News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by antris on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:26PM (#25718579)
>BigTech has just now gone nuclear in their censorship efforts

Who's being censored? Twitter, Facebook etc. are private platforms and they've been banning users who break their TOS throughout their histories.

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by dang on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:40PM (#25720230)
This has been and is being discussed in so many HN threads right now that this is not a great place to re-rehearse the same flamewars. Let's not let the generic drown out the specific—that's the main thing that reduces intellectual curiosity on the site.

https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

(Yes, the GP comment started it by including flamebait, but it's not necessary to take the bait, and the guidelines ask everyone to resist that.)

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by antris on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:45PM (#25720287)
Yeah, fair enough. I'm just worried about these kinds of statements going unchallenged.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Illusory_truth_effect

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by mandelbrotwurst on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:36PM (#25718693)
Private entities can and do engage in censorship.
Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by WClayFerguson on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:39PM (#25718744)
The best analogy to help low-information people understand this is to just remind them that AT&T owns the hardware and can shut down people too. Do we want powerful companies to be allowed to censor Americans at their whim is the question. I say no.
Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by jazzyjackson on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:52PM (#25718889)
So lobby the government to break up AT&T so they don't have monopoly power... (oh wait)
Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by deanstag on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:50PM (#25718876)
Does that mean an alternative solution would allow inciting violence?
Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by antris on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:42PM (#25718773)
Sure, but the parent poster seems to imply that banning people who incite violence on social media is somehow a new thing or "going nuclear" with censorship.

Trump got clapped not because of censorship, but because social media platforms decided to no longer exempt him from their TOS because of his position. Any normal person posting similar content would have been banned ages ago. Besides, he is the POTUS who can go on TV any time he wants. Thinking that he cannot get his message out there is ridiculous.

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by WClayFerguson on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:19PM (#25719993)
Trump never called for any violence. However there are lots of left wing people on Twitter calling for violence and the left-wing operated BigTech think that's just fine, while they will ban any right wing person at the drop of a hat for completely made-up reasons like saying something wrong about gender pronouns. Look the Joe Rogan podcast with Tim Pool and Jack Dorsey, and try to educate yourself.
Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by antris on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:32PM (#25720151)
>Trump never called for any violence

Alright, so finally after a few seemingly innocuous arguments you took your mask off. A person who believes storming the Capitol was not organized by Trump at this point would be able to find a justification to anything he says or does.

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by WClayFerguson on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:54PM (#25720419)
This is an example of black-and-white logic, tribalism, and an inability to comprehend nuance. I can state any number of the 100s of lies and hoaxes told about Trump and the only thing Democrats can hear is a "praise" of Trump, rather than a statement of fact.
Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by blindgeek on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:22PM (#25720035)
Trump was also great advertising for Twitter, just like he was great for the news media. I'd argue that Big Media, Inc. is deeply complicit in the rise of Donald Trump. He was the goose that laid the golden egg. Additionally, the media mergers of the 80s and 90s gave us right-wing talk radio on the AM band, sewing the spores of hate from which the vile toadstool of Trumpism bloomed.

Big Tech, Inc., with its algorithms that promote radical right-wing content, also seems suspect.

To me the solution to all of these problems is to break up conglomerates and monopolies. Let's have more decentralization and more "small is beautiful" tech, like the chat system presented here. Let a million flowers blossom, smothering the aforementioned toadstool. (Wandering off to look at installing Cabal).

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by jb775 on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:40PM (#25718748)
If you broke the TOS of your water company, would it be acceptable for them to cut the water connection to your house?

I mean if you don't like it, you could always just go pick up your own water...or install underground pipes to a local water source.

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by fishtacos on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:50PM (#25718874)
What kind of analogy is that? Tweets vs. water?

Also, yes, you would not be provided water/electricity/cable/internet/pudding if you broke their terms of service. Apart from not paying your bill and perhaps willful destruction of their equipment, I'm having a hard time trying to come up with how else one breaks the terms of service for utility services. That sounds completely normal to me.

