News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by manigandham on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:22PM (#25718529)
Similar to the recent actions by Twitter, Google, Apple and Amazon; Visa and Mastercard are private companies and can do whatever they want.

Anyone who has an issue with what Visa/MC did must also take issue with the others.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by folli on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:15PM (#25719165)
I'm getting slightly fatigued with this point of view ("X is a private company and can do what it wants").

If a company reaches a certain size and has a quasi-monopolistic position so that other people or companies depend on it, it starts to have some degree of responsibility towards society that's beyond value maximization for shareholders.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by eznzt on Sunday January 10, 2021 @06:24PM (#25721520)
I think the comment you are replying to is meant to be sarcastic.
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by ars on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:21PM (#25720020)
Does that mean you are against AWS, Google, and Apple shutting down Perler? All of those are large enough, and are quasi-monopolistic to meet your definition.
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by LatteLazy on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:53PM (#25720399)
I'm not OP, and I'm not a trumper or Conservative but I am 110% into free speech and I don't like the parler ban.

That said, it's really not equivalent. There are 101 other services if AWS turn you down. You can still access the parler site from an apple/android phone too. On android you can still install the app, just not via the play store.

Censorship is incidious because many people support at least some. So you convince liberals to support banning parler and conservatives to support banning porn payments (or whatever). And they're both poorer for it. We should all be agreeing on this, not being fractional...

We should all be uniting in our call to get Visa , Mastercard, Apple, Google and a dozen others declared utilities. Rather than arguing over which problem is biggest, solve them all.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by manigandham on Sunday January 10, 2021 @08:28PM (#25723002)
Except that ban was clear collusion by Google, Apple and Amazon against a single organization.

It's concerning when an alternative no longer just means an alternative of the same service but also the entire infrastructure stack. We've seen similar situations during the digital piracy era of the early 2000s.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by commandlinefan on Sunday January 10, 2021 @06:39PM (#25721691)
I honestly can’t think of a better example of the egregious abuse of quasi-monopolistic power than the shutting down of Parler.
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by TingPing on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:44PM (#25720280)
Other hosts exist. But Apple shouldn't be allowed to prevent sideloading which makes the app store no longer a monopoly.
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by Bakary on Sunday January 10, 2021 @06:15PM (#25721390)
I don't see the point of closing Parler. It was a perfect platform to monitor those people and gather them in the same place. Now it will be more difficult.
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by PaulDavisThe1st on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:52PM (#25718896)
I'm willing to revise my take on the "big tech takedown" when someone explains to me how a random member of the American public can pay a pornographic performer/model without using Visa/Mastercard and in less than 24 hours.

If there were no alternatives to Twitter, Android, iOS and AWS then I'd be as unhappy about that as I am about Visa/Mastercard's decision here.

However, it's my judgement that there are alternatives to these technology platforms to do what recently became less easy for some people to do. I don't believe there are any viable alternatives for payment processing.

Show me how I'm wrong.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by occamrazor on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:59PM (#25718981)
Android/iOS is a duopoly as pervasive as Visa/MasterCard. The ither examples only to a much lesser degree.
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by adrian_b on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:15PM (#25719164)
The comparison is not valid.

For example my phones use Android, but I do not have a Google account.

There exists no legal action that could be done by Google and that could influence anything that I am using my phone for.

On the other hand, if Visa and Mastercard would decide to not let me buy something, that would be very bad for me, because I buy almost nothing with cash and most things that interest me could not be bought with cash anyway, because they cannot be found in the shops from my close neighborhood.

So the monopoly of Visa and Mastercard really matters and it is very hard to circumvent. That of Apple and Google, much less so.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by glogla on Sunday January 10, 2021 @05:38PM (#25720929)
For a common person, Google/Apple cartel is about as much unavoidable as Visa/MC one. You are one of the very few exceptions - just as there are surely exceptional people who can do financial transactions that avoid Visa/MC.

Society is not math or computer science where existence of one counterexample makes things invalid. Society is a thing of ratios and percentages. If something is almost impossible for most people, we have to treat it as impossible even though it is possible for some - otherwise bad actors get away with terrible stuff on technicalities.

