News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by judge2020 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @05:49PM (#25840006)
Supply chains at Apple’s scale take at least 3 years to set up and scale up. I’m surprised it didn’t take longer for them to fully disintegrate that supplier.
Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by rmsaksida on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @05:56PM (#25840076)
A supplier using child labor shouldn't be a "ok, let's gradually work this out" kind of issue. It should be a "immediately cut all ties to them" kind of issue. If it will disrupt a supply chain and hurt profits, so be it. Seems like a small price to pay compared to using child labor.
Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by ortusdux on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:05PM (#25840179)
They will continue to behave this way until the damage to their profits is higher than the damage from a supply chain interruption. To quote fight club:

> Now, should we initiate a recall? Take the number of vehicles in the field, A, multiply by the probable rate of failure, B, multiply by the average out-of-court settlement, C. A times B times C equals X. If X is less than the cost of a recall, we don't do one.

Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by rmsaksida on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:08PM (#25840209)
It will never happen because most people don't actually care that much about children being a part of the supply chain for their favorite products. Given the choice between a new iPhone and an alternative product that doesn't depend on child labor, most people would pick the iPhone.
Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by judge2020 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:21PM (#25840339)
Replace “iPhone” with “cheaper products”. Most Amazon products are Chinese imports that most definitely are sourced from manufacturers with little/no care for forced labor in their supply chain. The media singles Apple out because they’re big enough to force their suppliers to change, but still can’t switch on a dime.
Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by Triv888 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:04PM (#25840165)
But what would you think if you were a child in a poor country and that was your only way to eat?
Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by munk-a on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @07:41PM (#25841117)
I would think it's perfectly fair for you, as that child to seek out labour.

But I also think it'd be perfectly fair if some sort of social safety net resulted in an orphanage where you could eat if you were starving - but that safety net would need to be paid by taxes on income that Apple isn't paying to their employees.

Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by Triv888 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @08:30PM (#25841483)
That sounds good and all, but what if the local Government isn't doing it... what is the next step?
Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by munk-a on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @08:40PM (#25841554)
For Apple to not do business there because a bunch of entitled Americans yell at them over exploiting child labour... which, granted, isn't the best outcome for the locale in the short term but would result in the government making itself more acceptable as a overseas labour pool to US corporations.
Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by judge2020 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:25PM (#25840371)
I know this is probably sarcasm but the U.S. ideology is that the child should think “man I can’t wait for the United States to stage a coup in my government that brings capitalism and U.S. financial military aid to my country”.
Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by DanBC on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:40PM (#25840516)
Just checking you know that the US still uses child labour in the US.

https://www.hrw.org/video-photos/video/2014/05/13/made-usa-c...

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/jun/28/tobacco-child-...

> Child labor is common on tobacco farms in the United States, where children are exposed to nicotine, toxic pesticides, and other dangers. Child tobacco workers often get sick with vomiting, nausea, headaches, and dizziness while working, all symptoms consistent with acute nicotine poisoning. Many work 50 to 60 hours a week without overtime pay, often in extreme heat. They may be exposed to pesticides that are known neurotoxins. Many also use dangerous tools and machinery, lift heavy loads, and climb to perilous heights to hang tobacco for drying. The largest tobacco companies in the world purchase tobacco grown in the US to make popular cigarette brands like Marlboro, Newport, Camel, Pall Mall and others. These companies can’t legally sell cigarettes to children, but they are profiting from child labor. US law also fails these children, by allowing them to work at much younger ages, for longer hours, and under more hazardous conditions than children working in all other sectors. Children as young as 12 can work legally on tobacco farms and at even younger ages on small farms.

Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by Triv888 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:33PM (#25840456)
I'm not being sarcastic at all... I have not been in those countries and I don't know what the kids' alternatives are.
Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by DanBC on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:44PM (#25840562)
You're right, it's tricky. The alternative should be school and fair wages for adults.

https://www.thenewhumanitarian.org/news/2007/11/19/attitudes...

Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by aaomidi on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:00PM (#25840116)
I'm getting so tired of people defending Apple on this.

Like...No. This is a red line. Do a better job before you find a supplier.

Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by munk-a on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:33PM (#25840450)
I think it's acceptable to accidentally pick a bad supplier but when they learned of this three years ago they should've immediately cut ties. Oh, it's super expensive to change suppliers but own the mistake and pay the short term costs of being forced to rework supply lines while recognizing that inefficiency as the cost of skimping on your research on the supplier.

