News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by koolk3ychain on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:09PM (#25769282)
Someone really needs to give the New Yorker some serious credit for publishing what can genuinely be described as a thoughtful, well written, and objective article on social media and big tech. Bravo.

I'm honestly convinced that at some point this kind of big tech social media witch burning will eventually lead to private lawsuits aimed at non-combatants like Signal and Wickr. Please leave a comment if you disagree - down votes don't help sow discussion.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by cm2187 on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:24PM (#25769442)
Though the article doesn’t mention the coordinated and active censoring of the NY Post story, even in private conversations, which was already a heavy stroke of interference in the elections. It’s a lot of precedents. And there is nothing that suggests the temperature will cool down in the short term. I agree that big tech companies may do a lot more collateral damage but in my opinion they also already painted themselves with a bull eye on their back. Republicans will get back to power sooner or later and I think we should expect a regulatory backlash.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by Grustaf on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:39PM (#25769575)
I think it’s exceedingly unlikely they will get back into power in anything like their current form. We will now see a democratic government that is fully aligned, and has deep ties with, silicon valley. The big tech industrial complex has infinitely more control over our thoughts and proclivities than any previous power center.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by cm2187 on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:43PM (#25769621)
True but I still think there is a limit to how much one can influence a population’s opinion. My favorite example is Poland which after 60 years of communism, is the most conservative catholic country in Europe. Elections are often won at the margin (and this one was particularly tight in the key states), and therefore a marginal influence may be enough to tip the outcome. But I think it will do nothing to a broad base movement.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by Grustaf on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:41AM (#25775207)
Ah but a modern welfare state combined with the power of all the social networks, and much of the internet infrastructure, that combo can exert much more power than the soviet communists ever could.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by majormajor on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:48PM (#25769665)
> We will now see a democratic government that is fully aligned, and has deep ties with, silicon valley. The big tech industrial complex has infinitely more control over our thoughts and proclivities than any previous power center.

Nope. Huge swaths of the democratic party are opposed to these SV companies because they see Twitter, FB, etc, as having played a huge part in Trump gaining the influence he did and the conspiracy nutjobs evangelizing their craziness as well.

I expect pushes for regulation, just a different sort than Trump would've pushed for.

Here we have people dying because a President who was afraid of losing spent months preemptively setting up a fraud excuse. An excuse that was enabled and amplified by social media platforms that also helped people spread conspiracies about the supposed non-existence of a global pandemic, and thus the need for different behaviors.

Even if you end up saying Trump himself shouldn't have been banned, you have a huge echo chamber problem that has now passed the point where we can dismiss it with stuff like "they just need to feel heard." Lots of people listened, and it led to lots of violence, and is the way we're currently (not) regulating social media sufficient?

All of these nutjob theories have gotten MORE prevalent in the past 4 years DESPITE their candidate winning the 2016 election and DESPITE their candidate completely failing to expose any national pedophile conspiracy or any of the other nonsense they spout... The ultimate influence of the big social media platforms has been anything but left-leaning.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by xpe on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:44PM (#25769630)
> Though the article doesn’t mention the coordinated and active censoring of the NY Post story, even in private conversations, which was already a heavy stroke of interference in the elections.

You packed a lot into this one sentence.

Please share your evidence.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by NestedLoopGoBrr on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:48PM (#25769673)
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by xpe on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:02PM (#25769813)
The NY Post's credibility is in question on this matter, specifically. (Also, more generally.) Can you please point to another credible source?
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by NestedLoopGoBrr on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:42PM (#25770185)
That wasn’t what was in question, it was whether or not Twitter censored them, which they did. See the sibling comment to your post here for additional info from Twitter even on the topic. Even though they reversed the censorship, they _did_ do it.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by throw0101a on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:10PM (#25769886)
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by NestedLoopGoBrr on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:43PM (#25770195)
That doesn’t make what they did okay — if anything it shows exactly how much power and influence they wielded in suppressing a news story at a critical point in informing people during an election cycle. That cannot be understated.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by paganel on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:31PM (#25769500)
> Republicans will get back to power sooner or later and I think we should expect a regulatory backlash.