Additionally, people do go without certain utilities in times of economic hardship - this is nothing new. We're not guaranteed access any such services.

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by WClayFerguson on Sunday January 10, 2021 @05:01PM (#25720498)
Well if big companies get to just set arbitrary rules that discriminate against one set of political beliefs, what does that say about "Civil Rights" then? I guess you're not a big fan of civil rights...

Or, more likely, is it only when companies are doing things you agree with that you'll claim they have absolute power and authority? If you understand history, you might see the flaw in this logic.

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by fishtacos on Monday January 11, 2021 @09:09AM (#25729014)
These companies are not "discriminating" against any particular political view. Calls for political violence and extremism/terrorism have and continue to be moderated on these platforms from both sides.

It is unfortunate that you don't understand the distinction between inciting violence via either direct calls for such or indirectly by repeating the same unfounded lies of "a stolen election" VS political speech/civil rights, which have not been abrogated (there are plenty of conservative commentators on Twitter, some of whom I follow).

As for my background, I am an immigrant from a post-communist Eastern European country, live in the US in the South and finished with political science and journalism degrees. Can assure you my appreciation of civil rights is intact.

As a general rule, even when situations like this occur, I lean on the side of caution, so I understand the slippery slope argument you're making. There will continue to be a national discussion about what the limits are in the still-uncharted world of social media and the limits of expression vs. platform and publisher rights, but your alarmist view is, IMO, over the top.

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by WClayFerguson on Monday January 11, 2021 @03:14PM (#25735841)
Congress has held numerous hearings about censorship starting way back when the first nose-ring wearing, openly socialist, 20-something overlords in Silicon Valley started censoring heads of state, and government officials for clearly and blatantly partisan political reasons.

I mean after the election a poll showed 68% of voters had never even heard of the Hunter Laptop, because BigTech started banning anyone who dare even mention it. So don't be fooled that the censorship is to stop violence, it's to achieve political goals, and has been ratcheting up for the past 6 years. Twitter was canceling people for life even for daring to say such crazy things as "There's only two sexes."

Cancel culture has been getting out of hand for a long long time now, and people have had all they're going to take of it.

Now the left has gotten so brazen they're conspiring to shut down entire internet companies under these same false pretenses. And you have the audacity to call this "alarmist". Wow.

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by antris on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:45PM (#25718804)
Having your message broadcasted through Twitter is not a human right or essential to your survival. Also, what kind of TOS would a water company have that you can break? This example is ridiculous.
Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by WClayFerguson on Sunday January 10, 2021 @05:06PM (#25720554)
The obvious point is that both internet and water are public services, and the minute we let companies start cutting off services for political reasons we no longer have a democracy.
Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by jb775 on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:59PM (#25718978)
Sorry, but since the water company is privately owned they can do whatever they please. If you don't like it, you can build your own water company. Thanks!

...now you know how it feels for anyone on the opposite side of your argument.

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by fishtacos on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:27PM (#25719300)
Please post a link to the terms of service of your water company.

I'm doubtful there is no clause in your city's/county's/municipality's/state's, etc. that allows them to interrupt service without cause. That's why terms of service exist.

Now I'm genuinely curious to find out what terms of service you agreed to with the private water company. What type of settlement do you live in?

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by antris on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:13PM (#25719140)
Nah. The water infrastructure at my home isn't owned by a private company. I live in a state that has this radical policy that water is a human right and should not be commoditized.
Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by WClayFerguson on Sunday January 10, 2021 @05:11PM (#25720620)
On a related note: The Governor of California was cutting off electricity and water to homes for the crime of "peaceful assembly", recently... so it's not just free speech that's under assault, but probably you could say most rights, at this point.

The good ol' democrat mantra: "Never let a good crisis go to waste."

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by astura on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:45PM (#25720288)
What? I have municipal water.
Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by orf on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:48PM (#25718844)
I’m sure you can see how patently absurd comparing a provider of liquid essential to human life to... Twitter is.
Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by WClayFerguson on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:38PM (#25718724)
I started using the term "nuclear" once Amazon Cloud Services decided to terminate the Parler web server hosting.

