing here, I doubt we'll see them on store shelves any time soon.

Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by lozaning on Thursday February 18, 2021 @06:23PM (#26187257)
AMD already did this. The RX6K series are terrible cards for mining. The radeon 7 smokes the new cards because the new ones where designed to be as bad at mining as possible without effecting raster performance.

RX 5700 will hit 55mhs and the RX6K series will do ~68mhs, but the cost of the 5700 is typically like half that of a 6800.

There's a reason it's easier to find the new AMD stuff in stock than nvidia stuff, they've got a terrible mining roi.

Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by RealStickman_ on Saturday February 20, 2021 @03:58AM (#26202775)
Vega 7 is a compute beast. The RX5xxx and RX6xxx are tuned for gaming performance and sacrifice unnecessary compute performance for better power efficiency. No wonder the V7 is way better at mining.
Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by izacus on Thursday February 18, 2021 @10:48AM (#26181200)
And the reason you can't buy them is exactly the same reason nVidia is adding limitations - to try to make the cards less appealing to scalpers so the actual customers may get some.
Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by judge2020 on Friday February 19, 2021 @12:33AM (#26190114)
I think you mean 'miners' - scalpers don't care.
Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by slezyr on Thursday February 18, 2021 @11:37AM (#26181967)
5700XT costs 1000$ in Ukraine. It cost 500$ when it just got released. WTF?

Edit: 1100$ actually.

Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by COGlory on Thursday February 18, 2021 @02:34PM (#26184391)
I just sold a used one for $1100 that I paid $380 for on release. It's because crypto has gone up so much.
Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by encryptluks2 on Thursday February 18, 2021 @10:50AM (#26181231)
Except you won't be able to buy any of them, even when they are released.
Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by account42 on Thursday February 18, 2021 @11:13AM (#26181618)
You might not like the price, but the 6800/6900 ones tend to stay in stock these days in at least some parts of the world [0][1]

[0] https://www.mindfactory.de/Hardware/Grafikkarten+(VGA)/Radeo... [1] https://www.alternate.de/Grafikkarten/Big-Navi

Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by kmeisthax on Thursday February 18, 2021 @10:41AM (#26181085)
They mostly do, the problem is that they're even more supply-constrained than Nvidia right now.
Re:Nvidia announces mining GPUs, cuts the hash rate of RTX-3... by Jonnax on Thursday February 18, 2021 @10:42AM (#26181108)
I'm guessing their 3060 product is their budget card so it's easier for them to limit performance on that.