News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by Tarsul on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:16PM (#25738215)
and here we are arguing of the slippery road of pulling down posts because it's against freedom of speech. As if the risk to democracy and its people is not higher due to letting all this happen. If the republicans do not come around in the next few years, I fear for America.
Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by aksss on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:41PM (#25738672)
Freedom of speech != B&E, looting, vandalizing, threatening physical violence.

Freedom of speech protects the expression of beliefs and ideas, and there is a legal line between that and inciting riot.

Punish when the line is crossed, but protect the expression of ideas and beliefs up to that line.

Risk intolerance is behind the fear of letting people close to the line, but that's where we talk about slippery slopes - your risk tolerance is not the same as others, and if you start moving the bar down it happens for everybody (even the most righteous causes) not just the people you hate today.

> if {party people} do not come around in next few years, I fear for America

It's interesting that I've heard that in years past but from my friends on the right talking about Democrats and violent protests. I'm not justifying the actions in the Capitol (I condemn them frequently), but listening to people aligned with either part I do find it interesting that this feels like a [downward] spiral. The question is how to break out of it and reset.

Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by res0nat0r on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:55PM (#25738954)
The issue is the storming of the capitol last week is directly related to online disinformation, propaganda and the lack of removal of violent and lying rhetoric, and finally thanks to some real world violence the online companies are starting to crack down just out of fear of culpability and likely eventual regulation.

> It's interesting that I've heard that in years past but from my friends on the right talking about Democrats and violent protests.

The issue with this is one is rooted in reality and one is not. The biggest danger to US citizens right now is due to right wing violence, not left wing.

https://www.businessinsider.com/right-wing-extremists-kill-3...

Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by FFRefresh on Monday January 11, 2021 @09:27PM (#25741477)
> The biggest danger to US citizens right now is due to right wing violence, not left wing.

False dichotomy. You are hyper-focused on the american partisan culture war, that you've lost sight of the bigger picture. I'm guessing you consume a lot of content from the news & entertainment companies, as they do tend to convey this as well.

Let's take your 'right-wing extremists have killed 117 people since 2010' point that was presented in the article. Where does that 117 rank in terms of causes of death since 2010?

Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by MrMan on Monday January 11, 2021 @06:17PM (#25739423)
Next few days maybe
Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by downandout on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:50PM (#25738843)
If the republicans do not come around in the next few years, I fear for America.

What exactly do you mean by “do not come around”. Come around to what? That suppression of free speech is a good thing? I’m an independent, and I think Trump has a serious amount of responsibility for what happened here. But the suppression of free speech offends me on every level, regardless of who the target of the suppression is. We either have free speech or we don’t.

Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by polemic on Monday January 11, 2021 @06:23PM (#25739525)
> We either have free speech or we don’t.

Perhaps one of the best things Americans could do is throw away demonstrably false dichotomies like this. You have defamation laws, you have copyright & IP law, contract law etc.

Freedom of expression is a right that is balanced against other types of rights and freedoms. No doubt the USA puts more weight on freedom of expression over other rights, but it's by no means the only setting that confers a functioning democracy.

It's entirely valid to discuss where the balance should sit. Indeed it's the _only_ way to discuss it rationally.

Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by refurb on Monday January 11, 2021 @08:17PM (#25740999)
No, America has consistently valued free speech is all but the most limited circumstances.

Now isn’t the time to say “well that didn’t work” and roll back a right that is pretty core to the country itself.

Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by tjr225 on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @01:02PM (#25750693)
You've never had the right to do whatever you want on someone else's private property.
Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by brown9-2 on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:56PM (#25738982)
Republicans need to come around on topics like admitting who won the election, ceasing to lie to their voters about it, and asking themselves why such a large part of their voting base and media ecosystem is based around spreading or believing in obvious bullshit like QAnon.
Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by objectivetruth on Monday January 11, 2021 @06:06PM (#25739223)
> Come around to what?

When polls show nearly half of Republicans support the Capitol Insurgents, there are LOTS of things that Republicans need to come around to.

Come "back" around to the belief that the court is the final arbiter of disputes in our country, NOT whoever sends the most maniacs in a frenzied mob.

Come around to the belief that yes, they did in fact lose the 2020 presidential election fairly, as stated by every state and county election official, including the GOP's.

Come around to the belief that the US "peaceful transition of power" during presidential elections was in fact a good thing, not a centuries-old tradition to be thrown away in a futile attempt to install a game show host as dictator-for-life.

Source: https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2021/01/07/nearly-h...

Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by vorpalhex on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:28PM (#25738445)
Democracy requires freedom of speech, and to abridge that freedom is to destroy Democracy.

A building does not a government make. Whatever people harmed, windows broken, our government is not any worse off functionally than it was the day before. Yet this will be used to pass harmful laws, and like 9/11 it will do infinitely more damage to Democracy than whatever the original attackers did.

Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by ismaildonmez on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:33PM (#25738529)
For God’s sake, they were chanting “Hang Mike Pence”, make no mistake this could have been way worse if it wasn’t for the Secret Service and some brave police officer who mislead the mob away from Senate.
Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by malcolmgreaves on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:30PM (#25738494)
Your post reads as if it's downplaying the significance of Wednesday's failed coup attempt, and the incredible ramifications of it.
Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by vorpalhex on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:37PM (#25738602)
Did we lose the Senate? What about the house? Do we have an enemy force occupying our capital? Are our nation's leaders kidnapped? Are there insurgents fighting in the streets?

