News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by yholio on Saturday December 26, 2020 @11:36AM (#25544439)
Sounds like a safety critical bug. Rotating tires and replacing them asymmetrically (for example, after a tire explosion for me) is regular practice. If a small difference in wear disables critical safety systems and engages them in inappropriate circumstances, this can lead to deaths.

It seems simple enough to detect that, on a straight road with the steering wheel balanced, one of the wheels makes more rotations on average; then you calibrate the algorithm based on that. Sounds like a bug in this very algorithm, or maybe some hardware defect on your specific vehicle (i.e a sensor) that interferes with it.

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by aidenn0 on Saturday December 26, 2020 @11:45AM (#25544519)
Many AWD cars require replacing tires in sets in the manual
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by ComputerGuru on Saturday December 26, 2020 @11:56AM (#25544609)
As a long-time owner of AWD performance vehicles (Midwest for you, possible snow eight months of the year!) I can assure that whether or not you replace your tires four, two, or even just one at a time, there are absolutely zero visible/immediately tangible repercussions and the issue described with the Tesla is absolutely not normal even under those circumstances.

As for the long term ramifications, you’ll definitely see increased wear/camber on the opposing tire(a) and I’ve read it could theoretically cause issues with the diff, but I find that extremely hard to believe at least for the cats I’ve driven, because the front:back power ratio is dynamically recalculated and changed continuously depending on driving conditions. If it were 4WD rather than AWD, that might be the case though.

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by o-__-o on Saturday December 26, 2020 @12:55PM (#25545055)
Okay here is anecdotal experience. I had a set of treads on my rear tire at 15/32 while the fronts where at 9/32. Viscous coupled AWD with traction control via four-wheel braking. I first noticed something was up when the car would launch rather quickly. I added an odb-2 reader and saw my AWD clutch was engaging a lot. Thought this was by design due to my heavy foot. Then the clunking started.

The AWD would rather stay engaged which puts strain on the transmission to shift harder. Over time this showed up as increased transmission temperatures. My transmission is sensitive to heat but has a poor design which makes any heat a very big deal. At about the same time I was researching new wheels and determined I could fit 9” wide tires in the rear vs 8.5” in the front. A staggered wheel set would give me more rear wheel power bias, but the closest I could get in tire size was still almost .5% larger in diameter.

In all my research it turns out you need tires of the same size within 3/16 wear of each other to avoid non-full time AWD transmissions from doing dumb things like my car does. You see, the AWD clutch simply engages a power transfer unit and then depends on ABS to control power sent by the differential to individual wheels. That system needs to recalibrate itself regularly and it does this when the clutch disengages. When it doesn’t, all sorts of warnings are tripped (in my car I went down 6 floors of a spiraling parking garage exit at 15-20mph and at the 2nd floor a “service stabili-trak” icon appeared on my dashboard)

In cars with a well designed AWD system this will not happen.. but most cars are not designed to engage in AWD for prolonged periods of time and are really there as a beefed up version of traction control. For instance my Torsen Quattro AWD Audi had full time AWD and never had this problem nor would a Nissan GT-R. But for that fancy Lexus or Hyundai AWD, you may want to make sure you stick to the recommended tire rotation schedule

To end my story, I was at the service center and they mentioned I should get my transmission checked out by the bigger repair bay because of the clunking. I suggested it may be the wear of the tires and they agreed to see if that solved the problem. New set of tires and the clunking, extra AWD engagement, and transmission temps went away.

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by ComputerGuru on Saturday December 26, 2020 @01:04PM (#25545128)
Interesting story. And yes, I was specifically referring to full-time AWD with or without a rear bias, like that in the Audi Quattro (who I personally think does an excellent job).

I actually don’t consider a car that doesn’t have full-time AWD to be AWD at all, isn’t that considered 4WD?

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by o-__-o on Saturday December 26, 2020 @01:46PM (#25545424)
I understand AWD to be exactly that, all wheels providing driving traction. We have advanced long from the Audi 200 days to where part-time AWD is as simple as $700 in parts (for my car).

4WD (4x4) is full time (typically selectable but cannot be changed while in motion). 4WD has a greater gear ratio to really put power to the wheels that have grip, so while all 4WD cars can be considered AWD, AWD cannot be considered 4WD. I’m sure some jeep owner can give a better rundown on why 4WD is named the way it is..

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by alistairSH on Saturday December 26, 2020 @05:19PM (#25546884)
In the US, 4WD (4x4) means when the system is engaged, the center diff is locked. Sometimes there'll be some combo of front and rear lockers or LSD units, but not always. When engaged, the center diff is locked, so these systems are typically only engaged off-road or in snow.

