News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by mensetmanusman on Monday December 21, 2020 @02:46PM (#25498651)
This reminds me of something hilarious happening on Twitch that I recently learned from younger relatives.

There are normal people on the game ‘Among Us’ playing copyrighted music into their mic, so that if a celebrity Twitch streamer gets too close to this individual there is a chance their account would get banned due to the DMCA.

They are using DMCA as an in-game defensive aurora. Ha

Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by aryamaan on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:50PM (#25499389)
There is a joke in India. If you are in Airbnb and are concerned if there is a camera recording you, just play any song from T-Series label. They will find every corner of internet to get it removed.
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by sn_master on Monday December 21, 2020 @05:09PM (#25500214)
YouTube just mutes the music of that section of the video automatically. They only take the video down if there is video too. Maybe they used to take the whole video down in the old times, but nowadays they never do that.
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by gnopgnip on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @04:27AM (#25515947)
It depends on the rightsholder. They can take down an entire video and send a copyright strike to a channel for using their music. A few strikes and your channel is banned. But most rightsholders leave the videos up and either collect the revenue or mute the music
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by zbowling on Monday December 21, 2020 @05:25PM (#25500375)
same joke here to play disney music in the background of any risky videos you send your significant other so if they upload it to a revenge porn site later, Disney will take it down.
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by nezgar on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:19PM (#25502487)
I think you mean "risqué"
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by Aeronwen on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:59AM (#25504036)
If you're trying to keep it off a revenge porn site, it's both.
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by abiogenesis on Monday December 21, 2020 @06:09PM (#25500820)
Playing Disney music in the background of a "risky" video sounds... weird...
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by l3_ on Monday December 21, 2020 @11:08PM (#25502743)
let it go
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by kmeisthax on Monday December 21, 2020 @07:10PM (#25501367)
Wasn't T-Series started by selling pirated mixtapes?
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by 29083011397778 on Monday December 21, 2020 @08:46PM (#25501959)
Didn't Metallica make it big by surfing a wave of tape traders [0][1] before becoming the face of the Napster lawsuit?

[0] https://www.salon.com/2000/05/09/metallica_fan/ [1] http://www.metalforcesmagazine.com/site/feature-metallica-mf...

Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by dspillett on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @06:02AM (#25505048)
Got to love the chutzpah in the hypocritical disparity between the content and other behaviour of Metallica and their ilk.

RAWK THE SYSTEM!!!!! Apart from that bit of the system which pays for my flash car, that bit of the system is just fine. BUT RAWK THE REST OF THE SYSTEM! Just to be clear, if you rock the bits of the syetm we like, we'll be sending the big boys round in their fancy suits, BUT RAWK EVERY OTHER PART OF THE SYSTEEEEEEEMMMMMMMM!!!!!!!

Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by kmeisthax on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @12:33PM (#25519922)
I'm going to do something that 10 year old me would absolutely hate and defend Metallica... a little.

While it's true that they definitely did grow thanks to tape trading, Napster wasn't just a bunch of tape traders. They were trying to turn tape trading into an actual business that makes money. It would be sort of like if a record store decided that instead of selling CDs, they were just going to sell tape machines and CD-R drives and have half the store be open for people to trade CDs around. Furthermore, Metallica didn't just get angry that people were trading their old songs around. They found out about Napster because new songs they were writing were starting to circulate through it and wind up on the radio. It's sort of like if you were halfway through writing and editing a book, and then suddenly your second draft shows up on Amazon Kindle Unlimited.

T-Series and Metallica weren't doing the same things back in the 80s, either. Metallica was giving away their own songs as a way to gain publicity, sort of like the music equivalent of shareware. T-Series was just outright selling you other people's songs. There's a huge gulf between noncommercial sharing - especially if encouraged by the creator - and commercial bootlegging. The former is more or less just collectors throwing files at one another. They don't really harm the market, they were going to buy it anyway and filesharing is just a hobby. The latter, the bootleggers, are actually harming the market by trying to compete with the original creators of a work. 80s T-Series looks a lot more like Napster than 80s Metallica, IMO.

Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by dpacmittal on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:49AM (#25503324)
AFAIK, Metallica was already pretty big in early 90s.
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by harry8 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:58AM (#25504033)
Metallica got big in the 80s, that's before the lawsuit.
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by theshrike79 on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:47PM (#25499368)
The same is a bit of a joke for recording "home videos" with your partner.

