News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by kd913 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @04:41PM (#25651524)
I remember watching a video from Wendover Production talking about the decline of 747 and A380s mainly due to a lack of guaranteed passengers to fill the plane routes in both directions.

Exceptions being some airlines which are able to operate hub and spoke models and where fuel is cheap like the middle east airlines.

Wouldn't these types of planes be more suitable for a role in logistics which can benefit the greater density of packing?

I am guessing this is something to do with fuel savings, and new composite materials meaning that smaller planes are still more efficient. However, would that necessarily apply to recent 747s/a380s which I think have composite materials and can be retrofitted to efficient engines? I figure these specific planes must be on sale as they are withdrawn from service so I am curious about the use of 767s here.

Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by nickff on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @05:01PM (#25651778)
The A340, A380, 727, 747, and L-1011 existed because of the hub-and-spoke model, and the requirement for a minimum of three engines for transoceanic flights. The 777 was the harbinger of their doom, as it brought ETOPS with it.

Somewhat tangentially, there is a (strong) argument that twin-engine aircraft are actually safer than three or four engine aircraft. First, they are at lower risk of having an engine problem (as they have fewer engines). Second, the requirements all focus on having sufficient performance with a single engine out, which means that a twin engine aircraft normally has at least 200% of the power required to keep it aloft, whereas the four-engine aircraft only has 133% of what it needs. Given that many problems can be solved with a sufficient application of power, the twin-engine airplane is actually at an advantage!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ETOPS

Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by mannykannot on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @06:17PM (#25652612)
Where do you get that 133% figure from? you appear to be suggesting that a four-engined aircraft could only tolerate the loss of a single engine, but if that were the case, four-engined aircraft would always have been more vulnerable to loss on account of an engine failure over the ocean than twin-engined ones. The introduction of additional requirements (in terms of stringent maintenance, ancilliary equipment redundancy and proximity of alternative destinations) before ETOPS was permitted strongly suggests that was not the case.
Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by nickff on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @06:29PM (#25652736)
If the aircraft is required to fly at a certain performance level with one engine out, a 4 engine aircraft must have 4/3x100% of minimum required power when in nominal operating condition, a 2 engine aircraft must have 2/1x100%...

I first heard this from a lecture by Henry Pohl (a truly brilliant engineer): https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/aeronautics-and-astronautics/16-...

Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by mannykannot on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @07:13PM (#25653172)
I think you are missing the point here, or at least misapplying it. These are minimum figures, but if the four-engined airliners used in transoceanic flights were actually built to have no more reserve power (above the minimum necessary to keep flying) than the 133% you are quoting, they would have always have been less safe from engine failure than contemporary twin-engined airliners (which, in practice, always achieved the 200% reserve), as they, just like the twin-engined aircraft, could not have tolerated any more than a single engine failure - but then, ETOPS would either not have been necessary, or should also have been applied to four-engined airliners. ETOPS is primarily about the risk of two engines failing (and secondarily about range with one engine out.)
Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by nickff on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @07:22PM (#25653253)
Maybe the people at the FAA in the 1950s who wrote the so-called 60-minute rule missed your point, but I don't know what to tell you.
Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by mannykannot on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @07:31PM (#25653324)
The 60-minute rule does not explain or justify your 133% claim with respect to four-engined aircraft - in fact, it is evidence against it: in practice, four-engined airliners, unlike twins, could tolerate more than a single engine failure.
Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by nickff on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:32PM (#25654095)
I just looked at a few airliners, and the 2-engine aircraft all had significantly higher power to weight ratios than the 4-engine aircraft.
Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by mannykannot on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:36PM (#25654433)
That does not justify your 133% figure, nor the explanation you gave for it. That explanation implied that four-engined airliners could only tolerate the loss of a single engine.
Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by mr_toad on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:01PM (#25654262)
A 747, once airborne, can climb on 3 engines. Fully loaded, with gear down.

A jet requires a lot less power to cruise than to take off. Normally they’d operate at 80-90% power when cruising, but they can stay airborne with much less power.

How much power it takes to stay airborne depends on many factors, such as weight, altitude, wind conditions and temperature, but 747s have been known to fly and land safely with just two engines.

Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by 7952 on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @03:05AM (#25655596)
The minimum power is what is needed to fly to the closest diversion airport. This could be at a lower altitude and reduced speed. It is substantially less than the power used in take off or go around. Airplanes work in a variety of conditions and do not need 100% to get home in an etops situation.

The rule you talk about is more clearly applicable to rockets that run at 100% for most of the flight.

Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by kd913 on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @11:34AM (#25659227)
Looking at Maximum Take off-weight it appears that a 747 has almost double the MTOW of a 767.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_airliners_by_maximum_t...

I can imagine this being the case mainly because the calculation is assuming 1 engine failed.

Given this, and assuming an almost maximum payload, would there necessarily be scenarios here for the 747 to be more fuel efficient?

Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by supernova87a on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @03:05AM (#25655599)
Well, a related item is that airlines simply got tired of maintaining 4 engines (I'm putting it somewhat jokingly but not too far from the truth). For the not much better fuel efficiency and capacity, the complexity of the 747 4 engines are that much more of a headache to maintain properly.
Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by jrockway on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @05:59PM (#25652421)
What is interesting to me is that having 200% power onboard is more cost efficient than only having 133% power onboard.
Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by nickff on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @06:09PM (#25652518)
Lots of reasons for this, here are a couple:

Having extra power helps you climb to cruising altitude quickly. This is a significant consideration, as a great deal of fuel expenditure takes place during the climb through dense, drag-inducing atmosphere.

