https://i.imgur.com/a2JmlyQ.jpg
Of course, I have a fairly advanced understanding of options and knew it was mathematically impossible to have lost that amount, so to me it was just a humorous and quirky bug in some startup software.
What I think needs to be noted is that the only way this young man would have gotten access to the level of options required to place a trade like that was to deliberately lie on his account application. Someone who was qualified to have the level of trading access he had would have immediately known he wasnt $780k in the hole. So while Robinhood wrote some bad code, there is some personal responsibility that should be assigned here. Such a sad situation.
But Robinhood obviously makes no attempt to verify the answers. If two kids, one riding on the other’s shoulders inside of a trench coat walked into a bank and claimed to be an adult, you’d put at least some blame on the bank if those kids walked out with a loan.
A kid lying to an adult is different from an adult lying to an adult.
I recently applied for (and was granted) the ability to trade options.
For the question "How long have you been trading options?" I wrote "never - because I can't yet".
My application was approved.
If each party only makes the one trade and has no other securities in his portfolio, maybe. That's almost never the case.
For example, if you're a market maker at Goldman Sachs and you sell 10k calls to a hedge fund, you want the stock to go up monotonically and gradually so that the customer profits on direction, you profit on volatility, and you can make money on the unwind trade as well. Win-win.
Short put vertical: Underlying is at 392, sell 200 390P, buy 20 389P. Underlying moves to 387, counterparty exercises 20 ITM puts, now you’re long 2,000 shares at 390, you exercise your ITM 389P and sell 2,000 shares at 389 for a net $2,000 loss.
Long put vertical: Underlying at 392, buy 20 390P, sell 20 389P. Underlying moves to 387, counterparty exercises 20 ITM puts, now you’re long 2,000 shares at 389, you exercise your ITM 390P and sell 2,000 shares at 390 for a $2,000 net gain.
Either one of these would’ve shown a negative $780,000 balance when the early exercise happened, poor kid didn’t know it was recoverable.