It depends which type of Republicans, right now it looks like the party is de facto split in two. Even though today's vote showed that they still think the Trump side will win out in the medium to long term, otherwise I can't explain why they chose to face the media storm directly and voted against impeachment.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by ABeeSea on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:40PM (#25769584)
Rep Swalwell (member of intelligence and judiciary committees) said on msnbc today that several republicans lawmakers told him they would vote no because they feared for their and their family’s safety. The Republican Party is afraid that Trump’s base will murder republicans who turn against Trump.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by cm2187 on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:36PM (#25769541)
I think Trump has become radioactive, even within the republican party. They may not want to impeach (and I am not sure what is the point of impeaching a president after he left office) but I doubt a come back is on anyone’s mind at this stage. But Trump’s electorate will remain however.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by mullingitover on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:47PM (#25769655)
> I am not sure what is the point of impeaching a president after he left office

If a military officer commits a felony offense the week before they're discharged, I don't think the military would/should say "well you're so close to leaving, so we'll still give you an honorary discharge and a pension."

I feel like the same concept applies here, otherwise we're opening the door to the president being able to commit impeachable offenses with impunity as long as they're close to the finish line.

Also, not a lawyer, but I feel like conviction after impeachment would make conviction in subsequent civil suits a slam dunk.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by alasdair_ on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:23PM (#25770017)
>Also, not a lawyer, but I feel like conviction after impeachment would make conviction in subsequent civil suits a slam dunk.

I doubt it. Congress can impeach for almost anything - it doesn't have to be anything illegal - they just need to have enough votes for it.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by mullingitover on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @08:19PM (#25770495)
> Congress can impeach for almost anything - it doesn't have to be anything illegal - they just need to have enough votes for it.

I know this part is true. However, and again I'm not a lawyer, but I think inciting an insurrection is actually illegal?

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @08:28PM (#25770572)
> However, and again I’m not a lawyer, but I think inciting an insurrection is actually illegal?

It is, but even if they use the name of a crime or tort, Congress isn’t bound to apply the same definitions or rules of evidence as a court of law, and the decisions of the Senate in an impeachment trial can’t be entered as evidence of the facts found by the Senate in a civil case the way a criminal conviction can.

So, while the trial (regardless of outcome) may generate a potential trove of free-for-others-to-use evidence, I don’t think a Senate conviction (or acquittal, for that matter) has much direct bearing on future civil litigation.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:48PM (#25770235)
> Also, not a lawyer, but I feel like conviction after impeachment would make conviction in subsequent civil suits a slam dunk.

No, unlike a criminal conviction, I don’t think it would.

OTOH, any evidence gathered and publicly presented against Trump in the impeachment trial could be a valuable gift to those with substantially-related civil claims.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by jfim on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:43PM (#25769615)
> I am not sure what is the point of impeaching a president after he left office

Impeachment may prevent him from running again: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-trump-impeachment-exp...

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by alasdair_ on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:22PM (#25770003)
>I am not sure what is the point of impeaching a president after he left office

Doing so bans the person from holding federal office forever. In other words he couldn't run again in 2024.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by dragonwriter on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:47PM (#25784762)
> Doing so bans the person from holding federal office forever.

Not inherently, but presumably (as it is the only remedy left, and apparently requires only a majority vote after conviction) the Senate would adopt the forward ban allowed by the Constitution if it convicted.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by masonic on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:44PM (#25784737)
Alcee Hastings was impeached, convicted, and yet became a Congressman quickly after.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @08:10PM (#25770416)
> They may not want to impeach (and I am not sure what is the point of impeaching a president after he left office)

Trump has already been impeached the second time (it didn’t happen after he left office.)

Conviction after he left office would be limited to a lifetime bar on future office (assuming it is legal at all, but I suspect that were it challenged it would be found to be), but the main purpose would arguably not be the actual disability to Trump, but drawing a line of accountability for Presidents in general. (Politically, it would also be an opportunity for some Republicans to concretely distance themselves from Trump, which they may see as beneficial for future elections.)

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by amanaplanacanal on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:40AM (#25776130)
He could potentially also lose his pension. Given how strapped he is right now, this could be quite painful for him.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:53PM (#25770281)
> Even though today’s vote showed that they still think the Trump side will win out in the medium to long term, otherwise I can’t explain why they chose to face the media storm directly and voted against impeachment.

Personal fear of the people whose affection for Trump led them to erect a gallows and storm the Capitol with weapons, restraints, etc., screaming “Hang Mike Pence!” when Pence merely wouldn’t steal an election for him could also be a factor.