And AWD is any system that drives all 4 wheels permanently. In fancy systems, the ratio sent to front vs rear might vary from 50/50 to 0/100, but it's always engaged to some extent. These systems are safe for regular on-road use.

Pick-up trucks and truck-based SUVs usually have 4x4 systems (with a few exceptions like the Land Cruiser and Lexus GX which are both AWD).

Cute utes and cross-overs, plus the odd-ball sedans and wagons (Subaru, VW 4Motion, Audi) are usually AWD.

Edit - as noted in a sibling comment, the line has definitely blurred with fancy electronically controlled and viscous couplings, but generally "truck" = 4x4 and cross-over/wagon = AWD.

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by ComputerGuru on Saturday December 26, 2020 @03:38PM (#25546284)
I don’t think 4WD/4x4 is a strict subset of AWD or the other way around. One is typically manually selected, the other is typically always on at a certain ratio but (at least in modern variants) dynamically adjusted (or at least theoretically adjustable) either on a front/back or even on a per-wheel basis based on dynamic real-time feedback.

TBH the line has blurred considerably in recent years and what once would have been 4x4 (manually engaged fixed-ratio four wheel mode) is being marketed as AWD. I’m sitting in a rental GMC Terrain (very crappy car, with or without AWD) and it must be manually switched from 2WD to 4WD mode but it’s an electronic button (rather than gear selection lever) that can be changed at speed, and can also be used in 4WD mode at highway speeds without redlining. This is considerably different from body-on-frame SUVs/pickups with “true” 4x4 mode that have regular 2WD but can be changed into 4L or 4H to get different gearing ratios inside the transfer case for four wheel drive.

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by macintux on Saturday December 26, 2020 @02:03PM (#25545545)
> typically selectable but cannot be changed while in motion

Not true for a long time now. Manually locking hubs required egress while stopped but at some point 4wd tech progressed.

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by frankchn on Sunday December 27, 2020 @03:50AM (#25549789)
Yeah, the most advanced systems can switch between 4WD and RWD while the drivetrain is under considerable stress too. For instance, the F90 M5 can engage the front wheels on command while in the middle of a power slide and let the front wheels pull the car out of the slide.
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by o-__-o on Sunday December 27, 2020 @10:05AM (#25551498)
M5 is not 4WD. Just an electronically controlled clutch like my car.
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by thatcat on Saturday December 26, 2020 @06:56PM (#25547487)
there are different forms of awd. Some "awd" is mechanical with even 50:50 or a 40:60 distribution of power like the quattro system that have a center differential. These systems still work great with large differences in traction: if you put snow tires on the front and regular tires on the rear, you can bust some sweet drifts and drive right out no problem. I wouldn't try bad tires on the front though. Other systems use electronic sensors and have a front bias giving 80+% to front wheels while giving rear varying amounts when the front loses traction. It reacts much slower and there is probably a bit of over/under correction from the control system if the tires don't have even traction. I could see this leading to a quickly cycling clutch that would over heat your system.
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by Dylan16807 on Saturday December 26, 2020 @04:32PM (#25546602)
> In all my research it turns out you need tires of the same size within 3/16 wear of each other to avoid non-full time AWD transmissions from doing dumb things like my car does.

9/32 + 3/16 = 15/32 so I guess not

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by bayindirh on Saturday December 26, 2020 @05:42PM (#25547017)
Opel Calibra is extremely sensitive to asymmetric tyre wear. The speed difference damages the third, central differential. To prevent the problem, you need to rotate your tyres periodically.

It’s one of the main reasons why that car is notorious in terms of maintenance.

Too bad, I love that car though.

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by aidenn0 on Saturday December 26, 2020 @03:20PM (#25546168)
I don't know if it does or does not actually cause issues, but the manual for my friends Subaru definitely says the tire wear needs to be even (possibly in pairs?). It came up when she got a nail through one tire about halfway through the lifetime.
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by o-__-o on Sunday December 27, 2020 @10:08AM (#25551516)
Ugh this is my story right now. $500 cost for a new tire. I will probably get it patched and then put on a set of winter wheels while I figure out the next step
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by Spooky23 on Saturday December 26, 2020 @01:12PM (#25545185)
None. Arguing with Tesla people on the internet is like arguing with vegans... not a productive exercise for either party.

I have a guy at work who has been without a car for 4 months due to Tesla fuckups, and he basically defends Elon’s honor on the internet as a hobby.

