News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I followed my dreams to get demoted to software developer by kazinator on Monday February 08, 2021 @04:20PM (#26070294)
Since everyone has valid anecdotes, and that person is a member of everyone, the inescapable logical conclusion is that, indeed, he has valid anecdotes.

I reiterate that I'm using a standard for "valid" that is befitting of anecdotes, which is confined to the facts. It doesn't cover the cherry-picking of observations that are selected as the basis for anecdotes, or the means of drawing conclusions, or the appropriateness or relevance of the anecdotes to the discourse and the like.

Re:I followed my dreams to get demoted to software developer by carlisle_ on Monday February 08, 2021 @04:56PM (#26070738)
Nobody is going to care about how semantically correct you are given one of his anecdotes was him admitting he treats women differently because of their gender. Feel free to call that valid to appease your dictionary definition, however colloquial definitions matter just as much in casual conversation.
Re:I followed my dreams to get demoted to software developer by kazinator on Monday February 08, 2021 @05:08PM (#26070886)
> admitting he treats women differently because of their gender

OK, I see the misunderstanding.

I'm not aware of a colloquial usage of "anecdote" which covers confessions of a behavior, let alone a habitual behavior. (By which I don't intend to deny that the usage is real; it's just not known to me.)

An anecdote could certainly include an admission; anything can happen in personal stories.

Still, even if your definition of "anecdote" extends to admissions, I don't see how you could then call it false.

If someone confesses that he treated specific women A, B and C differently, or else that he habitually does so, then the only way that can be false is that he's making it up.

Re:I followed my dreams to get demoted to software developer by carlisle_ on Monday February 08, 2021 @06:54PM (#26072029)
It's the definition of the word '[in]valid' I was referring to. I'd also say this is the same thing as when I said his anecdotes were not true. What I saw was somebody using biased and bigoted thought to justify their reasoning.

I think I understand your reasoning for not wanting to call human experience invalid. I don't think it applies here because of the informal context (casual conversation) and because the anecdote was used as evidence. He extends his own behavior (treating women differently) to others without any factual basis in his anecdote (since I do it other people do it too). That's entirely invalid.

It also goes without saying that people often tell bald faced lies in the form of anecdotes. These anecdotes are obviously false or invalid as well.