Glenn has done great work in the past for which he should be commended, but these days he's a contrarian in search of hot takes. It's just how the Twitter / Patreon journalist economy operates. He will throw a huge hissy fit about the mainstream media but then happily go on Fox News with Tucker.
But having said that, it's clear lately he puts politics / optics first and then dives into an issue.
https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/several-well-know...
> Tarrio does not appear to have been present during the insurrection.
> This is almost certainly false. For example, see the arrest of the leader of the Proud Boys (for events prior to Capitol, but played active role on Parler encouraging proud boys violence that day):
And this:
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/06/technology/capitol-twitte...:
> Those alternative social media sites were rife with Trump supporters organizing and communicating on Wednesday. On Parler, one trending hashtag was #stormthecapitol. Many Trump supporters on the sites also appeared to believe a false rumor that Antifa, a left-wing movement, was responsible for committing violence at the protests.
> “WAKE UP AMERICA, IT’S ANTIFA and BLM operatives who are committing the violence, NOT TRUMP SUPPORTERS!,” said one Parler account member called @Trumpfans100, offering no evidence for the claims.
Even though Greenwald is wrong, he's not totally wrong. I think he's correct that the "majority" of the planning happened on Facebook, but that was kind of a funnel to Parler. My understanding is that was mostly for seemingly legit stuff, event for protests, was done on Facebook. Those pages then linked to Parler, where more extreme planning took place, out-of-reach from Facebook's policies.
You seem to be talking about Enrique Tarrio, the latino leader of the "Proud Boys" who was arrested when he stepped off his plane, for the crime of burning a blm symbol in DC the month before.
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/proud-boys-leader-arres...
But you also seem to be trying to correlate that to this event. I don't know how they are related to Parler, can you explain?
Glenn Greenwald also chose to make the fake Giuliani/Hunter Biden laptop story the hill on which he wished to die upon, related to his resignation from the Intercept, so whatever credibility he had remaining has long since departed.
https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=greenwald...
The same kind of people now openly railing against GG are the same kind of people who will do everything they can to not acknowledge Ray McGovern because his professional and personal past make him a harder target on the topic. Of course, it wouldn't surprise me to see plenty of them try the same charater assasination on him, but it's an obvious marker of complete rejection of truth in favor of tribalisms.
Disgusting seeing so many turn on GG et al so quickly. Ya'll should be ashamed of yourselves.
He believed a story with little evidence and his journalistic integrity became questionable.
In his own words:
“I don’t think that the emails — so far — reveal a huge scandal. They so far just establish standard sleaze and DC corruption. The huge scandal to me is the blatant rank-closing and cone of silence — a prohibition — erected by journalists around this story to defend Biden,”
“Is there a single journalist willing to say with a straight face they believe the emails relating to the Bidens are either fabricated or otherwise fraudulently altered, but the Bidens just aren’t saying so?,”
“When you report a huge archive, there’s no way to prove the negative that none of it is altered. You investigate & confirm as much as you can, then use your journalistic judgment. The only way you get confirmation is when the subjects of the reporting don’t deny the authenticity,”
“You know the subjects of the reporting will immediately claim they’re fake if the are. Of course they will: that would kill the reporting!”
“There’s a reason the Bidens aren’t claiming they’re fake,”
He thought the laptop story was true and barked about it for days. He had no evidence to think it was true, it just was to him.
His substack work was after he humiliated himself on Twitter and is largely trying to justify how stupid he was.
Downvote all you want Biden lackies, it doesnt change the uncomfortable facts!
See now I know this is about political identity to you and not about the truth.
Your response here indicates you were never trying to have a conversation at all.
Projection at its most obvious.
> While I will intentionally not link to the New York Post, I want be clear that this story is eligible to be fact checked by Facebook's third-party fact checking partners. In the meantime, we are reducing its distribution on our platform.
https://twitter.com/andymstone/status/1316395902479872000?re...
What was fake about it?
AFAIK no factual claim has been refuted and some have been robustly proved (e.g. the gmail sent emails that have been published pass DKIM validation).
If you want to say the timing of it was a transparent attempt at political manipulation, I'd fully agree.
> So as I blogged before, the emails contained DKIM information, which the original reporters could and should have verified. So I eventually got a copy of the email and run DKIM verification on it. It passed:
https://twitter.com/erratarob/status/1322007153415200768
I think he's pretty active (and well-respected) on HN.
That is, I do agree with you and your technical analysis, but don't see the point of nitpicking his Twitter reporting. I think if you're on Twitter, you already know that you're not getting every little detail of a story.
You can also download all the uncensored photos on many leak websites. The photos are clearly Hunter Biden in many sexually explicit positions (although none of them appear to be underage as was suggested by some).
I think there is a prima fascia case against Hunter for his ties to Burisma and his appointment being purely for political clout and a power move; a move that should be investigated for possible direct security risks to the American government and the American people.
