News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chinese Demography by bhouston on Monday December 28, 2020 @05:36AM (#25558155)
Very few cou tries right now have a self sustaining birth rate. I believe no first world nation has a self sustaining birth rate.

This does appear to be a major problem everywhere that is going to be one of the big challenges we face in the coming decades.

Not sure what the answer is but off hand it seems that conservatives and those that are religious have higher birth rates than those who are secular and liberal thus part of this problem is clearly values/cultural.

Re:Chinese Demography by bluescrn on Monday December 28, 2020 @06:25AM (#25558367)
While it’s an economic problem for a while, a declining population is wonderful news.

It’s the best thing that could happen to reduce our destruction of the environment, and the pyramid scheme of ‘endless growth on a finite planet’ had to end at some point.

Re:Chinese Demography by bhouston on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:16AM (#25558619)
Declining birthrates are not equal across all demographics. I believe that because liberal and secular have the lowest birthrates it means the future of the world is religious and conservative, no?

This means generally tolerance and science literacy could decline. That worries me.

Re:Chinese Demography by simonh on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:29AM (#25558686)
Religious behaviour and attitudes are declining rapidly world wide. It turns out having religious parents doesn’t guarantee you will be religious. The same goes for political views.

I don’t know where politics is going in the short term, but I suspect it goes in cycles. Conservatism might be winning at the moment, but it will reach its limits, mistakes will be made and there will be a resurgence of liberalism.

Re:Chinese Demography by oblio on Monday December 28, 2020 @11:42AM (#25560613)
There are religious groups where what you're saying isn't happening. Only a very small minority leave the in-group.
Re:Chinese Demography by simonh on Monday December 28, 2020 @03:27PM (#25562854)
Oh sure of course there are local or specific exceptions, I'm just talking about global trends, but then I was responding to a comment about the world as a whole.
Re:Chinese Demography by AntiImperialis2 on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:43PM (#25565236)
No they aren't. More new religions and sects are being created than ever before.

Also, just because you believe your set of looney beliefs is not a religion does not mean that it's any different from any other religion.

Re:Chinese Demography by simonh on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:46AM (#25567949)
Religion generally is fragmenting rapidly yes, but I hardly see that as a sign of health. Rather it's a sign that more people are questioning traditional religious beliefs, some of those are latching on to new belief systems, but many are simply disengaging from religion.

I completely agree that magical thinking and conspiracy theory delusions seem to be growing and that's a real problem. I won't quibble about you equating it to religion, it's a valid point.

Re:Chinese Demography by 4gotunameagain on Monday December 28, 2020 @06:24PM (#25564547)
And that's the entire point. Opposing systems fighting each other for a perpetual oscillating dance around the balance..
Re:Chinese Demography by thaumasiotes on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:30AM (#25558688)
> I believe that because liberal and secular have the lowest birthrates it means the future of the world is religious and conservative, no?

No. There is a lot of conversion from religious/conservative backgrounds to liberal/secular affiliations. Religious/conservative demographics having birthrates several times higher than the mainstream is a phenomenon that's been going on for centuries.

Re:Chinese Demography by Melting_Harps on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:29AM (#25558682)
> Declining birthrates are not equal across all demographics. I believe that because liberal and secular have the lowest birthrates it means the future of the world is religious and conservative, no?

Poor, non and under developed nations with poor living standards are the only ones that still have persistently neutral to positive replacement birth rates. And, yes, this has many consequences, which his why I hope S. America, Africa and South E. Asia are the benefactors of a weaker China and they too begin to modernize as the whole Species stands to benefit from that and we decouple from the CCP's violent and belligerent stance against the World.

I agree that in the immediate sense a lower population is net boon to allow the Planet to heal itself from myopic Human action/pollution/over consumption, but as we're getting closer to becoming a multi-planetary species we will have to increase this population size significantly to meet the demand of those efforts and I think their is a significant lag time if the culture of having 2 kids per married couple and has been reduced to 2 dogs per married family for my generation and likely those to come and has become the norm in order to remain relevant in the ever shrinking labour market.