(I for example pay everything with cash or wires which are free and instantaneous in my country - I use card only once in a while to withdraw cash - but it does not invalidate Visa/MC duopoly any more than your special Android that only one in ten thousand people can use either)

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by adrian_b on Sunday January 10, 2021 @06:08PM (#25721315)
I am an exception just in the sense that every time when I buy a new phone I reject many times the insistent suggestions of Android to open a Google account and to enable Google Services / Google Play, until Android gives up and bothers me no more.

I do not need extra apps from the Google Store, because all the phones that I buy do the things that I need, e.g. voice calls, SMS messages, Internet browsing, photo/video recording, document reading, etc., without needing to install anything else. Things like Google Maps can be accessed in the browser, there is no need for an app.

So it is not difficult to avoid Google.

To avoid Visa and MC, one would need exceptional connections, because most online shops do not accept other methods of payment and it would not be easy to convince them to create a special method for you.

I choose wire transfers whenever I can instead of credit cards. For payments within the country there are no fees, but for payments to other countries, the fees are larger than for credit cards and the vendors are less likely to have wire transfers as an alternative method of payment.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by manigandham on Sunday January 10, 2021 @06:18PM (#25721453)
Just because you avoid Google (and go far out of your way to do so) doesn't mean it's the same for billions of other people on the planet (and Google is far more than some apps on your phone). Likewise billions of people also use cash or other payment tech more often than Visa/MC and are not in the same situation as you.

This is why personal anecdotes are meaningless for these topics.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by PaulDavisThe1st on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:10PM (#25719115)
Well, here's the thing.

If you agree that the required ability is "use my portable cell-connected computing device to exchange messages with others on their similar devices", then absolutely, I agree that there's a duopoly there (I'm ignoring the possibility to use alternative app stores on Android, because it doesn't seem particularly central).

But if you instead think the required ability is "be able to exchange messages with others in more or less realtime", then the duopoly in the portable cell-connected computing device world is of much less importance.

For years, because I don't have a cell phone, I was excluded from communications taking place via SMS (there were a few 1-way linux-accessible gateways, but they didn't really change anything there). But I didn't feel that my ability to communicate with others was really particularly impaired, and eventually Telegram (and others came along) that I could use from a desktop, and I was more or less back at parity for "real time communication with others".

So whether or not the android/ios duopoly matters in this sort of instance depends on precisely what functionality it is that you think people have a "right" to ...

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by leetcrew on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:12PM (#25719132)
can someone ELI5 why Visa/MasterCard is frequently called a duopoly? as someone who mostly uses my amex and discover cards for day-to-day purchases, I don't really understand this. four major processors (two being their own issuers) seems like a decent amount of competition and diversity of offerings.
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by ksec on Sunday January 10, 2021 @05:17PM (#25720681)
1. If you look into Credit Card World Wide, Amex and Discover Cards aren't even viable outside US.

2. If you look at transaction, Amex and Discover may have higher processed transaction value of something like 15% in US. But if you look at transition volume, Visa / Master are 90%+.

3. Both are Credit Card only. Debit Card is where the majority are using for Payment.

3. Consider there are no other electronic / digital payment method that is as ubiquitous as Visa / Master payment network ( ignoring Asia ) and they are the baseline method for e-payment, as well as an extreme high level barrier of Entry. The two are considered as Duopoly.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by banana_giraffe on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:32PM (#25719375)
Visa and Mastercard combined represent 83% of the number of credit cards in circulation, and 100% of the number of debit cards in circulation.

That last one, too, is probably a big part of the reason for the classification. There are more Visa/MC debit cards out there than their are credit cards.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by techdragon on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:22PM (#25719240)
I’m an Australian and as much as I want an Amex I’d have to change banks to get one, it’s quite rare over here and in a number I’d other countries from what I’ve been told by other people.
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by PurpleFoxy on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:49PM (#25720349)
From what I have seen, most businesses explicitly refuse to accept it since it charges higher fees than visa and MasterCard
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by adrian_b on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:19PM (#25719211)
Only Visa/MasterCard matter outside USA.
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by tidepod12 on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:17PM (#25719185)
Then the pornographic performers should just make their own payment network, no?

That's what everyone's been telling Parler since they started being removed from these platforms.

I also don't know how you can reconcile this comment with the fact that Gab and others were removed from Visa/MC networks, to much fanfare.

