News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi... by johno215 on Thursday June 02, 2011 @11:34AM (#2612401)
Modern (post gold standard) currencies have no intrinsic value either. Their only value is that people think they have value.
Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi... by tptacek on Thursday June 02, 2011 @12:02PM (#2612529)
No, modern currencies are backed by the full faith and credit of nations, and while reasonable people can disagree about the value of the US credit rating, no reasonable person thinks it is zero.

People need to start naming the dubious syllogisms bitbugs deploy in discussions like this.

Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi... by icarus_drowning on Thursday June 02, 2011 @01:07PM (#2612834)
Bitcoin is, in a way, backed by the value that it brings as a currency-- privacy and anonymity. We can argue whether that value is $10 per BTC, but I also don't think any reasonable person thinks that it is zero.
Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi... by tptacek on Thursday June 02, 2011 @01:09PM (#2612852)
No, in fact, plenty of reasonable people do believe it is zero, and you cannot nerd your way out of that fact.
Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi... by icarus_drowning on Thursday June 02, 2011 @01:24PM (#2612930)
But that's not reasonable. Its just ignoring the privacy/anonymity value of BTC. Again, we can argue about the monetary value as compared to dollars, (especially given the tradeoffs-- i.e., convertibility to established currency, places to spend, etc) but that's real, practical value. You can't simply ignore it.
Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi... by scott_s on Thursday June 02, 2011 @02:03PM (#2613130)
Sure it's reasonable. I think bitcoins have zero value. I recognize that there may be people out there who are willing to pay real dollars for it right now, but I think that in the long run, no such people will exist. Hence, I place its value at zero.
Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi... by icarus_drowning on Thursday June 02, 2011 @04:37PM (#2613856)
Bitcoins don't have to be tradable to dollars to represent nonzero value. Their utility is in and of itself valuable. It might not have value to you, but that's different than suggesting that it has no value at all.
Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi... by scott_s on Thursday June 02, 2011 @06:20PM (#2614245)
I fail to see how their "anonymity" has value when it cannot be exchanged for real currency.
Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi... by icarus_drowning on Thursday June 02, 2011 @11:36PM (#2615067)
Currency is a placeholder for value. So long as I can exchange bitcoins for value, they will function as a currency. The design of bitcoin makes it very difficult for governments to make such a scenario impossible (or even difficult). For that reason alone, bitcoins will remain valuable, if for nothing other than goods or services that governments don't like.
Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi... by scott_s on Friday June 03, 2011 @07:49AM (#2615963)
People who participate in illegal trade (such as drugs, guns, prostitution, etc.) still need most of their purchases to be in the legal economy. Hence, illegal trade still uses real currency.
Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi... by achompas on Thursday June 02, 2011 @02:09PM (#2613173)
I couldn't care less about the privacy/anonymity of BTC if the market falls out and my BTC wallet ~ $0. At that point no government will come to my aid because, hey, I invested in something that has no value.
Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi... by icarus_drowning on Thursday June 02, 2011 @04:39PM (#2613862)
As I mentioned above, Bitcoins value relative to the dollar is irrelevant, because its value is found in its utility. So long as there are goods and services to purchase with Bitcoin (and it seems very difficult for a government to stop such services from existing), the utility of the currency remains valuable, regardless of its exchange rate to the dollar.

EDIT: The fact that government would have a very difficult time shutting down the Bitcoin economy is yet another example of its utility and value.

Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi... by scott_s on Thursday June 02, 2011 @10:46PM (#2614958)
Utility for what. If things have real, actual value, then they can be exchanged for dollars, even if it's only on the black market. We don't mean there has to be an official exchange rate between bitcoins and dollars. We mean there has to be someone willing to say "I'll give you X USD for Y bitcoins" even if that's just under the table. If no one is willing to do that, then bitcoins have no value.

What I, and others, are saying is that in the future, no such people will exist. Our prediction is that the current bitcoin economy is transient and will eventually vanish. Hence, we say bitcoins have no value. It's similar to saying that a particular stock has no value if you think that that particular company will collapse.

Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi... by icarus_drowning on Thursday June 02, 2011 @11:34PM (#2615063)
*there has to be someone willing to say "I'll give you X USD for Y bitcoins"

Not really. They have to be willing to say "I'll give you X thing that you value in exchange for Y bitcoins." The entire point is that the design of bitcoin makes that scenario likely to always be true precisely because it is nearly impossible to stop. As I said above, the very fact that it represents a system that is very difficult for state actors to attack ensures that it will almost certainly be used for exchanging goods and services that governments would rather not exist. Not a terribly noble future, perhaps, but certainly one that ensures bitcoins have value.

Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi... by scott_s on Friday June 03, 2011 @07:46AM (#2615957)
If people are willing to trade goods for it, then someone will be willing to trade dollars for it (or yen, euros, or any established currency).

For a reason that I am unaware of, you seem to think that just because something can be traded it will be traded. That's not true. People tend to only trade things that are readily exchangeable in the larger economy - things that have value.

Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi... by achompas on Thursday June 02, 2011 @12:01PM (#2612525)
Well it's more than people--my government believes the US dollar has value too, and it's willing to insure my bank accounts as a result. That's a hell of a vote of confidence.
Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi... by glenra on Thursday June 02, 2011 @02:39PM (#2613312)
> my government believes the US dollar has value too, and it's willing to insure my bank accounts as a result. That's a hell of a vote of confidence.

Really? When dollars were "silver certificates" the bank's willingness to let you come collect your silver was a real vote of confidence in the currency. But nowadays if they "insure your bank account" they only pay you back in dollars. They're insuring that its value doesn't drop in dollars. How does that constitute a vote of confidence in the currency itself? I'd say it's only a vote of confidence in (a) the bank, (b) the government's ability to print more money, (c) the government's ability to tax.

Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi... by kragen on Thursday June 02, 2011 @09:01PM (#2614742)
There are several confusions in your short post.

First, assuming you're talking about the US, your bank accounts are insured by the FDIC, and the FDIC is not part of or formally backed by the US government. There are lots of people who believe that if the FDIC were in danger of bankruptcy, the US government would step in to support it — as it did with Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac — but until the government actually promises to do that, you can't call it a "vote of confidence".

Second, the US government's dollar position is short, not long — its dollar-denominated debts are greater than its dollar-denominated assets. In financial terms, a short position is a way to bet against the value of the underlying commodity. The US government is currently about $7 million million dollars "short".

An illustration may help to clarify. Suppose you are a private in the Zimbabwean military in September 2007. Suppose your monthly pay is about US$180, but you are paid in Zimbabwean dollars, so your pay packet is actually Z$5.4 million for the month. The Zimbabwean dollar has been hyperinflating, and you expect it to continue to lose value. You don't currently need to pay any expenses. Consider the following options:

A. Keep the Z$5.4 million in cash.

B. Immediately buy other commodities with it; for example, buy 300 kilograms of rice and store it in Tupperware in the pantry.

C. Immediately buy other commodities with it, and also borrow an additional Z$10 million some poor sucker is willing to lend you at an extortionate 20% APR, and use that to buy rice too.

Option "A" is maintaining a "long" position in the Zimbabwean dollar. This amounts to a bet that the Z$ will retain its value. If you had taken this option, you would have lost 90% of your salary within a few weeks.

Option "B" is maintaining no position in the Zimbabwean dollar. It doesn't matter what the Zimbabwean dollar does thereafter; you still have the same amount of rice. (Practically speaking, in situations like this, there tend to be price controls on most things you can buy with the collapsing currency.)

Option "C" is maintaining a "short" position in the Zimbabwean dollar. If you had somehow found such a sucker, then within a few weeks, you could have paid them back by selling off a tiny percentage of the rice you bought, as the Zimbabwean dollar continued to inflate.

This is the position the US government has taken relative to the US dollar.

There are, of course, other reasons to take long or short positions on commodities other than speculation on their future value.

Third, even if we accept the premise that the implicit guarantee of the US government to keep the FDIC afloat amounts to "the US government is willing to insure my bank accounts", that is simply a further short position. FDIC insurance is for dollar-denominated accounts up to a fixed dollar limit. Whoever is on the hook to underwrite that insurance in the end, they'll have an easier time paying out their claims if the US dollar loses value. If your bank account has $78000 in it and the currency loses ¾ of its value (which happened here in 2001), the FDIC bailout only has to come up with the current equivalent of $19500 to pay you back.

Fourth, the government is not "more than people". It's just people.

Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi... by achompas on Friday June 03, 2011 @04:35PM (#2617879)
Thanks for the great explanation on the US government's dollar position. I also thought about my comment some more later, and realized that inflation really devalues the FDIC's deposit insurance.

I'll take issue with the government being "just people," but that's just a nit in a great post.

Re:The Quora post that killed Bitcoins. Please discuss if hi... by beagle3 on Thursday June 02, 2011 @10:38PM (#2614938)
An excellent explanation. Sadly, I can only upvote it once.