News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by scotty79 on Friday January 01, 2021 @08:49AM (#25603223)
That's how we got to the current cutting edge. Research of most important technological inventions of the past century was funded by beaurocrats. Market is only good at figuring out how to make things cheaper and in volume. Both very important things. But true scientific breakthroughs that push the business over next decades happen on taxpayers bill as distributed by beaurocrats.

It sucks a bit that it's this way but if you are profit driven, you can't gamble 140 billion of your own money in hopes of developing new tech.

Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by yvdriess on Friday January 01, 2021 @09:15AM (#25603391)
Yep, this cannot be repeated enough. Government funding is how a lot of innovations happen, but it's not as visible as a private company bringing that innovation to market.

To put in optimization terms, private companies are good at following the gradient. Government funding is necessary to escape the well and find new minimas.

Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by dahele on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:12PM (#25604700)
Very well put. Take AI as an example - foundational research in deep learning and reinforcement learning was first done in academia. Everyone knows the story of how long neural networks languished in the shadows, before its time. Even commercial research labs only really took note after the potential of these methods was discovered.

Government funding is a good thing, but it’d be even better would be if we could harness the free market. One solution could be to equip research institutions with the means to capture value from IP that follows on from basic research.

Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by WanderPanda on Friday January 01, 2021 @01:10PM (#25605213)
I was thinking in a similar direction. What about an adaptive patent law? Where the duration of the protection in a particular area of interest can be set by e.g. a committee (with a strict ruleset and a big time constant of course). So when there is not much progress in a certain area (e.g. cancer or nuclear fusion) the patent protection is increased to incentivise investments. A problem with this approach are obviously the unknown unknowns, which might prevent this system from incentivising inventions like the transistor. So this approach can probably only help with problem driven areas and not in cases where the tech innovation gives rise to new problems/solutions
Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by throw0101a on Friday January 01, 2021 @10:12AM (#25603750)
> Government funding is how a lot of innovations happen, but it's not as visible as a private company bringing that innovation to market.

A recent example of 'basic' research coming to fruition in a practical fashion (eventually):

> "S glycoprotein signal peptide (extended leader sequence), which guides translocation of the nascent polypeptide chain into the endoplasmic reticulum" - part of the BioNTech/Pfizer vaccine. I don't ever want to hear anyone question fundamental science again. 1/2

> The level of control and understanding we now have over our biology came from literally millions of person-years spent working on things that at the time were obscure and "useless". And now? We can leverage all this into a 95% efficient vaccine _at the first try_. 2/2

* https://twitter.com/PowerDNS_Bert/status/1342159339767934978

We have no way of knowing ahead of time what knowledge will be needed or "useful" in the future, so in some ways it is prudent to try to acquire as much knowledge of the natural world as possible and sort it out later.

Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by hungryhobo on Friday January 01, 2021 @11:55AM (#25604559)
I love this analogy!
Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by rapsey on Friday January 01, 2021 @09:33AM (#25603501)
Government funding is extremely wasteful and will generally go into the pockets of the well connected. The problem is this game has been played for a long time and it has diminishing returns. The players have had decades to get the exploitation down.

Yes sillicon valley exists because of government money. But that was like 70 years ago. The world has changed and corruption is more severe. You will get no such bang for your government grant buck now.

Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by ClumsyPilot on Friday January 01, 2021 @11:05AM (#25604173)
Remind me how is that WeWork and Theranos investment going?
Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by nickpp on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:48PM (#25605024)
Plenty of startups crash and burn. It comes with the territory. What is your point?
Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by ClumsyPilot on Friday January 01, 2021 @01:26PM (#25605344)
No-no, this is not examples of ordinary wastefullness and 'crash', these were outright fraud.

The exact same thing the OP accuses government grants of perpetuating.

Your post is a perfect example that with startups that's just accepted and glossed over.

Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by nickpp on Friday January 01, 2021 @01:29PM (#25605373)
Well maybe because in government grants waste and fraud are the rule, while in private startups they are the exception.

And it is the investors problem when a startup fails, and they are aware of it. But with governments, it is OUR money squandered away by politicians and their friends.

Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by Apocryphon on Friday January 01, 2021 @05:03PM (#25607676)
> Well maybe because in government grants waste and fraud are the rule, while in private startups they are the exception.

Are they really? What are the failure rates for both?

> But with governments, it is OUR money squandered away by politicians and their friends.

https://qz.com/1719019/wework-and-ubers-losses-may-be-subsid...

https://www.businessinsider.com/weworks-investors-include-pe...

Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by andybak on Saturday January 02, 2021 @06:03AM (#25611950)
> The world has changed and corruption is more severe

Are you sure? This rather smacks of the "good old days" fallacy.

Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by krona on Friday January 01, 2021 @10:23AM (#25603851)
Then by your own definition, and the statement issued by the EU commission, this is a bad investment.

I've worked for the large, sclerotic organisations that once put man on the moon. They will take your 100bn, crush it in to dust, and outsource the production of 1 million pages of documentation in 32 languages detailing the workings of something your never asked for. All in the blink of an eye.

Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by scotty79 on Friday January 01, 2021 @11:05AM (#25604176)
Yes. It's bad investment for the one who pays. Possibly great for everybody else and humanity in general.

If efficiency is your thing go into business. The smaller the better. But if you want to have a chance at literal moonshot stay in your job and swallow inefficiencies that come from size, ample capital, and no expectation of monetary profit.

Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by andi999 on Friday January 01, 2021 @11:10AM (#25604229)
Why 32 languages? I thought there is only one language in the country that put a man on the moon (apart from the one other language)
Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by zpeti on Friday January 01, 2021 @01:01PM (#25605125)
Even if I agreed with you, we are talking about the cutting edge of optimisation, of driving down costs, of doing things in volume. The exact things you also say a market is needed for.

We aren't talking about a military research project like packet switching, or getting to the moon for the first time.

Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by thu2111 on Friday January 01, 2021 @11:30AM (#25604364)
Research of most important technological inventions of the past century was funded by beaurocrats

Important defined how?

The car wasn't. The mobile phone wasn't. Computers in their post-WW2 form basically weren't, for the last half decade if not more it's all been private sector. Yes, DARPA did some very early work on packet switching networks and their work became widely adopted mostly because it was free: nice. But the moment these inventions started to matter, all R&D was taken over by the private sector.

Governments spray so much money at things that I'm sure for almost any broad category of thing, you can find something they funded. But that's no evidence that stuff would never have been researched anyway, given the enormous and long term R&D efforts routinely mounted by non governmental entities. Look at AI: government funded institutions are constantly lagging behind.

It sucks a bit that it's this way but if you are profit driven, you can't gamble 140 billion of your own money in hopes of developing new tech.

Alphabet alone spends something like $21 billion on R&D per year. It doesn't take many years of that to reach $140 billion, and Alphabet is not the only company doing basic research.

Having spent many years reading research papers coming out of both academia and industry, my conclusion has been that the best papers are always those with corporate funding - some academic teams receive partly corporate funding and these tend to be in the middle, pure corporate labs tend to do the most exciting work. The bureaucrat-distributed money often gets allocated for decades to intellectual dead ends nobody cares about, purely through inertia and lack of institutional incentives to maximise ROI.

Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by oblio on Friday January 01, 2021 @11:49AM (#25604516)
Companies rarely do basic research. Yes, there are exceptions.
Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by thu2111 on Sunday January 03, 2021 @07:08AM (#25621309)
I don't think that's true. If you look at the computing industry, virtually all basic research is done by companies or academics who are grant funded by companies.

AI? Basically all funded by the private sector and has been for a decade. Universities try to keep up but complain they can't.

Chip design? When was the last time academia contributed much to that? Probably RISC in the 80s? There have been tons of breakthroughs in basic research in silicon throughout my entire lifetime, all of them privately funded. For example look at the recent Optane DIMM tech (based on new chalcogenide chemistry).

Compilers? No, the most advanced compiler in the world is Graal, which is more or less funded by grants from Oracle. The second most is LLVM, which was originally written by Chris Lattner as his master's thesis i.e. he paid for it with his own student debt. Apple pretty quickly saw that it was good work and took over the funding of it.

PL design? Here, academia has indeed done a lot of basic research into various ML derived languages like Haskell. But this has largely been reviewed carefully and then ignored by the languages people actually use - it was basic research into ideas that didn't work well and not many people really care about. All new languages that have got popular for real-world usage in the past 10 years are imperative languages that trace their heritage all the way back to C i.e. Bell Labs (Rust, Kotlin, Swift, Go, etc).

The reality is, the computer industry demonstrates that you don't need government funding of basic research. Industries will certainly accept such research if it happens to be useful because they were taxed to pay for it regardless, but they don't need it.

Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by nickpp on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:44PM (#25604976)
Companies do plenty of research, just not basic, since they don’t need to: the government funds it instead. With money taxed from said companies, so...
Re:EU Signs €145B Declaration to Develop Next Gen Processors... by oblio on Friday January 01, 2021 @02:59PM (#25606325)
Yeah, us peons don't pay any taxes and corporations don't evade them...

All those taxes are collected from companies, look at the nice graph that proves it:

https://www.lynalden.com/wp-content/uploads/corporate-tax-ra...

I'm being ironic, the average corporate tax rate went from 40% in 1960 to 10% today.