Good. I hope these companies die. This business model is more toxic than Dow Chemical.
I recently stopped thinking of myself as an Internet user on the web but rather an advertising ID holder.
If only one company does it, they lose. But if everyone is forced to do it, noone will lose.
It's also not a zero sum at all. An advertisement that is not within the user's interest is wasted, rather than going to the competitor.
Not completely, if there is anything to the concept of "brand awareness" (and I believe there is, and a good chunk of advertisers do too). An ad that is not within user's interest still makes an imprint of the brand, product and vendor in their head. Later on, where user's interest change, that brand/product/vendor is a bit more likely to be recalled by them. A mistargeted ad is better than no ad at all.
Has anyone actually compared this over long stretches of time and compared apples to apples, not apples to oranges?
Additionally, most people don't want personalized ads based on tracking: https://www.emarketer.com/content/do-people-actually-want-pe...
I'm sure customers also don't want planned obsolescence. — it is very good for business, however.
I think race to the bottom deserves to be its own type of "planned obsolescence" (again, not mentioned in the Wikipedia classification). While in a highly competitive market, the design process may boil down to "do the same as competitor X, but slightly cheaper" instead of explicitly setting the durability target low, the end result is the same - products that have no business existing enter the market, live very briefly, and forever enter the waste stream. It's a systemic problem, and it's planned in the sense that if you enter such a market, you've already decided to create short-lived trash.
--
[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planned_obsolescence#Types
No, that's one of the big wins of GDPR. You cannot just force the users to sign away their rights.
You may or may not agree on whether the right to privacy should be on the same level as the right to vote, but other than that, it's really the same principle.
Too bad the big bad governement regulation prevent me from selling it. It's absolutely ridiculous, all my customers wants it and I pay my taxes.
Look, I understand if you feel "privacy rights" and "voting rights" are not in the same class of rights, I even mentioned explicitly that even though the same principle applies, you may not agree they're comparable. But you can't deny that the only reason voting rights are not transferable is because we said so - we have laws that dictate "voting rights are not transferable". It's easy to imagine a world where voting rights would, in fact, be transferable. It's just as easy to imagine a world where advertisers don't have the right to build a profile about you.
What is happening now is that we started with a world where (online) privacy rights were non-existent, and laws like GDPR are aiming to change that. You may not agree with the change, but others do, and it's a legitimate sentiment to have. It's not necessarily outrageous to want to "impose on everybody" my view of privacy rights. No more than it was to "impose on everybody" the view that e.g. women should be allowed to vote.
[+]https://theconversation.com/shadow-profiles-facebook-knows-a...
What you are suggesting is not like "women should be allowed to vote" it's akin to "women must vote".
> sharing users' personal data, something that influences only them
It does not influence only them, and I gave you an example. Also, I don't care what's FB's business model, I advocate that nobody should have an automatic right to build user profiles. I explicitly advocate that you should not have the right to demand payment in "data" because privacy should not be considered currency. Is that a strawman? I thought that was your entire argument "people should be free to decide to pay with their data!". NO THEY SHOULD NOT. Data is not currency, just like votes are not currency. You ask for currency, if you need payment - you don't ask for profile data.
> it's akin to "women must vote".
Well, it's an analogy, if you don't find it useful, let's drop it. The gist of it is, I feel very strongly that we should legislate that privacy is not currency, you seem to feel otherwise. It is fine to disagree, but it doesn't make my position irrational or absurd in any way. Yes, I feel that allowing people to pay with privacy _is_ exactly "taking their rights away", in the same way that allowing them to pay with their voting rights would be.
But none of that seemed to be relevant to the Grindr fine. And one thing I should have probably mentioned before - I don't know Grindr and how the subscription works there, but my opinion on paying(subscription) vs giving data away would also depend if there were additional features granted in the subscription (now thinking about it probably yes) or not. This would in my opinion qualify as forcing user into paying even for thing he might not necessarily want to just to protect own privacy.
Also, prior to GDPR, the "pay with your data" aspect wasn't even mentioned by the companies. Ultimately, GDPR doesn't prevent people from donating their data - it just requires that it's explicit and not mandatory.
Below are excerpts run via Google Translate. I'm truly very surprised by what I just saw - the directness and honesty of communications is even more refreshing than privacy-friendliness itself. Their FAQ covers privacy and advertising concerns separately, and is very specific. If I had a need for German-language news, I'd subscribe to this just as a token of appreciation.
--
[0] - "We continue to advertise our own products discreetly because SPIEGEL readers expect information about new products from the company. We cannot technically remove advertising from podcasts and our digital edition, but this is played without tracking. Individual sponsorships are just as difficult to fade out, and separate page areas such as voucher and sports betting marketplaces that are independently offered by the providers there are only to be made inaccessible in the navigation of our journalistic offers - but not, for example, for searches from outside. This is the level at which the exceptions move."
[1] - "We depend on it [internal usage measurements] for both basic control and further development of the news site, especially in order to optimize our payment model: Which texts are of interest to readers, where do operating elements not work, which pay offer might interest a reader and which rather not?"
[2] - "What data does DER SPIEGEL collect from PUR subscribers? The customary reach comparisons and usage statistics for the control and optimization of the site, especially via our first-party service provider Adobe." - I'm not sure what they mean by Adobe being a "first-party service provider", but I don't like it collecting anything.
--
EDIT: here [3] is a list of cookies they set for PUR subscribers. Seems to be true to their word (and it's nice this list wasn't hard to find in the first place), but I'm worried about the presence of Outbrain on that list. I can't imagine any legitimate interest a third-party chumbox provider would have.
--
[3] - https://odbdegi64ni2b3m74jattyok7i--www-spiegel-de.translate...
If Grinder was fined 10% of revenue - why exactly aren't they fining Facebook 2.2 billion? It'd be much more impactful, and hopefully help put an end to those practices.
>Consent must also be freely given. The DPA highlighted that users should have a real choice not to consent without any negative consequences. Grindr made use of the app conditional on consenting to data sharing or to paying a subscription fee.
I thought that this was allowed. Kind of puts companies depending on advertising in really bad position. One would expect that having choice of paying or getting tracked would be, at least for some people, better than just having to pay to get to the content.