Re:Counterfeiting Stock – Explaining illegal naked shorting ...
by Dylan16807 on Monday February 01, 2021 @03:58AM
(#25986882)
> In free market economies, shitty companies fail by themselves because their competitors offer better good or services. Short activists don't help make better competitors.
If you want the market to encourage people to investigate fraud and bad news, then they need to be able to profit off of announcing it.
When people don't figure out fraud, the company still suffers eventually but it does so much harder and hurts more people. For example, if Enron's cheating had been exposed a lot earlier it could have been stopped.
Shorting has real and important benefits. And real downsides too, when shorters try to tank companies that had perfectly acceptable fundamentals. But it's definitely a tradeoff, not shorters being parasites.
If you want the market to encourage people to investigate fraud and bad news, then they need to be able to profit off of announcing it.
When people don't figure out fraud, the company still suffers eventually but it does so much harder and hurts more people. For example, if Enron's cheating had been exposed a lot earlier it could have been stopped.
Shorting has real and important benefits. And real downsides too, when shorters try to tank companies that had perfectly acceptable fundamentals. But it's definitely a tradeoff, not shorters being parasites.