While I think it would be cowardly to withhold action on that basis, I don’t think anyone in their position could fail to have significant fear that betraying the GOP base by supporting impeachment would be painting a giant target on themselves for violent domestic extremists who are often more even more hostile to betrayal from “their side” than they are to the other side (to whom they are plenty hostile to start with.)

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by rayiner on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:45PM (#25769643)
It doesn’t matter who wins, they’re united on that point. They’ve seen the power of the platforms to filter the information people get and the willingness of the folks who control it to put a thumb on the scale in favor of Democrats.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by tptacek on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @11:10PM (#25771871)
No. Conservative thought absolutely rofltstomps on Facebook and is all over Twitter, which was, until a few days ago and by his own choice Trump's most important media venue. Conservative thought is so prevalent on Youtube that people post videos of the insane PragerU stuff their 8 year olds get recommended after watching a video or two.

There's really only two things that have reliably gotten people booted from any of these platforms:

* Appeals to violence

* Overt KKK-grade bigotry

I've been watching the "alternative" platforms for the last couple years. It got boring last year when it was looking increasingly like one of the major two, the one accurately described as "one of the less popular Mastodon instances", was simply going to fold --- the bot posts were outnumbering the real ones. That's because all the conservatives were on Twitter and Facebook, and they still are.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by lawnchair_larry on Saturday January 16, 2021 @09:31PM (#25807519)
This kind of comment suggests that you are completely devoid of conservative perspective. When people respond to complaints of biased moderation by saying that social media is full of conservatives, they haven't heard the complaint. The fact that you call PragerU "insane" seems to further support that.

Even though I find that it's rare for folks on the left to understand what's happening on the right, I'm surprised that even you are so misinformed about what gets people booted. Appeals to violence and "KKK-grade bigotry" are not what these complaints are about, and don't even approach the correct universe in describing the types of folks getting moderated (although hate speech should be allowed IMO). Not only that, but twitter is chock full of appeals to violence, which, as long as it's directed at conservatives, has remarkable staying power compared to anything directed elsewhere.

It's worth watching some of the opposing folks that you've been taught to hate once in a while, even if just to keep abreast of the concerns being discussed. Otherwise, all you get are the distorted caricatures of the fringes.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by ghaff on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:30PM (#25769494)
One can simultaneously roll their eyes about slippery slopes, argue that this is simply banning obvious illegal activities, etc.--and be at least a little bit discomfited that a bunch of private companies can basically disappear someone from public discourse if they want to.

Mind you. Historically most people didn't have access to a platform anyway. And the record from at least some players like AWS is that their ban bar is pretty high. But it certainly suggests that big tech can decide to cut off some slices of discourse if they feel it's convenient.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by TheOtherHobbes on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:48PM (#25769670)
Private companies have been disappearing small business owners for two decades. PayPal locks your account. YouTube decides to kill your channel for copyright strikes to content you created. Amazon does - all the shady things Amazon is famous for. Apple kills your app because reasons.

And so on.

This is not about disappearing people. Or businesses. This is about disappearing politicians.

The real game here is that the mainstream media - especially on the far right - have suddenly discovered they're no longer owners of the narrative space, and their game tokens can be removed without notice.

Of course they're unhappy about this.

So if we're going to talk about concentrated media influence, we should be questioning the international reach and centralised narrative control of the Fox network (and others) at least as much Twitter or Amazon's ability to ban someone who was literally planning an insurrection in the US.

There is no free speech issue here, because the kind of "free" political speech we're talking about is very, very expensive, and only available to a tiny selection of headline operators.

Everything else in the social media space is noise farmed for engagement, and is unlikely to unduly trouble anyone who matters.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by xpe on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:56PM (#25769738)
> So if we're going to talk about concentrated media influence, we should be questioning the international reach and centralised narrative control of the Fox network (and others) at least as much Twitter or Amazon ...

Yes, we cannot ignore the system effects of shared ownership and control. Many economists understand the concept of market power [1]. I'm not so sure that laws and cases around regulating speech have adequately explored the analogous ideas.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_power

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by xpe on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:57PM (#25769751)
> There is no free speech issue here, because the kind of "free" political speech we're talking about is very, very expensive, and only available to a tiny selection of headline operators.

I'm not following. Could you say it in a different way or perhaps with more words?

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by Chris2048 on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:33PM (#25770105)
> the mainstream media - especially on the far right

What far-right mainstream media? In any case, why should any media own the narrative?