Re:Chinese Demography by yorwba on Monday December 28, 2020 @09:03AM (#25559202)
> I hope S. America, Africa and South E. Asia are the benefactors of a weaker China and they too begin to modernize as the whole Species stands to benefit from that and we decouple from the CCP's violent and belligerent stance against the World.

There are plenty of belligerent countries in those regions, it's just that they're not considered important enough for their saber-rattling to be noticed internationally, and their enemies tend to be sub-national groups formed around shared ethnicity, control of resources (drugs, oil, mines) or religion who are even less likely to attract attention.

By now, lots of people have heard about Mexican drug cartels, Kurdistan or Joseph Kony's "Lord's Resistance Army", but who cared about the Houthis in Yemen before their civil war turned into an international proxy war? Who could've predicted the civil war in Ethiopia? And who knows whether the Movement for the Autonomy of Kabylie, the Naga nationalist movement, the Wa state or the Free Papua Movement will be next to make international news?

Modernization doesn't guarantee peace and democracy; it also means higher availability of more powerful or more, cheaper weapons. Combined with population growth, even small areas are able to raise substantial armies, while declining resources (relative to population) incentivize wars to secure a larger slice of the pie.

I expect that we'll continue to see large countries only held together by shared colonial history disintegrate violently into smaller regions with more complex borders.

Re:Chinese Demography by selimthegrim on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:27PM (#25565090)
Nagas are pretty well in hand I think
Re:Chinese Demography by viraptor on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:33AM (#25558704)
> because liberal and secular have the lowest birthrates it means the future of the world is religious and conservative

Not necessarily. It depends on the environment too and can shift with new generations. For example Poland was nearly 100% catholic a few decades ago and there's still lots of that influence, but even the official number is trending down. (Which means the real one of people who actually care is likely below 90%)

Re:Chinese Demography by ehmish on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:25AM (#25558660)
Doesn't worry me too much, presumably conservative religious folk like being conservative and religious so they'll be in their own self made heaven and i'll probably be long gone.
Re:Chinese Demography by Shorel on Monday December 28, 2020 @02:59PM (#25562618)
Demographic explosion is a strategy several religions have used successfully in the past, in order to become the mayority of people.

Very democratic governments are susceptible to be overthrown by this tactic again.

That's why they do it!

Re:Chinese Demography by legulere on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:33AM (#25559051)
Children tend to be less religious than their parents.
Re:Chinese Demography by raducu on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:30AM (#25559032)
It depends on WHY the population is declining, isn't it?

If it turns out it is the modern way of life/thinking, then that modern way of life/thinking is doomed, isn't it?

Re:Chinese Demography by kijin on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:38AM (#25559071)
It also depends on HOW MUCH the population will decline. We're obviously not going to get to zero as long as people have sex.

If the world population ends up stabilizing around one billion, for example, or half a billion or whatever, we would be far from "doomed", only a lot more sustainable than we currently are. Absent a whole lot of global catastrophes, it might take a couple of centuries for us to get there. Meanwhile everybody cries bloody murder because they have no idea how to extrapolate current trends into the far future.

Re:Chinese Demography by arvinsim on Monday December 28, 2020 @11:56AM (#25560761)
> It also depends on HOW MUCH the population will decline. We're obviously not going to get to zero as long as people have sex.

We already have the capability to decouple sex and procreation.

Re:Chinese Demography by coddle-hark on Monday December 28, 2020 @01:58PM (#25562034)
I’ve yet to see a contraceptive that claims to prevent 100% of pregnancies.
Re:Chinese Demography by Noos on Monday December 28, 2020 @11:58AM (#25560784)
Actually I'd bet the less and older population, the less people will even care about the environment at all because they don't have the excess productivity to worry about it.

Environmentalism is a luxury good that people think about when basic needs are met and requires capacity above that. It's going to be hard to care about coral reefs when we need to devote more of our scarce young people to the practical needs of a gerontocracy.