To be clear, I'm in favor of Parler going away, but I can't help but notice the double standards.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by PaulDavisThe1st on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:58PM (#25719712)
Nobody is suggesting to Parler that they build anything like the equivalent of a payment processing network.

They just need a hosting service. If they relied heavily on specific services provided by AWS, they would need to either recreate them or reengineer their code to do things differently.

These are on an entirely differently level of "just make your own" from "make your own payment network".

Unless, that is, there is no hosting service that will have them (and maybe no colo facility that will allow them presence). If so, then I would view the situations as essentially equivalent.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by tidepod12 on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:02PM (#25719773)
When Gab was removed from MC/Visa, plenty of people were indeed saying "MC/Visa are private companies and have no obligation to serve Gab. If Gab wants to accept payments, they can build their own network or use cash/crypto".
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by PurpleFoxy on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:52PM (#25720389)
So in order to build a controversial but legal social media system you must first build your own hosting company, own payment processor, own debit cards, and own ISP.

I think it’s fair to say you just can’t realistically run a website of the majority of tech corporations are against you.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by tomatotomato37 on Sunday January 10, 2021 @05:43PM (#25721004)
Wait, ignoring the freedom implications, why is it so necessary for Parler to rent compute in the first place? If the twitter clone analogy holds as true as I think it does they are just serving text snippets and the occasional image; that's well within the capabilities of a rack or two of servers sitting in an office closet somewhere.
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by glogla on Sunday January 10, 2021 @05:41PM (#25720973)
> but I can't help but notice the double standards.

Yes! It's almost as if Nazis and terrorists are not the same thing as sex workers.

What a puzzling thing.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by tidepod12 on Sunday January 10, 2021 @05:48PM (#25721073)
Are you aware of what "double standards" means? The fact that they are not the same thing is the point.

Furthermore, please review the HN guidelines for posting. Your comment is not substantive nor constructive.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by manigandham on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:23PM (#25719245)
Use American Express or ACH or wire transfers or cash or Paypal/Venmo/Cashapp or bitcoin.

As to your other point, an alternative to Twitter was made. Then it was banned by Google and Apple from devices, and then Amazon from computing infrastructure. It's no longer about an alternative of the primary service but all through the stack and that is much more concerning.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by PaulDavisThe1st on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:55PM (#25719676)
In the USA, domestic wire transfers typically US$20. ACH requires that the receiver provides you with their bank account and routing number, which while common in the EU, is extremely unusual and invasive in a US context.

You are right that PayPal/Venmo (same company) may be an alternative for now, although they generally end up applying the same restrictions as Visa/MC.

American Express ... wow, it's been years since I did this but I think it involves actually going to an Amex brick-and-mortar location, and so wouldn't actually count.

Bitcoin is equivalent to paying in a different currency, which while possible, mostly breaks the terms of the comparison, since you could argue for using some other non-crypto-currency to avoid some or all of the limitations of Visa/MC.

Parler failed to meets the ToS set by its chosen platform (picked in all likelihood because its founder was ex-AWS). Had it either met the ToS by providing sufficient moderation, or picked a different hosting service, it would have had a different experience.

As I said in my opening comment, if there is really no alternative hosting service where Parler can allow people to openly discuss violence towards specific individuals, violence towards state actors and generally be as obnoxious and wrong as they feel like, then sure, I'd agree there's a problem.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by manigandham on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:44PM (#25720283)
You're arbitrarily discounting alternatives to fit your narrative. If you think that ACH or Amex is less accessible then that's no different than other networks not having the same scale or distribution as Twitter and Apple. Why is it ok for some but not others when they all technically have alternatives?

Anyways my greater point is that illegal actions should be forwarded to the appropriate state department which can investigate and prosecute with appropriate authority and accountability. Private companies are setting a dangerous precedent, especially as they gain superior scale and then collude at multiple layers against the same organization.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by PaulDavisThe1st on Sunday January 10, 2021 @05:23PM (#25720756)
ACH takes longer than 24 hours, so there's no goal post moving there.

As I indicated below, I think it is pretty hard to get paid via Amex if Visa/MC have blocked you (3rd party payment processors such as paypal will likely block you too).

