News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by that_guy_iain on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @05:18AM (#25914208)
EEA has all the laws and requirements of the EU but without representiation. So they have to follow the laws and rules but don't have a voice in the rules. I have no idea what the benefit of the EEA is for it's members other than political that they can say they're not in the EU but there must be some, maybe they don't need to pay in like EU members do?
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by hkh28 on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @05:49AM (#25914389)
> I have no idea what the benefit of the EEA is for it's members

We have the option to reject certain EU-rules, and can negotiate special exemptions into our agreement. Norway has some exemptions in fishing rights that are central to our agreement. Under the previous government we also rejected the EU Postal Directive, though the current government has since accepted it.

Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by that_guy_iain on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @07:03AM (#25914843)
The UK had those too while being a member.
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by foepys on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @09:36AM (#25916164)
The UK always got special treatment while they were in the EU. No other country was allowed to come even close. Which made Brexit so much more surprising to the EU.
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by Hamuko on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @11:22AM (#25917618)
Perhaps it's not that surprising that the curmudgeon with one foot out of the EU already decided to take the second one out as well.
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by momento on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @06:05AM (#25914486)
Contrary to popular belief, the EEA is not required to follow every law set within the European Union.

> The EEA Agreement does not cover the following EU policies: common agriculture and fisheries policies (although the EEA Agreement contains provisions on trade in agricultural and fish products); customs union; common trade policy; common foreign and security policy; justice and home affairs (the EEA EFTA States are however part of the Schengen area); direct and indirect taxation; or economic and monetary union.

See section 5, "What is not covered by the EEA Agreement?": https://www.efta.int/eea/eea-agreement/eea-basic-features

Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by anthonybennis on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @05:19AM (#25914212)
Benefit is equal access to Common Market as an EU member.
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by that_guy_iain on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @05:19AM (#25914215)
Sorry, I meant benefit of EEA over EU membership.
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by thefounder on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @05:22AM (#25914230)
They have some "special rights" on natural resources. i.e oil, fishery. I think the EU will close that loophole soon.
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by vidarh on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @06:11AM (#25914510)
They can't "close that loophole". It's an integral part of the EEA treaty. If the EU withdraws from the EEA treaty it would virtually guarantee that support for EU membership in Norway would sink like a rock out of sheer anger. It would lead to Norway withdrawing further from the EU, not joining, so it'd be entirely counterproductive.
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by olavgg on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @07:20AM (#25914978)
This is true, Norway and Switzerland are strong economies that can stay outside EU. Norway have a lot of oil compared to the number of people who lives there, which makes Norway a more independent economy than for example UK. I do think Norway would benefit by becoming a full EU member. But there are also good reasons not to. So the EEA treaty is the best of both worlds. Norway lose and gain some.
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by Majestic121 on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @05:47AM (#25914375)
Is there any reason for the EU to close that loophole now ?

It seems to be a pretty good partnership so far, and I did not read anything about a will from either side to change anything about it yet, but I might be misinformed

Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by kristofferR on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @10:51AM (#25917172)
It's pretty stupid to call it a loophole at all. It's like calling the Xbox Series S a next-gen gaming loophole.
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by kristofferR on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @11:00AM (#25917306)
Not having to adopt the Euro is also a "special right".

It's not well known, but all EU countries are required to adopt the Euro (except for Denmark who have a real opt-out). The countries who haven't are using a loophole to bypass the requirement of Euro adoption, by purposefully failing to fulfill some standards.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enlargement_of_the_eurozone

Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by xyproto on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @05:40AM (#25914336)
Also, EU has a ruleset adapted to the climate of central Europe and not to cold places where almost no food grows and eating seals and fighting polar bears is how you stay alive. This is an extreme example, but Norway is more dependent on fish for sustenance than many other countries.
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by vidarh on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @06:21AM (#25914572)
Norway is dependent on fish mostly because of the export value. A lot of fish is eaten in Norway, sure but the Norwegian economy is such that local production has very little to do with what people choose to eat.

The only place in Norway Polar bears live is Svalbard, far North of the mainland. Most Norwegians have never visited because it's far away (a 1h 40m flight North from Tromsø in Northern Norway - similar to how long it takes to fly South to Central Europe from Oslo) and way too cold and miserable.

Seal is something few people eat very often. A huge proportion of the population will never ever have tasted it. Like whale, it's uncommon these days.

Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by ginko on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @05:45AM (#25914361)
> eating seals and fighting polar bears is how you stay alive

Your image of Norway may be a bit off..

It's true though that Norway is overly protective of its food industry. And arguably for good reason since it wouldn't be competitive at all if integrated with the rest of Europe.

Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by vidarh on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @06:17AM (#25914544)
As a Norwegian, I do like the idea that foreigners see me as capable of fighting a polar bear.

As for seals, I've eaten seal, I think, but it's hardly been a dietary mainstay... We used to have whale regularly when I was a kid, mostly because back then it was much cheaper than beef (and much tougher, and oily... it was not great meat - it's expensive now due to low supply and nostalgia).

Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by xyproto on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @10:38AM (#25917002)
I am Norwegian, apparently I just didn't express myself clearly enough.
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by martin8412 on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @05:23AM (#25914239)
For Norway the reason is fish. Since they're not in the EU, they don't have to allow others access to fish in their waters.
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by xyproto on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @05:37AM (#25914311)
It's tragicomic that this was part of the reason for Brexit, but they ended up with letting other countries fish in their waters anyways.
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by josefx on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @07:33AM (#25915101)
Weren't pretty much all the reasons for Brexit bullshit from the start? I heard that some politicians even gave nonsensical statements in more recent interviews so that searches for various keywords would hit those instead of the original Brexit promises.
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by detaro on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @05:52AM (#25914413)
and agriculture (and agriculture subsidies).
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by vidarh on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @06:08AM (#25914498)
This is a big one for Norway as food security has been a big strategic focus for Norway ever since the British naval blockade against Denmark-Norway during the Napoleonic wars, reaffirmed by the hardships during the Nazi occupation.