Re:Chinese Demography by powerapple on Monday December 28, 2020 @05:52AM (#25558221)
If technology is on track of disrupting our society, countries with advanced technology and smaller population may be the one benefiting a lot from it. A smaller population means the whole expenditure of supporting the population will be small, job losses are affordable, economic solutions such as basic income can actually work better. In order to support smaller populations, the infrastructure needed for a robotic economy is more achievable. You don't need to pump the economy to keep people in jobs. The large developing economy with big population and less advanced technology will be left behind forever.
Re:Chinese Demography by raducu on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:45AM (#25559114)
Right, so actually a country with a population of 1 individual would benefit the most?

Who knew that the technology game will be won by some loonie that declares his basement a sovereign country?

Re:Chinese Demography by agd on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:32AM (#25558700)
A problem in some ways yes, but also an opportunity. A fantastic opportunity for the environment and to solve the housing crisis.

I’m still amazed how many politicians think a pyramid scheme of population increase is a good, sustainable way to pay for pensions and healthcare.

Re:Chinese Demography by raducu on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:35AM (#25559062)
The environment will need us to solve the mess we created. No way a declining population would be able to, we need at least a stable population.

The real crisis is the zombie crisis -- zombie empires and zombie societies that lost all touch with family values and morality, or mental sanity; the problem is all of the developed world is the same, so no winner to take over.

Re:Chinese Demography by cik on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:40AM (#25559088)
I'm in Israel - we have a self-sustaining birth rate amongst both the Jewish and Arab populations, both religious and secular. Then again culture here is very, very family based.
Re:Chinese Demography by JoeAltmaier on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:48AM (#25559124)
Yet even Israel has seen it drop drastically, not yet to settle. See this, graph at the end: https://ifstudies.org/blog/a-new-normal-an-updated-look-at-f...
Re:Chinese Demography by cik on Monday December 28, 2020 @02:35PM (#25562410)
Our birth rate has barely dropped. It's gone from an average of 3.11 births in 2018 to 3.08 births in 2019. Interestingly, the birth rate varies greatly by city, with Jerusalem's being twice Haifa's.
Re:Chinese Demography by JoeAltmaier on Monday December 28, 2020 @06:19PM (#25564501)
There were populations that were as high as 9 in the 1960's. All have fallen in line with global trends.
Re:Chinese Demography by docdeek on Monday December 28, 2020 @06:04AM (#25558266)
Israel (2.4) is above replacement rate, and France is below but close (1.9) for a larger developed country. Other than that, though, they are thin on the ground. [0]

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_and_d...

Re:Chinese Demography by oblio on Monday December 28, 2020 @06:27AM (#25558380)
Israel is that high primarily due to ultra orthodox Jews. Who might actually create a sustainability problem if they keep it up since they have many kids per family (4+).
Re:Chinese Demography by bhouston on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:20AM (#25558636)
So Israel's liberal/secular population is declining relative to the religious/conservative? That is my thesis generally. What effect does that have on culture/society in Israel?
Re:Chinese Demography by esarbe on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:34AM (#25558713)
Less tolerance across the board and strong tendencies towards a theocracy?
Re:Chinese Demography by JoeAltmaier on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:49AM (#25559131)
They're also dropping fast, just a little behind the curve but not much different from every one else.
Re:Chinese Demography by oblio on Monday December 28, 2020 @10:47AM (#25560065)
They are? The last articles I read (maybe from 2018) didn't seem to believe this would happen. Do you have a more recent reliable source?

Thanks!

Re:Chinese Demography by JoeAltmaier on Monday December 28, 2020 @02:58PM (#25562606)
Re:Chinese Demography by sudeepj on Monday December 28, 2020 @05:45AM (#25558192)
To add to the problem it is generally believed/conjectured that once a fertility rate drops, it does not go up [1] (barring few temporary spikes)

[1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4822437/

Re:Chinese Demography by arc-in-space on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:25AM (#25558661)
The paper you link makes the case that this hypothesis has no real evidence to stand on. I'm not sure how concerned anyone should be about this particular brand of fortune-telling.

Wikipedia states this about the referenced 'demographic transition' model. Note the last sentence:

> It must be remembered that the DTM is only a model and cannot necessarily predict the future. It does however give an indication of what the future birth and death rates may be for an underdeveloped country, together with the total population size. Most particularly, of course, the DTM makes no comment on change in population due to migration. It is not applicable for high levels of development, as it has been shown that after a HDI of 0.9 the fertility increases again.