Your decision that Trump "Plan[ned] an insurrection" isn't well supported - He's accused of inciting a crowd. But why couldn't any similar narrative escalate (or be escalated) when all narrative are monopolised by left-associated media?

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by imgabe on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:53PM (#25769718)
Most people didn't use to have a platform like Twitter where you could instantaneously reach the whole world, no. But the argument was always "If you don't like it just build your own thing". So, sure, maybe the NYTimes didn't have to publish you, but you could go buy a mimeograph or a printing press and put out your own newsletter, even if you had to stand on the street corner and hand it out yourself.

But now the companies that make printing presses won't sell to you. The machine shops that make the parts to build printing presses also won't work with you. Maybe you're supposed to mine your own ore and refine your own metal to build your own printing press?

In the long run, we're going to have to find a better way to deal with odious speech that by simply cutting people off and shutting them completely out of the public sphere. For one thing, this requires us to trust that the gatekeepers who control access are always going to be fair and just and only shut out genuinely bad actors. There's needs to be a process where anyone who wants to can still see and inspect the banned speech to audit whether it was really worth banning or not.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by ccortes on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:57PM (#25770313)
>For one thing, this requires us to trust that the gatekeepers who control access are always going to be fair and just and only shut out genuinely bad actors. There's needs to be a process where anyone who wants to can still see and inspect the banned speech to audit whether it was really worth banning or not.

How is this different from what we have today? Who decides what's really worth banning? Why should that person/entity and not another one?

There's no end to this, there's always going to be a something that is just completely arbitrary. IMO the only "solution" is to have a truly decentralized platform.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by XorNot on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:09PM (#25769879)
This is all still a special pleading that people are entitled to an audience of millions, rather then what they actually have a right to which is speech in public spaces protected from censure by the government. Not from private individuals.

I'm more then happy for us to decide that some parts of the internet should be public spaces, paid for out of general revenue and provided for the common good by the government. Internet access should be a basic human right.

But frankly, once you have IP-packet routing functionality, that's as much as I think you should be offered. No one else has any obligation to associate with you.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by Grustaf on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:36PM (#25769544)
Well, people didn’t use to have a lot of things, it’s still a big problem if you ban certain people from a platform but not others. Those that are allowed gain a huge advantage.

It’s especially problematic if these de facto monopolies take sides in elections.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by throwawayboise on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:58PM (#25769761)
There's a name for a economic structure where corporations are privately owned, but operate in alignment with the governments political agenda and goals. Perhaps out of coercion, or perhaps just trying to avoid scrutiny.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by Dracophoenix on Thursday January 14, 2021 @02:09PM (#25780747)
Corporatism?
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by jimmygrapes on Friday January 15, 2021 @11:38PM (#25800092)
Italian Fascism.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by Dracophoenix on Friday January 22, 2021 @01:37AM (#25869050)
Which has its roots in Italian/Catholic Corporatism.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by bobmaxup on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:47PM (#25769653)
How is it any different than if I was banned from HN or an IRC channel?

These "platforms" are just large message boards.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by xpe on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:51PM (#25769691)
Both AWS and payment processors are substantially different from message boards.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by koolk3ychain on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:56PM (#25769741)
Cannot agree more, what Obama started in regards to politically weaponizing payment processors (both VISA and companies that interact directly with their networks) against certain industries and individuals in the wake of Sandy Hook is legitimately concerning. AWS creating DNS and routing features is equally concerning, personally I don't want to live in a world where platforms start to build, control and ultimately monopolize the infrastructure they rely on to exist.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by squidlogic on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:58PM (#25769772)
Don't you think that's a little reductionistic?
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by Grustaf on Thursday January 14, 2021 @03:07PM (#25781754)
Few people on HN have 89 million followers.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by kiwidrew on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:56PM (#25769735)
Is "the Internet" really a platform, though?

I see it as more like the telephone: customers that want to receive calls (i.e. TCP connections) sign up for the service and receive a number (i.e. an IP address) that others can then use to contact them. And some of these customers choose to have their number published in a public directory of subscribers (i.e. DNS) to make it more convenient for others to find them.

