Lots of people seem to think gold is 'safer' than paper currencies, while it seems the same. Am I missing something important here?
Quite possible.
A few large organizations control the vast majority of it, and this is especially true since governments have not needed to hold gold for years
Say what? A few large organizations, who are not governments, hold the vast majority of the world's gold? Are we into conspiracy-theory talk here?
Lots of people seem to think gold is 'safer' than paper currencies, while it seems the same
"Safe" depends on what you mean. For instance, you could say "US dollars have a 99% chance of retaining at least 80% of their value in five years, and a 99.9% chance of retaining at least 10% of their value in five years. Gold has only a 80% chance of retaining at least 80% of its value in five years, but a much higher 99.999% chance of retaining at least 10% of its value in five years".
Gold gives you much more volatility in the short term, but acts as a hedge against the collapse of any particular currency.
I wouldn't buy it though. I'd buy land (with houses on it), which acts as a hedge and pays you income.
http://symmetricinfo.org/category/goldprices/ estimates 50% of gold stock is in jewellery, 12% in industry. Of course, some fraction of that jewellery is bought because people believe that the gold will be a store of value, not just because of how it works; though I wouldn't expect selling jewellery for its gold content to give particularly good returns.
I'll add a link to this story if I can dig one up.
In so far as red gold acted in the same way as gold for jewellery and industrial uses, it would probably decrease the value of gold to some proportion, and set a base level on this red gold production. But this is like asking why diamonds are valuable, or designer clothes, or expensive watches. In many cases, it's a combination of marketing, status display effects (ostentatious useless consumption), artificial restriction on supply, and market fixing (e.g. arranging to buy watches on secondary markets at headline prices for PR purposes). They too are confidence games, and if the confidence goes due to a bad association with the brand, the price will fall through the floor. All that is left is productive uses like industry.