Always play copyrighted music and prominently display Disney properties like Mickey Mouse in the video. If it leaks, it'll be taken down at the speed of light by The Mouse's lawyer army :D

Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by sn_master on Monday December 21, 2020 @05:17PM (#25500283)
Unless the website it got leaked into ends in ".ru"...
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by pas on Monday December 21, 2020 @05:44PM (#25500576)
So just scream Navalny instead of whatever you'd scream.
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by function_seven on Monday December 21, 2020 @05:58PM (#25500720)
Is this like some real life polyglot thing? Instead of a program that is valid perl, python, bash, erlang, etc.; you "taint" your home movies to cover as many jurisdictions as possible?

I'll try. Play the Frozen soundtrack, scream "Navalny", have a Winnie the Pooh plush doll in the frame, do some questionable saluting, and feature a poster-sized image from South Park S5E4 (or that Charlie Hebdo cover) on the wall.

Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by sn_master on Monday December 21, 2020 @06:23PM (#25500953)
Be careful about the last part, you might get more than you were asking for.

https://abcnews.go.com/Technology/story?id=4344105&page=1

Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by vagrantJin on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:39AM (#25504912)
Or play taylor swift.
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by rhcom2 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:39AM (#25503274)
Release the audio as your first musical track then file your own DMCA takedown when people repost the video.
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by spacemanmatt on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @06:20AM (#25505164)
Like it's hard to strip audio from video
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by theshrike79 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:13AM (#25506963)
Like people posting leaked porn would bother to change the audio or pixelate mickey.
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by spacemanmatt on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @01:21AM (#25514978)
If they wanted to damage their target, they have the option
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by dragonwriter on Monday December 21, 2020 @02:49PM (#25498703)
> There are normal people on the game ‘Among Us’ playing copyrighted music into their mic, so that if a celebrity Twitch streamer gets too close to this individual there is a chance their account would get banned due to the DMCA.

You mean “due to copyright law”. The DMCA doesn’t do anything to encourage the ban, it just stops Twitch from being liable for copyright infringement the moment the copyrighted content is on the stream at all.

Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by toast0 on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:00PM (#25498848)
It's not really copyright law either, it's just Twitch's policy.

DMCA provides a safe harbor for Twitch as long as they take down content in a timely fashion when notitified; they can put it back if counter-notified, and they don't have an obligation of prior restraint. They just don't want to deal with the hassle involved with accounts that get a lot of DMCA notices, so if you do, they kick you off.

Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by dragonwriter on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:07PM (#25498934)
Fair point. My point was just that copyright law outside of the DMCA is the legal impetus here; the DMCA, if anything, weakens the incentives to a ban policy, it doesn’t create them.
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by devwastaken on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:07PM (#25498938)
DMCA is the copyright law in question.
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by dragonwriter on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:11PM (#25498986)
No, DMCA weakens the incentive for Twitch to implement a policy like this compared to copyright law outside of the DMCA. With the DMCA, serial offenders are just a bureaucratic headache as Twitch has to deal with takedowns. Without the DMCA, Twitch would be potentially liable for copyright infringement at the first offense by a streamer, and facing much greater risk of large damages for contributory infringement for continuing to fail to prevent repeat violations by known serial offenders.

The copyright law motivating the ban policy is the basic exclusive rights of copyright, not the DMCA.

Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by josefresco on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:30PM (#25499205)
Isn't mic support 3rd party only? I don't understand how this would help a "normal person" playing Among Us - care to explain? My kids play but I've never heard them using a mic.
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by corobo on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:37PM (#25499264)
There's a mod that adds proximity voice chat to the game which a few Twitch streamers have started using after exhausting the vanilla game and house rules
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by boxmonster on Monday December 21, 2020 @04:07PM (#25499556)
I love how creative people are on the internet. I read something amazing like this just about everyday and is part of the reason I spend so much time on the net.
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by recursive on Monday December 21, 2020 @05:31PM (#25500451)
Any reason to believe people are any less creative off the internet?
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by boxmonster on Monday December 21, 2020 @06:30PM (#25501031)
I said I liked apples. I didn't say they were better than oranges. Did you enjoy making a negative reply to my positive statement, or is there something else that is bothering you about my comment?
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by recursive on Monday December 21, 2020 @06:55PM (#25501247)
You do you.

It just seems odd to me that peoples' creativity would be any different on vs off the internet.

I would make the analogy differently.

> People wearing hats have a lot of good ideas. I trust people wearing hats.

Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by boxmonster on Monday December 21, 2020 @07:33PM (#25501543)
The enthusiasm behind my statement was really about the internet enabling people to be creative in never before seen ways. I have a high need for novelty. Using DMCA as a defensive shield in games gave me the hit of novelty I crave, so I was feeling that when I commented. Ordinary life generally doesn't provide people with novel ways to be creative. Many people do it, but not in a way that is as easily accessible to me. Somewhere out there is a structural engineer with a solution that would blow my mind if I knew about it.