I didn’t read tfa, but my guess is that with more senses involved, you get better short term memory coherence. Waiving your hands around the board or looking at pen-paper and drawing also helps. When in doubt, walk. When it is really hard, bathroom.
Only if there are voices you hear in return are you considered "psychotic", with psychosis being defined as seeing or hearing things that are not real or attributed to self.
Our thoughts are real and there is nothing wrong with speaking those thoughts out loud any more than making a Youtube video for others to watch later (even yourself).
I'll pace around talking to myself when prepping for a meeting - it's basically practice for the topics I know we'll be discussing. I even practice responses to what I anticipate their likely responses will be.
It really helps because verbalizing something makes you think more deeply about how to communicate the idea or concept and will sometimes reveal gaps in your understanding or will reveal that you understand it but need to find a good way to concisely convey it to someone else who may not have the same level of expertise.
Works great.
Your boss might not understand
“Who should we give the promotion to?”
“How about Joe, he’s been killing it this quarter”
“That guy talks to himself. I’m worrying about him killing ME next quarter. Let’s promote Bob instead”
Sometimes i come up with a well phrased final conclusion, but that's more rare i think. Usually it's impossible to follow from the outside.
Practically speaking, it helps get my work done.
He does the same thing all the time and in one episode even so much as to leave a deep, donut shaped trench in his floor.
At home, this earned me the nickname "satellite". I felt uncomfortably self aware when I just moved in with my partner. Fortunately she finds it soothing.
Also, I sloppily "conduct" classical music I'm listening too if I'm working in something hard alone.
Having a private space is nice.
When I work from the office I take long walks outside when I need to think
I also "occupied" one (very) small meeting room and made it my private office, so I can close the door when I need it
But honestly sometimes talking about the problem with other people works as well as talking with yourself or the laptop
I work in an office but since Covid-19 I have been working remotely which has been extremely beneficial for me for this reason.
[p.s. I've gotten good result with elongated ovals too, btw. The main feature seems to be that the body is "going back to where one started". This seems to help the thinking process.]
My current apartment's topology is such that I can make 8's in it (while thinking of course). I'd never think a simple change in topology can make your thought process a little bit more interesting.
All my complex architectures and systems were also conceived while pacing, so I hear you, but I never considered walking in circles in a room.
Now I'm curious – is that better than walking outside? Why not walk in nature or a park?
I understand not wanting to walk in a dangerous / unknown area (the pace regime implies full autopilot), but a tiny apartment sounds extreme. And isn't the proximity of external tools – like a computer – distracting to your thought process?
Last time I started a new project and worked on its architecture, I walked over 10km in a single day, according to my cellphone pedometer. In a tiny apartment! This trend lasted for a month, after which I sat down to actually implement this.
I thought it was just me being autistic but it's interesting to know others do it as well :)
I never worked in an office setting, but I can only imagine it would be extremely prejudicial to people like me and the author. Restraining us to a table would limit our output for the sole reason we would be unable to pace and think (no space and too much social pressure).
Anecdata: sometimes I visit my parents and work from their place. I can't pace there because I don't feel comfortable doing so, and that alone is enough for me to not be able to tackle challenging problems there.