I would agree about the "forward to the government" part if that was part of normal business to find the illegal actions. I read the Visa/MC - Pornhub thing as more as a case of of Visa/MC saying "look, we think its clear that there's illegal stuff happening on your platform; we're not going to play detective here; we don't want to run the risk of being complicit of processing payments for illegal stuff, so we're cutting you off." That is, it's a statement about their desire to (not) take legal risks. They are operating within a legal context where others may do what you are suggesting and then put them in legal jeopardy.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by manigandham on Sunday January 10, 2021 @06:32PM (#25721598)
They wouldn't be complicit. The legal structure allows companies to operate with protection from their users engaging in illegal activities until it's explicitly proven or otherwise ordered by the state.

The "we think it's clear" is the dangerous part, especially when applied outside of a few easy targets discussed here. MC/Visa have numerous examples of shutting down completely legitimate businesses, and so do Google and Apple usually with a weekly HN thread highlighting yet another startup/app unceremoniously wiped off the net. Either it's all a problem or none of it is. Do you disagree with this?

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by PaulDavisThe1st on Sunday January 10, 2021 @11:16PM (#25724415)
I don't care (much) about apps. Part of that is because I'm old, part of it is because I don't use a cell phone, part of it is because I do most of what people do on their cell phones from ... uhm ... more traditional computing devices.

If I did care, then perhaps I'd see Google/Apple store bans etc. as more equivalent to Visa/MC payment processing bans.

As it stands, I don't.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by Anon1096 on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:06PM (#25719835)
> bank account and routing number, which while common in the EU, is extremely unusual and invasive in a US context

So now you're moving the goalposts and saying that it being extremely unusual precludes it as an option? Of course any alternative to the Mastercard/VISA duopoly is going to be unusual. By definition, since they are dominant, any other way of payment will have to be outside the norm.

> American Express ... wow, it's been years since I did this but I think it involves actually going to an Amex brick-and-mortar location, and so wouldn't actually count.

It does not require going in person at all. You can get qualified for a card online and they'll ship it to you.

> Bitcoin is equivalent to paying in a different currency, which while possible, mostly breaks the terms of the comparison

Again, by construction of the question, alternative payment schemes will necessarily be different. The other players here are PayPal, Discover, and AMEX.

The alternatives for Parler (going to another hosting provider than AWS, alternate App Store on Android, and no app on iOS) are at least as unusual compared to the alternatives for payment. Just like your Discover card won't be accepted at most places, or Bitcoin or PayPal, most users are not going to accept a modern day service that doesn't have an app. Or even more egregiously, in Stormfront's case, users are absolutely not going to learn how to use Tor just to access a site. Parler isn't there yet, but it may well be soon if their domain registrar drops them. Or even Level3 or BGP providers.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by PaulDavisThe1st on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:52PM (#25720387)
>So now you're moving the goalposts and saying that it being extremely unusual precludes it as an option

Well, what I should have said was "ACH rarely completes inside 24 hours to a new account", which doesn't move the goalposts.

>(Amex) It does not require going in person at all. You can get qualified for a card online and they'll ship it to you.

Not sure this has anything to do with the ability to pay a 3rd party. They would need to have an Amex merchant account or an equivalent proxy via an intermediate payment processor, and my impression is that when Visa/MC drops you, the 3rd party will too, even if Amex didn't.

> users are absolutely not going to learn how to use Tor just to access a site

Parler had no privacy (and from what I read, very lax security), so I don't think that a Tor-accessed site is a part of the replacement for what they had. They just a hosting site that can run some moderately but not extraordinarily complex backend stack.

The "lack of app" question goes back to a comment I made here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25719115

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by IshKebab on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:01PM (#25718995)
There aren't really alternatives to Android/iOS. But I would say they need regulation too.

Payment is critical infrastructure. It's crazy that most of the world is subject to this duopoly.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by slg on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:14PM (#25719149)
This is a bizarre comment. The complaint isn't that Pornhub, Visa, or Mastercard lack the right to do what they are doing. People are explaining reasons why it is a bad decision and those reasons aren't relevant to Twitter, Google, Apple, and Amazon. There is nothing contradictory about someone who believes these companies have the right to kick people off their platform while also thinking that these companies can make mistakes regarding who they kick off.
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by manigandham on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:17PM (#25719187)
The point is that if you have an issue with companies taking private action over state prosecution then that should apply to all decisions.