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by donkeyd on Saturday December 26, 2020 @02:04PM (#25545552)
It's almost like arguing with any other fanboy on the internet. Maybe the brand doesn't really make a difference, maybe it's just the being of a fanboy.
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by throwaway0a5e on Saturday December 26, 2020 @02:25PM (#25545729)
Some fanboys are more numerous than others.

Personally I find discussing Toyota on the internet to be far less productive than Tesla.

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by bookofjoe on Sunday December 27, 2020 @09:07AM (#25551104)
Make Apple Great Again
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by falcolas on Saturday December 26, 2020 @12:08PM (#25544695)
The op isn’t in an awd vehicle. He’s in a Tesla with only RWD.
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by bookofjoe on Sunday December 27, 2020 @09:02AM (#25551082)
Whoa, wait! >... for example, after a tire explosion for me...

I'm 72 and have yet to experience a tire explosion or be in the vicinity of one. How many have you had?

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by iforgotpassword on Monday December 28, 2020 @03:54AM (#25557745)
I've witnessed one on a huge truck about 300m in front of me. It was loud as hell, could feel it in my whole body. I was super confused and didn't realize what happened right away. Luckily there wasn't much traffic and the driver managed to pull over safely.
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by nikau on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @02:32AM (#25579458)
Trucks use retread tires to save money with the trade off of higher blowout rates.

The driver could pull over safely as each axle has more than one tire.

This is also why retreads are not popular these days (or illegal) for car use as you don't have redundancy if a tire blows.

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by Denzel on Saturday December 26, 2020 @11:55AM (#25544594)
This is not a bug.

I also drive a Model 3, spiritedly. Of course, I’ve rotated my tires many times, on schedule, but I replace them all at the same time. It’s standard practice. I’ve never experienced OPs behavior.

The algorithm is such that there’s a limit to the amount of “slippage” it will accept before traction control engages. A difference in tire diameters, exacerbated by a hard curve, leads to more slippage than the algorithm is willing to accept. What do you think would happen if traction control was off? :)

Furthermore, there are unknowns here - OP hasn’t specified the diameter (between 2 and 8/32’s) of their old tires. They simply stated that the tires had enough tread to meet their personal standards. Clearly traction control sees the situation differently.

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by jacquesm on Saturday December 26, 2020 @12:03PM (#25544664)
Definitely a bug. If tires are within spec the traction control should not trigger, it should trigger when a wheel slips, not when it is in fact having good traction.
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by AndrewBissell on Saturday December 26, 2020 @12:46PM (#25544984)
A bug? In a Tesla? Naaaaaaah ...
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by speedgoose on Saturday December 26, 2020 @01:59PM (#25545521)
It's fine, they will update your car remotely and remove the bug. Eventually. By the end of a year.

Still want one though.

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by wkearney99 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @02:31AM (#25549505)
tried driving a Taycan yet?
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by speedgoose on Sunday December 27, 2020 @03:32AM (#25549713)
No, there is no Porsche Taycan to rent in my area. It seems to be a very nice car.
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by foolmeonce on Saturday December 26, 2020 @12:56PM (#25545062)
Why would AI or fuzzy logic need to be provided with perfect sensors when human drivers are not? If you break 101 times out of 100, whoever rear ends you is at fault, 99 out of 100, OTOH..
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by jacquesm on Saturday December 26, 2020 @01:02PM (#25545110)
Because traction control is a safety system and if it kicks in when you don't expect it it can turn a safe system into an unsafe one.
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by zeusk on Saturday December 26, 2020 @01:11PM (#25545177)
I guess people already forgot what caused 737 MAX
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by wkearney99 on Sunday December 27, 2020 @02:29AM (#25549498)
Had an '05 Jeep Grand Cherokee that LOVED to kick in traction control right at the critical moment of trying to make an abrupt U-turn. Like pedal down, lurch.... ummmm, think... ok, here's SOME throttle... while there's a SEMI barreling toward you... Ya learned NOT to try u-turns that might require haste.
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by jacquesm on Sunday December 27, 2020 @02:49AM (#25549570)
Oh that seriously sucks.
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by o-__-o on Sunday December 27, 2020 @10:15AM (#25551563)
My TC does the same thing. All cars after 2008 will cut throttle and apply brakes if losing traction. Turning off traction control disables this system until you press the brakes which then enables passive traction control (the car will not actively brake but will cut power)

