News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by andygcook on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:11PM (#25574254)
BMI isn't a reliable indicator to gauge obesity. For example, Tom Brady at 6' 4" and 225 lbs is considered overweight, which is obviously not the case.

That being said, as an American, it really did shock me how fit the majority of people were in Italy when I visited there for the first time last year.

This New England Journal of Medicine chart really does a good job of showing that America has gotten heavier over the years: https://www.nejm.org/na101/home/literatum/publisher/mms/jour...

Source: https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMsa1909301

Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by tasty_freeze on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:27PM (#25574482)
Every time BMI is mentioned someone has to come up with an example of a body builder or fit athlete who has a high BMI. Yes, everyone realizes this already, and nobody who is in that position is going to be mislead into thinking they are obese. Sure, it would be great if everyone could do a caliper test or a water displacement test, but that isn't ever going to happen, and BMI is a trivial and good enough place to start.

Because being overweight/obese is normalized because it is seen everywhere, there are tens of millions of people who have no idea they are at an unhealthy weight ... they rightly think they look like everyone else. The BMI is a an easy metric to get people to evaluate if they need to do something about it.

Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by tokamak-teapot on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:45PM (#25574737)
It should be an easy metric, yes. I think it does help some people realise they are in poor physical health.

The problem with it is that it’s so commonly responded to with ‘muscle means it isn’t right’.

I used to be fairly fit and fairly strong and a bit too much towards the ‘obese’ category. I remember semi-believing it was muscle pushing me up the scale that far.

I’m now right in the middle of the ‘healthy weight’ category and I’d like to go back and convince my younger self that it’s time to fix the food intake and that muscle isn’t what’s pushing the weight up.

Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by VanillaCafe on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:54PM (#25574865)
You're not wrong that BMI is okay enough of a metric for most people. But, in terms of a metric that is even more simple (one simple measurement tool instead of two), accounts for athletic builds, and is arguably more predictive of health outcomes (example: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1071369/), it would be great if we could standardize on waist-to-hip ratio instead of BMI.
Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by t-writescode on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @04:04PM (#25574995)
Scales are common, fabric tape measures are rare; and, even men's jeans no longer correspond to their inch number. Learned that one the hard way this year.
Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by kbenson on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:35PM (#25574584)
> Yes, everyone realizes this already, and nobody who is in that position is going to be mislead into thinking they are obese.

No, but someone who works out the numbers and realizes that the BMI doesn't match them well, or their circumstances well, realizes it calls the study and what it represents into question. Using controversial metrics because they are easily available is counter-productive in the long run, because once people realize you were misrepresenting your credibility is lost. At best it's lazy.

Right now I'm obese. In high school according to the BMI I was almost half-way through overweight edging towards obese, and that was with very little fat, a very active lifestyle, and a visible six-pack. How do I consider studies that make claims about percentages of people that fit into those categories? As extremely ambiguous in what they are actually indicating.

Do Americans have a problem with weight? I think so. Does using false numbers to overestimate the problem help? I don't think so, especially when people realize the metrics leave a lot to be desired.

Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by tasty_freeze on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @04:40PM (#25575383)
We have an epidemic of overweight people. We can worry about misleading BMI stats when we have an epidemic of bodybuilders who worry they might actually be overweight.
Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by kbenson on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @05:15PM (#25575720)
Isn't that exactly what I'm addressing? How using misleading or bad metrics can lead to a mistrust in what is being conveyed?

Think "Reefer madness" and all the bunk science out about Marijuana in the 80's and 90's. Did anyone trust the information coming out at that time? I would hazard most in their teens and twenties didn't, which is exactly who that information was intended to sway.

Trust is important. If people don't trust that what you're saying is accurate because it's easy to point out the shortcuts taken that muddy the results, I think eventually they are going to look at most results about that subject with a grain of salt. At that point they've been trained to do so.

The best ammo against a problem is clear and accurate information. Not fear-mongering and FUD, or even something adjacent that's just imprecise enough to be easily called into question. All that does is cause confusion and arguments over veracity.

Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by viraptor on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:51PM (#25574818)
The measurements don't have to be precise to show a trend, relation, or infer a number of valid results. If someone calls the study into question based on using imperfect methods, rather than using those methods incorrectly... That's their opinion, but it's not useful.
Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by kbenson on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @04:23PM (#25575213)
They don't have to be precise to show a trend, but there needs to be some assurance that the measurements affects subgroups similarly and a measurement of how it affects those subgroups to infer a number of valid results.

How does BMI accuracy scale with age? How does it scale with different ethnic groups? How do these interact? How do you infer an accurate number without knowing these variables and accounting for them and the relative sized of those cohorts?

If the measurements to create the BMI were taken from a statistically valid cross section of the current makeup of Americans, then I would have no problem. But how was the BMI generated? When? With what type of participants?

This article itself notes that Asians experience relatively more problems at a lower BMI. Without knowing what the BMI is tuned to, how an we interpret how it applies to a cross section of Americans for a singular study?

As a measurement of similar studies seeing a change over time, I agree it's less problematic (but could still be affected by trends in physiology over time, possibly from immigration).

Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by worik on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @04:00PM (#25574942)
The fallacy of applying statistical measures to individuals. That fallacy has a name, which I cannot recall
Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by bambataa on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:24PM (#25574430)
Why, how many Americans have the figure of Tom Brady? Is that number big enough to have a meaningful impact on average BMIs?

I don’t understand why everyone is so quite to dismiss BMI based on edge cases, especially when the finding is backed up by your other evidence.

Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by lumost on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:30PM (#25574526)
It makes it so that people don't have a strong sense of what a healthy version of themselves is, and can assert that they must be healthy "as they are".

I've found Body fat % to be a more useful number, it's easy to understand what you'd look like with 10% less body fat - and you won't see many/any athletes with 30%+ body fat. When I first started tracking this I was shocked by the initial number (35%) and managed to work it down to 17% over time, my total weight didn't change by more than 5%.

Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by mmcconnell1618 on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:48PM (#25574774)
I think body fat percentage is a reasonable metric but even that isn't absolute. For example, studies on Sumo wrestlers in Japan found that while they had lots of fat, they didn't suffer from the adverse affects of obesity while they maintained their active workout schedule. Once they left the career and stopped exercising, the obesity related health problems showed up. Exercise and activity play a significant role in overall health, not just fat percentage and weight.

https://www.businessinsider.com/sumo-wrestlers-obesity-diet-....

Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by sergiotapia on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:34PM (#25574568)
Because it forces people to confront the reality of their obesity and how out of shape they are.
Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by sangli on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:22PM (#25574397)
BMI isn't a reliable indicator go gauge obesity FOR EVERY SINGLE PERSON. I would think most of us agree that the people like Tom Brady, Dwyane Johnson (the rock), or competitive body builders would be extreme ends of this scale.

For average people BMI is a reliable indicator.

Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by mirekrusin on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:26PM (#25574450)
That’s because muscles are heavier than fat, right?
Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by treis on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @04:12PM (#25575088)
BMI assumes you have an average amount of muscle. Any weight above that is assumed to be fat. So for someone like the Rock it treats a lot of muscle as though it were fat.
Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by rhino369 on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:42PM (#25574683)
It also doesn't a good job of modeling ideal weight for short or tall people. BMI models a human in only two dimensions.
Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by pmalynin on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:27PM (#25574479)
They are more dense, yes.
Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by diarmuidc on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:22PM (#25574395)
A professional athlete doesn't need a simple metric to understand if he's at his ideal weight. It's part of his job. The general public do need a simple metric which covers 95% of the population. BMI is that.
Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by Buttons840 on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:23PM (#25574414)
It goes the other way too. You might have a BMI in the "healthy" range, but actually have an unhealthy amount of body fat [0]. Of course, nobody puts themselves in this category.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_mass_index#/media/File:Co...

Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by t-writescode on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @04:08PM (#25575033)
That tends to be called skinny fat, and it's the worst feeling and takes a whole different kind of work to escape.

A lot of non-cardio gym time and protein eating.

Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by Sodman on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @04:03PM (#25574974)
Professional athletes, along with most people who work out 4+ days / week, have their own more advanced/expensive ways of determining their own personal weight and judging where they should be, factoring other measurements like muscle mass percentage. They also make up a very small percentage of the US population. For everyone else, it's a decent approximation of weight.

As anecdata - I'm on the opposite end of the physical activity spectrum to Tom Brady, I'm also 6'4" and the heaviest I've been is about ~210 lbs. I was definitely starting to feel "a bit too big" at that, and would confidently say I'd feel overweight at 225 lbs, so the scale doesn't feel massively miscalibrated to me.

Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by forrestthewoods on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:25PM (#25574446)
Define reliable.

If a metric had 95% accuracy would that qualify as reliable? I would certainly say so. Especially if the 5% outliers are not random but in fact an extremely obvious edge case?

I do not know how “reliable” BMI is. But elite athletes represent an exceedingly small percent of the population.

My intuition is that BMI is a pretty darn good first approximation. And instances where it’s not good there is supporting evidence.

Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by JackMorgan on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:39PM (#25574642)
No athlete I know bothers with BMI - it's meant for non-athletes. Likewise athletes often accept that bodyweight corresponds almost directly with lifting potential, but obviously we know that's it's only true for athletes, otherwise every obese person would be setting world record deadlifts.
Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by syshum on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:45PM (#25574741)
BMI is a poor indicator of Individuals Health

BMI is a good metric for POPULATION level studies, infact it was designed explicit for that purpose

So me calculating my individual BMI then making health judgments solely on that number is stupid.

However A person calculating the BMI of all persons in a Population then using those numbers to judge to overall condition of the population is valid

Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by mirekrusin on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:24PM (#25574428)
Same Paris, metro gates would simply filter out three quarters of population if installed in US.
Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by lldbg on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:30PM (#25574522)
Literally the exception that confirms the rule.
Re:More than 73% of American adults are overweight or obese by cma on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:22PM (#25574394)
For a population study BMI is fine, elite NFL players aren't going to move the needle.