News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by dragonwriter on Monday December 21, 2020 @02:49PM (#25498703)
> There are normal people on the game ‘Among Us’ playing copyrighted music into their mic, so that if a celebrity Twitch streamer gets too close to this individual there is a chance their account would get banned due to the DMCA.

You mean “due to copyright law”. The DMCA doesn’t do anything to encourage the ban, it just stops Twitch from being liable for copyright infringement the moment the copyrighted content is on the stream at all.

Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by toast0 on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:00PM (#25498848)
It's not really copyright law either, it's just Twitch's policy.

DMCA provides a safe harbor for Twitch as long as they take down content in a timely fashion when notitified; they can put it back if counter-notified, and they don't have an obligation of prior restraint. They just don't want to deal with the hassle involved with accounts that get a lot of DMCA notices, so if you do, they kick you off.

Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by dragonwriter on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:07PM (#25498934)
Fair point. My point was just that copyright law outside of the DMCA is the legal impetus here; the DMCA, if anything, weakens the incentives to a ban policy, it doesn’t create them.
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by devwastaken on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:07PM (#25498938)
DMCA is the copyright law in question.
Re:YouTube Class Action: Same IP Address Upload Pirate Movie... by dragonwriter on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:11PM (#25498986)
No, DMCA weakens the incentive for Twitch to implement a policy like this compared to copyright law outside of the DMCA. With the DMCA, serial offenders are just a bureaucratic headache as Twitch has to deal with takedowns. Without the DMCA, Twitch would be potentially liable for copyright infringement at the first offense by a streamer, and facing much greater risk of large damages for contributory infringement for continuing to fail to prevent repeat violations by known serial offenders.

The copyright law motivating the ban policy is the basic exclusive rights of copyright, not the DMCA.