If internet service providers can shut down speech they disagree with, by going after the servers, then we're no longer living in a democracy.

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by antris on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:51PM (#25718879)
>If internet service providers can shut down speech they disagree with, by going after the servers, then we're no longer living in a democracy.

You present this as if Parler is being shut down because people there have the wrong opinion on tax rates.

People on Parler are planning violent fascist overthrow of government, which is illegal. Why would Amazon be obligated to host sites that cater to terrorists?

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by WClayFerguson on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:08PM (#25719850)
The social media purge began long before Parler even existed. Yes people are getting banned from Twitter for life for having the wrong political opinions. It you deny that everyone knows you're either dishonest or uninformed.

People on the left are allowed to call for violence and say all kinds of racist things hate filled things, but if someone on the right even says something like "There are only two sexes" that's enough to get banned for life. The only reason the democrats all deny the existence of any double-standard is because MSM and BigTech happen to be in their tribe, so they all dare not call out one of their own.

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by antris on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:13PM (#25719922)
"BigTech has gone nuclear with censorship" immediately after a coup attempt is a wildly different statement than "there is a long-running political double standard that exists in tech companies when it comes to enforcing their TOS". Should I take take it that you have conceded your previous statement?

I would like to complete the discussion on the previous point before moving on to another topic of discussion.

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by WClayFerguson on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:33PM (#25720170)
Trump organized a demonstration. That's the American way of voicing political dissent.

If a politician organizes a peaceful rally and violent people show up and do violent things, and you blame the politician for the violence, then I'm curious about something.... Do you hold the Democrats responsible for all the violence of 2020 when we had cities burning down, and the MSM saying things like "Who ever said protests had to be peaceful"

The Democrats calling the capitol mob a "coup de tat attempt" is absolutely hilarious and just shows their complete lunacy in their attempt to vilify the other side, even when they're clearly just being absurd. It was a mob who were let into a building. Hell they didn't even damage any of the priceless paintings. If anyone's to blame is was the security who let the doors get breached when their job was to guard the building with machine guns.

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by jkepler on Sunday January 10, 2021 @06:48PM (#25721801)
Do you have a source on the priceless paintings not being damaged? I heard otherwise.
Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by jv22222 on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:49PM (#25718861)
I “think” that’s a false equivalency because democracy is the government and private companies are something different.
Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by djtriptych on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:04PM (#25719800)
when the "speech" consists of active planning of mass violence it's obviously no longer protected.

The whole point of Parler is to be a safe haven for speech that has already been banned elsewhere, for the same reason. It was doomed from the start.

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by WClayFerguson on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:15PM (#25719950)
If you really believe the social media purge is about stopping violence then you've been hoodwinked. People who haven been watching this censorship battle for years know this is purely about taking down political adversaries.
Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by djtriptych on Sunday January 10, 2021 @06:50PM (#25721831)
Oh right "people". Forgot about them.
Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by dmerks on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:06PM (#25719062)
As far as I know, AWS is not an ISP-- it's a business, a bit like the one not selling cakes to homosexual individuals.
Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by antris on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:11PM (#25719120)
It's more akin to "no shirt no service". Parler can continue using Amazon if they moderate their platform, you can put on a shirt to get a cake. You cannot change your sexuality or skin color.
Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by WClayFerguson on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:42PM (#25720261)
You can't moderate a platform if there's millions of people posting and only a handful of moderators.

Remember, AT&T is also incapable of stopping criminals from conspiring using text/telephone messages...and based on your logic the Feds could just shut down AT&T and blame AT&T for being "complicit". No obviously that's moronic. Wake up and stop giving our rights away. Eventually you're going to loose your own.

Re:Cabal: A peer-to-peer, off-grid, community-first, hackabl... by aquadrop on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:29PM (#25720111)
You can change your religion. Should amazon be able to tell to scram fx to some scientology church website hosting?