Engines and aircraft structure are non linear in both up-front cost, maintenance, and economy. Two larger engines have about half as many parts as four smaller ones, impacting production costs and service requirements. Larger fans are also more efficient than smaller ones for a variety of reasons. Fuel systems and aircraft structures are also simpler, lighter, and less expensive with fewer engines.

Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by dingaling on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @07:13PM (#25653176)
> The 777 was the harbinger of their doom, as it brought ETOPS with it.

The A300 brought ETOPS, quickly followed by the 767.

Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by nickff on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @07:25PM (#25653279)
My understanding is that the A300 brought the so-called 'early ETOPS', A.K.A. ETOPS-90 and ETOPS-120; 777 brought ETOPS-180.
Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by xvf22 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @04:55PM (#25651691)
Cargo companies seem to have older fleets and the 767s are being displaced from passenger service and have a cargo conversation option. The a380 doesn't have a cargo conversation option as far as I've seen. Plenty of old 747s are in service for cargo flights. Kalitta air has a bunch of older 747s and Atlas has a sizable fleet including some 8Fs.
Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by excitom on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @06:08PM (#25652514)
Interesting point: The original reason for the double deck design on the 747 was to allow the entire nose to be a cargo door. Having an upstairs lounge or first class cabin was side benefit.
Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by nickff on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @06:13PM (#25652569)
Boeing looked at many possible configurations for the 747, a full-length double-deck among them (photos exist of such a wind tunnel model). The short top deck exists for a variety of reasons, one of the more interesting ones is that the 747 was designed to be faster than later airliners, so the Whitcomb area rule is a factor in its design, especially noticeable in the -400 model, where the top deck ends above the wing root leading edge.
Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by dingaling on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @07:19PM (#25653226)
Note that the 400 and 800 freighters kept the short bump because the longer upper deck reduced main deck height and impaired cargo handling. That's also the main reason that passenger 400s are seldom converted to freighters.
Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by nickff on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @07:26PM (#25653286)
Thanks for the info (I did not know that)!
Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by formercoder on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @05:04PM (#25651815)
Pretty sure I’ve read there will never be a cargo a380 because its max takeoff weight is low compared to its volume.
Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by csours on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @05:39PM (#25652213)
I think cause and effect may be chasing each other here. You're not wrong, but also the A380 was not designed to have a high takeoff weight because they never intended it to carry cargo, so it will never carry cargo because it has a low takeoff weight compared to its volume.

It was a design decision to be a people mover. [0]

0: https://www.flexport.com/blog/airbus-a380-no-cargo-equivalen...

Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by tormeh on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @07:19PM (#25653231)
Many low-density things need to be shipped fast, though. But I guess that niche is not big enough.
Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by oblio on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @06:21AM (#25656713)
> cargo conversation

I guess you mean "cargo conversion"?

Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by notatoad on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @12:26AM (#25654891)
There's enough existing 747 cargo fleets to soak up any excess supply of decommissioned passenger 747s.

The A380 wasn't designed for cargo so the economics don't work out for many cargo loads. It's also limited in what airports it can operated out of. I'm sure there is some route out there where it will end up as an ideal freighter when they start retiring from passenger service, but it is not very flexible. Definitely not where you'd want to start building out your cargo fleet.

Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by pwarner on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:13PM (#25654328)
The A380 is harder to load cargo into so they never even built a cargo version. The 747 freighter is still being produced and delivered today! Look up and see a contrail lately and it might be a 747 freighter, they are all flying!

https://www.businessinsider.com/boeing-747-resurgence-in-car...

https://simpleflying.com/ups-boeing-747-deliveries/

Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by Theodores on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @04:47PM (#25651593)
The 767s are twin engine and more efficient than the 747.

The A380 never was a cargo plane, big that it is. It also has the four engines with the added maintenance.

Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by GordonS on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @06:16PM (#25652603)
I wonder, is there such a thing as a plane that carries both cargo (in a significant way) and passengers?

Not sure if it would make any economic sense, but maybe it could if the layout could be changed rapidly, with a passenger cabin "slotted in" when needed.

Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by shiftpgdn on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @06:28PM (#25652726)
That's already the case. USPS relied heavily on being able to move cargo in the belly of passenger planes which lead to disruptions this year. You can also fairly quickly take all the seats out of most passenger planes since they're just stuck in there with L track.
Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by verhey on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @06:42PM (#25652880)
You are thinking of "combi" aircraft. In North America, you see a lot of them operating in Northern Canada and Alaska.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combi_aircraft

Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by leesalminen on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @06:35PM (#25652790)
I saw a TV show called Ice Pilots years ago which focused on an airline in the northern parts of Canada. If memory serves, they flied planes that had a configurable cabin where they could add rows of seats as needed and a divider leaving the rest for cargo.
Re:Amazon buys 11 Boeing 767s to expand its cargo fleet by dehrmann on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:07PM (#25653971)
> where fuel is cheap like the middle east airlines.

They're also in a strategically good location for connecting Europe to Australia and North America to Africa and India.