Re:Von Braun Class Station
by nullifidian on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @07:43PM
(#25450854)
This video by Columbia based researchers https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b3D7QlMVa5s says that Coriolis acceleration induced canal sickness could be a major issue, and we don't know exactly what humans can tolerate. In the worst case scenario such torus has to be about one kilometer in diameter, which is prohibitively expensive.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by goda90 on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @08:05PM
(#25451040)
The only experiments that we've done are earth based and involve horizontal acceleration. Sounds like we need to do some real life space tests! Maybe we can get something going with a central weight and a tether so the test pod can rotate around it at high speeds.
Also, I recall there being studies into changing how the inner ear is reacting to movement. Maybe someday space goers will have implants to calm the inner ear against coriolis.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by rbanffy on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @08:23PM
(#25451169)
An inflatable habitat could hold a small-ish centrifuge enough for some tests and to provide some semblance of gravity for sleep and exercise. If it gets really bad, the centrifuge can be dismantled and its remains used as divisions for what would be a very large empty space.
Tethering two Dragons together would be complicated and maybe require an EVA to attach the tether. The trunk remains attached during a launch abort, so it can survive 1g without flying away (the Dragons will need it for deorbit after the experiment). I'm also guessing they'd need some redesign, because you don't want to mess with the parachute fixation points and, even if you did, the "floor" of the capsule should, for this exercise, be perpendicular to the acceleration.
In short, I guess we need sci-fi grade engines that can pull 1g for weeks at a time.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by didericis on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @08:29PM
(#25451205)
I think you’d want to do experiments with two equally weighted pods on each end of a “salt and pepper” (see https://youtu.be/U-a_gtcftZg) type setup.
I hope to see tests in space as well. There’s likely some sweet spot that strikes a good balance between mitigating sickness, providing enough gravity to be useful, and being a reasonable size, and I think testing different configurations with a minimal rig where you change the diameter and rotational speed is the only way to discover it.
I might be wrong though. There might be compelling evidence there is no such sweet spot and that looking for one would be a waste of time.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by codesnik on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @08:00PM
(#25451002)
I once made napkin calculations that for 1g "gravitation" a station even about 50 meters in diameter would introduce coriolis force so great you'll have a lot of trouble even trying to stand up from a chair.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by aetherson on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @09:09PM
(#25451533)
Nobody knows what effects long-term exposure to low, but not zero, gravity will have, but assuming that it is substantially better than microgravity, stations with rotational gravity of somewhere in the 1-5m/s2 seem like they may offer benefits with substantially lower engineering challenges.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by firefix on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @08:04PM
(#25451030)
Man. Von Braun? That’s not someone to name anything after.
Please read Operation Paperclip by Annie Jacobsen.
What Von Braun did was beyond horrible so much so to make the death camps look less bad in comparison, which is really saying something.
They plowed through people making them death march then dig huge underground missile factories with their bare hands, then had them make missiles to kill their families and to help their enemies try to win the war, with the majority of them dying in the process.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by frostburg on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @08:07PM
(#25451060)
Among other things, it must be said that each V2 was completely useless to the war effort and cost as much as several tanks. They didn't even tie up anti-air resources because it was impossible to intercept one.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by Thrymr on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @08:46PM
(#25451330)
It also took ~30,000 potatoes to make the alcohol fuel for each rocket, while German food supplies were running low during the last winter of the war [0].
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by peter_d_sherman on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @08:12AM
(#25442075)
>"The Gateway Foundation was formed to build the first spaceport. To do that we must first build a few smaller structures. One of the most important projects is the Von Braun Class of rotating space stations. This will likely be the first commercial space construction project in history."
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by paranoidrobot on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @08:25PM
(#25451183)
Warning: the video on their site contains completely unnecessary and pointless stock images of severe medical conditions that are quite shocking. I stopped and bailed after the first few images.
Whatever they're trying to encourage support for, they've completely lost it as far as I'm concerned.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by lreeves on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @09:31PM
(#25451672)
It is weird to show but unless I missed something it seems like it's just severe water retention in the legs and a back rash, I don't think those are shocking but maybe I have an iron stomach.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by TimTheTinker on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @07:33PM
(#25450779)
Sounds like some great ideas for SpaceX to implement.