Re:Chinese Demography by sudeepj on Monday December 28, 2020 @11:30AM (#25560497)
You are right. I should have pointed this out. I was trying to find citation about the conjecture I mentioned. I remember reading somewhere but only found this which says that it is an assumption.
Re:Chinese Demography by kace91 on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:04AM (#25558563)
> Not sure what the answer is but off hand it seems that conservatives and those that are religious have higher birth rates than those who are secular and liberal thus part of this problem is clearly values/cultural.

Mainly an issue with feminism being widespread but living/working conditions not having caught up with it. Society is set up assuming that the wife will stay home to care for the kids. As a result having children pretty much requires either enough disposable income to outsource caring for the kids (nanny, extracurricular activities, etc), or one of the parents staying at home.

For conservatives it's less of a problem because it's more accepted to have the wife stay home.

If we want birthrates to raise again we're going to have to figure out how to make having kids not be a stopper for your career.

Re:Chinese Demography by langitbiru on Monday December 28, 2020 @11:52AM (#25560716)
What about part-time jobs for mothers of young children? It's a compromise between working full-time and staying home.
Re:Chinese Demography by kace91 on Monday December 28, 2020 @01:45PM (#25561894)
Why mothers?
Re:Chinese Demography by langitbiru on Monday December 28, 2020 @11:38PM (#25566785)
It could be fathers as well. If a father wanted to stay at home taking care kids, I wouldn't mind at all. But I'm replying the argument above which stated "the wife will stay home to care for the kids".
Re:Chinese Demography by Miner49er on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:22AM (#25558645)
> Mainly an issue with feminism being widespread but living/working conditions not having caught up with it.

Are you sure that women entering the workforce wasn't _because_ of economic reasons? It seems to me that "feminism", as you put it, may have only been allowed to win, because it was desirable economically.

In other words, could feminism be a result of living/working conditions and not the cause?

Following this, people are having less kids because there is huge economic incentive not too.

Re:Chinese Demography by kace91 on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:34AM (#25559061)
> Are you sure that women entering the workforce wasn't _because_ of economic reasons? It seems to me that "feminism", as you put it, may have only been allowed to win, because it was desirable economically.

I'm not sure where the disagreement is there. Yes, one of the reasons women entered the workforce was the increase in income for two-earner households.

The point is that both having two earners per household and having good birth rates are beneficial to society as a whole, but we don't yet have a system where both are compatible; we just exchanged one for the other, as the negative effects of low birth rates aren't immediate.

The economic incentive to not have kids is where the problem lies, and it's what needs to be tackled. Flexible schedules, paid paternal/maternal leave, free education/healthcare, access to affordable housing for young couples... There is no silver bullet, it's a sea of deal breakers that need to be addressed individually.

Re:Chinese Demography by raducu on Monday December 28, 2020 @09:04AM (#25559205)
The reason humans have babies is sex is pleasurable and no birth control was available.

Nobody cared 50% of children died before turning 5, nor that they got shit education, nor that women were oppressed.

Our expectations and sensibilities grew much faster than everything else, not the least or biological natures.

Re:Chinese Demography by strulovich on Monday December 28, 2020 @01:36PM (#25561772)
Actually, some people theorize the opposite causation for one thing you mentioned: kids survival rate increasing means one could have less kids. In a world where half the kids don’t make it to 5, and people depend on their kids for their elder life, people are likely to have more of them.
Re:Chinese Demography by morlockabove on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:36AM (#25558723)
It was desirable economically to the upper classes. It was, obviously, bad for workers (two-income trap). The only way it would be a net economic positive for them would be through their share of gains to the overall economy... but we know that the median person's proportional share of the economy has shrunk, so that's a bust.
Re:Chinese Demography by Miner49er on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:44AM (#25558772)
> It was desirable economically to the upper classes. It was, obviously, bad for workers (two-income trap).

Long term yes. But did women enter the workforce because of the economic benefit originally? Then as women continued entering wages fell (supply and demand) and the working class ended up trapped, as you say.

Another huge factor is globalization. Women maybe had to enter to earn enough when work started being outsourced.

