You broke the site guidelines egregiously by turning this into a gender flamewar. Seriously not cool. Please don't do this on HN again.
I've seen some incredibly useless dudes sit back and rest and vest for months and months without any repercussions. I don't have an equivalent story for women because I work with significantly less women. Let's try focusing on the apparent and obvious biases against women before we start keeping score on how men are so disenfranchised.
I think one of the issue of work is that you have to be overly bold to crack through the process, even if you're an incompetent employee on many levels, you'll get there through tribal-ish reflexes. And I think masculine traits align with that, which make them get hired a lot more.
Reverse sexism is completely real, just like "regular" sexism. It doesn't compensate for it in any way, of course.
Reverse sexism helps some women, some of the time.
It doesn't help women, as such, in the big picture.
Sure I can when they're filled with obvious and apparent cognitive biases.
Anecdotes might not support the conclusions they are intended to support, but that doesn't make the anecdotes per se false.
Anecodotes are, well, "anecdotal".
That doesn't depend on whether or not someone got banned.
That user unfortunately resorted to some behaviors that looked like antagonizing another user at the personal level.
His interpretations of some of his experiences are off the mark.
E.g. how some coworker hired interns in order to sexually victimize them is clearly not an example of women getting some sort of easy advancement or free pass. That the events happened is plausibly true; there is no basis for denying the raw facts of the anecdote. It's just not a relevant anecdote, really.
I reiterate that I'm using a standard for "valid" that is befitting of anecdotes, which is confined to the facts. It doesn't cover the cherry-picking of observations that are selected as the basis for anecdotes, or the means of drawing conclusions, or the appropriateness or relevance of the anecdotes to the discourse and the like.
OK, I see the misunderstanding.
I'm not aware of a colloquial usage of "anecdote" which covers confessions of a behavior, let alone a habitual behavior. (By which I don't intend to deny that the usage is real; it's just not known to me.)
An anecdote could certainly include an admission; anything can happen in personal stories.
Still, even if your definition of "anecdote" extends to admissions, I don't see how you could then call it false.
If someone confesses that he treated specific women A, B and C differently, or else that he habitually does so, then the only way that can be false is that he's making it up.
I think I understand your reasoning for not wanting to call human experience invalid. I don't think it applies here because of the informal context (casual conversation) and because the anecdote was used as evidence. He extends his own behavior (treating women differently) to others without any factual basis in his anecdote (since I do it other people do it too). That's entirely invalid.
It also goes without saying that people often tell bald faced lies in the form of anecdotes. These anecdotes are obviously false or invalid as well.
You can't find my anecdotal experiences to be untrue because you haven't experienced my anecdotal experience. This is physically impossible.
What you can claim is that my anecdotal experiences do not apply to women in engineering corporations in general. However, this is not a claim that I made as I caveated my point with the fact that what I'm saying is based off of my own anecdotal evidence.
> I don't have an equivalent story for women because I work with significantly less women.
Evidence is the only way to make sense of the reality we live in and there are two basic types: Anecdotal and Statistical. You claim here that you have no anecdotal evidence. That means statistical evidence is your only option (a stronger option btw) so where is it?
>Let's try focusing on the apparent and obvious biases against women before we start keeping score on how men are so disenfranchised.
Why should I focus on your claim that has no evidence? If men are indeed disenfranchised shouldn't that deserve focus? Are womens' rights superior to mens rights? Are you implying men can't be treated unfairly?
Why can't we focus on the rights of both genders?
Ask yourself that question. In response to somebody writing about their experience changing careers you brought up how men aren't treated fairly.
She was given leeway and my guess is because she's a woman among other things. Women do have advantages that men don't.
Women also have disadvantages but that is not my point. I am simply pointing out one area where women have an advantage in a male dominated field. It's a real advantage.
How do you not see how contradictory that statement is?
Out of all possible advantages (let's say 1000 in total) your saying men hold 100% of all these advantages and women can't even hold one advantage?
What in your mind is more realistic?
If you wanna line up your complaints alongside mountains of empirical evidence showing how women are disenfranchised repeatedly feel free, just don't expect people to take you seriously when you call yourself a feminist.
If you actually want to call yourself a legitimate feminist you should spend more time listening and learning. It might make you actually feel silly to complain about how men are treated in tech.
Show me the data for this specific case of horizontal movement in engineering organizations for women and you have an argument that can change my view.
>If you actually want to call yourself a legitimate feminist you should spend more time listening and learning. It might make you actually feel silly to complain about how men are treated in tech.
I am listening and learning. Show me your data. <-- that is literally a call for you to prove your points so that I can "listen and learn"
>I'm saying what's the point of even keeping score when the odds are so stacked against women.
Who's keeping score? I'm just bringing up one specific case of unfair treatment. I never tried to turn this into a battle of "which sex is treated more unfairly"
Anyway, I see guys mentoring guys all the time. There's nothing sexual 'bout it!
[1] https://www.grammarly.com/blog/capitalization-family-title/
Is there somewhere in my post where I implied otherwise? Please cite what I said that made you think I am not a feminist.
I literally worked in a place where a coworker had sex with the interns he "mentored" and he "mentored" them directly for the opportunity of sex. This happened, and it's not in my power to control what happens in the real world.
My coworker also "hired" these interns and I can guarantee you they wouldn't have been hired if they were dudes. Not saying this happens everywhere, but this stuff definitely happens.
Literally what did I say or do that was against equal opportunities for both genders? Nothing. If I'm wrong, find evidence and make your case.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26069552
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26069593
You have to judge this sort of thing by the entire community response cycle, though. Indignation, provocation, trolling often gets heavily upvoted—but then the rest of the community reacts appropriately and flags it. Usually that will bring it to our attention, too, in which case we can take further moderation action.
Pretty sure this commenter thought of themselves as non-biased. Irony is a cruel mistress.
Do you think it's possible to live in a world where women are the only gender that is mistreated? Or do you think it's more realistic to live in a world where infractions are committed against both genders?
This is off topic, but if my statement about this one case pissed you off because you're an ardent supporter of womens' rights I think you need to watch the video below and keep in mind... I literally never said anything AGAINST women's rights.
And what wrong with switching from Janitor to SWE? Same basic job switch from one another field with completely different skillets but completely different treatment due to perceived ranking.
Asserting that someone working in UX research/design is in an entirely unrelated field from software development is also wildly incorrect. UX folks work with SWEs regularly and are working on the same projects, albeit from a different perspective.
There are also examples of men at my company making fairly similar changes across organizations. I'd love for you to take a minute and consider why you approached my story with the preconceived notion that I've only gotten this opportunity because I'm a woman.
Haranguing other users who show up here to discuss their work is one of the worst things anyone can possibly do here—and yes, that's what you've did: "If that's the case present your data!" — that you were not hired because of your sex and your looks? What the fuck.
We want authors show up on HN to discuss their writings. The choice between having that vs. having trolls who personally attack them is not a difficult one.
So many people nowadays learn coding using "non-traditional" means, and some of those people are REALLY good. Her skills were evaluated over a period of time and she was found to be worthy of a place. Why is that so difficult to believe? If this story were about a man, how would your reaction be different?