... don't get me wrong, this is really great, but I have doubts whether this company will be able to financially accomplish this without an already-established revenue stream and no previous projects accomplished yet.
Who knows, maybe they will be able to accomplish this, but if SpaceX's success teaches us anything, doing so probably requires someone at the helm with a stomach for huge financial risk as well as unique financial and engineering savvy. It also requires a clear roadmap involving smaller, revenue-generating wins.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by MichaelZuo on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @11:06PM
(#25452328)
It’s an interesting design for a Torus, seems technical and economically doable once SpaceX’s starship gets going and with some motivated billionaires/organizations pooling together money.
If it could even generate enough revenue to cover operating costs that would be a huge win and serve as great demonstrator for future endeavours. An ambitious timeline would be by 2040. Recovering the cost of capital may need a much more developed market. An ambitious timeline here may be by 2070, a full generation later.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by ahelwer on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @06:55PM
(#25450430)
Maybe we should stop naming things after a man who was not only a nazi, but a uniform-wearing member of the SS? A future-looking project should leave such things in the past.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by reitzensteinm on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @08:07PM
(#25451059)
I think this is a pretty good overview, an interview with the author of a recent biography. I am partial to your view.
I don't have a problem recognizing his achievements and celebrating his abilities, but using his name to honor him is going further than that.
There are probably still people alive today that had a parent that died in slave labor at Mittelwerk building his rockets. I can't imagine how awful this would feel for them.
Regardless of his achievements, his legacy should carry a stain.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by chadash on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @09:34PM
(#25451703)
> There are probably still people alive today that had a parent that died in slave labor at Mittelwerk building his rockets.
My grandfather, who is still alive, was a slave laborer there before he was liberated by the American army. His descriptions of the place are pretty horrific.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by ahelwer on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @07:21PM
(#25450667)
"His employer of the time" is doing a lot of work for voluntarily joining the Nazi party, later misrepresenting that fact, voluntarily joining the SS, getting promoted a bunch of times, and regularly wearing his SS uniform to work.
Lots of terrible people have accomplished great and useful things. Good for them! I'm not taking that away from them. Just leave them & their names in the past where they belong. This is standard practice in medicine, a field with its own share of past nazis.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by trhway on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @07:25PM
(#25450716)
> zero attention to his ideals and life legacy.
the one's ideals and legacy are worth less than nothing if it is built, with the one's full awareness and willful participation, by concentration camp slaves dying in droves from malnutrition, physical abuse and the hard labor while building those ideals and legacy.
> employer of the time
that defense line of "i was just carrying out the orders" was explicitly addressed at the Nuremberg trials.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by matthewdgreen on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @07:52PM
(#25450940)
The V2 was built using slave labor at Mittelwerk. 250 workers perished per day at some points and their bodies were incinerated. The entire factory was built underground to escape allied bombing. It is hard to imagine a more horrible place. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mittelwerk
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by zzzeek on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @07:48PM
(#25450898)
well they were and it was quite horrific!
> The record of Nordhausen is a most unenviable one, and we were told that 250 of the slave workers perished every day, due to overwork and malnutrition. ... They also saw stretchers heavily saturated in blood, a room in which there was a slab on which the bodies were drained of blood, and the incinerators in which the bodies were burnt.
> Wernher von Braun, the Technical Director of a separate facility at Peenemünde Army Research Center, visited the Mittelwerk on 25 January 1944,[12] and a 1991 author alleged he witnessed Mittelwerk and Buchenwald war crimes.[6]
but by all means name this space station after the guy who ran the whole operation and claimed to have no idea. because they just can't think of a single person besides him!
