Most other brokers WILL NOT allow this. When I applied for options Schwab had a broker call me and make sure I knew about all the risks involved for the level I applied for.
RH was also down a couple times in March, which lost me a good amount of money. A week is a VERY long time if you're playing short-term options. There's also other issues where they were holding customer shares in margin when they had cash to cover, and when they've allowed customers to leverage 5k -> 1M of positions (a huge nono).
The conclusion here is that RH is a toy broker following the mantra of move fast and breaks things. Good if you're casually investing, but for options and serious investing with real amounts of cash it's worth getting a broker that is serious at providing reliable service.
I personally see them at the Juul of the finance world. They're intentionally targeting young inexperienced people and telling them "just download this app and you'll be rich! all your friends are doing it, don't miss out!"
TDA, Fidelity, Webull, Interactive Brokers, Tasty works, ETrade, and more all make options just as accessible as RH.
I opened both Fidelity and E*Trade brokerage accounts in the last 3 weeks and it took minutes to submit options applications for both, at max levels. ET was approved instantly and Fidelity the next day. Not a single piece of paper from either one.
I remember reading when the original story broke that the negative balance / suicide happened over a weekend.
And about the the negative balance, I've had a similar story (with much less). The problem is that once a long-short vertical option expires worthless, Robinhood showed a negative balance for the full amount of the short position, even if you had a long position covering most of it. Because they don't update the available balance/money you made from the long side until it clears (which can take a few days).
I believe it was extremely bad UX on Robinhood's part, even my heart skipped a beat when I saw the negative bal, and that was for only 5k.
If all it took was a lie on an application for Robinhood to grant someone the ability to use extremely risky trading strategies, that's still Robinhood's fault. Robinhood isn't absolved of responsibility just because the student did something dishonest.
Given the fact he was 20 years old, his options application should have automatically been under a heightened degree of scrutiny, if not immediately rejected. That it wasn't indicates Robinhood is not responsibly implementing KYC controls, which is a huge deal.
In your world, do we blame casinos when someone goes in and gambles away their money? My naive perspective sees no difference. The concept of an individual being responsible for their own terrible choices really seems to have changed unbelievably in the last 20 years.
If Robinhood wants to carry same responsibility as casinos, they should call themselves a casino.
Then they will loose certain privileges like in UK it's illegal for casinos to provide leverage or 'gambling debt', they will be subject to payout percentage regulation, etc. https://www.casino.co.uk/guides/payout-percentages-rtp/
Try CTRL+F "suitability" for a five-second read of why the casino comparison doesn't apply here.
For the perspective that Robinhood owns his risk somehow, from not following their suitability guidelines, I'm not familiar with any of this so can't speak about it. Naively reading this, it appears to be extremely open ended, requiring a consistent internal process for approval, along with a warning, rather than anything specific.
The burden's on the firm to demonstrate why it believed the customer was qualified to trade the product, and to demonstrate that it made an effort to evaluate the customer's goals, finances, and needs.
> ... shall recommend to any customer any transaction ...
> ... that the recommended transaction is not suitable
Was Robinhood recommending transactions, or just enabling transactions? Even if not, this seems very open ended with no specifics, since “reasonable” is up for interpretation. I suppose we’ll see, probably sooner rather than later. I assume some actual specifics will result from all of this though.
I'm not excusing it. I'm just making an observation.
And I'm not blaming parents for that. The world has changed and it's harder than it used to be to simultaneously protect kids and give them room to grow.
By your logic, you might as sue all auto manufacturers for not installing BAC interlocks on the vehicles they sell, or all tobacco companies just because the users are too stupid to read the giant warning labels. That's not the society I want to live in.
Like this? https://www.cnbc.com/2020/12/16/robinhood-reportedly-facing-...
>all tobacco companies just because the users are too stupid to read the giant warning labels
Like this? https://www.publichealthlawcenter.org/topics/commercial-toba...
In our society, we hold companies responsible for being poor citizens. And "our users are stupid" is not a valid justification for being a poor citizen, whether you like that or not.
They have an investigation, but we'll see what it turns up. Remember, we work on an innocent until proven guilty basis.
If you're saying that companies need to be good citizens or we shut them down, then you should close almost all businesses. You don't think the other brokers take the same steps that RH does? I can tell you from the inside that they do.
When COVID/2008 hits the fan, its the young people on zero hour contract that loose their income first, landlords might loose some, and banks loose least.
If anything our system is setup so that the higher you are, the less consequences you face. I believe this is the new phenomenon and its not helped by 'kids these days, back in my day...'.
It is usually quite explicit that they are not providing investment advice with the online ones.
It is the company's job to make sure the screening process is not too permissive.
Do they have no process to talk to a customer who has lost a lot of money? This is not a rare freak event, it's key part of the business they are in. You'd think about this within the first 10 minutes of even entertaining the idea of starting a trading firm. Even the WSB reddit had a link to a suicide prevention hotline, how is RH more irresponsible than a random web forum.
We as a society don't need to bend over backwards to accomodate these zero-support business models - and especially not as the bedrock of our economy.
Lastly, I want to share a court case from Russia: for a few years it was common for banks to mass send out loan contracts in the post to random Tom, Dick and Harry. It would just appear in your postbox randomly, and if you countersign it you would get the money. One bloke scanned the document and amended it, he really went to town: increased the borrowing limit, put in a negative interest rate, etc. The bank signed it without realising. Obviously the bank sued, argued that their business model made it impossible to read every contract and the that the guy knew that.
The judge held up the contract, saying it wasn't the customers problem their business model involves spamming people and signing things without reading.
Isn't this a problem with most brokers? They all seem to require that you claim experience trading an asset class before they let you trade that asset class.
Many brokers seem to have gotten very lax about this in recent years, and even Schwab/Ameritrade allowed me to trade options without verifying anything. My guess is that the recent Robinhhood/GME fiasco is going to see FINRA cracking down hard and reinstating some strict verification procedures.
(I was still in college and did not know what I was doing, but fortunately only ended up losing a few hundred bucks.)
This isn't new - it's how it's worked for a good long while.
With older brokerage firms, they use to call you up after you signed up. You would have to chat with them on the phone before they unlocked your account.
It would be trivially simple to empty out your entire account by buying foolishly deep out-of-the-money options. (E.g. betting that GameStop shares will be worth $800 by the end of the week).
but the catch is that he didn't lose the money really ... it was a UX glitch that made him suicide
Could you please clarify, what does the application ask that he would have had to lie about?
I've been declined for top options levels before because my total net worth was too low even with years of actual options trading experience (including complicated multi-leg strategies).
You have to go out of your way to trade options (they're disabled by default), and the only way you can get options enabled in Robinhood as a college freshman is to straight up lie on the application.
> “Worse, Robinhood provided almost no investment guidance, and its customer ‘service’ was virtually non-existent, consisting of automated e-mail replies devoid of any human contact or interaction,” the family alleged in the suit.
How many brokers provide investment guidance? How many do it without additional fees?
I've only reached out to Robinhood two or three times but a person has responded to the initial inquiry in all but one instance (where an automated email just said it would be a while, and a person followed up about a week later to actually address the issue).
Robinhood is a shit company and I look forward to incoming class action lawsuit but this is a grieving family lashing out and should be dismissed. If anything comes of this the only thing that's going to happen is there are going to be more roadblocks for retail investors to invest.