News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Preps Next Mac Chips with Aim to Outclass Highest-E... by gameswithgo on Monday December 07, 2020 @11:50AM (#25333898)
If they stick with UMA, gpu performance is going to be severely limited, unless they can make the unified memory GDDR6 or something.
Re:Apple Preps Next Mac Chips with Aim to Outclass Highest-E... by ksec on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:11PM (#25334153)
I would love to know as well. I think it could be HBM2, something similar to Fujitsu A64FX [1], the problem with both GDDR6 and HMB2 is that are limited in capacity to ~64GB, or at best 128GB. Which is far from the 1.5 TB of memory the current Mac Pro is capable of.

[1] https://www.anandtech.com/show/15885/hpc-systems-special-off...

Re:Apple Preps Next Mac Chips with Aim to Outclass Highest-E... by dylan604 on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:14PM (#25334189)
What if you gave the GPU its own dedicated memory again?
Re:Apple Preps Next Mac Chips with Aim to Outclass Highest-E... by ksec on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:20PM (#25334275)
Then it would make sense to have the two chip separate and not on the same Die. Which is essentially what the current PC system are doing. The whole hypotheses is built on Mark Gurman's suggestion of Mac Pro using something similar to SoC like the current M1.
Re:Apple Preps Next Mac Chips with Aim to Outclass Highest-E... by dylan604 on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:27PM (#25334372)
Why? Clearly, I'm not a chip designer, so maybe it's a dumb question. If you can place GPU cores, CPU cores, Neural Engine, and RAM on the same die, why can't you then use a second bank of RAM dedicated for the GPU cores? Why would this not be considered similar?
Re:Apple Preps Next Mac Chips with Aim to Outclass Highest-E... by gameswithgo on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:39PM (#25335436)
Whether CPU and GPU share ram is orthogonal to whether the gpu and cpu are on the same die. You can do any combination of same die same ram, different die same ram, etc etc.

The advantage of GPU having it's own memory is you can use super high throughput ram that the GPU needs, while using higher capacity/lower energy/cheaper ram for the cpu.

The downside of using separate ram is that you have to shuttle data back and forth from one ram to the other quite a bit, as well you get less flexibility in how your total memory is used.

Re:Apple Preps Next Mac Chips with Aim to Outclass Highest-E... by wmf on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:56PM (#25334806)
There's nothing stopping a chip from having HBM and, say, DDR5 DIMM slots but that has only been done once before by a doomed Xeon Phi.

It's more likely that the future Mac Pro will use Lifuka which everyone in this thread is ignoring.

Re:Apple Preps Next Mac Chips with Aim to Outclass Highest-E... by ksec on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @05:46AM (#25343763)
Because Lifuka; the GPU, hasn't had any other source other than the first Taiwanese publication. And those publication has been known to pop up all kinds of rumours only to pump up TSMC's stock price. And has relatively poor track record of any Apple information, or as a matter of fact, any information.

It would be interesting if Apple did make a discrete GPU, that would means they are making a separate GPU die for their Mac Pro and iMac with volume estimated to be no more than 1M unit per year. It makes sense from a technical perspective, it surely doesn't from a cost perspective. Although Apple could happily charge $1000 just for the GPU to make up for ROI.

Re:Apple Preps Next Mac Chips with Aim to Outclass Highest-E... by wmf on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @01:02PM (#25349014)
Yeah, it worries me a little that Apple thinks they can charge anything for the Mac Pro and probably iMac Pro. $10,000 starting price anyone?
Re:Apple Preps Next Mac Chips with Aim to Outclass Highest-E... by marmaduke on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:43PM (#25335480)
Xeon Phi is actually a pretty nice system to work with but as picky about performance as a GPU while more expensive and harder to find. Combining regular tool chains for code with high core count and SMT on top of AVX512 was nice. 68 cores, 4 way SMT, and 16 way SIMD, provides 4k “threads” in the GPU sense, except the memory hierarchy isn’t nearly as harsh because of the MCDRAM.
Re:Apple Preps Next Mac Chips with Aim to Outclass Highest-E... by an_opabinia on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:03PM (#25334052)
Why couldn’t they? The 3090 ships with 24GB of GDDR RAM today.
Re:Apple Preps Next Mac Chips with Aim to Outclass Highest-E... by wmf on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:57PM (#25334814)
A future Mac Pro should support 1-2 TB of RAM which isn't really possible with GDDR.
Re:Apple Preps Next Mac Chips with Aim to Outclass Highest-E... by jmnicolas on Monday December 07, 2020 @02:14PM (#25335902)
Given the premium Apple charges for RAM, I don't even want to "napkin calculate" how much a 2 TB ram Mac pro would cost!
Re:Apple Preps Next Mac Chips with Aim to Outclass Highest-E... by zimpenfish on Monday December 07, 2020 @03:06PM (#25336613)
It was £200 to go from 8GB to 16GB which makes 2TB ... £51,200 or thereabouts.
Re:Apple Preps Next Mac Chips with Aim to Outclass Highest-E... by rthille on Monday December 07, 2020 @07:53PM (#25340061)
Well, on the current Mac Pro, going from 32GB to 1.5TB is $25K, but you also have to upgrade to the higher spec CPU @ $6K.