Re:Chinese Demography by oblio on Monday December 28, 2020 @11:50AM (#25560691)
I'm guessing you're a guy? Women entering the workforce was good for them because like any teenager knows (boy or girl), true independence happens when you earn your own money.
Re:Chinese Demography by morlockabove on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @03:34AM (#25567885)
Good for individual women who genuinely want to work, bad for women as a class when everybody does it because now even those young-ish married women who would have been happier raising the kids have to work because of the incrementally lowered cost of labour.

Some people making a choice causes a cascade, taking the choice away from everyone else, kind of like car ownership in the mid 20th century.

(And bad for all the men, too.)

Re:Chinese Demography by raducu on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:56AM (#25559179)
So the great news is as we become richer and richer, the economic incentive not to have children will be so great that we die out as a species?

"Feminism" is many things to many people.

To me it is like the abolition of slavery, makes perfect sense in a modern context.

"Feminism" as it stands today in the west, just like other "-ISMS" to me, are abominations, both the cause and effect, the narcissistic, entitlement and victim culture combined with hating (average)men -- it is the dragon eating its own tail that destroys the modern society.

Re:Chinese Demography by nerdponx on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:08AM (#25558582)
What exactly is bad about this?
Re:Chinese Demography by srean on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:26AM (#25559012)
The population shifts to the elderly. That can lead to reduced number of people who are actively contributing unless retirement age too is pushed upwards. Gains in productivity can offset this to an extent. Savings scheme where the inflow from new generation pays for the outgoing generation can become unsustainable if the demographics becomes top heavy.
Re:Chinese Demography by JoeAltmaier on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:50AM (#25559140)
But automation is proceeding at breakneck speed (especially this year). It wont take 'young people' to make the goods that everyone needs, not for much longer (years). And its actual goods and supply, that determine the value of money which is after all, imaginary points.
Re:Chinese Demography by inglor_cz on Monday December 28, 2020 @09:39AM (#25559484)
Goods are only part of the necessary economy.

A society with a lot of elderly = demand for huge amounts of daily care, which is hard to automate away, though probably not impossible. (The Japanese are definitely trying.)

The only way out of this conundrum would be a breakthrough in longevity, where people would live to 110 in a relatively good shape and being able to care for themselves, then die within weeks from some fast degenerative process.

Re:Chinese Demography by VelNZ on Monday December 28, 2020 @03:15PM (#25562742)
I had a flashback to Brave New World reading the last sentence. I highly recommend that book which effectively describes such a (dystopic) society.
Re:Chinese Demography by inglor_cz on Monday December 28, 2020 @04:08PM (#25563241)
To me, healthspan almost as long as lifespan would be a good outcome. What dreads me is spending several years in a nursing home, immobile, riddled with pain, low-key hoping for death.
Re:Chinese Demography by nerdponx on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:56PM (#25584026)
Sounds more like Soylent Green. There is a lot more going on in Brave New World than how people die.
Re:Chinese Demography by sudosysgen on Monday December 28, 2020 @12:12PM (#25560907)
I'm not sure automation is the answer, but if it did work then the people freed up from other jobs would be able to do that kind of care.
Re:Chinese Demography by inglor_cz on Monday December 28, 2020 @12:41PM (#25561197)
The question is: would they want to?

Unless it was very well paid, this job is far from enticing. Trying to keep a doubly incontinent geriatric patient from smelling for decades is an arduous and depressive job with no perspective of improvement. Geriatry as a subset of medicine is struggling to find new recruits, because as far as prognosis of the patients goes, it is the single worst branch of healthcare.

There are people with wherewithal to do this for decades, but this pool of willing is going to be overwhelmed.

Re:Chinese Demography by sudosysgen on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @02:11PM (#25573541)
If we arrive at the point where a large majority of production is automated, I'm not sure that will be that much of a problem.

Most old people aren't anywhere near that bad. For those who are, it will have to be operating almost on rotation and with large financial incentive.