At the most fundamental level, the Internet is nothing more than a vast and automated network for establishing point-to-point (i.e. private) calls between two parties.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by potta_coffee on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:40PM (#25769587)
Platforms are like nuclear weapons. Nobody had them before, now the countries that have them are more powerful than everybody else. I think the analogy admittedly falls apart if you carry it too far.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by ahurmazda on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:42PM (#25769608)
Couldn’t one argue that we have had a (gnarly) A/B test in the past few years— Twitter, FB mostly let different groups use the platform as the latter see fit. End result is (mind you not theoretical): erosion of civil discourse, platforms being used to organize illegal activities, proliferation of misinformation (during a pandemic) etc. We are kinda beyond what we could happen if company X did not allow Y to begin with. It has already happened.

I am more worried about where are we heading as a society? Why the heck is a regular joe (me) lying awake at night about armed unrest in the most powerful country in the world. Just beyond depressing.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by LudwigNagasena on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:54PM (#25769723)
> erosion of civil discourse

What erosion of civil discourse are you talking about? 10 years ago half or more Americans were against gay marriage, today 30% of the US is against that, except nowadays they are also called neonazis and are being deplatformed from major platforms. Do you think 50 years ago there could be civil discourse on legalizing rape or celebrating Holocaust? No, these people would get the same treatment. Or, as a non-imaginary example, just remember McCarthyism.

What changed is the level of discrepancy of Overton windows between rural and urban America. That’s all.

> platforms being used to organize illegal activities

Hah, but when they are used to organize illegal activities in countries like Egypt or Belarus it was not an issue.

> proliferation of misinformation (during a pandemic)

If you think that an average citizen is too stupid to think for themselves, we might as well just abolish voting rights. And surely there is a better way to combat misinformation than giving censorship powers to private technocrats.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by ahurmazda on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:14PM (#25769926)
>If you think that an average citizen is too stupid to think for themselves, ...

I sincerely have no such intent. Apologies if it came out that way.

>> erosion of civil discourse

Maybe my naivete but it seems that online discussions are much less nuanced compared to face to face discussions we had when growing up. Sure I disagreed with relatives but it certainly feels a lot more intense now a days (quite possible that its just the nature of the medium).

>>level of discrepancy of Overton windows between rural and urban America

Do you have any recommendation on how to lessen this gap? I live in a major metropolis. But I keep getting a feeling that such a widening chasm can not be good for the society.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by LudwigNagasena on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @08:50PM (#25770775)
> Maybe my naivete but it seems that online discussions are much less nuanced compared to face to face discussions we had when growing up.

How often did you talk with complete strangers about politics when you were growing up? Are you now having more intense discussion with your relatives? Do you think it is can be attributed to Facebook?

> Do you have any recommendation on how to lessen this gap? I live in a major metropolis. But I keep getting a feeling that such a widening chasm can not be good for the society.

Uniform education with officially supported views on main topics will bridge the gap and, also anti free speech laws. Neither European countries nor China have such divergence of opinions. All of them police speech and ban certain viewpoints. Of course people from different stratas of society will always have different opinions: small business owners, industrial workers, intelligentsia, government workers, non-working people all have different interests. But common national viewpoints keep the fabric of society intact.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by amanaplanacanal on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:46AM (#25776169)
I would rather internet platforms censor only on their own platform than have the government censor all of us.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by sliken on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:58PM (#25769763)
Dunno, they claim it's technology and demoncracy. Seems more like inciting people to break the law and kill people.

Does it really matter if it was twitter, facebook, a new paper, a radio station, a tv station, or really anything that can communicate.

If it was 100 years ago and the same events happened (invasion of the Capitol building and 5 people died) because of an op-ed piece in the NYTimes (printed on paper of course) would cause the same "deplatforming".

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:26PM (#25769466)
I completely agree with you regarding Signal. The main knock against Parker, at least at the beginning, was that it was used to plan violence, and that is too dangerous and public safety trumps “free speech”.

