News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by mycroftiv on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @02:28AM (#2578900)
This is a clear case where we see the idea that governments should represent the will of their citizens break down completely. Every power structure serves its own needs first. In areas where the interest of governmental systems and the citizens are in alignment, democracy can work - but when there is a conflict between the will of a power structure to extend its power and influence and the desires of the citizens, governments almost invariably choose to serve their own systemic interests.

Internet censorship is a dramatic example of this. Even in democratic societies with large majorities in favor of free communication over the internet, the internal imperatives of governments to monitor and control trump the will of the people, no matter who is in power. In the matter of desiring to be able to read everyone's email, the governments of the world are in nearly unanimous alliance against their own citizens.

Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by gizzlon on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @04:09AM (#2579071)
While I agree with most of what you say, I'm not so sure "large majorities in favour of free communication over the internet"

Do you have any data to back this up?

My guess is that if you frame it the right way, most people would vote for censoring the Internet

Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by marknutter on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @09:09AM (#2579636)
If by favoring free communication over the internet you mean "my email will be private", I think you can safely assume large majorities will be in favor of it.
Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by jm4 on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @09:41AM (#2579742)
I am not so sure. We have seen this before. It goes something like this:"What's the problem with trading a little privacy for security? I don't have anything to hide." These people who have nothing to hide because they have never done anything wrong have ceded their privacy and rights at every turn. Why would the internet be different?

Well, people are very protective of their email, that's why. Email is the key to a person's online identity and should be guarded like one's wallet or house keys. But wait until the children are brought into the debate. "Of course, everyone knows _you_ are legit, but there are predators creeping around in the seedy underbelly of the internet. These sexual predators will prey on your children through email and social networking sites. We need safeguards in place to ensure that predators are not able to operate freely on the internet and thus ensure your and your family's freedom and security."

Those predator shows on MSNBC where they basically entice some disturbed person with a made up fantasy, parade him in front of the cameras, talk about all the what-ifs and then arrest him only to have him show up on the next episode reinforces this. Aside: It drives me bonkers when the host says, "You came here to meet a 14 year old boy. What would have happened if we were not here?" I'll tell you. Absolutely nothing. Because there was no 14 year old boy in a chat room looking to meet 45 year old child molesters and there was no 14 year old boy waiting for him in the house.

There are smart people- good parents- who will eat that kind of crap up. They are the kind of parents that are involved in their children's lives. They help them with homework and know their friends and their friend's parents. They talk to their children about risks and staying safe. These are the kind of parents who have the least to worry about, but also the ones who will argue most passionately in favor of policies like this.

Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by jellicle on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @09:28AM (#2579693)
Not at all. If the question is "Should the government be able to access email to track down pornographers and terrorists?", the answer is that 99% of the population is in favor of it.
Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by dantheman on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @09:36AM (#2579717)
That's quite the claim and I don't believe it for a second.
Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by jm4 on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @09:56AM (#2579786)
The greater point is getting lost in the BS statistic. Make no mistake; the debate could be skewed any which way if you start with the right question. There was an episode of "Penn and Teller: Bullshit!"[1] where they talk to a pollster who does this for a living. He does a few demo polls where he basically starts by saying what result he wants and then asks the question that will produce exactly that.

1. Season 4, episode 9 "Numbers"

Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by d0ne on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @03:38PM (#2581278)
I'm with ^
Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by RyanMcGreal on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @10:24AM (#2579905)
"Not without a warrant."
Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by nitrogen on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @06:48AM (#2579361)
To interested readers: there is an interesting auto-killed response from oelewapperke that can only be read if you turn on showdead in your HN account settings. I suggest enabling showdead and reading the comment.
Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by khafra on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @08:24AM (#2579536)
He definitely has an axe to grind, and the first Google result casts some doubt on the 90% figure: http://journal.webscience.org/138/

But his larger point remains intact: Freedom of the press/Internet is only an axiomatic good in educated America and Europe. It's on shaky ground in the rest of the world, which in a democratic referendum would make the educated population of America and Europe a rounding error.

Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by Joakal on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @07:16AM (#2579406)
I read the comment, it seems heavily opinionated touting worldwide numbers with hyperbole and more. Overall it seems the poster has an axe to grind.

I'm not sure if it was constructive. However, the parent poster was asking for sources.

Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by ignifero on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @07:21AM (#2579413)
I especially disagree with his/her views on Europeans. If anything, we are more sensitive on those matters than the US, that's why the world's dissidents seek refuge here.
Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by Joakal on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @05:45AM (#2579255)
Wiki article on Internet Censorship in Australia: https://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Internet_cens...
Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by mahmud on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @03:06AM (#2578977)
Counter argument: why do you want to allow gay-married Muslim homosexual commies to sneak into our country and piss on our burning flag after taking our jobs and blowing up our kindergartens? Is that what you want? puppy-AIDS and Sharia law?
Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by xorglorb on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @03:19AM (#2578994)
That is not an argument, that is a propaganda tool used against the easily-persuaded.
Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by mahmud on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @03:25AM (#2579004)
The easily-persuaded pretty much describes the majority of the electorate, at least in my country.

The average American votes against his best interest. The official response to any opposition to totalitarian tactics is .. FUD. Something only less blatant than what I have written above.

Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by waqf on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @09:01AM (#2579608)
I'm not saying you're wrong, but have you considered how you would disprove the alternate possibility that the "easily-persuaded majority" is a bogeyman conjured up by the media to explain why the candidate that everyone you know voted for wasn't elected?
Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by mahmud on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @09:38AM (#2579725)
You assume I take my opinions from "the media". No. You can tail -f the legal Changelog of your favorite state and deduce the fuckedupness-beyond-repair of the populace.
Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by waqf on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @11:02AM (#2580072)
I'm confused, you seem to be assuming that my favorite state is democratic somehow? Otherwise I can only deduce fuckedupness of the politicians, which is not in dispute.
Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by mahmud on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @11:20AM (#2580152)
I was speaking specifically of the United States. I don't know of any state in the union that isn't democratic.

I know Texas' redistricting shenanigans are sleazy, but it's still a democracy.

Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by xorglorb on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @03:47AM (#2579036)
Sadly true.
Re:G8 agenda calls for "civilized Internet": monitored, gove... by crististm on Tuesday May 24, 2011 @09:59AM (#2579800)
That is exactly the problem: you get results by persuasion, not by logical arguments.