It's also not a zero sum at all. An advertisement that is not within the user's interest is wasted, rather than going to the competitor.
Not completely, if there is anything to the concept of "brand awareness" (and I believe there is, and a good chunk of advertisers do too). An ad that is not within user's interest still makes an imprint of the brand, product and vendor in their head. Later on, where user's interest change, that brand/product/vendor is a bit more likely to be recalled by them. A mistargeted ad is better than no ad at all.
Has anyone actually compared this over long stretches of time and compared apples to apples, not apples to oranges?
Additionally, most people don't want personalized ads based on tracking: https://www.emarketer.com/content/do-people-actually-want-pe...
I'm sure customers also don't want planned obsolescence. — it is very good for business, however.
I think race to the bottom deserves to be its own type of "planned obsolescence" (again, not mentioned in the Wikipedia classification). While in a highly competitive market, the design process may boil down to "do the same as competitor X, but slightly cheaper" instead of explicitly setting the durability target low, the end result is the same - products that have no business existing enter the market, live very briefly, and forever enter the waste stream. It's a systemic problem, and it's planned in the sense that if you enter such a market, you've already decided to create short-lived trash.
--
[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planned_obsolescence#Types
If only one company does it, they lose. But if everyone is forced to do it, noone will lose.