Thank Ford+Bridgestone for this

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by foolmeonce on Saturday December 26, 2020 @01:34PM (#25545351)
Yes and a good driver can get you killed from good reaction time. Driving is a game of russian roulette that involves a lot of intelligences with poor senses doing random things.
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by jacquesm on Sunday December 27, 2020 @02:51AM (#25549577)
Yes, but you don't add extra complications to see if the drivers reaction time is 'good enough' or not, especially not since (1) this is a solved problem and (2) it is supposed to make you safer, not less safe. Tesla should simply fix this.
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by o-__-o on Sunday December 27, 2020 @10:14AM (#25551555)
Then maybe follow your manufacturers maintenance guidance and stop assuming all cars are made the same?
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by BoorishBears on Saturday December 26, 2020 @02:50PM (#25545924)
This is table stakes for TC which companies like Bosch solved and commoditized. I don't know why you're defending it.
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by dzhiurgis on Saturday December 26, 2020 @06:24PM (#25547293)
Sounds like fail-safe design. It decelerates instead of spinning out of control. You’re overreacting a bit.
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by jacquesm on Sunday December 27, 2020 @01:48AM (#25549360)
Traction control can selectively apply the brake to the wheel that it thinks is spinning too fast. If the wheel isn't spinning too fast that that can throw the vehicle into a skid (the reason traction control exists is to avoid going in to a skid).

So it's not just decelerating the vehicle, it's decelerating the wheel that it thinks is rotating too fast to make it match the speed of the road. When in a curve as described by the OP if the wheel is a front & driven wheel this could cause severe understeer causing the car to move further out, which will in turn cause the inboard wheels to slow down further relative to the outboard ones. This could cause a positive feedback loop. Note that if you start braking one wheel that's on a diff the other wheel will attempt to speed up.

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by t0mas88 on Saturday December 26, 2020 @03:12PM (#25546112)
It may be "within spec" for a Tesla, but other brands with traction control don't have this problem. And that is a typical issue with Tesla, they have too many software guys and too little real world automotive experience. So they'll create these kinds of problems by implementing their own things instead of going with proven existing tech.

The most rampant example was the rain sensor on the early model S. They decided not to buy the same perfectly working sensor that any German car had for 10+ years at the time, no they decided to implement the rain sensor by training some image recognition on the camera that's behind the windscreen. Worst idea ever, because it meant the 100k+ euro Model S had no automatic wipers for a long time and when they got there it was worse at detecting rain than the standard sensor on a 20k euro VW Golf...

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by jonahrd on Saturday December 26, 2020 @05:48PM (#25547051)
To specify further: this is a problem in Teslas with autopilot 2.0+ hardware, where they switched from 1 front facing camera to 3. That left no room for the Bosch rain/light/humidity sensor, so they put developed their own light/humidity sensor, but still didn't have enough room for rain sensing hardware. The solution was left up to the autopilot team since it was assumed (wrongly) that sensing rain using a camera was easier than using specific optical sensors designed for the task.

Source: I worked on the replacement TH sensor.

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by londons_explore on Saturday December 26, 2020 @07:30PM (#25547665)
It is an odd design decision, since I assume a rain sensor at its core is simply an LED and a light sensor carefully arranged. Total cost of the core components: $0.03. Neither need to be physically large either.

It's even more odd considering the cameras can totally also be used as light sensors (simply read back the exposure time for example). Why get rid of one unnecessary sensor without getting rid of another?

I wonder if perhaps it was done to force the vision teams to become less science/research oriented and more 'we need this result now, we have angry customers waiting' based.

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by 11thEarlOfMar on Saturday December 26, 2020 @03:48PM (#25546343)
Mine thinks that a chip in the windshield is a raindrop. I had to turn off automatic wipers.
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by m463 on Saturday December 26, 2020 @03:29PM (#25546225)
I believe tesla will recalibrate all this after you drive for a certain distance.

Thing is - they would get complaints because the system would disable certain functions with a message during recalibration.

I wonder if they have now turned the dial too far the other way.

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by Dylan16807 on Saturday December 26, 2020 @04:41PM (#25546658)
If they can't recalibrate in the background, that's an entirely different problem. It's not a matter of turning a dial, it's fixing a flaw.
Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by Dylan16807 on Saturday December 26, 2020 @04:38PM (#25546637)
This is a bug.

The slippage calculation should take tire size into account. Anything else gives you wrong numbers.

Re:Print this file, your printer will jam (2008) by moonbug on Saturday December 26, 2020 @01:56PM (#25545504)
uhoh. you're going to rattle the Tesla fanbois.