News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by AlexandrB on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:03AM (#25633044)
Another sign that several FAANGs exist as a monopoly. When you're so big that you can provide effectively no customer service to a customer spending in the 10s of millions (and they have no competitor they can go to afterwards) there's a problem.
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by smnrchrds on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:24AM (#25633438)
I agree with you. When the issue of Apple's anti-competitive behaviour comes up on HN, it is always rebuffed by saying Apple does not have a monopoly—its US share of smartphone market is merely 40%. This is demonstration that you don't need a 100% market share to act anti-competitively. Facebook and Google each have less than 30% market share in ad spend in the US.
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by absolutelyrad on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:30AM (#25633548)
The fact that 30% app store tax exists and both stores (App Store by Apple and Google Play Store) have somewhat similar strategies highly indicate collusion going on. Apple only changed it for people making under $1m a year after people got mad and they got sued by Epic Games or they knew Epic Games was coming for their asses. But they know that majority of their revenue comes from pubs making over $1m a year which they still tax at 30%.

Then the fact that they hold Safari backwards to cripple the adoption of PWA's (Modern Web Apps). They don't allow real competitors to Safari either. The competitors that exist like Chrome or Firefox are just Safari under the hood on iOS.

iOS and Apple have single handedly crippled the innovation on mobile web. Safari is the modern Internet Explorer but Apple forcing people to use it directly or indirectly and not allowing real competition on iOS.

This is straight up anti trust material and they should face scrutiny for it. Sleepy lawmakers should wake up.

Not only does it harm American businesses, but also businesses across the world.

Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by mhh__ on Monday January 04, 2021 @12:54PM (#25635163)
Even if Apple shouldn't be subject to an anti-trust suit, I think the whole industry should be regulated to counter how Apple goes about it's business - if Google could get away with acting like Apple does to it's customers they probably would, Microsoft would also love to but they've been bitten before.

Basic legislation guaranteeing certain freedoms for the consumers costs Apple and Google et al. nothing but massively empowers consumers in a sector where information about the products is largely controlled by the creators of said products.

This also prevents products becoming e-waste when the company is done supporting them.

Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by JKCalhoun on Monday January 04, 2021 @03:28PM (#25637401)
Perhaps you would also consider book publishers as colluding since they too have a "tax" to publish books.

Even with ePubs book publishers are likely to take 50—75%. Print books the publishers still take 85% and higher.

Now that is a tax. But I would not call it collusion.

Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by absolutelyrad on Monday January 04, 2021 @10:59PM (#25641903)
There was distribution that costed precisely $0 in middle man fees. Software downloaded from the web (if you already have the audience, the distribution costs are marginal on the web).

Then Apple decided to cut it out. And also cripple web apps so they can't even be alternatives properly. Can you build a Mail app on the web? No. Apple didn't add the required features to Safari that developers could build on top of. And Chrome/Firefox/Edge did add them and they work. However on iOS, Apple does not allow them, instead they're forced to use Safari under the hood with Chrome/Google branding sprinkled on top.

Tell me how much publishers pay to distribute on Windows from their websites? Or the WebApps that don't need to be installed? Apple provides little value as a middle man.

The just wanted to be parasite middlemen and they don't deserve to be. They're the mafia.

Go for them under anti-competition clauses. And if there is indication that they have colluded, start trust busting on both. Google is already not trustworthy. They colluded with Facebook already. And Apple colluded to lower wages with other tech companies.

It is entirely reasonable to think that this is anti-competitive and hinders innovation.

Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by valuearb on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:17PM (#25642044)
The reason the 30% exists isn’t collusion, it’s what both thought they needed to charge to make money on 99 cent purchases given how high transaction costs were.

Even today, it’s likely they don’t make much on those 99 cent purchases, last I looked transaction costs were probably over 10%.

Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by philjohn on Monday January 04, 2021 @02:24PM (#25636543)
To be fair - I'm more concerned about things like buying companies so that they have exclusive access to various technologies thereby denying other companies the ability to use them, e.g. the sensor used in the Kinect.
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by BikiniPrince on Monday January 04, 2021 @01:26PM (#25635695)
Sadly, only 40% when your opposition is fragmented and frankly a crap interface.

There are many things I like about Android, but most of them are philosophical.

I find navigating it atrocious and I have spent quite a bit time reverse engineering some applications.

Again, this is the competitor to apple? How much does each market capture. I suspect apple is doing much better here.

Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by RockyMcNuts on Monday January 04, 2021 @01:44PM (#25635999)
I think in USA, it's 60/40 in favor of Apple. Globally, 70/30 in favor of Android https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/mobile/worldwide
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by mrtksn on Monday January 04, 2021 @05:57PM (#25639451)
When Apple rejects your App you receive an explanation and even screenshots and a call from the reviewer with suggestions how to fix it.
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by grishka on Monday January 04, 2021 @07:32PM (#25640365)
Except sometimes Apple rejects your app such that you can't do anything to fix it. They straight up tell you that your whole concept isn't allowed to exist on the app store. I think I've seen a couple of stories about this a while ago. Or if there's any semblance of UGC, you're supposed to have a moderation team that would enforce Apple's ridiculous policies. Oh you're an individual and don't intend to turn that into a company? Tough luck, sorry.
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by torgard on Monday January 04, 2021 @06:13PM (#25639603)
They do? I was under the impression that they don't.

I specifically remember submitting an app, and getting denied. The response we got was relatively vague, saying it was breaking ToS. No screenshots, no call or anything of the sort.

This was the first submission though.

Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by mrtksn on Monday January 04, 2021 @06:28PM (#25639723)
They do, Previously I wrote a few things about my experience with Apple. Rejection is manageable when you deal with people since you can actually reason with, unlike algorithms.

Here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25137475

Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by elliekelly on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @02:09AM (#25642965)
I can at least get Apple on the phone. Sometimes I can’t even get an actual human to email me back from Google.
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by xiwenc on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:08AM (#25633128)
I’m curious why the author didn’t take this to court?

Perhaps it can evolve into a class action lawsuit. That would teach FB and other FAANGs.

Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by logronoide on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:10AM (#25633177)
The author is fully dependent from FB. He cannot bite the hand that feeds him. I think it’s a smart move to reach the front page of HN before taking this to court.
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by ben_w on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:18AM (#25633314)
If he’s been kicked off their network, does he have anything to lose by biting the hand that used to feed him?
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by mandelbrotwurst on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:24AM (#25633434)
I think the idea is that they might be more likely to reverse the discussion in response to a forum discussion than to being served legal papers.
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by s1artibartfast on Monday January 04, 2021 @02:59PM (#25637016)
The cost of lawyers is >0 and the chance of winning is 0. Better to take whatever cash you have and walk away than sue.
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by slumdev on Monday January 04, 2021 @05:01PM (#25638850)
Whining at the right people has a nonzero chance of getting him back on Facebook.

Lawyering up has zero chance.

Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by gpm on Monday January 04, 2021 @01:28PM (#25635718)
To court... for what? Choosing not to do business with the author? That's not illegal. That doesn't become illegal just because they've done quite a bit of business in the past.
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by missedthecue on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:08AM (#25633127)
Facebook and google are not the only places to advertise.
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by simplecto on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:10AM (#25633166)
Please enlighten us. Porn networks do not count.
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by tiborsaas on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:30AM (#25633546)
I haven't spent a dime on online ads, but if it were my problem, I'd go though the top Alexa websites and see if they accept money for ads.
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by londons_explore on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:38AM (#25633709)
The days of that kind of thing are over. Everyone does placements using ad networks.

Best you'll manage along those lines is approaching celebrities and youtube/insta stars and getting them to endorse your product.

Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by underdown on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:42AM (#25633768)
This is typically what companies spending 57m on ads do. Its less expensive per click/impression as fb/Google don't take a cut. More expensive to manage.
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by theflyinghorse on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:14AM (#25633243)
what do you have in mind other than Facebook and Google as online advertising (actually any advertising) that has the same reach?
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by missedthecue on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:18AM (#25633310)
believe it or not, advertising existed before 2010.
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by JosephRedfern on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:26AM (#25633465)
Believe it or not, people used to physically borrow movies from shops and return them 2 days later!!! That doesn't mean that I can still walk to my newsagents and borrow a copy of Pulp Fiction on VHS.

Things change, and Facebook and Google are now the big players in online advertising, accounting for a large majority of the ad market. Other platforms exist, of course, but by cutting out Google Ads and Facebook you're going to be targetting a very different user base and are cutting out a significant share of the market.

Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by AlexandrB on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:28AM (#25633504)
Online Facebook + Google take something like 50% of all ad revenue. Since the product being advertised is a website, offline advertising is probably a lot less effective than online.
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by craftinator on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:21AM (#25633368)
It did, and it still does. The biggest difference is that now, FB and Google and a few others have a scope that is an order of magnitude larger than all other advertisers combined. They've gained almost total market control over advertising, hence the word monopoly.
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by marcus_holmes on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:22AM (#25633398)
and then there was a massive revolution in the way that people consumed content, and now FB and Google account for the vast majority of advertising consumption (not spending: consumption)
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by minitoar on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:09AM (#25633154)
Sorta. Where else would you advertise if you’re specifically trying to reach people who are doing web searches for your product category?
Re:After spending $57M on Facebook ads, I was kicked off by petercooper on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:25AM (#25633448)
To be fair, ads on Facebook aren't generally appearing in response to searches. But there are plenty of high value lower traffic options, such as specialized blogs and newsletters that have audiences fitting your target market - you have to work to find and work with them but at a certain scale it makes sense (at "I have $57m to spend on ads" scale, potentially not).