I would be absolutely unsurprised if someone instrumental in setting up this partnership still got a bonus after this was discovered due to the low cost of producing the part.

Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by mlthoughts2018 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:03PM (#25840153)
It’s doubtful that any large bureaucracy can execute that decision quickly, though I do agree 3 years is way too long. I’d put 3 months as hard minimum even assuming every internal decision process went as smoothly as possible, and 6 months as a more realistic amount.

Just legal validation alone would take weeks even under emergency round-the-clock conditions. It’s the same with most open and shut zero-tolerance style firings as well, for all but the most fungible roles.

This largely has nothing to do with how grievous the transgression is or how sincerely the management wants to do the right thing. It has to do with red tape that is designed from first principles to permit zero exceptions or special cases that can cut through it quickly.

It would require refactoring not just Apple’s red tape infrastructure but the entire concept across virtually all of corporate America to optimize for speed of firing vendors based on child exploitation.

It’s like choosing an O(n^2) algorithm, baking it in as a load-bearing centerpiece, then being upset something doesn’t happen in O(1).

Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by ramenmeal on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:05PM (#25840175)
Make it a law, or expect companies to follow the $. It's sad, but it's the state of our capitalism in the US.
Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by munk-a on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @07:09PM (#25840819)
I don't find it that sad honestly. Corporations don't exist to be charitable organizations - it'd be nice if they were a bit less cutthroat in chasing profits but there always have and will always be people who abuse norms to get an edge over others. Encoding a norm into law makes it more just by making the norm clearer to those who might have grown up elsewhere and cements a punishment.
Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by haltingproblem on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @05:55PM (#25840066)
Can you explain this more. If it takes them 3 years to scale up, does it now mean all the vendors are locked in for that period. If a vendor starts failing quality checks will they still take 3 years to disintegrate them? If not then why would violation of their own labor standards take 3 years to remove them?

FWIW, except forced labor, I am against child labor standards since it usurps the wisdom of the parents without providing for that child. No parent no matter how poor wants their child to work unless they cannot afford to feed them. The alternative to working in a apple supplier factory might be working in a more hazardous factory or construction site.

Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by stagger87 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:03PM (#25840155)
> does it now mean all the vendors are locked in for that period?

Probably contractually, yes. For large scale manufacturing there are agreements and purchases that look ahead years in advance. Parts and labor are allocated. If you have quality control issues at any point (which is common), you fix them.

Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by alicorn on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:23PM (#25840359)
> No parent no matter how poor wants their child to work unless they cannot afford to feed them. As anyone who has grown up in a country where child labor was normal will tell you, this is patently false. If it is the norm in the country in question, everyone does it and it is expected. Children who do not work and their families are in many cases ostracized. Then of course there are jobs and jobs, and a certain type of parent might vie for a job for their child that is less backbreaking than the average. But not working at all is frowned upon. Source: lived experience in Soviet Union.
Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by dragonwriter on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:44PM (#25840568)
> No parent no matter how poor wants their child to work unless they cannot afford to feed them.

Okay, I was a child when my father (who could very much afford to feed our family) set up my first paid (cash, completely under-the-table) computer-related gigs. I would say parents often would want children to work if the work was something that would aid the child’s development and future prospects, even if not necessary for immediate support.

What that looks like for a middle class family in a first world information economy and what it looks like for a poorer family in a less developed country is likely to be very different.

But its worth noting that child labor standards are historically adopted to force up wages for adult laborers, so that child labor is not necessary for employed parents to be able to feed their children. So while I don’t agree that “no parent, no matter how poor wants their child to work unless they cannot afford to feed them” is true, I do think there are dead-end, body-ruining factory jobs for which that is true, and those are exactly the jobs into which that horrible choice is forced on parents by the economic conditions created by the absence of child labor standards.

Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by haltingproblem on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @07:51PM (#25841183)
Clearly I was not talking about gigs in the local supermarket or computer related gigs in the first world. My father also put me to work and we were upper middle class. This was purely for character building and experience and life skills. Those are not the gigs which land a 14 year old working in an iPhone factory in China.