Whether you consider an individual decision to be a mistake is entirely subjective and irrelevant.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by slg on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:42PM (#25719514)
>The point is that if you have an issue with companies taking private action over state prosecution then that should apply to all decisions.

Why? I can agree that someone has a right while also disagreeing with how they exercise that right. I have no idea why you are labeling the specifics irrelevant.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by adrian_b on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:13PM (#25719927)
Visa and Mastercard should not do whatever they want, because they are just middlemen in transactions and all their decisions affect their paying customers, much more than themselves.

Visa/MC take the money of their customers, who use their cards, by promising to help them pay for anything they want.

Visa/MC do not have any right to decide unilaterally what their customers might want to buy (as long as no illegal goods are involved), without consulting their customers first.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by manigandham on Sunday January 10, 2021 @11:09PM (#25724355)
I'm only saying that what Visa/MC did is the same as what Twitter/Google/Apple/Amazon did. They all took private action against what they deemed as illegal acts without involving the state or any law enforcement.

I would much rather leave such things to the proper authorities instead of massive corporations that control so much without any accountability or transparency.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by PurpleFoxy on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:56PM (#25720429)
As it stands right now they do have the right to do whatever they want. I guess you are proposing that this needs to be changed.
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by adrian_b on Sunday January 10, 2021 @05:22PM (#25720754)
All large companies that have a quasi-monopoly, e.g. the large cable providers, ISPs, mobile phone companies, and so on, take frequently abusive decisions that affect negatively many of their customers.

In most cases the customers are forced to accept these unilateral decisions, because they do not have the power to attempt a legal battle with those companies, e.g. for modifying the fees or the data caps.

Nevertheless, even when we do not want or cannot fight such decisions, we should not say that they are private companies and they can do whatever they want.

Those companies are not independent to do whatever they want, they are in contractual relationships with their paying customers.

They may use their power to unilaterally change the contracts as they want to, but that does not mean that we must accept that might is right.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by PurpleFoxy on Sunday January 10, 2021 @05:29PM (#25720830)
I agree that they should not be able to do what they want. I’m just saying that they can. Which is something also think should be changed but it doesn’t change the reality of how it is currently.
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by fwip on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:27PM (#25719297)
This argument always reminds me of the evergreen dril tweet: https://twitter.com/dril/status/473265809079693312?lang=en (cw: profanity). You've rhetorically zoomed out so far that only the most abstract description of the category of the action is up for discussion. But this is begging the question - there's no reason that this must be the case.

This rhetorical trick of categorizing all of these as "private companies denying service," is the same one used by those who opposed anti-discrimination laws. Should an ice-cream store be able to kick out a person pissing on the floor? Should they be able to kick out a black person for being black? In each case, it's simply "a private company doing whatever they want." But, obviously, these two cases are not the same.

Personally, I think it's quite a different thing to kick people who incite violence off your social media platform than it is to ban sex-workers from using you as a payment processor. And, because they are different actions, with different intent and effects, it is, of course, possible to think "Hey, it's good that [x] is happening, but bad that [y] is happening."

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by manigandham on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:38PM (#25719450)
I compared these situations because both are about explicility illegal activities clearly defined by law. They're more similar than different.

Your personal opinion on which decision you support is just that, your personal opinion, and only reinforces my point about the subjectivity and inherent hypocrisy of it all and whether private company action over state prosecution is the correct course of action.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by fwip on Sunday January 10, 2021 @07:08PM (#25722050)
Just because something is subjective does not mean it is hypocritical.
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by elric on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:03PM (#25719019)
> Anyone who has an issue with this must also take issue with the others.

Yeah .... no. For a variety of reasons. But for one, it's impossible to do business online if you're not in the good graces of major payment providers (assuming you want to get paid). It might be hard(er) to advertise your business if Twitter bans you, but that's in no way comparable to how essential Visa/MC are to any business.

Providers of critical infrastructure (payments, search, appstores, probably a few other things), when they're big enough to be a monopoly/duopoly, could really use more oversight. If you piss off Google/Apple, your business can be ruined, and you'll have virtually no recourse -- as evidenced by the frequent "google/apple killed my app" threads on HN.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by manigandham on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:14PM (#25719154)
None of this is considered critical infrastructure today, that's the point. What's important to you is entirely subjective and these are private companies that can apply their terms however they see fit. Visa/MC can easily say that ACH and cash payments exist as an alternative.

