In your world, do we blame casinos when someone goes in and gambles away their money? My naive perspective sees no difference. The concept of an individual being responsible for their own terrible choices really seems to have changed unbelievably in the last 20 years.
If Robinhood wants to carry same responsibility as casinos, they should call themselves a casino.
Then they will loose certain privileges like in UK it's illegal for casinos to provide leverage or 'gambling debt', they will be subject to payout percentage regulation, etc. https://www.casino.co.uk/guides/payout-percentages-rtp/
Try CTRL+F "suitability" for a five-second read of why the casino comparison doesn't apply here.
For the perspective that Robinhood owns his risk somehow, from not following their suitability guidelines, I'm not familiar with any of this so can't speak about it. Naively reading this, it appears to be extremely open ended, requiring a consistent internal process for approval, along with a warning, rather than anything specific.
The burden's on the firm to demonstrate why it believed the customer was qualified to trade the product, and to demonstrate that it made an effort to evaluate the customer's goals, finances, and needs.
> ... shall recommend to any customer any transaction ...
> ... that the recommended transaction is not suitable
Was Robinhood recommending transactions, or just enabling transactions? Even if not, this seems very open ended with no specifics, since “reasonable” is up for interpretation. I suppose we’ll see, probably sooner rather than later. I assume some actual specifics will result from all of this though.
I'm not excusing it. I'm just making an observation.
And I'm not blaming parents for that. The world has changed and it's harder than it used to be to simultaneously protect kids and give them room to grow.
By your logic, you might as sue all auto manufacturers for not installing BAC interlocks on the vehicles they sell, or all tobacco companies just because the users are too stupid to read the giant warning labels. That's not the society I want to live in.
Like this? https://www.cnbc.com/2020/12/16/robinhood-reportedly-facing-...
>all tobacco companies just because the users are too stupid to read the giant warning labels
Like this? https://www.publichealthlawcenter.org/topics/commercial-toba...
In our society, we hold companies responsible for being poor citizens. And "our users are stupid" is not a valid justification for being a poor citizen, whether you like that or not.
They have an investigation, but we'll see what it turns up. Remember, we work on an innocent until proven guilty basis.
If you're saying that companies need to be good citizens or we shut them down, then you should close almost all businesses. You don't think the other brokers take the same steps that RH does? I can tell you from the inside that they do.
When COVID/2008 hits the fan, its the young people on zero hour contract that loose their income first, landlords might loose some, and banks loose least.
If anything our system is setup so that the higher you are, the less consequences you face. I believe this is the new phenomenon and its not helped by 'kids these days, back in my day...'.
If all it took was a lie on an application for Robinhood to grant someone the ability to use extremely risky trading strategies, that's still Robinhood's fault. Robinhood isn't absolved of responsibility just because the student did something dishonest.
Given the fact he was 20 years old, his options application should have automatically been under a heightened degree of scrutiny, if not immediately rejected. That it wasn't indicates Robinhood is not responsibly implementing KYC controls, which is a huge deal.