I can foresee a lot of the people who were on Parker before going to signal. I am sure there is close to a 100% chance that there will be messages advocating violence like death threats on there. Some enterprising investigative journalist will gain access to a private group and publish screenshots with vile threats. Of course, Signal is unable to do any moderation, and the calls will come for it to be de-platforms as well. Their hosting cut, their domain registration removed, their GitHub account locked, etc.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by rdiddly on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:31PM (#25770093)
I found it a bit rambly and got annoyed at the "wow these are tough questions no one can ever answer" sentiment. Glenn Greenwald a.k.a. "the guy who helped Snowden get the word out" and could be described as a disillusioned liberal, seems to have clearer principles and hence wrote a clearer article: https://greenwald.substack.com/p/how-silicon-valley-in-a-sho... One of the takeaways that nobody's really talking about is that Parler itself didn't really deserve this. If a bunch of Nazis walk over and stand near me, am I suddenly a Nazi? It's guilt by association, and if we're going with that... if we're going to, in the secret little court in each of our minds, "hold Parler liable for its moderation decisions" despite the fact that Section 230 won't allow that in a real court, then every outlet that has given Trump a voice for the past 4-5 years is just as guilty, starting with network news shows in 2016 putting his phone calls "from the campaign trail" on the air, knowing his wisecracks would draw more viewers. The profit motive accounts for 4 years of your never being able to escape Trump. And I believe the change of administrations (i.e. kissing up to the new one), not the Capitol thing, accounts for the sudden and belated change of heart. It's not Hanlon's razor but yeah never assume "ideology" as an explanation where "greed" will suffice.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:44PM (#25770198)
> Glenn Greenwald a.k.a. “the guy who helped Snowden get the word out” and could be described as a disillusioned liberal,

Greenwald might be a disillusioned Leftist (not liberal), but then, so the original neoconservatives were disillusioned Trotskyites.

Disillusionment is what spawns radical conversion and radical converts are often the least-open-minded, most most fact-averse, ideological crusaders.

> if we’re going to, in the secret little court in each of our minds, “hold Parler liable for its moderation decisions” despite the fact that Section 230 won’t allow that in a real court,

Other than civil liability of the types which are specifically dependent on status as a “publisher or speaker”, Section 230 doesn’t prevent them from being held liable.

Criminal liability, or civil liability not dependent on status as a publisher (though some courts have, controversially, extended Section 230 to liability as a “distributor”) is generally outside of the scope of Section 230 protection.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by rdiddly on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @08:07PM (#25770393)
Just as often, the disillusioned are perfectly open-minded. Especially in cases where the dissent from former colleagues centers around the very issue of open-mindedness, as it does with Greenwald. In general and in this case it behooves us to ask what caused the disillusionment. Sometimes the people on your side betray the principles you thought you all had in common, for example. Which is what happened with Greenwald's former colleagues at The Intercept (which ironically he founded) and I would say is happening with the Democratic party in big ways, ever since Bill Clinton's time. When the "left" started cozying up to big money and selling out poor working people, it ceased being on the "left," and you could have predicted today's political climate and events without much effort.

You're right about the scope of section 230, and given that Parler is not considered a publisher or speaker (which I think is appropriate), there is currently nothing else to consider holding them liable for, so I was using shorthand. I'm actually mostly talking about each person's individual opinion. Personally "holding them liable" for anything at this point depends on a guilt-by-association argument.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @08:17PM (#25770483)
> You’re right about the scope of section 230, and given that Parler is not considered a publisher or speaker (which I think is appropriate), there is currently nothing else to consider holding them liable for,

Generally, relieving them of being found to be the “publisher or speaker” of content they distribute would leave them as a distributor, having civil liability for content where they have actual (or constructive) knowledge of unlawful content that they distribute, rather than liability independent of their knowledge of the content based on the presumption of control that goes with status as a publisher.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by darepublic on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:52PM (#25769711)
Eventually the browser itself might be held accountable. How dare chrome display child's pornography or allowing users to send http requests filled with hate. Chrome should be able to filter that stuff out
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by Viliam1234 on Friday January 15, 2021 @02:23PM (#25795076)
When that day comes, Google will fix this problem in Chrome with artificial intelligence, and logging everything on their servers.

But the free browsers will be gone.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by fortran77 on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:16PM (#25769364)
The best sources of news seem to be the ones I pay for: New Yorker, New York Times, Wall Street Journal, Washington Post
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by Animats on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:32PM (#25769504)
They have actual reporters. The number of US news sources with a sizable reporting staff is rather small.

Weirdly, Fox News recently exited primetime news. Their 7 PM news hour is being replaced with another opinion show.[1] This was before the riot; it was a decision based on ratings. It's a concern in that it disconnects a sizable fraction of the US population from any source of information about real-world events. Fox will still have a hard news show, but at 3 PM.

[1] https://keyt.com/news/money-and-business/2021/01/11/fox-news...