If you feel that monopolistic powers by major tech companies need more oversight then that should apply equally. I don't see why communications networks are any less important than payment networks.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by adrian_b on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:41PM (#25719491)
Visa/MC are really critical infrastructure, because for many people they are the main means of payment or even the only one.

In most cases they are the only existing means for making remote payments. I would have much preferred a world in which the remote payments would not have been done by credit cards, but by wire transfers (with much lower fees than the current fees for wire transfers), but we do not live in such a world.

I am not sure about what weird conditions might be written in the small print of the contracts for credit cards, but certainly when Visa/MC advertise their services, they claim that you should pay for their cards in order to buy anything that you want, they do not invite you to pay them in order to let you buy only what they like.

So I do not believe that it is correct to say that VISA/MC are private companies that can do anything they like.

They have also obligations towards the customers who use their cards and they cannot decide unilaterally to ban some sellers, unless those are selling something illegal, which is not the case with Pornhub (after they took down what was said to be illegal content).

I do not think that making a referendum among Visa/MC customers about whether to ban some vendor or another would be the most appropriate solution, but certainly unilateral decisions taken just by the Visa/MC management are an abuse.

While I have never used Pornhub, so I have no opinion about how correct were their actions, I have paid in the past for a few other sites with erotic content and I would not like to discover one day that Visa or MC has again decided to block such a site without any valid reason.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by Dma54rhs on Sunday January 10, 2021 @07:05PM (#25722008)
There are plenty of alternatives though, they don't own anything to porn industry. They just don't want to associate themselves with these people and it's their right to do so.
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by wmf on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:20PM (#25719224)
The banking/payment industry is acting as a cartel to shut down certain activities. This is what antitrust law is for.
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by cathyreisenwitz on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:29PM (#25719317)
"Visa and Mastercard are private companies and can do whatever they want." Not without DOJ pressure, unfortunately.
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by LatteLazy on Sunday January 10, 2021 @04:43PM (#25720264)
Really they're utilities.
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by xirbeosbwo1234 on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:40PM (#25719471)
>Anyone who has an issue with this must also take issue with the others.

That doesn't follow. Someone can acknowledge that companies have the right to run itself however it wants but disagree with this particular decision. It is possibly incoherent to argue that Twitter may ban people but Visa may not ban anyone; it is perfectly coherent to argue that Twitter should ban certain people and Visa should not ban these particular businesses.

Also, I don't think it's a contradiction even to say that Visa may not ban anyone. Running a website is a form of speech. Every website absolutely must be moderated beyond what is required to remove spam or what is required by law. Telling them what kind of community they are allowed to run is an excessive infringement on their freedom of speech. This is similar to why I support net neutrality but fervently oppose any sort of mandatory neutrality on websites. It would take a tortured argument to claim that routing packets is a form of speech (particularly when these packets are encrypted), while running a website always requires taking an editorial role.

No one would find it strange if a book store decided not to carry a particular book. People would find it very strange if their credit card company refused to process a payment for a particular book.

I neither support nor oppose banning payments to Pornhub since I don't know much about the website. I have no skin flicks in the game.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by bjeds on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:39PM (#25718735)
<I deleted my comment because people only want to argue.>
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by marcinzm on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:44PM (#25718791)
[delete]
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by jowsie on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:53PM (#25718905)
>I found some of what it promoted disturbing to be honest.

But was it illegal?

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by Daho0n on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:47PM (#25719585)
>No, no it's not. Seriously, browse PornHub's recommended videos in incognito mode. Go through a few pages. Click into a few categories. Don't even do weird searches, just go through what it recommends. I found some of what it promoted disturbing to be honest.

Disturbing !== illegal.

Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by andrepd on Sunday January 10, 2021 @03:05PM (#25719043)
Are you implying abuse, or just "kinky shit"?
Re:Sex workers say 'defunding Pornhub' puts their livelihood... by read_if_gay_ on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:46PM (#25718818)
> browse PornHub's recommended videos in incognito mode. Go through a few pages. Click into a few categories. Don't even do weird searches, just go through what it recommends.

Yeah, I totally never did that before at all.