True
>Look at the Soviet Union for an example of what happens when no companies ever go bankrupt.
The Soviet Union was not a free market economy.
>Short activists expose shitty companies and as such, they play an important role in the economy.
In free market economies, shitty companies fail by themselves because their competitors offer better good or services. Short activists don't help make better competitors.
Companies in the Soviet Union needed more competition than short selling.
>Maybe Wirecard's fraud scheme would still be going on if it wasn't for short sellers.
Who knows? Tesla wouldn't exist if short sellers had their way either.
If you want the market to encourage people to investigate fraud and bad news, then they need to be able to profit off of announcing it.
When people don't figure out fraud, the company still suffers eventually but it does so much harder and hurts more people. For example, if Enron's cheating had been exposed a lot earlier it could have been stopped.
Shorting has real and important benefits. And real downsides too, when shorters try to tank companies that had perfectly acceptable fundamentals. But it's definitely a tradeoff, not shorters being parasites.
and some companies do, that is the point.
Why do you feel you need to help it to go down?
Why let people make money on someone's fail?
Why let people have incentives to ruin other people lives?
We should build safety cushions for people, not companies.
> Why do you feel you need to help it to go down?
Do you think it is a good idea to help Intel go bankrupt because it's shitty right now in comparison to AMD?
I would say that short sellers are even more important around primary transactions because then share price matters more. Good prices prevent new investors being left holding the bag and inefficient allocation of capital which could have gone to a different business with better investment opportunities.
Of course not. But if either one of them has secret bad information, it's good for everyone to have it revealed to the public so the stock price can be more accurate.
Fraud may be rare but companies have negative info all the time.
This is the crux. "Shitty" as in obsolete business model: Yes. Shitty as in fraudulent company behaviour: No.
In fact, fraudulent behaviour creates a competitive advantage. And there is only an incentive for the regulator to intervene in the most extreme cases.
Wirecard employed thousands of employees, paid taxes, contributed to social security, and created wealth for investors. Tesla has accelerated the spread of EVs and similarly created enormous wealth for investors. These are real, significant positive effects.
https://www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2020/09/24/w...
That's what disclosed shorting is for. Why is naked shorting needed?
Are you thinking of Melvin Capital, GameStop, or both?
What about shitty hedge funds overusing illegal[1] financial mechanisms to their advantage?
And there's already a less risky mechanism for that: put options.
Look at the Soviet Union for an example of what happens when no companies ever go bankrupt.
Short activists expose shitty companies and as such, they play an important role in the economy.
Maybe Wirecard's fraud scheme would still be going on if it wasn't for short sellers.
Maybe shorting, in particular naked shorting, is not ideal. But there needs to be a way to reward people for taking shitty companies down.