Re:Chinese Demography by srean on Monday December 28, 2020 @09:49AM (#25559558)
For laborious work yes. For intellectual work not so much.
Re:Chinese Demography by oblio on Monday December 28, 2020 @11:52AM (#25560722)
Even for laborious work... How do you automate holding the hand of a lonely senior citizen or frankly, wiping his butt when he can't do it himself?
Re:Chinese Demography by srean on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @12:44AM (#25567104)
You have a point.
Re:Chinese Demography by nerdponx on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:34AM (#25559055)
Sounds like a temporary problem with long term benefits, to me.
Re:Chinese Demography by 88840-8855 on Monday December 28, 2020 @05:41AM (#25558177)
The answer is migration. Even Japan is reforming it's ultra conservative migration rules.

Let's don't forget that we are soon 8 billion people on this planet. Imagine 8 billion elephants or 8 billion Tigers living on earth. We are too many and that's not sustainable.

Re:Chinese Demography by inglor_cz on Monday December 28, 2020 @09:47AM (#25559543)
This answer brings a lot of questions with it.

The rise of the far right in Europe is mostly caused by clashes of cultural norms of native Europeans vs. immigrant Muslims.

As of 2020, it is not entirely clear if France, for example, can prevent emergence of dozens of alienated urban zones which aren't part of the national whole in any meaningful sense - a scattering of small Gaza Strips across the map.

Neither is it clear whether all of the grooming gangs (mostly Pakistanis of Mirpuri origin) in UK have already been extirpated and how long will the P.R. disaster be remembered.

This is a huge headache, because even in the Islamic world, high fertility is typical for backward, bigoted regions. Secular urban centers like Tehran and Izmir are no better than Europe, as far as total number of kids goes, so they cannot serve as a reservoir of workforce.

Total fertility today is strongly negatively correlated with education of women, which means that most kids are born in places hostile to female education attainment. Such as Niger, Afghanistan or Yemen. But these are precisely the places whose cultural norms work as a bombshell when suddenly transplanted into Europe.

Re:Chinese Demography by dominicl on Monday December 28, 2020 @05:58AM (#25558241)
Have heard this before 8 billion would be too much. I've learned human population is always in an equilibrium with the technological ability to provide for them. So agriculture innovation leads to further population growths. What hard limit are we running into? Why not further innovation and 16 billion?
Re:Chinese Demography by esarbe on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:32AM (#25558701)
Yeah, no. There's no equilibrium. What we are currently doing is predatory ecosystem exploitation where we destroy our own life support system for the short gain. All that loss of habitats and of biodiversity? That's going come back to bite use hard and it's not waiting for the far future. This shit is happening within the next 25 years.

To think that we are in any kind of equilibrium is to delude yourself.

Re:Chinese Demography by viraptor on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:44AM (#25558775)
Long term equilibrium for the species is not a great concept for us right now. At some point we'll run into an ecological problem wiping out most of the corn in the US for a year. That could be a potato famine level event, but we'll regrow in a few decades... equilibrium kept, but it doesn't help those who starved.
Re:Chinese Demography by mytailorisrich on Monday December 28, 2020 @06:06AM (#25558278)
We are not in equilibrium as the climate and environmental situation makes absolutely plain.
Re:Chinese Demography by lnsru on Monday December 28, 2020 @06:28AM (#25558385)
Maybe climate is in absolute equilibrium. Warmer climate opens new areas for living. Just look at the globe - there are much more land in the north than on equator.
Re:Chinese Demography by mytailorisrich on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:41AM (#25558756)
Destroying the environment in order to expand our use of resources is not an equilibrium.

We've never been in equilibrium. We've continuously expanded at the expense of other species. It's just that now the limit of this expansion has become very visible

Re:Chinese Demography by esarbe on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:28AM (#25558674)
Well, it's not. In equilibrium, that is. Whatever you mean by it - it's not.

What makes you think that these countries will let in the desperate fugitives? No, that won't happen.

