All three branches of the government are whole (and save the executive, functioning, but the executive wasn't functioning before the coup either) and business is moving on. That doesn't mean we shouldn't respond with physical security, press charges appropriately or react - but calling it a coup attempt is something that not even the NYTimes supports: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/07/world/americas/what-is-a-...
I see you understood the word “coup” but the “failed…attempt” surrounding that word.
Attempted murder doesn’t stop being a serious offense because no one died, and attempted coup doesn’t become a minor event because only a handful of people died and the attempt to improperly seize power by force failed.
I agree though, it doesn't seem like a coup since they got in and then had no plan for what to do once there. It was just unfocused anger.
Well, there were the little matters of the American Revolutionary War and the American Civil War. And a few others of varying scope in this incomplete list:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_rebellions_in_the_Unit...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newburgh_Conspiracy
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Business_Plot
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brooks%E2%80%93Baxter_War
(This isn't to disagree with you; or to downplay the seriousness or support the events of the sixth.)
Edit: List formatting
Do we actually need to guarantee universal Freedom of Speech to have a democracy?
Free speech= democracy isn't a very nuanced view.
Just because it’s not absolute doesn’t mean it’s not true.
I think this is the US specific part :p.
The rest I all agree with
> Do we actually need [FoS]?
It probably depends on how much you trust the government to be "self-regulated" in prioritizing the liberty of the people over time. Democracy is not the natural state of things by any means.
In a real democracy, the majority could decide to lock you up simply because they didn't like you.
In a rights-driven system, everything is ultimately decided by the courts, which are run by elites.
Confusingly, Bill-of-Rights "Freedom is Speech" is really a right rather than a freedom. You can brazenly violate the live-and-let-live principle and still be safe.
Do we actually need to guarantee universal Freedom of Speech to have a democracy?
My view, no. If anything the Bill of Rights is the source of the rift that is pulling US democracy apart. Through the bill of rights, the judiciary became an unelected and unwieldy legislative body. US politics has been distilled into a vicious contest about who gets to make Supreme Court appointments. No other country has this dynamic.Whether Germany can be ranked as a democracy is debated: the extreme left and right believe it is a US protectorate, QAnon believes it is run by lizard people/Jews/Freemasons/5G chips... If you go by a freedom of press index, human development index, democracy index, it usually ranks below the Scandinavian countries but in a decent place.
The usual paradox of tolerance applies: if you don't censor some speech, you might be the one who will have zero free speech.
That sounds like something someone in an abusive relationship might say. "Yeah, he burned my wardrobe but I didn't like those clothes anyway". Please seek help.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_free_speech_exce...
A building does not a government make. Whatever people harmed, windows broken, our government is not any worse off functionally than it was the day before. Yet this will be used to pass harmful laws, and like 9/11 it will do infinitely more damage to Democracy than whatever the original attackers did.