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by evgen on Thursday December 17, 2020 @12:07PM
(#25457507)
Maybe do a bit of research before asking a question that is both trivial to discover the answer to and which is phrased in a way that can be interpreted as dismissive of just how horrible the conditions under which von Braun's slaves were worked.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by AndrewBissell on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @08:28PM
(#25451202)
Not surprising! Ignoring and downplaying the crimes of Operation Paperclip Nazis is a well established pastime among U.S. historians. "A Secret Agenda" by Linda Hunt is an excellent read on the subject, and goes into lots of detail about the Mittelwerk rocket factory which Von Braun ran: https://wikispooks.com/wiki/File:Secret_Agenda.pdf
And if you think Von Braun was bad, wait until you hear about Kurt Blome (who after WWII worked closely with Sidney Gottlieb, the head of the CIA's MKULTRA program) or Klaus Barbie!
In the 1970s, former SS officer Otto von Bolschwing was made president of a California company by its director, J. Paul Getty, Jr. (Gavin Newsom's dad William A. Newsom was also on the Board). Although it should be noted they claim not to have known about Bolschwing's SS history: https://spitfirelist.com/news/ex-nazi%E2%80%99s-brilliant-u-...
Whatever you do, just don't go to Wikipedia to read about this stuff ....
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by rsynnott on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @09:24PM
(#25451620)
The Nazis used slave labour very extensively; it’s probably safe to assume that it was involved in most of their industrial production. In this particular case, though, it was extensive, well documented, and extremely nasty.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by friendlybus on Thursday December 17, 2020 @02:08PM
(#25459066)
There's a certain lack of credibility in this complaint when the space race and a great source of global unity was found in the moon landing off the back of the Saturn V. The Americans had the choice to erase werner von braun from significance and instead chose to benefit on a grand scale from his slave-built knowledge.
You're right Von Braun is part of the past now. He's apart of the Usa's past. It's difficult to hear complaints about his nazi past, long after all the hard choices about what it means were already made.
VB's work is inexplicibly stamped into space flight and trying to get rid of that influence now, is like having your cake and eating it too.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by ahelwer on Thursday December 17, 2020 @02:21PM
(#25459229)
Many other fields have this same problem with terrible people making foundational contributions. The usual compromise is to rename phenomena that were named after them, not name any new things after them, and let their name drift into history. The history of the field is there for anyone who wants it, but it is just that - history. They are not venerated going forward.
If you want to make the case that this field should be forced to bear von Braun's name as a stain, I guess that's a somewhat interesting idea but I think it would have the effect of improving von Braun's legacy rather than forcing spaceflight to reckon with its past.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by friendlybus on Friday December 18, 2020 @12:13AM
(#25464119)
I would let the things he did sit with is name and prevent future things being named after him.
White-washing your past after you make billions off the back of slaves he killed and his work, is just a little too much sting to bear. I don't think you should be 'forced to bear his name as a stain'. It's just reality for what your space agencies did and hiding it isn't a valuable addition.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by ahelwer on Thursday December 17, 2020 @01:17PM
(#25458427)
Actually no, nazi action does not have a good side. Nazism is bad, through-and-through. Any benefits it purports to have for the people it doesn't kill is predicated on the murder & oppression of the people it does kill. You are a nazi apologist and should think long & hard about why you believe these things.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by lreeves on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @09:34PM
(#25451698)
Completely tasteless, I really don't get why you would put any effort into this project and name it after a Nazi (unless, and I'm being extra cynical here, that's the way they lean??)
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by perennate on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @08:26PM
(#25451187)
Why quote that when the Wikipedia article that it's from is titled "rotating wheel space station"? Rotating wheel is more descriptive than Von Braun or Tsiolkovsky or Potočnik.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by rsynnott on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @09:30PM
(#25451660)
Tsiolkovsky lived in the Soviet Union, where he worked as a maths teacher. Von Braun was a member of the Nazi party and SS who made weapons with an enormous slave labour force; by some estimates more people died making the things than were killed by them.
Personally, I’d probably go for the maths teacher, when it comes to naming stuff.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by gnarbarian on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @08:37PM
(#25451262)
If that's your actual beef, Forced Labor Camps/ Gulags were far more heavily used by the Soviet Union than by the Nazis. They were also used to produce weapons.
