News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by Slartie on Sunday November 29, 2020 @08:34AM (#25245025)
If I were Canon, I would make this guy a generous job offer to integrate a better stock heat spreading solution and optional external cooling into future camera models.
Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by robin_reala on Sunday November 29, 2020 @08:41AM (#25245052)
Why? He’s just hacked on an external cooling system that is in no way meeting the basic quality requirements of a production device. For that you’d want to hire a heat transfer engineer with experience of designing small-sized passive solutions, and with both a valid work visa for Japan and fluency in Japanese.

Kudos to the guy for debugging his particular problem, but that doesn’t make a product.

Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by grenoire on Sunday November 29, 2020 @08:45AM (#25245066)
His practical business solution to it is quite sensible and likely overlooked: "Matt also believes that Canon could have designed the camera to dump the heat toward the bottom of the camera and then sold a separate base attachment for videographers that provides vastly extended recording times."

In the video he more specifically describes how it could be possible to use the mounting point's metal base to transmit heat to a mounted cooling attachment.

Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by Rillen on Sunday November 29, 2020 @09:14AM (#25245202)
Its quite clear that canon engineeres or managers are aware how to build it like this.

I haven't even started watching this video and had the same thought of transporting the heat through the bottom.

Whatever made canon made it like this, was on purpose.

Either the concentrated on picture for the most time and realized to late and it would have required rebuilding core parts and not getting it out in time or they will bring out a camera/pro version to this with unlimited 8k recording and with a higher price.

The assumption that a hobby engineer can solve this issue while canon can't, is not realistic.

Based alone on the original firmware approach, i would argue that time or priority was the issue.

Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by chrismorgan on Sunday November 29, 2020 @09:23AM (#25245256)
Yeah, no way they overlooked something like that. I had my Sony α6100 overheat within 20 minutes on mere 1080p video when the ambient temperature was at least 45°C. When these things run hot, it’s easy to feel where the hottest areas of the body are, and attaching a heatsink is obvious, and at that time, dumping heat to the tripod mount was the first thing that occurred to me when I contemplated how I might do it.
Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by samatman on Sunday November 29, 2020 @03:13PM (#25247671)
The flip side of this is that Sony (finally) made an APS-C mirrorless, in the α6600, which has a recording time that's only limited by power or storage.

So it was never impossible, and it isn't just a Nerf to segment customers into the cinema bracket. It's just an area where they're willing to compromise.

Without IBIS, the αN < 6500s aren't great for many video applications, they're photo cameras which can also take some video. I suspect that Sony just didn't realize the degree to which the YouTube generation would be using their entry-level mirrorless systems for extensive video. Consider that it took them a generation to make flip screens standard, and that they bumped the battery size and ability to record indefinitely on (only) the model which has IBIS: that's a nudge, saying "If you want to record a lot of video, the α6600 is the model you want".

Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by chrismorgan on Sunday November 29, 2020 @03:39PM (#25247886)
It was the α6000, α6300 and α6500 that were time-limited, because they generated more heat in their video encoding. The newer α6100, α6400 and α6600 don’t run so hot, using a newer and better chip for the encoding. You’re wrong about the ability to record indefinitely: this is not specific to the α6600; all three of the newer generation get it. I’m recording 100 minute videos weekly on my α6100 with no sweat now (plugged in by USB, otherwise the battery will be down to 5–10% by this time—with the camera fixed in place for these recordings I also don’t care about image stabilisation, whether in-lens or in-body), it was only having trouble in the middle of summer when the ambient temperature was at least 45°C.
Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by samatman on Sunday November 29, 2020 @04:07PM (#25248096)
Alright, good to know.

I think that's more evidence that the overheating problem wasn't a deliberate attempt to segment customers into the cinema bracket, but rather something Sony didn't realize would be such a problem, because who is going to want to film 100 minutes on their photo camera? Practically everyone as it turns out.

Yeah, they could have and should have added better heat dissipation: but they can and should make (much) better software as well, and don't, because... it's Sony.

Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by grenoire on Sunday November 29, 2020 @09:52AM (#25245395)
It doesn't have to be the engineers who overlooked it, I am sure there were a lot of great cooling solutions thought of once the overheating issues were discovered.

However, the management did overlook it. Now the machine overheats and requires hours of cooling down to shoot continuously for more than 20-25 minutes. Is that an acceptable amount considering any kind of film work?

Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by Rillen on Sunday November 29, 2020 @09:56AM (#25245423)
Its not build as a film camera and its not a film camera. Its a picture camera.

The market segmentation is totally different for that.

I would still buy it. I have a Canon 80d and 90d and i rarely do any video recording at all. why? Because just a recording ready body doesn't give you good video. You need audio equipment etc. and 8k video is huge like wtf huge.

Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by yholio on Sunday November 29, 2020 @09:43AM (#25245345)
It's absolutely clear that Canon made the camera work like this deliberately, to not canibalize their line of cinema cameras with a body intended for stills that is half the price. So yeah, it's a nice hack to force the design to deliver more than the manufacturer allowed it, but don't expect them to be happy about it.
Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by spuz on Sunday November 29, 2020 @10:06AM (#25245479)
The fact that the two thermal pads only partially cover the heat-spreader on the main processor is pretty damning evidence against Canon's claims that they did not deliberately cripple the camera's video functionality. It seems they want to encourage film makers to buy their more expensive cinema line of cameras.
Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by bserge on Sunday November 29, 2020 @10:50AM (#25245814)
Of course, this has been their MO since DSLRs started being able to compete with dedicated camcorders in video quality. Nikon is an even worse offender.
Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by formerly_proven on Sunday November 29, 2020 @11:36AM (#25246167)
Nikon's poor support for video (even though being one of the first to market) boggles the mind. They don't even have professional video cameras that could be cannibalized, I don't think they even make camcorders.
Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by jefftk on Sunday November 29, 2020 @12:49PM (#25246661)
That seems like a pretty strong evidence against this theory?
Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by jolux on Sunday November 29, 2020 @01:56PM (#25247097)
I don’t think it’s intentional that not all DSLRs don’t also make great video cameras. The requirements are very different for great stills cameras vs great video cameras. Size and heat dissipation are the most significant.
Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by bserge on Monday November 30, 2020 @05:24AM (#25252394)
It might not be intentional, but it sure doesn't hurt them. Buy a DSLR for photos, even if it can do great video, just get a separate camera for video.

Probably the same reason laptop manufacturers design their cooling to be barely adequate. It would cost less than a dollar to make it dissipate the maximum TDP at full load (not just "normal" load).

To make it easy, let's ignore ultrathin laptops - even mobile workstations have had the same terrible heat dissipation for over a decade, with very few exceptions.

Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by jolux on Monday November 30, 2020 @10:39AM (#25254845)
> It would cost less than a dollar to make it dissipate the maximum TDP at full load

How do you figure?

> It might not be intentional, but it sure doesn't hurt them.

I just explained why video cameras have different requirements than DSLRs. Besides which, 4K30 or 1080p60 is plenty of unlimited video capability for most consumers. The camera can even do 8K30 and 4K60 for longer than most people take videos.

Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by bserge on Monday November 30, 2020 @02:31PM (#25257871)
I don't have any skin in this game, I'm just sharing my thoughts. Besides, in Europe they're limited to 30 minutes of recording (otherwise they're classed and taxed differently iirc).

The laptop thing - using a bigger heatsink, or more copper, or better thermal paste, or multiple heatpipes instead of one (that was actually HP's solution to their overheating ZBooks) would cost pennies and would actually keep the CPU/GPU under throttling limits.

I've repasted and modified enough laptop heatsinks to know it's a very easy thing to do. But the manufacturers don't care. I get it, a dollar saved on one machine is a lot of money overall. I'd rather have it cost $10 more but have a decent heatsink.

Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by jolux on Sunday November 29, 2020 @10:56AM (#25245868)
It will still record 4K 30p just fine for as long as you want.
Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by jolux on Sunday November 29, 2020 @10:52AM (#25245828)
Seems more likely a sign of being assembled quickly on an assembly line and not having been designed with the thermal mass to properly dissipate the heat of the device recording in 8K raw. This is primarily a stills device, after all.
Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by bserge on Sunday November 29, 2020 @10:49AM (#25245800)
Canon and Nikon have had these "issues" for over a decade. In markets where they're not limited to 30 minutes of video recording by law, they would overheat in less than an hour.

Yes, they're working as intended.

Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by dqv on Sunday November 29, 2020 @08:45AM (#25245068)
Canon has better heat spreading already - you just have to buy the more expensive camera models ;)
Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by codeulike on Sunday November 29, 2020 @09:10AM (#25245181)
Really? Thats interesting, have you got a link?
Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by geerlingguy on Sunday November 29, 2020 @09:28AM (#25245275)
Cinema cameras: https://www.usa.canon.com/internet/portal/us/home/products/l...

SLRs are optimized for handheld, photography use. The body just doesn't have the surface area for proper long-term cooling, and even if it did, it could be difficult to get it to work well while maintaining water resistance and retaining the compact grip.

Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by Godel_unicode on Sunday November 29, 2020 @10:16AM (#25245561)
The r5 is a mirrorless design, not a (d)slr. Sony sells plenty of video optimized cameras in both mirrorless and DSLR designs, in particular the a7s line are explicitly video cameras which can take stills. They can overheat eventually in very hot weather, but it takes some doing.
Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by lhoff on Sunday November 29, 2020 @10:35AM (#25245692)
Canon has the EOS C70 that is more or less what you called a mirrorless design. Its just recording 4k and has a smaller sensor. So its not that canon isn't able to come up with a camera like the Alpha 7S series. And the Alpha 7s is also not able to record in 8k.
Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by jolux on Sunday November 29, 2020 @10:57AM (#25245876)
It’s much larger and I believe it has a fan, though.
Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by jolux on Sunday November 29, 2020 @10:34AM (#25245676)
None of them do 8K raw though.
Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by Godel_unicode on Sunday November 29, 2020 @11:58AM (#25246311)
More pixels more better? I'll take 4k raw at 16-bit with larger pixels over 8k 12-bit and needing more light. To each their own.
Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by jolux on Sunday November 29, 2020 @12:57PM (#25246714)
Same, but the R5 will do 4K 30p cropped for as long as you want, or 1080 60p. As will my older EOS R. The part that’s unique and that involves heat issues is 8K recording. We’re in the megapixel war again, this time between Canon and Sony, which is the only reason anyone’s complaining about 8K video performance in the first place.
Re:Watercooling a Canon R5 to enable unlimited 8K recording by nitrogen on Sunday November 29, 2020 @01:07PM (#25246772)
I believe it was mentioned in the video that scaling 8K to 4K gives better quality (maybe by averaging out the color mosaic filter pattern?).