Broadly speaking, the more desirable properties you try to obtain at once, the more you constrain the design, and it is absolutely possible to constrain the design to the point where there are zero solutions. Arrow's theorem shows an example of that in a voting context. You can not have all of the five desirable properties laid out in the theorem, and it isn't a matter of finding a clever algorithmic solution; they are actually contradictory. You have to loosen the requirements somehow.
There is no guarantee that any given set of desirable properties has a solution. There is no guarantee that BitCoin is even close to having a solution, there's no guarantee that it is merely one requirement over the line, it may well contain multiple contradictions. There's no guarantee that there is anything more optimal than government fiat money.
I'm in favor of experimentation to find out, in general. But it should be pointed out that there is not necessarily going to be a solution at all, and I certainly would say it's not going to be easy to just "take BitCoin and fix the problems" or any variant thereof. There is something stopping people from just "creating an alternative", it's going to be freaking hard, and again, I don't just mean hard in the way that creating an open source operating system from the efforts of thousands of not-centrally managed programmers is, I mean, potentially hard in the way that proving P != NP is, really, actually, hard. Starting from BitCoin isn't necessarily even starting from a useful base.
Bitcoin is supposed to be a currency. That means that it's supposed to be effectively the same thing as USD or the Euro. It's not supposed to replace any other currency, it just needs to be able to do everything that any other currency can(except pay taxes). The problem is that it doesn't do that right now, and I don't see any way of making it actually work. To actually be a useful currency, people need to be able use it on everything, otherwise it's just a proxy for a "real" currency with an added gambling element.
Right now, it's basically the same thing as paypal or Google Checkout-something that people use to buy things online. By that standard, it's not even decentralized anymore, because everyone gets their BTC from MtGox, and they have to keep logs of all their transactions.
What would happen if a new gold-like element was discovered? "Red Gold" that had almost all the attributes of gold but it had a somewhat redish color and was actually a different element and it was proven to be of about the same scarcity worldwide. Would that halve the price of gold and would everyone jump onto red gold immediately or would it be shunned as not the real thing and be mostly worthless?
I'd be interested to know others' insights on this.
In so far as red gold acted in the same way as gold for jewellery and industrial uses, it would probably decrease the value of gold to some proportion, and set a base level on this red gold production. But this is like asking why diamonds are valuable, or designer clothes, or expensive watches. In many cases, it's a combination of marketing, status display effects (ostentatious useless consumption), artificial restriction on supply, and market fixing (e.g. arranging to buy watches on secondary markets at headline prices for PR purposes). They too are confidence games, and if the confidence goes due to a bad association with the brand, the price will fall through the floor. All that is left is productive uses like industry.
Lots of people seem to think gold is 'safer' than paper currencies, while it seems the same. Am I missing something important here?
Quite possible.
A few large organizations control the vast majority of it, and this is especially true since governments have not needed to hold gold for years
Say what? A few large organizations, who are not governments, hold the vast majority of the world's gold? Are we into conspiracy-theory talk here?
Lots of people seem to think gold is 'safer' than paper currencies, while it seems the same
"Safe" depends on what you mean. For instance, you could say "US dollars have a 99% chance of retaining at least 80% of their value in five years, and a 99.9% chance of retaining at least 10% of their value in five years. Gold has only a 80% chance of retaining at least 80% of its value in five years, but a much higher 99.999% chance of retaining at least 10% of its value in five years".
Gold gives you much more volatility in the short term, but acts as a hedge against the collapse of any particular currency.
I wouldn't buy it though. I'd buy land (with houses on it), which acts as a hedge and pays you income.
http://symmetricinfo.org/category/goldprices/ estimates 50% of gold stock is in jewellery, 12% in industry. Of course, some fraction of that jewellery is bought because people believe that the gold will be a store of value, not just because of how it works; though I wouldn't expect selling jewellery for its gold content to give particularly good returns.
I'll add a link to this story if I can dig one up.
It's not valued above industrial value.
What is the intrinsic value of Bitcoins, then? That people are willing to spend money on Bitcoins?
As an investment vehicle these are terrible. Commodities (diamonds, zinc, gold, wheat, oil, etc.) will always be demanded as factors of industrial production or farming. Equities generate real-world wealth for investors in the form of dividends. Both are demanded because they generate real value for investors.
Bitcoins have no intrinsic value. If you're in to make a quick buck, that's fine--this is a big arbitrage opportunity. But for any decently-sized time T, Bitcoins --> $0 as t --> T.
Part of the value is in their utility as an anonymous currency: try taxing the guy that's paid in Bitcoins.