Re:Chinese Demography by chrisco255 on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:23AM (#25558650)
Yes but despite the rhetoric about runaway warmth, northern Canada and Russia remain fairly inhospitable.
Re:Chinese Demography by killtimeatwork on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:35AM (#25558717)
I suspect it's a matter of time. However, from what I've read most of the soil in Siberia is very poor for farming, so I guess there won't be much food production coming from there even if the climate becomes warmer...
Re:Chinese Demography by kijin on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:58AM (#25559182)
If you really want to, soil quality can be fixed with heavy machinery and chemical fertilizers. But the new, warmer climate isn't particularly stable yet, so it's probably not wise to pour too much resources into that mega-project at this time.
Re:Chinese Demography by chrisco255 on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @10:43AM (#25570782)
Don't bet on it. We're still in an ice age and a glacial period will return before Canada and Russia become tropical paradise.
Re:Chinese Demography by morlockabove on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:40AM (#25558749)
Presumably you want every country to be developed. So what happens when every country in the world has a shrinking population?
Re:Chinese Demography by snowwrestler on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:50AM (#25559136)
Then we finally start to manage the planet as the finite resource it is.
Re:Chinese Demography by robjan on Monday December 28, 2020 @06:47AM (#25558481)
Migration from where? If all developed countries are below replacement birth rate the only solution is to remove skilled workers from developing countries which ultimately damages their economies.
Re:Chinese Demography by killtimeatwork on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:30AM (#25558692)
Migration across the world and across history was and is generally about unskilled workers. The skilled people are less incentivized to move (the in-demand skills guarantee somewhat decent living in most places on Earth), while for unskilled people from poorest countries migrating can be about baseline survival, so the motivation is very strong. Also, the unskilled people are more welcome in the target country, as they do the worst jobs for the least money [1], which basically increases everybody's standard of living.

[1] For example, there would be serious problems in the German society if not for Eastern European immigrants who take care of millions of older people for pennies. If these immigrants were not there, the older people and their families would have to pay 3-4x times the amount for German caretakers, which would of course break the budget of many.

Re:Chinese Demography by corty on Monday December 28, 2020 @08:40AM (#25559084)
That is quite untrue, especially for Germany. Germany does not only siphon off unskilled (mostly seasonal) laborers from eastern Europe. We also draw in a lot of their educated workforce, which is especially apparent and problematic in fields like medicine, where doctors and nurses wander westward and are the missing in their countries of origin.
Re:Chinese Demography by baybal2 on Monday December 28, 2020 @12:20PM (#25560983)
> We are too many and that's not sustainable.

Not a sound argument.

Earth can easily sustain hundreds of billions of people even at modern day technology level in supreme comfort. By some calculations, even one trillion is possible without having anybody switching to algae diet.

Re:Chinese Demography by raverbashing on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:29AM (#25558683)
Bringing people that share none of your values/cultural background? Thanks but no thanks

Which doesn't mean it couldn't be done, but not the way it is done currently.

Re:Chinese Demography by 9HZZRfNlpR on Monday December 28, 2020 @11:27AM (#25560468)
Maybe for America that is such a young country of immigrants all over the world but definetly the majority of world nation states don't see mass immigration as a solution to the problem.
Re:Chinese Demography by mytailorisrich on Monday December 28, 2020 @06:09AM (#25558294)
The answer is to accept and embrace the end of population growth, and even cheer for population decline.

This obviously requires a paradigm shift but ultimately can be a net positive for the environment, quality of life, and individual wealth.

Re:Chinese Demography by esarbe on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:29AM (#25558684)
While some population decline is probably for the best, we need to stabilize the population at some point. Otherwise there's no foundation for a sustainable civilization.
Re:Chinese Demography by mytailorisrich on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:32AM (#25558702)
Obviously. No-one is suggesting to make our species extinct...

But let's remember that we were less than 1 billion not too long ago while we're on course to be 10 billion soon, with individual consumption massive increased on top of that. We won't solve climate and environmental problems unless this is tackled. The aim of civilization is to make people better off, not to squeeze them into a dystopian world of overpopulation and environmental collapse.

Re:Chinese Demography by esarbe on Monday December 28, 2020 @07:51AM (#25558817)
Absolutely! I think it would be fine to go back to 1 billion, although the transition to a less extensive infrastructure will probably be quite rough. It's good that we already started concentrating most of the population in cities. This will help with the transition immensely.
Re:Chinese Demography by raducu on Monday December 28, 2020 @09:10AM (#25559254)
Has the concentration of population in cities helped us in the past when things gotten quite rough?
Re:Chinese Demography by esarbe on Monday December 28, 2020 @11:33AM (#25560519)
The most important factor in keeping people alive nowadays is infrastructure. We're not self-sufficient anymore and it's pretty delusional to think that we'll be able to move back to some kind of pre-industrial pastoral idyll. We are dependent on high-tech and that's not going to change.