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by flyinglizard on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:40PM (#25769580)
Do these newspapers provide thought provoking articles, or just fuel confirmation bias for their readers? I was a subscriber of NYT for a few years, and the one time there was a dissenting opinion - that of Tom Cotton - it led to editors being fired. WSJ seems better, maybe because business reporting tends to be somewhat less opinionated.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by bmarquez on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:51PM (#25769695)
> thought provoking articles, or just fuel confirmation bias for their readers?

I'd argue that NYT has fallen into the latter, with dissenting voices stifled internally, example Bari Weiss:

https://www.poynter.org/newsletters/2020/breaking-down-the-c...

https://www.washingtonpost.com/media/2020/07/14/bari-weiss-r...

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by fortran77 on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:59PM (#25769787)
Agreed. And it was disgusting what they did to her.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by dragonwriter on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:59PM (#25769783)
> I was a subscriber of NYT for a few years, and the one time there was a dissenting opinion - that of Tom Cotton - it led to editors being fired.

If that was the “one time there was a dissenting opinion” in the NY Times, what do you call Ross Douthat’s and Brett Stephen’s columns about that incident that the NY Times also ran?

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by tedunangst on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:48PM (#25769666)
Pretty sure NY Times has published more than one dissenting opinion over the years.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by theplague42 on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:50PM (#25769686)
Was the editor fired because of a "dissenting opinion" or because Cotton was effectively calling for martial law against protestors?

The NYTimes op-ed section has plenty of dissenting opinions and/or conservatives... just not ones calling for violence.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by flyinglizard on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:56PM (#25769744)
There was absolutely nothing outrageous in Cotton's op-ed. Mind, the same National Guard that Cotton was calling for was now sent to the Capitol, and I don't think NYT was up in arms.

That aside, he's a public representative of the highest order (a Senator). He needs to be heard whether we like it or not. I've not seen any public representative being censored in the country I'm from, that including opinion pieces from extremist parliament members on both sides. This is clearly a US thing.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by d1zzy on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:32PM (#25770103)
> That aside, he's a public representative of the highest order (a Senator). He needs to be heard whether we like it or not.

And to achieve that you're going to force businesses to host content that hurts their bottom line (the loss of income from the advertisers that will pull out from working with a company that hosts such content).

> This is clearly a US thing.

In the country where you live all news organizations are forced to publish everything a politician says?

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by flyinglizard on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @08:07PM (#25770396)
>> And to achieve that you're going to force businesses to host content that hurts their bottom line (the loss of income from the advertisers that will pull out from working with a company that hosts such content).

NYT makes more money from subscriptions than from ads (60% vs 30%), and as a (formerly) paying subscriber I'd like to think it lends them some independence. That aside, many other news sources would find Sen. Cotton's opinions pretty mainstream (certainly these opinions may have even had majority across the general public) and publish such views just fine, without advertisers pulling out.

>> In the country where you live all news organizations are forced to publish everything a politician says?

Of course not. They publish on their own accord, and extremists get an outsized exposure because they are interesting to read (just like click baits, right?). It's how I'd have expected most news organizations to work, you know: reporting on the unusual and unexpected. For me, NYT stopped being a news organization the moment it decided some opinions are forbidden from being published: not because they are fringe (a significant part of the American public agreed with Cotton), not because they come from fringe sources (he's a Senator after all), but because they are contrarian.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by rhino369 on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:29PM (#25770075)
>Was the editor fired because of a "dissenting opinion" or because Cotton was effectively calling for martial law against protestors?

Cotton was just 7 months too early.

Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by Chris2048 on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:49PM (#25770246)
"martial law against protestors" suggests violence against protest. What was actually suggested:

  an overwhelming show of force to disperse, detain and ultimately deter lawbreakers
If lawbreaker = protestors in your book, then maybe we differ in what constitutes valid protest.

Also, Cotton pre-emptively disagrees with your characterisation also:

  This [law] doesn’t amount to “martial law” or the end of democracy, as some excitable critics, ignorant of both the law and our history, have comically suggested
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by amanaplanacanal on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:51AM (#25776215)
I thought that’s what local police were already doing? An overwhelming show of force against peaceful protesters in an attempt to deter lawbreakers.
Re:The platforms have acted, raising hard questions about te... by pseudalopex on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:01PM (#25769808)
Comments about witch burning don't help sow discussion.