Another part is the integrity of the currency: the currency is backed by math, rather than men, and not subject to hyperinflation resulting from corruption (i.e. the US Fed can create money out of thin air, but there is no authority that can create Bitcoins out of thin air: they must be mined).
Meanwhile, I've already discussed Bitcoin's potential as an alternative currency (or lack thereof) in other comments. If people demand Bitcoins as a "tax haven" from the government, then Bitcoins aren't long for this world.
Whatever the mechanism, fiat currencies are subject to inflation through the pressure of an ever-increasing money supply.
>If people demand Bitcoins as a "tax haven" from the government, then Bitcoins aren't long for this world.
It'll be interesting to see how the state tackles this. It'll be easy to drive it underground, but preventing its use will be another matter. Bitcoin transactions through a VPN seem hard to prevent.
As they should be, given that populations increase.
Anyway, even if Bitcoins go underground, they'd have to be priced such that they'd be cheaper than other money laundering channels. Due to their finite supply, though, money laundering through Bitcoins will get very expensive. So their utility re: taxes will be squashed by either the government or the black market.
Is the U.S. Population increasing like this? [1] That's what the U.S. monetary supply looks like.
More correctly, fiat money supply should ideally match total economic output, not population. But the GDP graph also doesn't look anything like that monetary supply graph.
Given this, the BitCoin phenomenon is understandable: savers are looking for a currency that's not subject to manipulation and is most of all predictable in terms of supply. Whether or not it succeeds, I'm glad there's the pressure of a competing, not-centrally-manipulated currency.
[1] http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/graph/?s%5B1%5D%5Bid%5D...
[1] http://books.google.com/books?id=ZNAhXe2pz1cC&lpg=PA196&...
Read the sentence "Prices might even fall gradually as higher incomes led people to want to hold a large fraction of their wealth in the form of money." Inflation is a Money Supply / Money Demand phenomenon. In the long term, Money Demand tracks real output, but in the short term (such as the recession we're currently in) you can see major swings in demand that counteract what would normally be a quite inflationary money printing exercise.
Huh? [0]
[0] http://www.google.com/publicdata?ds=wb-wdi&met_y=ny_gdp_...
Edits: To make it clear I'm not arguing with the statement that money supply has tracked GDP fairly well until recently. Or that GDP has trended up exponentially.
Yeah, I won't take part except to say (a) you're sampling 4 years of incredibly volatile economic activity, and (b) the other, uh, 96 years exhibit a pretty strong exponential trend.
Imagining a rant, and a classification for the discussion, is not helpful. Your two points (a) and (b) I agree with.
That is only true if T-bills are generated slower than the rise of other money instruments. In the last few years, that has not been the case (and evidence for that is seen in the tanking dollar value compared to any other currency, including gold).
Easy - I collect taxes at the point where physical goods are exchanged for bitcoins or are used to deliver products.
If you can't use bitcoins for food, housing, netaccess, or energy....
Or just collect the taxes at the point where it's converted from BTC to a real, government-backed currency. It's simpler, because there needs to be a paper trail there.
The state does this, but people already get around this by conducting cash transactions. Bitcoin creates another option for this.
Govts tolerate a certain amount of black market because it costs too much to reduce the black market to 0. However, that toleration goes away when govts are seriously hurting for revenue.
...try hiring the guy who is willing to be paid in Bitcoins.
They would tax Bitcoin receipts the same way they tax service-for-service or service-for-property exchanges. The government will calculate the fair market value of the services/property received at $X dollars (based on facts and circumstances such as the amount exchanged in similar cash-based transactions), deem the taxpayer to have received $X in income, and impose a tax of $Y on that deemed income.
Gold has very little - it is used in jewelery, CDR coating, teeth and a few other industries -- but you can't live in it, nor can you eat it. Beans have more intrinsic value than gold of the same weight....
Yet, no one doubts gold as a currency.
The main, strike that, ONLY, relevant feature of a currency is the willingness of others to exchange stuff for it. At this point in time, bitcoin possesses this feature.
Gold is a commodity, not a currency. It is a scarce commodity that is highly demanded as a part of luxury goods. Thus, it commands a high price on the open market.
Beans are also commodities, but they are plentiful. Bean demand is easily met, so they're not priced very highly.
Bitcoins are not production inputs, so their only value is (ostensibly) as an alternative fiat money or value store. Unlike country-backed fiat money, you cannot exchange bitcoins for goods, so the only demand for bitcoins comes from people "investing" in them. If you want to play the bitcoin market, that's fine--in that case, you're generating wealth for yourself. Not value.