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by rsynnott on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @09:32PM
(#25451676)
“Far more heavily used” is incorrect (particularly in Tsiolkovsky‘s time; they became a big deal a bit later), but yes, the gulags existed. Tsiolkovsky wasn’t personally involved with them, though (he was a maths teacher).
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by avmich on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @10:29PM
(#25452107)
According to Chertok, GULAG workforce wasn't used at least when Baykonur, a significant project, was being built. It was direct involvement of Army corps used there.
Imprisoned labor force was used in WWII time Soviet aviation and rocketry development (Tupolev, Glushko, Korolyov). Other large projects were possibly too technical, challenging to employ forced labor?..
Re:Von Braun Class Station
by elil17 on Wednesday December 16, 2020 @08:35PM
(#25451246)
Sorry to be a little pedantic but genocide specifically means mass killing based on race, ethnicity, or nationality. The word was coined in response to the Nazi Holocaust because the systemtimatic, ethnically motivated killings were considered to be so abhorrent. There’s no such thing as genocide based on political affiliation.
"All early drafts of the U.N. genocide convention included social and political groups in its definition. But one hand that wasn’t in the room guided the pen. The Soviet delegation vetoed any definition of genocide that might include the actions of its leader, Joseph Stalin. The Allies, exhausted by war, were loyal to their Soviet allies – to the detriment of subsequent generations.
Naimark argues that that the narrow definition of genocide is the dictator’s unacknowledged legacy to us today."
Also, I recall there being studies into changing how the inner ear is reacting to movement. Maybe someday space goers will have implants to calm the inner ear against coriolis.
Tethering two Dragons together would be complicated and maybe require an EVA to attach the tether. The trunk remains attached during a launch abort, so it can survive 1g without flying away (the Dragons will need it for deorbit after the experiment). I'm also guessing they'd need some redesign, because you don't want to mess with the parachute fixation points and, even if you did, the "floor" of the capsule should, for this exercise, be perpendicular to the acceleration.
In short, I guess we need sci-fi grade engines that can pull 1g for weeks at a time.
I hope to see tests in space as well. There’s likely some sweet spot that strikes a good balance between mitigating sickness, providing enough gravity to be useful, and being a reasonable size, and I think testing different configurations with a minimal rig where you change the diameter and rotational speed is the only way to discover it.
I might be wrong though. There might be compelling evidence there is no such sweet spot and that looking for one would be a waste of time.
Yes, that's why Steve Jobs built his with a .5km diameter. ;-)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Park
Please read Operation Paperclip by Annie Jacobsen.
What Von Braun did was beyond horrible so much so to make the death camps look less bad in comparison, which is really saying something.
They plowed through people making them death march then dig huge underground missile factories with their bare hands, then had them make missiles to kill their families and to help their enemies try to win the war, with the majority of them dying in the process.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/V-2_rocket
Whatever they're trying to encourage support for, they've completely lost it as far as I'm concerned.
... don't get me wrong, this is really great, but I have doubts whether this company will be able to financially accomplish this without an already-established revenue stream and no previous projects accomplished yet.
Who knows, maybe they will be able to accomplish this, but if SpaceX's success teaches us anything, doing so probably requires someone at the helm with a stomach for huge financial risk as well as unique financial and engineering savvy. It also requires a clear roadmap involving smaller, revenue-generating wins.
If it could even generate enough revenue to cover operating costs that would be a huge win and serve as great demonstrator for future endeavours. An ambitious timeline would be by 2040. Recovering the cost of capital may need a much more developed market. An ambitious timeline here may be by 2070, a full generation later.
It is not known what level of gravity attenuates the health effects to what degree.
This kind of a structure is going to be flimsy. An odd number of spokes like five would lessen the chance of harmonic vibrations.
I don't have a problem recognizing his achievements and celebrating his abilities, but using his name to honor him is going further than that.
There are probably still people alive today that had a parent that died in slave labor at Mittelwerk building his rockets. I can't imagine how awful this would feel for them.
Regardless of his achievements, his legacy should carry a stain.
https://www.airspacemag.com/space/a-amp-s-interview-michael-...