For a start, the silencing competitors argument doesn't really work with AWS because they just do hosting.
The complaint alleges there are deeper ties:
Less than a month ago, AWS announced with a press release a new multi-year deal with Twitter. AWS will “provide global cloud infrastructure to deliver Twitter timelines.” Twitter Selects AWS as Strategic Provider to Serve Timelines, Press Center, Amazon, (Dec. 15, 2020), https://press.aboutamazon.com/news-releases/news-release-det....
I should stress that some partisan democrats have also been just as wrong, but Greenwald is just making it up to downplay what did actually happen.
To anyone who hasn't, please go and read the Wiki article on it - it's very detailed and clears up a lot of frankly worrying narratives I see on this website that are frankly a little disappointing considering the average reader is usually quite fastidious with technology.
That could be true, I don't know, but Parler was certainly hosting some violent real-time threats: https://twitter.com/slpng_giants/status/1347190280492089344
This isn't hard. The majority of people arrested had Parler accounts -- it's everywhere.
I think a more interesting (and neutral) approach for Greenwald to take would be to show that all of these prominent figures were most likely active on ALL social media platforms, yet only Parler has been singled out.
I can't find evidence of this. Could you share your evidence?
Greenwald did significant research here and said he found no active users from those arrested:
Google “baked alaska parler”. It’s literally on the first page of results.
What Glenn is saying is technically true, but also complete garbage. It's meant to fool people who can't do the minimum levels of research.
https://www.insider.com/washington-dc-protest-livestream-bak...
Also what does it matter if Jan 6 was not planned on parler? Jan 17th and inauguration shenanigans were being planned there until the site got yanked.
https://www.dailydot.com/debug/man-who-died-capitol-riot-par...
[1] https://www.splcenter.org/hatewatch/2021/01/08/far-right-ins...
Do you want to bet on what percentage of them own Smart Phones? I would wager 100%.
At least 19 people died last summer. Don't downplay it.
MAGA bludgeoned a Capitol Police Officer to death. Last summer doesn’t compare.
You can state this opinion as fact but I think it is important to acknowledge that many people experienced the events of last summer in a way that makes it quite comparable to them.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/oct/23/texas-boogaloo...
Sympathy for white supremacy within law enforcement is its own thorny issue, but we certainly shouldn’t let it deter us from taking action against places we know domestic terrorists plan their attacks.
Conspiracy theories aside Parler wasn’t removed in relation to involvement with the capital invasion. They got booted off for poor moderation - repeatedly not being willing to do anything about illegal/hate content and the increase in number of complaints.
I don’t think Amazon or Apple (and to a lesser extent Google) can be viewed as competitors to Parler in any material way.
https://twitter.com/azforeman/status/1348648808390008832/pho...
If he didn't bother to look at a famous person like the "QAnon Shaman", why does the rest of this claim stand to scrutiny?
[1] https://greenwald.substack.com/p/the-threat-of-authoritarian...
The guy lost all credibility pushing that fake bullshit story so far he lost his job at his own news org.
https://nypost.com/2020/10/29/glenn-greenwald-quits-the-inte...
https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.cnn.com/cnn/2020/12/09/poli...
Update: replaced link with a more relevant one
The refusal to release the full messages with complete headers was a point of contention in the original reporting of this story. If enough information was released, to let the public inspect the messages and verify the DKIM signatures themselves, this is a new development that goes beyond what was originally reported and alleged.
Have the full messages been released to the public so this can be verified?
It's not a very new development, but most or all mention of it was removed on many platforms including on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24942678
That appears to be one single email with limited context. The README.md in that repo outright states that the context for the email is absent and does not necessarily provide concrete proof of any specific narrative:
> ... Remember that while the email is validated, the context isn't. It's possible this reflects a secret meeting to conspire with Vice President Biden. Or, it's possible the guy attended one of the many Washington D.C. social functions whereby people shake hands with politicians and exchange pleasantries. As Richelieu is claimed to have said "Give me six words by the most honest of men and I'll find something to hang him by". Give me an email dump from the most honest of persons, and I'll pull one out of context to hang them in the court of social media. ...
> ... I personally have many doubts about where this email came from, and the overall "narrative" they are trying to push. Regardless, I can validate the basic facts about this email.
Are there any more emails with full headers?
> Do you know how many of the people arrested in connection with the Capitol invasion were active users of Parler? Zero. The planning was largely done on Facebook. This is all a bullshit pretext for silencing competitors on ideological grounds: just the start.
> For those asking the basis for that last claim: I spent the weekend reporting on the removal of Parler from the internet, including reviewing lots of documents and interviewing people associated with the companies involved, including Parler.
> The article will be up shortly.
https://twitter.com/ggreenwald/status/1348619731734028293
I would be more interested in hearing if all these prominent figures in the Capitol protests were active across multiple (or all) social media platforms, which often seems to be the case. If that is true, then it makes for an even stronger argument that Parler has been singled out.