I think you are agreeing and disagreeing at the same time ;)

Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by somethingwitty1 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:29PM (#25840415)
Outside of the other concerns people have raised, it is important to remember even if all parents are making the right choice for their kids, it isn't always (and in many cases, isn't) the parent making this decision. For example, another case where Apple has gotten outed, they were actively aware of the forced child labor by the schools: https://www.channelnews.com.au/apple-admits-to-using-child-l...

And if you believe the children, they also weren't really being paid and had no choice to participate in these "internships".

Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by haltingproblem on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @10:47PM (#25842366)
I had a forced labor exception in my statement.

The concerns people have raised are fairly pedantic namely working in developed or semi-developed economies. That is the not the topic under discussion - 8-12 hour shift in iPhone factories is the topic under discussion.

My dad who grew up in a fairly prosperous family of humble origin in the third world worked through from age 10 to age 18 in the family concern. It is what everyone did.

Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by adamcstephens on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:13PM (#25840258)
Parents make plenty of awful decisions for their kids. They beat them, rape them, and more. Why is there an assumption that they’re doing the “better alternative” by putting them to work?

If American companies condone child labor, then they’re encouraging it.

Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by LatteLazy on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @05:52PM (#25840040)
You'd think they call that supplier and the supplier would (within a few hours) stop using child labour...
Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by keehun on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @05:55PM (#25840063)
While still meeting delivery targets? Even if budget weren't a concern, how do you scale up new employees that quickly?

I'm NOT condoning the behavior. This is disgusting. Still, "the supplier would (within a few hours) stop using child labour" is completely unrealistic.

Apple should have cut ties immediately even if it meant a breach of contract or shortage of inventory.

Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by xupybd on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:25PM (#25840378)
They should have but they made the bet they could slowly transition to another supplier with no impact to profits by getting out without anyone finding out.

I'm also betting their hit to profits will be less even after this revelation, than if they cut ties with the supplier and run short on inventory.

I wouldn't be surprised if that cold calculation came into play as well.

Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by judge2020 on Saturday January 30, 2021 @01:31AM (#25966794)
Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by TLightful on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:01PM (#25840134)
With the utmost respect. F@ck delivery targets.
Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by hinkley on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:08PM (#25840207)
You'd think they call that supplier and the supplier tries to convince them they've stopped using child labour.

For some reason I was looking at pictures of textile equipment recently. Some of that equipment is built so that it's only accessible to growing children or adults with growth disorders. That's structural bias to such a degree that it is in fact literal. The requirement of child labor is literally built into the factory. I have no way of knowing if that's true for this factory, but if they're capitalistic at all then accessibility for (local) above-average humans is an opportunity cost that would have been eliminated in the name of efficiency. And if that worked so well why not try it again on the next assembly line, only goosed a little harder?

In any case, there is no "overnight" because you have to train new people for a high throughput task. But would you even believe them once they did?

For the west that's such a basic boundary at this point that if someone goes past it, it's because their ethical model is so different from yours that you can't reason about whether they've actually done what you've asked, or they've employed a new coping mechanism to seem 'normal'. Like just rearranging the factory so that your section has all the people over 16, which means the other building is now almost entirely children (making the situation more dangerous, not less). Or the children work second shift when you won't be around to audit, which is both dangerous and more unhealthy.

They didn't get your objection to begin with. Their response is likely to resemble the sort of thing a sociopath would do: identify your discomfort and arrange for it never to be triggered, rather than truth and reconciliation.

Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by stunt on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:00PM (#25840120)
Maybe not hours, but days or months. I don't understand why they haven't done anything in 3 years to not lose Apple.

I'm worried if Apple didn't push hard enough during all that 3 years, and later they moved to a different supplier for other reasons.

Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by Jtsummers on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:20PM (#25840337)
If you read the article linked from this one at The Information, the child labor case boils down to this:

The minimum age was 16.

An audit revealed 2 15-year-olds were working at Suyin.

3 months later (the time companies are given to remedy things like this), 3 more underage workers were found (ages 15 and 14) in a follow-on audit.

At that point, Apple stopped giving new contracts to Suyin due to the repeated violations, but permitted existing contracts to run their course.

Apple did do something, just probably not what most people would want them to do.

Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by jibcage on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @05:55PM (#25840062)
They have leverage if they’re the only gig in town, though.
Re:Apple knew a supplier was using child labor but took 3 ye... by herodoturtle on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @05:55PM (#25840065)
You'd think within a few hours and not right away?