I first heard this from a lecture by Henry Pohl (a truly brilliant engineer): https://ocw.mit.edu/courses/aeronautics-and-astronautics/16-...
A jet requires a lot less power to cruise than to take off. Normally they’d operate at 80-90% power when cruising, but they can stay airborne with much less power.
How much power it takes to stay airborne depends on many factors, such as weight, altitude, wind conditions and temperature, but 747s have been known to fly and land safely with just two engines.
The rule you talk about is more clearly applicable to rockets that run at 100% for most of the flight.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_airliners_by_maximum_t...
I can imagine this being the case mainly because the calculation is assuming 1 engine failed.
Given this, and assuming an almost maximum payload, would there necessarily be scenarios here for the 747 to be more fuel efficient?
Having extra power helps you climb to cruising altitude quickly. This is a significant consideration, as a great deal of fuel expenditure takes place during the climb through dense, drag-inducing atmosphere.
Engines and aircraft structure are non linear in both up-front cost, maintenance, and economy. Two larger engines have about half as many parts as four smaller ones, impacting production costs and service requirements. Larger fans are also more efficient than smaller ones for a variety of reasons. Fuel systems and aircraft structures are also simpler, lighter, and less expensive with fewer engines.
Somewhat tangentially, there is a (strong) argument that twin-engine aircraft are actually safer than three or four engine aircraft. First, they are at lower risk of having an engine problem (as they have fewer engines). Second, the requirements all focus on having sufficient performance with a single engine out, which means that a twin engine aircraft normally has at least 200% of the power required to keep it aloft, whereas the four-engine aircraft only has 133% of what it needs. Given that many problems can be solved with a sufficient application of power, the twin-engine airplane is actually at an advantage!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ETOPS