At this point in time, you can. Next week, that might not be true. But the same could be said of the currency of Belarus, which was devalued 50% overnight last week (the USD in 1931 suffered the same fate after physical gold was confiscated). Which is all that is required to make it a currency.
> Gold is a commodity, not a currency. It is a scarce commodity that is highly demanded as a part of luxury goods. Thus, it commands a high price on the open market.
:) That's a game of semantics. Gold's current price has little to do with its luxury good status, and everything to do with its scarcity and historical claim to fame as a currency. That was historically gold's role in the last 3000 years or so, and it hasn't been dethroned yet.
> Unlike country-backed fiat money, you cannot exchange bitcoins for goods
But you can. And people around the world are not accepting USD as much as they used to 20 years ago - in the past, in most middle eastern and south american countries, you were able to pay with US dollars everywhere. That is no longer true. Does that make the fiat US dollar less of a currency?
You can play semantics all you want, but gold and to some extent silver are used as currencies.
:) That's a game of semantics. Gold's current price has little to do with its luxury good status, and everything to do with its scarcity and historical claim to fame as a currency.
"Semantics" have nothing to do with it. Commodities [0] != currencies [1], whether you're familiar with the definitions or not. One exists as a medium of exchange, while the other is a good with no differentiation between sources. Currencies are differentiated by the trustworthiness of the governments that issue them (you'd probably accept a US dollar today before accepting a German papiermark [2] in 1924).
Also, gold's price is a function of the market's supply and demand for gold as either (a) an investment vehicle or (b) an input in the production of goods. Investors don't give a damn that the US dollar was pegged to gold 200+ years ago--they're simply investing in it to make money.
The idea that gold is "currency" is ridiculous. Name a first-world country where gold is widely accepted as currency. Some places in some parts of the world might accept gold, but it's not backed by a central body nor does it carry a relatively stable value (unlike fiat money).
[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commodity
Semantics have everything to do with it, as I will demonstrate below.
> One exists as a medium of exchange, while the other is a good with no differentiation between sources.
Well, as long as the USD is not fake, you don't care what the source is :) Similarly, for non-fake gold.
> Currencies are differentiated by the trustworthiness of the governments that issue them.
Today, that is true. However, the Chumash people had a currency that -- like bitcoin -- was not centrally managed, and reflected work put into something, rather than any fiat or backing store of value. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chumash_people#Culture - I can't remember where I read a more detailed account. Basically, you could sit on the beach all day and make money -- and it took slightly longer than the equivalent exchange rate would get you in food (so you could hunt/gather food, or make money, with comparable time expenditure, and exchange them). The whole system broke down when European drills (as manufacturing tools) were introduced and made money making simple.
> First: I admit I wasn't aware that retailers accepted bitcoins when I posted that comment. I've discovered otherwise now, so the "hill of beans" comment is wrong. Sorry.
So - let's get back to semantics: do you agree bitcoin is currency? (exists as a medium of exchange), or commodity? (a good with no differentiation between sources) because it has both properties, thus showing that the definitions are not mutually exclusive. A USD is currency but not commodity; Beans are commodity but not currency. Gold, Chumash beads and bitcoin are both.
> Name a first-world country where gold is widely accepted as currency.
In NYC where I live, hundreds of stores will accept your gold in exchange for other merchandise (at a bad exchange rate for you...). You can identify them by the sign "We buy gold". You must have seen them in other places too.
> but it's not backed by a central body
True, but ....
> nor does it carry a relatively stable value (unlike fiat money)
Wrong, and if you truly believe that you might be beyond help. The US devalued the USD by 50% in 1931. Belarus did it to their fiat currency last week. Between 2002 and 2006, the EUR/USD exchange rate went from 0.8 to 1.5 (almost 100%) - "stable"?
In fact, up until 1971, the backing for the USD (and most other currencies) was gold - it only became a true fiat currency in 1971! Before that, it was a claim on some amount of gold in fort knox, and value was derived from that.
People need to start naming the dubious syllogisms bitbugs deploy in discussions like this.
EDIT: The fact that government would have a very difficult time shutting down the Bitcoin economy is yet another example of its utility and value.
What I, and others, are saying is that in the future, no such people will exist. Our prediction is that the current bitcoin economy is transient and will eventually vanish. Hence, we say bitcoins have no value. It's similar to saying that a particular stock has no value if you think that that particular company will collapse.