The easiest way to make everyone able to participate in that high-tech is to have high-density population centers with little infrastructure benefiting the most people.

Re:Chinese Demography by raducu on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @10:25AM (#25570580)
This is only true today because infrastructure is made ridiculously expensive by the same overlord-leaches that benefit from artificial scarcity of real-estate of those overpopulated cities which enslaves people and is driving the birthrate decline.

A battery one order of magnitude better than what we have today would obliterate that need for infrastructure.

Internet from the sky, VR, remote education, remote(AI) medicine, flying electric cars, compact fusion power, would mean unchaining the whole world from the sociopaths that are running it today, but we can't have that, because the sociopaths at the top like centralization in order to leach off the rest of the world.

Re:Chinese Demography by esarbe on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @11:36AM (#25571538)
No, it wouldn't. Nothing but a miraculous fabricator that can power and fabricate itself would obliterate the need for infrastructure.

Let's just take one example; VR. For VR, you need VR googles. These need to be produced somewhere, in an industrial mass production because otherwise these VR googles would be prohibitive expensive. That means industrial scale energy production and industrial scale energy transportation and industrial scale energy storage. This industrial scale industry needs to be repaired and upgraded, probably by people. These people need housing, food, education, ... Now take a guess on what you need to provide each and every one of these? Yeah, right; infrastructure.

It's a rat's tail. You cannot get a way from infrastructure if you want any kind of technological civilization.

Re:Chinese Demography by oblio on Monday December 28, 2020 @11:54AM (#25560736)
We've never been in this timeline before.

Preindustrial cities can't serve as reference.

Re:Chinese Demography by raducu on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @10:29AM (#25570620)
Why?

Because the devastation would be unimaginable by preindustrial standards?

I don't want it to happen either, but that's not a valid reason why it couldn't happen.

Re:Chinese Demography by esarbe on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @11:41AM (#25571619)
Why do we need the infrastructure of cities to survive? Because we are too many people to live off the land like our ancestors were able to do. Also, we lack the knowledge to be self-sustaining.

Why are pre-industrial cities not a good model, i.e. why didn't pre-industrial cities provide the protection we have knowadays?

Exactly because we were able to leave out pre-industrial cities in times of turmoil. Since we cannot rely on our self-sufficiency to survive, we need to maintain infrastructure to keep us alive. Maintaining infrastructure is cheapest when the infrastructure is used by as many people as possible. Having a widely distributed population requiring well maintained, widely distributed infrastructure will not be possible.

Re:Chinese Demography by raducu on Monday December 28, 2020 @09:08AM (#25559235)
You can only cheer if you know you can actually stop the population decline before it leads to a catastrophic disruption of the world wide civilization, right?

Who and when will do it?

Are we willing to take away women's rights if its the only way to stop a population decline?

There's nothing to cheer if you really look into it.

Re:Chinese Demography by mytailorisrich on Monday December 28, 2020 @11:53AM (#25560726)
Not sure what or who you are replying to here, certainly not to anything I wrote...

Taking away women rights? Where does that come from, that's ludicrous. Countries where women have the most rights are the ones with lower birth rates as it happens, and for good reasons.

Re:Chinese Demography by raducu on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @10:36AM (#25570710)
I'm not sure why is it hard to understand the implications of what I said.

1. at some point we "HAVE" and humanity WILL put an end to birthrate decline.

2. "Countries where women have the most rights are the ones with lower birth rates as it happens"

Therefore, one solution would be to take away women's rights.

That's not something I would stand for, but for certain totalitarian countries, it would work.

That's a very easy solution any idiot could come up with, just like slavery.

The other, MUCH, MUCH harder solution would involve completely changing world order, creating a much flatter and equal society, which is IMPOSSIBLE to do by the current world wide idiocracy.