My grandfather, who is still alive, was a slave laborer there before he was liberated by the American army. His descriptions of the place are pretty horrific.
https://www.nasa.gov/centers/marshall/history/vonbraun/bio.h...
Lots of terrible people have accomplished great and useful things. Good for them! I'm not taking that away from them. Just leave them & their names in the past where they belong. This is standard practice in medicine, a field with its own share of past nazis.
the one's ideals and legacy are worth less than nothing if it is built, with the one's full awareness and willful participation, by concentration camp slaves dying in droves from malnutrition, physical abuse and the hard labor while building those ideals and legacy.
> employer of the time
that defense line of "i was just carrying out the orders" was explicitly addressed at the Nuremberg trials.
> The record of Nordhausen is a most unenviable one, and we were told that 250 of the slave workers perished every day, due to overwork and malnutrition. ... They also saw stretchers heavily saturated in blood, a room in which there was a slab on which the bodies were drained of blood, and the incinerators in which the bodies were burnt.
> Wernher von Braun, the Technical Director of a separate facility at Peenemünde Army Research Center, visited the Mittelwerk on 25 January 1944,[12] and a 1991 author alleged he witnessed Mittelwerk and Buchenwald war crimes.[6]
but by all means name this space station after the guy who ran the whole operation and claimed to have no idea. because they just can't think of a single person besides him!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mittelwerk
And if you think Von Braun was bad, wait until you hear about Kurt Blome (who after WWII worked closely with Sidney Gottlieb, the head of the CIA's MKULTRA program) or Klaus Barbie!
In the 1970s, former SS officer Otto von Bolschwing was made president of a California company by its director, J. Paul Getty, Jr. (Gavin Newsom's dad William A. Newsom was also on the Board). Although it should be noted they claim not to have known about Bolschwing's SS history: https://spitfirelist.com/news/ex-nazi%E2%80%99s-brilliant-u-...
Whatever you do, just don't go to Wikipedia to read about this stuff ....
You're right Von Braun is part of the past now. He's apart of the Usa's past. It's difficult to hear complaints about his nazi past, long after all the hard choices about what it means were already made.
VB's work is inexplicibly stamped into space flight and trying to get rid of that influence now, is like having your cake and eating it too.
If you want to make the case that this field should be forced to bear von Braun's name as a stain, I guess that's a somewhat interesting idea but I think it would have the effect of improving von Braun's legacy rather than forcing spaceflight to reckon with its past.
White-washing your past after you make billions off the back of slaves he killed and his work, is just a little too much sting to bear. I don't think you should be 'forced to bear his name as a stain'. It's just reality for what your space agencies did and hiding it isn't a valuable addition.
Not even that, using that name, doesn't necessarily mean to honor nazi.
"There's a difference between supporting nazism and choosing to honor a nazi, sure, but we shouldn't do either."
Using von Braun's name isn't "honoring nazi action", but it is honoring a nazi. Not sure where this isn't connecting with you.
even when it is honoring nazi, doesn't necessarily mean honoring its action.
even when it is honoring nazi action, doesn't necessarily mean honoring its bad action
Even nazi can have its good side.
Likewise, you should think long & hard about why you believe what you believed.
"Originally proposed by Konstantin Tsiolkovsky in 1903, the idea was expanded by Herman Potočnik in 1929."
Personally, I’d probably go for the maths teacher, when it comes to naming stuff.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gulag#Economic_role
Imprisoned labor force was used in WWII time Soviet aviation and rocketry development (Tupolev, Glushko, Korolyov). Other large projects were possibly too technical, challenging to employ forced labor?..
https://news.stanford.edu/2010/09/23/naimark-stalin-genocide...
"All early drafts of the U.N. genocide convention included social and political groups in its definition. But one hand that wasn’t in the room guided the pen. The Soviet delegation vetoed any definition of genocide that might include the actions of its leader, Joseph Stalin. The Allies, exhausted by war, were loyal to their Soviet allies – to the detriment of subsequent generations.
Naimark argues that that the narrow definition of genocide is the dictator’s unacknowledged legacy to us today."