Not really. They have to be willing to say "I'll give you X thing that you value in exchange for Y bitcoins." The entire point is that the design of bitcoin makes that scenario likely to always be true precisely because it is nearly impossible to stop. As I said above, the very fact that it represents a system that is very difficult for state actors to attack ensures that it will almost certainly be used for exchanging goods and services that governments would rather not exist. Not a terribly noble future, perhaps, but certainly one that ensures bitcoins have value.
For a reason that I am unaware of, you seem to think that just because something can be traded it will be traded. That's not true. People tend to only trade things that are readily exchangeable in the larger economy - things that have value.
Really? When dollars were "silver certificates" the bank's willingness to let you come collect your silver was a real vote of confidence in the currency. But nowadays if they "insure your bank account" they only pay you back in dollars. They're insuring that its value doesn't drop in dollars. How does that constitute a vote of confidence in the currency itself? I'd say it's only a vote of confidence in (a) the bank, (b) the government's ability to print more money, (c) the government's ability to tax.
First, assuming you're talking about the US, your bank accounts are insured by the FDIC, and the FDIC is not part of or formally backed by the US government. There are lots of people who believe that if the FDIC were in danger of bankruptcy, the US government would step in to support it — as it did with Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac — but until the government actually promises to do that, you can't call it a "vote of confidence".
Second, the US government's dollar position is short, not long — its dollar-denominated debts are greater than its dollar-denominated assets. In financial terms, a short position is a way to bet against the value of the underlying commodity. The US government is currently about $7 million million dollars "short".
An illustration may help to clarify. Suppose you are a private in the Zimbabwean military in September 2007. Suppose your monthly pay is about US$180, but you are paid in Zimbabwean dollars, so your pay packet is actually Z$5.4 million for the month. The Zimbabwean dollar has been hyperinflating, and you expect it to continue to lose value. You don't currently need to pay any expenses. Consider the following options:
A. Keep the Z$5.4 million in cash.
B. Immediately buy other commodities with it; for example, buy 300 kilograms of rice and store it in Tupperware in the pantry.
C. Immediately buy other commodities with it, and also borrow an additional Z$10 million some poor sucker is willing to lend you at an extortionate 20% APR, and use that to buy rice too.
Option "A" is maintaining a "long" position in the Zimbabwean dollar. This amounts to a bet that the Z$ will retain its value. If you had taken this option, you would have lost 90% of your salary within a few weeks.
Option "B" is maintaining no position in the Zimbabwean dollar. It doesn't matter what the Zimbabwean dollar does thereafter; you still have the same amount of rice. (Practically speaking, in situations like this, there tend to be price controls on most things you can buy with the collapsing currency.)
Option "C" is maintaining a "short" position in the Zimbabwean dollar. If you had somehow found such a sucker, then within a few weeks, you could have paid them back by selling off a tiny percentage of the rice you bought, as the Zimbabwean dollar continued to inflate.
This is the position the US government has taken relative to the US dollar.
There are, of course, other reasons to take long or short positions on commodities other than speculation on their future value.
Third, even if we accept the premise that the implicit guarantee of the US government to keep the FDIC afloat amounts to "the US government is willing to insure my bank accounts", that is simply a further short position. FDIC insurance is for dollar-denominated accounts up to a fixed dollar limit. Whoever is on the hook to underwrite that insurance in the end, they'll have an easier time paying out their claims if the US dollar loses value. If your bank account has $78000 in it and the currency loses ¾ of its value (which happened here in 2001), the FDIC bailout only has to come up with the current equivalent of $19500 to pay you back.
Fourth, the government is not "more than people". It's just people.
I'll take issue with the government being "just people," but that's just a nit in a great post.
Yes there is. The protocol is not documented at all. That's one of the reason I'm a little hesitant to touch it.
There's also the source code to bitcoinj, which is a very well-commented implementation of the protocol.
I thought there was no centralized point-of-failure?
Given the rewards that have already accrued to Bitcoin early adopters, I am surprised other competing cryptocurrency networks have not yet already been created. Lots of people who wish they had started mining coins back in the days before GPU mining would be eager to get in on the ground floor of an alternative.
Most problems with the critiques of Bitcoin like those in the linked Quora post is that they are debunking a straw man - the idea that Bitcoin is intended as a universal replacement for all other currency systems. By those standards of course it will fail. Looked at in another way, think of Bitcoin as something more like MMORPG loot. If people are willing to spend vast amounts of "real money" on items for their WoW character, spending that money on Bitcoins instead makes it seem like a sane investment rather than just flushing it away.
I've mentioned before that I think governmental action to criminalize Bitcoin and analogous technology is an even more serious threat to long-term value. If there is one thing that really might make the world's governments team up to completely ban strong encryption, it is a potential threat to governmental control over taxation and currencies.