All three branches of the government are whole (and save the executive, functioning, but the executive wasn't functioning before the coup either) and business is moving on. That doesn't mean we shouldn't respond with physical security, press charges appropriately or react - but calling it a coup attempt is something that not even the NYTimes supports: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/07/world/americas/what-is-a-...

Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by dragonwriter on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:40PM (#25738649)
> Did we lose the Senate? What about the house? Do we have an enemy force occupying our capital? Are our nation’s leaders kidnapped? Are there insurgents fighting in the streets?

I see you understood the word “coup” but the “failed…attempt” surrounding that word.

Attempted murder doesn’t stop being a serious offense because no one died, and attempted coup doesn’t become a minor event because only a handful of people died and the attempt to improperly seize power by force failed.

Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by miguelmota on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:40PM (#25738654)
A successful coup or a failed coup, is still a coup. We can argue semantics but based on what happened it's clear this was a poorly executed attempt to undermine the government and seize political officials.
Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by desertrider12 on Monday January 11, 2021 @09:29PM (#25741485)
We didn't lose any branches of government, but the proceedings of the legislature were disrupted for most of a day. I'm sure if they had been working on an emergency thing and not a formality that it could be continued in a bunker but it still feels like a huge deal to me. Maybe it's mostly symbolic, idk.

I agree though, it doesn't seem like a coup since they got in and then had no plan for what to do once there. It was just unfocused anger.

Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by ordinaryradical on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:33PM (#25738532)
It is downplaying. What happened was unprecedented political violence and the only reason to make an argument like the parent is because you cannot admit it deserves a serious, judicial response.
Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by cgriswald on Monday January 11, 2021 @06:26PM (#25739579)
> What happened was unprecedented political violence...

Well, there were the little matters of the American Revolutionary War and the American Civil War. And a few others of varying scope in this incomplete list:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_rebellions_in_the_Unit...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newburgh_Conspiracy

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Business_Plot

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brooks%E2%80%93Baxter_War

(This isn't to disagree with you; or to downplay the seriousness or support the events of the sixth.)

Edit: List formatting

Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by joshgel on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:39PM (#25738637)
Do all Western democracies guarantee Freedom of Speech like in the US? I seem to remember reading this is actually a US-centric view that isn’t universally shared. Eg nazi slogans in present day Germany.

Do we actually need to guarantee universal Freedom of Speech to have a democracy?

Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by staticman2 on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:55PM (#25738958)
All Democracy's, including the United States, have limits on freedom of speech. Try publishing Harry Potter fanfiction in book stores in America and see what the court system does to you. Try showing female nipples on network television and see what the legal system does to you. Try sticking the Apple logo on your product without Apple's permission and see what the court system does to you.

Free speech= democracy isn't a very nuanced view.

Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by refurb on Monday January 11, 2021 @08:19PM (#25741015)
The US does value freedom of speech greater than pretty much every other country on the planet.

Just because it’s not absolute doesn’t mean it’s not true.

Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by koonsolo on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @02:14AM (#25743435)
> Try showing female nipples on network television

I think this is the US specific part :p.

The rest I all agree with

Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by aksss on Monday January 11, 2021 @06:04PM (#25739176)
England has been pretty notoriously abridging the "right to offend" for years now. And as you point out, there's Germany.

> Do we actually need [FoS]?

It probably depends on how much you trust the government to be "self-regulated" in prioritizing the liberty of the people over time. Democracy is not the natural state of things by any means.

Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by cturner on Monday January 11, 2021 @06:18PM (#25739445)
Rights and democracy are in conflict.

In a real democracy, the majority could decide to lock you up simply because they didn't like you.

In a rights-driven system, everything is ultimately decided by the courts, which are run by elites.

Confusingly, Bill-of-Rights "Freedom is Speech" is really a right rather than a freedom. You can brazenly violate the live-and-let-live principle and still be safe.

    Do we actually need to guarantee universal Freedom of Speech to have a democracy?
My view, no. If anything the Bill of Rights is the source of the rift that is pulling US democracy apart. Through the bill of rights, the judiciary became an unelected and unwieldy legislative body. US politics has been distilled into a vicious contest about who gets to make Supreme Court appointments. No other country has this dynamic.
Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by nullsense on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:55PM (#25738953)
Mostly what you need is sensible people that value democracy. That's all that's really required. If you have that the rest tends to work itself out, if you don't have that then nothing else matters.
Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by iSnow on Monday January 11, 2021 @06:44PM (#25739897)
In Germany, it is contextualized. You can show a swastika flag in a film or anything remotely educational but not to promote Nazi ideology. So, no, there is no absolute FoS in Germany.

Whether Germany can be ranked as a democracy is debated: the extreme left and right believe it is a US protectorate, QAnon believes it is run by lizard people/Jews/Freemasons/5G chips... If you go by a freedom of press index, human development index, democracy index, it usually ranks below the Scandinavian countries but in a decent place.

The usual paradox of tolerance applies: if you don't censor some speech, you might be the one who will have zero free speech.

Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by majormajor on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:33PM (#25738537)
Democracy requires people to put a very high value on the preservation of democracy. It requires work, more than any abstract principles. Hiding behind those principles to excuse doing things that directly endanger democracy is shameful.
Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by triceratops on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:56PM (#25738976)
> A building does not a government make.

That sounds like something someone in an abusive relationship might say. "Yeah, he burned my wardrobe but I didn't like those clothes anyway". Please seek help.

Re:FBI warns of plans for nationwide armed protests next week by miguelmota on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:37PM (#25738617)
Speech that incites imminent lawless action is not protected speech, for good reason.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_free_speech_exce...