It's still largely politically untenable in Norway to oppose agriculture subsidies.

Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by jacquesm on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @06:37AM (#25914656)
There is something a bit sad about having present day policy be determined by the Napoleonic wars.
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by vidarh on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @06:49AM (#25914741)
At this point it's more of a curiosity than something most people are aware of. It was the starting point of a realisation that choking off just a handful of trade routes could starve the country.

Today the main reminder is that Norwegian school children still tend to learn the epic poem "Terje Vigen" by Ibsen, about a man who braves the blockade to feed his family and is captured - coupled with food security being a talking point in other subjects. It's not pushed very hard, and many probably at this point don't even make the connection.

The main modern justification is WW2, where the subject of food security gets reinforced with stories of bread made with bark etc., and post-war rationing.

Couple that with the constant fear of the Soviet Union (to the point that when growing up, we had regular air raid siren tests - today they're so rare the newspapers write articles to explain what they are) only reducing to unease about Russia, and food security is still a political topic.

Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by jacquesm on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @07:24AM (#25915018)
We still do the air raid tests here too, every 1st Monday of the month at noon, but they are more for other kinds of disasters (pollution, gas leaks, large fires and so on). That system is about to be phased out completely, because mobile phones are a much faster way to reach people.

Personally I don't mind the sirens, they tend to work pretty reliably and every time the mobile phone network was used to indicate something was up for some reason I totally missed the message, never received it or received it more than a day later.

Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by gridder on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @05:45AM (#25914365)
And can fish without any external limit. See the pilot whales hunt in the faroe islands: https://youtu.be/ws99HlPBySA
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by vidarh on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @06:12AM (#25914520)
The Faroe islands are not Norwegian, and Norway does not allow hunt of pilot whales.

EDIT: That's not to say Norway doesn't still do whaling, but quotas are only for minke whales. Of a quota of 1278 for 2019, 429 where caught. But pilot whales explicitly still do not meet the conditions required (size of population etc.) for Norway to allow hunt.

Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by izacus on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @05:59AM (#25914454)
I think both EEA members could negotiate carve-outs where the EU rules don't hold for them and they keep certain privileges.

E.g. Switzerland can still have customs and charge customs charges on some items.

Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by yarcob on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @06:29AM (#25914608)
There are also passport checks when you fly to Norway from other EU countries. For flights between other EU countries you generally just show the QR code on your phone. At least that was my experience, but it's been a few years since I last flew. (Except flights to UK before Brexit, I think they always required passport checks)
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by gspr on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @06:47AM (#25914729)
> There are also passport checks when you fly to Norway from other EU countries.

This is incorrect. And the presence or absence of these checks is not a EU/EEA matter. The passport free movement is a matter of the Schengen agreement. This is why the UK had passport checks with most of continental Europe back when they were EU members (but not Schengen members).

Norway is a Schengen member, and an EEA member, but not an EU member.

This Venn diagram might help (note that it hasn't been updated for Brexit): https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/3c/Supranat...

Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by yarcob on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @12:58PM (#25919040)
> This is incorrect

You are right about Schengen.

But I had to show my passport a couple of years ago on a flight from Vienna to Norway, so I thought they weren't part of Schengen. I'm not sure why, but I believe the reason must have been the "temporary border controls" introduced in 2015.

Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by gspr on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @02:33PM (#25920115)
Yes. But that was a temporary, exceptional situation of border checks all over Europe.
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by xxs on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @08:22AM (#25915468)
>note that it hasn't been updated for Brex

Ah, even Croatia is outside the EU on the diagram - so it's way worse than that. That being said: Croatia is outside Schengen as well.

Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by xxs on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @08:08AM (#25915366)
>passport checks ... between other EU countries

The passport checks have nothing to do with the EU, it's the Schengen treaty[0] that allows omitting that part. Norway is a part of the treaty, so is Iceland for example. Some EU countries still don't meet the criteria to join, e.g. Romania, Bulgaria. Ireland and the UK are/were outside (voluntarily) of the treaty as well - which is one of the weirdest parts of the Brexit with the UK actually checking its own borders more than most of the rest of the EU.

For example traveling from Poland to Norway by car (and ferry Tallinn - Helsinki) requires zero passport/id card checks. (id cards are a valid traveling document within the EU and Schengen)

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schengen_Area

Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by dmitriid on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @06:36AM (#25914651)
> There are also passport checks when you fly to Norway from other EU countries.

Except countries in the Nordic Passport Union: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nordic_Passport_Union You need zero documents to travel between these (well, you need a ticket if you fly or travel by train or a bus).

Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by yarcob on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @06:45AM (#25914710)
So I read the article, and in theory there should be no passport checks with other EU countries either because of Schengen, but apparently they have "temporary border controls" since 2015 in violation of the agreements.
Re:Grindr to be fined almost €10M over GDPR complaint by dmitriid on Tuesday January 26, 2021 @07:02AM (#25914840)
Indeed.

I flew to Norway from Stockholm before 2015, and I was very surprised to just pass directly to the gate (and same on the way back).